An official website of the United States government
Motivated by the saturation of drag reduction effectiveness at high non-dimensional riblet spacing in turbulent boundary layer flows, this study seeks to investigate the influence of a secondary blade riblet structure on flow statistics and friction drag reduction effectiveness in comparison to the widely explored single-scale blade riblet surface. The turbulent flow dynamics and drag reduction performance over single- and multi-scale blade riblet surfaces were experimentally examined in a flow visualization channel across various non-dimensional riblet spacings. The shear velocity was quantified by the streamwise velocity distributions from the logarithmic layer via planar Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) measurements, whereas the near-wall flow dynamics were characterized by a Micro Particle Image Velocimetry (micro-PIV) system. The results highlighted that although both riblet surfaces exhibited similar drag reduction performances at low non-dimensional riblet spacings, the presence of a secondary riblet blade structure can effectively extend the drag reduction region with the non-dimensional riblet spacing up to 32 and achieve approximately 10% lower friction drag in comparison to the single-scale riblet surface when the non-dimensional riblet spacing increases to 44.2. The average number of uniform momentum zones (UMZs) on the multi-scaled blade riblet has also reduced by 9% compared to the single-scaled riblet which indicates the reduction of strong shear layers within a turbulent boundary layer. The inspection of near-wall flow statistics demonstrated that at high non-dimensional riblet spacings, the multi-scale riblet surface produces reduced wall-normal velocity fluctuations and Reynolds shear stresses. Quadrant analysis revealed that this design allows for the suppression of both the sweep and ejection events. This experimental result demonstrated that surfaces with spanwise variations of riblet heights have the potential to maintain drag reduction effectiveness across a wider range of flow speeds.
more »
« less
Turbulent boundary layer flow over regularly and irregularly arranged truncated cone surfaces
Aiming to study the rough-wall turbulent boundary layer structure over differently arranged roughness elements, an experimental study was conducted on flows with regular and random roughness. Varying planform densities of truncated cone roughness elements in a square staggered pattern were investigated. The same planform densities were also investigated in random arrangements. Velocity statistics were measured via two-component laser Doppler velocimetry and stereoscopic particle image velocimetry. Friction velocity, thickness, roughness length and zero-plane displacement, determined from spatially averaged flow statistics, showed only minor differences between the regular and random arrangements at the same density. Recent a priori morphometric and statistical drag prediction methods were evaluated against experimentally determined roughness length. Observed differences between regular and random surface flow parameters were due to the presence of secondary flows which manifest as high-momentum pathways and low-momentum pathways in the streamwise velocity. Contrary to expectation, these secondary flows were present over the random surfaces and not discernible over the regular surfaces. Previously identified streamwise-coherent spanwise roughness heterogeneity does not seem to be present, suggesting that such roughness heterogeneity is not necessary to sustain secondary flows. Evidence suggests that the observed secondary flows were initiated at the front edge of the roughness and sustained over irregular roughness. Due to the secondary flows, local turbulent boundary layer profiles do not scale with local wall shear stress but appear to scale with local turbulent shear stress above the roughness canopy. Additionally, quadrant analysis shows distinct changes in the populations of ejection and sweep events.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1738918
- PAR ID:
- 10338058
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Volume:
- 933
- ISSN:
- 0022-1120
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Motivated by the need for accurate determination of wall shear stress from profile measurements in turbulent boundary layer flows, the total shear stress balance is analysed and reformulated using several well-established semi-empirical relations. The analysis highlights the significant effect that small pressure gradients can have on parameters deduced from data even in nominally zero pressure gradient boundary layers. Using the comprehensive shear stress balance together with the log-law equation, it is shown that friction velocity, roughness length and zero-plane displacement can be determined with only velocity and turbulent shear stress profile measurements at a single streamwise location for nominally zero pressure gradient turbulent boundary layers. Application of the proposed analysis to turbulent smooth- and rough-wall experimental data shows that the friction velocity is determined with accuracy comparable to force balances (approximately 1 %–4 %). Additionally, application to boundary layer data from previous studies provides clear evidence that the often cited discrepancy between directly measured friction velocities (e.g. using force balances) and those derived from traditional total shear stress methods is likely due to the small favourable pressure gradient imposed by a fixed cross-section facility. The proposed comprehensive shear stress analysis can account for these small pressure gradients and allows more accurate boundary layer wall shear stress or friction velocity determination using commonly available mean velocity and shear stress profile data from a single streamwise location.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Abstract Coherent structures are critical for controlling turbulent boundary layers due to their roles in momentum and heat transfer in the flow. Turbulent coherent structures can be detected by measuring wall shear stresses that are footprints of coherent structures. In this study, wall shear stress fluctuations were measured simultaneously in a zero pressure gradient turbulent boundary layer using two house-made wall shear stress probes aligned in the spanwise direction. The wall shear stress probe consisted of two hot-wires on the wall aligned in a V-shaped configuration for measuring streamwise and spanwise shear stresses, and their performance was validated in comparison with a direct numerical simulation result. Relationships between measured wall shear stress fluctuations and streamwise velocity fluctuations were analyzed using conditional sampling techniques. The peak detection method and the variable-interval time-averaging (VITA) method showed that quasi-streamwise vortices were inclined toward the streamwise direction. When events were simultaneously detected by the two probes, stronger fluctuations in streamwise velocity were detected, which suggests that stronger coherent structures were detected. In contrast to the former two methods, the hibernating event detection method detects events with lower wall shear stress fluctuations. The ensemble-averaged mean velocity profile of hibernating events was shifted upward compared to the law of the wall, which suggests low drag status of the coherent structures related with hibernating events. These methods suggest significant correlations between wall shear stress fluctuations and coherent structures, which could motivate flow control strategies to fully exploit these correlations.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Dimensional analysis suggests that the dissipation length scale ( $$\ell _{{\it\epsilon}}=u_{\star }^{3}/{\it\epsilon}$$ ) is the appropriate scale for the shear-production range of the second-order streamwise structure function in neutrally stratified turbulent shear flows near solid boundaries, including smooth- and rough-wall boundary layers and shear layers above canopies (e.g. crops, forests and cities). These flows have two major characteristics in common: (i) a single velocity scale, i.e. the friction velocity ( $$u_{\star }$$ ) and (ii) the presence of large eddies that scale with an external length scale much larger than the local integral length scale. No assumptions are made about the local integral scale, which is shown to be proportional to $$\ell _{{\it\epsilon}}$$ for the scaling analysis to be consistent with Kolmogorov’s result for the inertial subrange. Here $${\it\epsilon}$$ is the rate of dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) that represents the rate of energy cascade in the inertial subrange. The scaling yields a log-law dependence of the second-order streamwise structure function on ( $$r/\ell _{{\it\epsilon}}$$ ), where $$r$$ is the streamwise spatial separation. This scaling law is confirmed by large-eddy simulation (LES) results in the roughness sublayer above a model canopy, where the imbalance between local production and dissipation of TKE is much greater than in the inertial layer of wall turbulence and the local integral scale is affected by two external length scales. Parameters estimated for the log-law dependence on ( $$r/\ell _{{\it\epsilon}}$$ ) are in reasonable agreement with those reported for the inertial layer of wall turbulence. This leads to two important conclusions. Firstly, the validity of the $$\ell _{{\it\epsilon}}$$ -scaling is extended to shear flows with a much greater imbalance between production and dissipation, indicating possible universality of the shear-production range in flows near solid boundaries. Secondly, from a modelling perspective, $$\ell _{{\it\epsilon}}$$ is the appropriate scale to characterize turbulence in shear flows with multiple externally imposed length scales.more » « less
-
Recent studies reveal that at large friction Reynolds number delta^+ the outer, inertially-dominated region of the turbulent boundary layer is composed of large scale zones of uniform momentum segregated by narrow fissures of concentrated vorticity. Experiments show that, when scaled by the boundary layer thickness, the fissure thickness is O(1/sqrt{delta^+}), while the dimensional jump in streamwise velocity across each fissure scales in proportion to the friction velocity u_tau. A simple model that exploits these essential elements of the turbulent boundary layer structure at large delta^+ is developed. First, a master wall-normal profile of streamwise velocity is constructed by placing a discrete number of fissures across the boundary layer. The number of fissures and their wall-normal locations follow scalings informed by analysis of the mean momentum equation. The fissures are then randomly displaced in the wall-normal direction, exchanging momentum as they move, to create an instantaneous velocity profile. This process is repeated to generate ensembles of streamwise velocity profiles from which statistical moments are computed. The modelled statistical moments are shown to agree remarkably well with those acquired from direct numerical simulations of turbulent channel flow at large delta^+. In particular, the model robustly reproduces the empirically observed sub-Gaussian behaviour for the skewness and kurtosis profiles over a large range of input parameters.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2021.946
