skip to main content

Title: Origin of Compositional Gradients with Temperature in the High-SiO2 Rhyolite Portion of the Bishop Tuff: Constraints on Mineral–Melt–Fluid Reactions in the Parental Mush
Abstract The Bishop Tuff (BT), erupted from the Long Valley caldera in California, displays two types of geochemical gradients with temperature: one is related to magma mixing, whereas the other is found in the high-SiO2 rhyolite portion of the Bishop Tuff and is characterized by twofold or lower concentration variations in minor and trace elements that are strongly correlated with temperature. It is proposed that the latter zonation, which preceded phenocryst growth, developed as a result of mineral–melt partitioning between interstitial melt and surrounding crystals in a parental mush, from which variable melt fractions were segregated. To test this hypothesis, trends of increasing vs decreasing element concentrations with temperature (as a proxy for melt fraction), obtained from published data on single-clast pumice samples from the high-SiO2 rhyolite portion of the Bishop Tuff, were used to infer their relative degrees of incompatibility vs compatibility between crystals and melt in the parental mush. Relative compatibility values (RCVi) for all elements i, defined as the concentration slope with temperature divided by average concentration, are shown to be linearly correlated with their respective bulk partition coefficients (bulk Di). Mineral–melt partition coefficients from the literature were used to constrain the average stoichiometry of the crystallization/melting more » reaction in the parental mush: 32 % quartz + 34 % plagioclase + 31 % K-feldspar + 1·60 % biotite + 0·42 % titanomagnetite + 0·34 % ilmenite + 0·093 % allanite + 0·024 % zircon + 0·025 % apatite = 100 % liquid. The proportions of tectosilicates in the reaction (i.e. location of eutectic) are consistent with depths of melt segregation of ~400–550 MPa and an activity of H2O of ~0·4–0·6. Temperatures of <770–780 °C are constrained by allanite in the reaction. Evidence that a fluid phase was present in the parental mush is seen in the decreasing versus increasing H2O and CO2 contents with temperature in the segregated interstitial melt that formed the high-SiO2 rhyolite portion of the Bishop Tuff. The presence of an excess fluid phase, which strongly partitions CO2 relative to the melt, is required to explain the compatible behavior of CO2, whereas the fluid abundance must have been low to explain the incompatible behavior of H2O. Calculated degassing paths for interstitial melts, which segregated from the parental mush and ascended to shallower depths to grow phenocrysts, match published volatile analyses in quartz-hosted melt inclusions and constrain fluid abundances in the mush to be ≤1 wt%. The source of volatiles in the parental mush, irrespective of whether it formed by crystallization or partial melting, must have been primarily from associated basalts, as granitoid crust is too volatile poor. Approximately twice as much basalt as rhyolite is needed to provide the requisite volatiles. The determination of bulk Di for several elements gives the bulk composition of the parental leucogranitic mush and shows that it is distinct from Mesozoic Sierran arc granitoids, as expected. Collectively, the results from this study provide new constraints for models of the complex, multi-stage processes throughout the Plio-Quaternary, involving both mantle-derived basalt and pre-existing crust, that led to the origin of the parental body to the Bishop Tuff. « less
Award ID(s):
Publication Date:
Journal Name:
Journal of Petrology
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. This paper presents the first detailed geologic map of in situ lower ocean crust; the product of six surveys of Atlantis Bank on the SW Indian Ridge. This combined with major and trace element compositions of primary magmatic phases in 99 seafloor gabbros shows there are both significant vertical and ridge-parallel variations in crustal composition and thickness, but a continuity of the basic stratigraphy parallel to spreading. This stratigraphy is not that of magmatic sedimentation in a large crustal magma chamber. Instead, it is the product of dynamic accretion where the lower crust formed by episodic intrusion, large-scale upward migration of interstitial melt due to crystal mush compaction, and continuous tectonic extension accompanied by hyper- and sub-solidus, crystal-plastic deformation. Five crossings of the gabbro-peridotite contact along the transform wall show that massive mantle peridotite is intruded by cumulate residues of moderately to highly evolved magmas, few of which could be even close to equilibrium with a primary mantle magma. This contact then does not represent the crust-mantle boundary as envisaged in the ophiolite analog for ocean crust. The residues of the magmas parental to the shallow crust must also lie beneath the center of the complex. This, and the nearlymore »complete absence of dunites in peridotites from the transform wall, shows that melt transport through the shallow lithosphere was largely restricted to the central region of the paleo-ridge segment. There is almost no evidence for a melt lens or high-level storage of primitive melt in the upper 1500 m of Atlantis Bank. Thus, the composition of associated mid-ocean ridge basalt appears largely controlled by fractional crystallization of primitive cumulates at depth, near or at the base of the crust, modified somewhat by melt-rock reaction during transport through the overlying cumulate pile to the seafloor. Inliers of the dike-gabbro transition show that the uppermost gabbros crystallized at depth and were then emplaced upward, as they cooled, into the zone of diking. ODP and IODP drilling along the center of the gabbro massif also found few primitive gabbros that could have been in equilibrium with the original overlying lavas. Evidence of large-scale upward, permeable transport of interstitial melt through the gabbros is ubiquitous. Thus, post-cumulus processes, including extensive reaction, dissolution, and re-precipitation within the cumulate pile have obscured nearly all evidence of earlier primitive origins. We suggest that many of the gabbros may have started as primitive cumulates but were hybridized and transformed by later, migrating melts to evolved compositions, even as they ascended to higher levels, while new primitive cumulates were emplaced near the base of the crust. Mass balance for a likely parental melt intruded from the mantle to form the crust, however, requires that such primitive cumulates must exist at depth beneath Atlantis Bank at the center of the magmatic complex. The Atlantis Bank Gabbro Massif accreted by direct magma intrusion into the lower crust, followed by upward diapiric flow, first as a crystal mush, then by solid-state, crystal-plastic deformation, and finally by detachment faulting to the sea floor. The strongly asymmetric spreading to the south, parallel to the transform, was due to fault capture, with the bounding faults on the northern rift valley wall cut off by the detachment fault, which extended across the zone of intrusion causing rapid migration of the plate boundary to the north.« less
  2. Volcano inflation, for durations of months to years immediately following an eruption, has been observed at a number of volcanoes, including the 2011/12 eruption of Cordón Caulle, Chile. Such reinflation is often explained by replenishment of the magma reservoir from a deeper source. Whether and why that is the case remains uncertain in most instances, but the implications for renewed eruptive potential may be profound. Here, we posit redistribution of melt within a zoned magma reservoir consisting of a crystal rich mush overlain by an eruptible layer of crystal poor rhyolite as an alternate mechanism for reinflation. Such a zoned magma body is consistent with conceptual models for how crystal poor rhyolites form and with the presence of mafic enclaves within the Cordón Caulle rhyolite. The enclaves can be interpreted as pieces of mush entrained into the overlying rhyolite during its withdrawal from the reservoir. We test the hypothesis that melt from the inter-crystalline pores of the mush can redistribute by porous flow into the overlying crystal poor rhyolite, causing inflation after an eruption. We simulate the flow of melt within the zoned reservoir during and after eruption with a numerical model. As crystal poor rhyolite is erupted, magma pressuremore »within the rhyolite layer above the mush decreases. Consequently, interstitial melt flows upward within the mush, toward the reduced pressure at the interface of mush and crystal poor rhyolite. The mush is treated as a poroelastic material, with interstitial melt flow governed by Darcy's law. Thus, the change in pressure caused by withdrawal from the overlying rhyolite diffuses downward into the mush as the interstitial melt flows upward. The change in pore pressure results in an elastic deformation of the mush matrix. Because pore pressure diffusivity is small, melt redistribution can persist for years after eruptive activity ends, leading to slow inflation compared to fast eruptive deflation. We predict a partial recovery of volume lost from the eruption. Reinflation occurs because the expansion of decompressing melt flowing from the mush into the crystal poor rhyolite exceeds compression of the poroelastic mush. For cases where the interstitial melt is moderately compressible due to exsolved volatiles, our model reproduces the deformation observed at Cordón Caulle.« less
  3. Interpretation of erupted products we observe on the seafloor requires that we understand the petrogenesis of melts in the oceanic crust and where crystallization initially takes place. Our work focuses on estimating depth of crystallization of the plagioclase megacrysts using CO2 and H2O concentrations from plagioclase ultraphyric basalts (PUBs). Samples were analyzed from the Lucky Strike segment on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge and from three locations on the Juan de Fuca Ridge (West Valley, Endeavor Segment, and Axial Segment). Melt inclusions were re-homogenized to remove the effects of post-entrapment crystallization. The CO2 in the vapor bubbles present in the melt inclusions were analyzed at Virginia Tech using Raman spectroscopy, and associated glassy melt inclusions were analyzed at WHOI using the ion microprobe for CO2 and H2O. Vapor-saturation pressures calculated from these volatiles stored in melt inclusions and vapor bubbles range from 359-3994 bars, corresponding to depths of 1.0-11.4 km below the sea floor. The proportion of CO2 partitioned in the bubbles range from 11-98%. In summary, about 14% of the melt inclusions from Lucky Strike record crystallization depths of 3-4 km, consistent with the depth of the seismically imaged melt lens, whereas ~55% of melt inclusions crystallized at depths >4 kmmore »with a maximum at 9.8 km. These data are similar to depths of formation determined through olivine-hosted melt inclusions from the same segment (Wanless et al., 2015), although a greater portion of plagioclase-hosted melt inclusions record crystallization below the melt lens. At the Juan de Fuca ridge, ~24% of the melt inclusions record crystallization depths of 2-3 km, consistent with a seismically imaged mid-crustal magma chamber at the Endeavor Segment, while an additional ~62% crystallize at depths >3 km with a maximum at 11.4 km. This suggests that while crystallization can be focused within the melt lenses and magma chambers at these ridge localities, a significant and greater proportion of the megacrysts were sampled from the lower crust or upper mantle.« less
  4. Abstract We present microbeam major- and trace-element data from 14 monzodiorites collected from the Malaspina Pluton (Fiordland, New Zealand) with the goal of evaluating processes involved in the production of andesites in lower arc crust. We focus on relict igneous assemblages consisting of plagioclase and amphibole with lesser amounts of clinopyroxene, orthopyroxene, biotite and quartz. These relict igneous assemblages are heterogeneously preserved in the lower crust within sheeted intrusions that display hypersolidus fabrics defined by alignment of unstrained plagioclase and amphibole. Trace-element data from relict igneous amphiboles in these rocks reveal two distinct groups: one relatively enriched in high field strength element concentrations and one relatively depleted. The enriched amphibole group has Zr values in the range of ∼25–110 ppm, Nb values of ∼5–32 ppm, and Th values up to 2·4 ppm. The depleted group, in contrast, shows Zr values <35 ppm and Nb values <0·25 ppm, and Th is generally below the level of detection. Amphibole crystallization temperatures calculated from major elements range from ∼960 to 830 °C for all samples in the pluton; however, we do not observe significant differences in the range of crystallization temperatures between enriched (∼960–840 °C) and depleted groups (∼940–830 °C). Bulk-rock Sr and Nd isotopes are also remarkably homogeneous and showmore »no apparent difference between enriched (εNdi = 0·1 to –0·1; 87Sr/86Sri = 0·70420–0·70413) and depleted groups (εNdi = 0·3 to –0·4; 87Sr/86Sri = 0·70424–0·70411). Calculated amphibole-equilibrium melt compositions using chemometric equations indicate that melts were highly fractionated (molar Mg# <50), andesitic to dacitic in composition, and were much more evolved than bulk lower continental crust or primitive basalts and andesites predicted to have formed from hydrous melting of mantle-wedge peridotite beneath an arc. We suggest that melts originated from a common, isotopically homogeneous source beneath the Malaspina Pluton, and differences between enriched and depleted trace-element groups reflect varying contributions from subducted sediment-derived melt and sediment-derived fluid, respectively. Our data demonstrate that andesites and dacites were the dominant melts that intruded the lower crust, and their compositions mirror middle and upper bulk-continental crust estimates. Continental crust-like geochemical signatures were acquired in the source region from interaction between hydrous mantle-wedge melts and recycled subducted sediment rather than assimilation and/or remelting of pre-existing lower continental crust.« less
  5. Abstract The solubility of CO2 in hydrous basaltic andesite was examined in fO2-controlled experiments at a temperature of 1125 °C and pressures between 310–1200 MPa. Concentrations of dissolved H2O and CO2 in experimental glasses were determined by ion microprobe calibrated on a subset of run glasses analyzed by high-temperature vacuum manometry. Assuming that the solubility of H2O in mafic melt is relatively well known, estimates of XH2Ofluid and PH2Ofluid in the saturating fluid were modeled, and by difference, values for XCO2fluid and PCO2fluid were obtained (XCO2 ~0.5–0.9); fCO2 could be then calculated from the fluid composition, temperature, and pressure. Dissolved H2O over a range of 2.3–5.5 wt% had no unequivocal influence on the dissolution of CO2 at the pressures and fluid compositions examined. For these H2O concentrations, dissolved CO2 increases with fCO2 following an empirical power-law relation: dissolved CO2 (ppmw) = 14.9−3.5+4.5[fCO2 (MPa)]0.7±0.03. The highest-pressure results plot farthest from this equation but are within its 1 standard-error uncertainty envelope. We compare our experimental data with three recent CO2-H2O solubility models: Papale et al. (2006); Iacono-Marziano et al. (2012); and Ghiorso and Gualda (2015). The Papale et al. (2006) and Iacono-Marizano et al. (2012) models give similar results, both over-predicting themore »solubility of CO2 in a melt of the Pavlof basaltic andesite composition across the fCO2 range, whereas the Ghiorso and Gualda (2015) model under-predicts CO2 solubility. All three solubility models would indicate a strong enhancement of CO2 solubility with increasing dissolved H2O not apparent in our results. We also examine our results in the context of previous high-pressure CO2 solubility experiments on basaltic melts. Dissolved CO2 correlates positively with mole fraction (Na+K+Ca)/Al across a compositional spectrum of trachybasalt-alkali basalt-tholeiite-icelandite-basaltic andesite. Shortcomings of current solubility models for a widespread arc magma type indicate that our understanding of degassing in the deep crust and uppermost mantle remains semi-quantitative. Experimental studies systematically varying concentrations of melt components (Mg, Ca, Na, K, Al, Si) may be necessary to identify solubility reactions, quantify their equilibrium constants, and thereby build an accurate and generally applicable solubility model.« less