Title: The Kirchhoff plate equation on surfaces: the surface Hellan–Herrmann–Johnson method
Abstract We present a mixed finite element method for approximating a fourth-order elliptic partial differential equation (PDE), the Kirchhoff plate equation, on a surface embedded in $${\mathbb {R}}^{3}$$, with or without boundary. Error estimates are given in mesh-dependent norms that account for the surface approximation and the approximation of the surface PDE. The method is built on the classic Hellan–Herrmann–Johnson method (for flat domains), and convergence is established for $$C^{k+1}$$ surfaces, with degree $$k$$ (Lagrangian, parametrically curved) approximation of the surface, for any $$k \geqslant 1$$. Mixed boundary conditions are allowed, including clamped, simply-supported and free conditions; if free conditions are present then the surface must be at least $$C^{2,1}$$. The framework uses tools from differential geometry and is directly related to the seminal work of Dziuk, G. (1988) Finite elements for the Beltrami operator on arbitrary surfaces. Partial Differential Equations and Calculus of Variations, vol. 1357 (S. Hildebrandt & R. Leis eds). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer, pp. 142–155. for approximating the Laplace–Beltrami equation. The analysis here is the first to handle the full surface Hessian operator directly. Numerical examples are given on nontrivial surfaces that demonstrate our convergence estimates. In addition, we show how the surface biharmonic equation can be solved with this method.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2111474
PAR ID:
10343187
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Date Published:
Journal Name:
IMA Journal of Numerical Analysis
ISSN:
0272-4979
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract We establish several useful estimates for a non-conforming 2-norm posed on piecewise linear surface triangulations with boundary, with the main result being a Poincaré inequality.We also obtain equivalence of the non-conforming 2-norm posed on the true surface with the norm posed on a piecewise linear approximation.Moreover, we allow for free boundary conditions.The true surface is assumed to be C 2 , 1 C^{2,1} when free conditions are present; otherwise, C 2 C^{2} is sufficient.The framework uses tools from differential geometry and the closest point map (see [G. Dziuk, Finite elements for the Beltrami operator on arbitrary surfaces, Partial Differential Equations and Calculus of Variations , Lecture Notes in Math. 1357, Springer, Berlin (1988), 142–155]) for approximating the full surface Hessian operator.We also present a novel way of applying the closest point map when dealing with surfaces with boundary.Connections with surface finite element methods for fourth-order problems are also noted. 
    more » « less
  2. We present a finite element technique for approximating the surface Hessian of a discrete scalar function on triangulated surfaces embedded in $$\R^{3}$$, with or without boundary. We then extend the method to compute approximations of the full shape operator of the underlying surface using only the known discrete surface. The method is based on the Hellan--Herrmann--Johnson (HHJ) element and does not require any ad-hoc modifications. Convergence is established provided the discrete surface satisfies a Lagrange interpolation property related to the exact surface. The convergence rate, in $L^2$, for the shape operator approximation is $O(h^m)$, where $$m \geq 1$$ is the polynomial degree of the surface, i.e. the method converges even for piecewise linear surface triangulations. For surfaces with boundary, some additional boundary data is needed to establish optimal convergence, e.g. boundary information about the surface normal vector or the curvature in the co-normal direction. Numerical examples are given on non-trivial surfaces that demonstrate our error estimates and the efficacy of the method. 
    more » « less
  3. Minimizing partial differential equation (PDE)-residual losses is a common strategy to promote physical consistency in neural operators. However, standard formulations often lack variational correctness, meaning that small residuals do not guarantee small solution errors due to the use of non-compliant norms or ad hoc penalty terms for boundary conditions. This work develops a variationally correct operator learning framework by constructing first-order system least- squares (FOSLS) objectives whose values are provably equivalent to the solution errors in PDE-compliant norms. We demonstrate this framework on the stationary diffusion and linear elasticity equations, incorporating mixed Dirichlet-Neumann boundary conditions via variational lifts to preserve norm equivalence without inconsistent penalties. To ensure the function space conformity required by the FOSLS loss, we propose a Reduced Basis Neural Operator (RBNO). The RBNO predicts coefficients for a pre-computed, conforming reduced basis, thereby ensuring variational stability by design while enabling efficient training. We provide a rigorous convergence analysis that bounds the total error by the sum of finite element discretization error, reduced basis projection error, neural network approximation error, statistical estimation error, and optimization error. Numerical benchmarks validate these theoretical bounds and demonstrate that the proposed approach achieves superior accuracy in PDE-compliant norms compared to standard baselines, while the residual loss serves as a reliable and computable a posteriori error estimator. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Trace finite element methods have become a popular option for solving surface partial differential equations, especially in problems where surface and bulk effects are coupled. In such methods a surface mesh is formed by approximately intersecting the continuous surface on which the PDE is posed with a three-dimensional (bulk) tetrahedral mesh. InH1-conforming trace methods, the surface finite element space is obtained by restricting a bulk finite element space to the surface mesh. It is not clear how to carry out a similar procedure in order to obtain other important types of finite element spaces such asH(div)-conforming spaces. Following previous work of Olshanskii, Reusken, and Xu onH1-conforming methods, we develop a “quasi-trace” mixed method for the Laplace–Beltrami problem. The finite element mesh is taken to be the intersection of the surface with a regular tetrahedral bulk mesh as previously described, resulting in a surface triangulation that is highly unstructured and anisotropic but satisfies a classical maximum angle condition. The mixed method is then employed on this mesh. Optimal error estimates with respect to the bulk mesh size are proved along with superconvergent estimates for the projection of the scalar error and a postprocessed scalar approximation. Higher-order surface approximations are also considered. 
    more » « less
  5. In this work, we propose a joint operator learning method for reconstructing images of conductivity coefficients from boundary data. Inspired by the idea of using partial differential equation (PDE) solvers as preconditioners for this inverse problem, we investigate a “solver-in-the-loop” training mechanism. This mechanism allows learnable parameters in a PDE solver module to interact with those in neural networks for image reconstruction. Specifically, we employ a fractional Laplace--Beltrami operator with a learnable fractional order to transform boundary data into high-dimensional features. These features are then used as input to a neural network, significantly improving reconstruction accuracy. For this purpose, we develop a Learning-Automated FEM (LA-FEM) package with PyTorch as the backend to support this “solver-in-the-loop” property. The new LA-FEM module allows automatic differentiation of an objective function to propagate through both the PDE solver for the forward problem and the coupled neural networks for the inverse problem. 
    more » « less