skip to main content

Title: Correcting for filter-based aerosol light absorption biases at the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement program's Southern Great Plains site using photoacoustic measurements and machine learning
Abstract. Measurement of light absorption of solar radiation byaerosols is vital for assessing direct aerosol radiative forcing, whichaffects local and global climate. Low-cost and easy-to-operate filter-basedinstruments, such as the Particle Soot Absorption Photometer (PSAP), that collect aerosols on a filter and measure light attenuation through thefilter are widely used to infer aerosol light absorption. However,filter-based absorption measurements are subject to artifacts that aredifficult to quantify. These artifacts are associated with the presence ofthe filter medium and the complex interactions between the filter fibers and accumulated aerosols. Various correction algorithms have been introduced to correct for the filter-based absorption coefficient measurements toward predicting the particle-phase absorption coefficient (Babs). However, the inability of these algorithms to incorporate into their formulations the complex matrix of influencing parameters such as particle asymmetry parameter, particle size, and particle penetration depth results in prediction of particle-phase absorption coefficients with relatively low accuracy. The analytical forms of corrections also suffer from a lack of universal applicability: different corrections are required for rural andurban sites across the world. In this study, we analyzed and compared 3 months of high-time-resolution ambient aerosol absorption data collectedsynchronously using a three-wavelength photoacoustic absorption spectrometer (PASS) and PSAP. Both instruments were operated on the same sampling inletat the Department of Energy's Atmospheric Radiation Measurement program's Southern Great Plains (SGP) user facility in Oklahoma. We implemented the two mostcommonly used analytical correction algorithms, namely, Virkkula (2010) and the average of Virkkula (2010) and Ogren (2010)–Bond et al. (1999) as well as a random forest regression (RFR) machine learning algorithm to predict Babs values from the PSAP's filter-based measurements. The predicted Babs was compared against the reference Babs measured by the PASS. The RFR algorithm performed the best by yielding the lowest root mean squareerror of prediction. The algorithm was trained using input datasets from the PSAP (transmission and uncorrected absorption coefficient), a co-locatednephelometer (scattering coefficients), and the Aerosol Chemical Speciation Monitor (mass concentration of non-refractory aerosol particles). A revisedform of the Virkkula (2010) algorithm suitable for the SGP site has beenproposed; however, its performance yields approximately 2-fold errors when compared to the RFR algorithm. To generalize the accuracy and applicabilityof our proposed RFR algorithm, we trained and tested it on a dataset oflaboratory measurements of combustion aerosols. Input variables to thealgorithm included the aerosol number size distribution from the Scanning Mobility Particle Sizer, absorption coefficients from the filter-basedTricolor Absorption Photometer, and scattering coefficients from amultiwavelength nephelometer. The RFR algorithm predicted Babs values within 5 % of the reference Babs measured by the multiwavelength PASS during the laboratory experiments. Thus, we show that machine learningapproaches offer a promising path to correct for biases in long-termfilter-based absorption datasets and accurately quantify their variabilityand trends needed for robust radiative forcing determination.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
Page Range / eLocation ID:
4569 to 4583
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract. Recent studies have shown that organic aerosol (OA) could have a nontrivialrole in atmospheric light absorption at shorter visible wavelengths. Goodestimates of OA light absorption are therefore necessary to better estimateradiative forcing due to these aerosols in climate models. One of the commontechniques used to measure OA light absorption is the solvent extractiontechnique from filter samples which involves the use of a spectrophotometerto measure bulk absorbance by the solvent-soluble organic fraction ofparticulate matter. Measured solvent-phase absorbance is subsequentlyconverted to particle-phase absorption coefficient using scaling factors.The conventional view is to apply a correction factor of 2 to absorptioncoefficients obtained from solvent-extracted OA based on Mie calculations.The appropriate scaling factors are a function of biases due to incompleteextraction of organic carbon (OC) by solvents and size-dependent absorption properties of OA.The range for these biases along with their potential dependence on burnconditions is an unexplored area of research. Here, we performed a comprehensive laboratory study involving three solvents(water, methanol, and acetone) to investigate the bias in absorptioncoefficients obtained from solvent-extraction-based photometry techniques ascompared to in situ particle-phase absorption for freshly emitted OA frombiomass burning. We correlated the bias with OC∕TC (total carbon) mass ratio and singlescattering albedo (SSA) and observed that the conventionally used correctionfactor of 2 for water and methanol-extracted OA might not be extensible toall systems, and we suggest caution while using such correction factors toestimate particle-phase OA absorption coefficients. Furthermore, a linearcorrelation between SSA and the OC∕TC ratio was also established. Finally, fromthe spectroscopic data, we analyzed the differences in absorptionÅngström exponents (AÅE) obtained from solution- andparticulate-phase measurements. We noted that AÅE fromsolvent-phase measurements could deviate significantly from their OAcounterparts. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    Abstract. Despite the potential importance of black carbon (BC) for radiative forcing of the Arctic atmosphere, vertically resolved measurements of the particle light scattering coefficient (σsp) and light absorption coefficient (σap) in the springtime Arctic atmosphere are infrequent, especially measurements at latitudes at or above 80∘ N. Here, relationships among vertically distributed aerosol optical properties (σap, σsp and single scattering albedo or SSA), particle microphysics and particle chemistry are examined for a region of the Canadian archipelago between 79.9 and 83.4∘ N from near the surface to 500 hPa. Airborne data collected during April 2015 are combined with ground-based observations from the observatory at Alert, Nunavut and simulations from the Goddard Earth Observing System (GEOS) model, GEOS-Chem, coupled with the TwO-Moment Aerosol Sectional (TOMAS) model (collectively GEOS-Chem–TOMAS; Kodros et al., 2018) to further our knowledge of the effects of BC on light absorption in the Arctic troposphere. The results are constrained for σsp less than 15 Mm−1, which represent 98 % of the observed σsp, because the single scattering albedo (SSA) has a tendency to be lower at lower σsp, resulting in a larger relative contribution to Arctic warming. At 18.4 m2 g−1, the average BC mass absorption coefficient (MAC) from the combined airborne and Alert observations is substantially higher than the two averaged modelled MAC values (13.6 and 9.1 m2 g−1) for two different internal mixing assumptions, the latter of which is based on previous observations. The higher observed MAC value may be explained by an underestimation of BC, the presence of small amounts of dust and/or possible differences in BC microphysics and morphologies between the observations and model. In comparing the observations and simulations, we present σap and SSA, as measured, and σap∕2 and the corresponding SSA to encompass the lower modelled MAC that is more consistent with accepted MAC values. Median values of the measured σap, rBC and the organic component of particles all increase by a factor of 1.8±0.1, going from near-surface to 750 hPa, and values higher than the surface persist to 600 hPa. Modelled BC, organics and σap agree with the near-surface measurements but do not reproduce the higher values observed between 900 and 600 hPa. The differences between modelled and observed optical properties follow the same trend as the differences between the modelled and observed concentrations of the carbonaceous components (black and organic). Model-observation discrepancies may be mostly due to the modelled ejection of biomass burning particles only into the boundary layer at the sources. For the assumption of the observed MAC value, the SSA range between 0.88 and 0.94, which is significantly lower than other recent estimates for the Arctic, in part reflecting the constraint of σsp<15 Mm−1. The large uncertainties in measuring optical properties and BC, and the large differences between measured and modelled values here and in the literature, argue for improved measurements of BC and light absorption by BC and more vertical profiles of aerosol chemistry, microphysics and other optical properties in the Arctic. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Abstract. The aerosol indirect effect on cloud microphysical and radiative propertiesis one of the largest uncertainties in climate simulations. In order toinvestigate the aerosol–cloud interactions, a total of 16 low-level stratuscloud cases under daytime coupled boundary-layer conditions are selectedover the southern Great Plains (SGP) region of the United States. Thephysicochemical properties of aerosols and their impacts on cloudmicrophysical properties are examined using data collected from theDepartment of Energy Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) facility at the SGP site. The aerosol–cloud interaction index (ACIr) is used to quantify the aerosol impacts with respect to cloud-droplet effective radius. The mean value of ACIr calculated from all selected samples is0.145±0.05 and ranges from 0.09 to 0.24 at a range of cloudliquid water paths (LWPs; LWP=20–300 g m−2). The magnitude of ACIr decreases with an increasing LWP, which suggests a diminished cloud microphysical response to aerosol loading, presumably due to enhanced condensational growth processes and enlarged particle sizes. The impact of aerosols with different light-absorbing abilities on the sensitivity of cloud microphysical responses is also investigated. In the presence of weak light-absorbing aerosols, the low-level clouds feature a higher number concentration of cloud condensation nuclei (NCCN) and smaller effective radii (re), while the opposite is true for strong light-absorbing aerosols. Furthermore, the mean activation ratio of aerosols to CCN (NCCN∕Na) for weakly (strongly) absorbing aerosols is 0.54 (0.45), owing to the aerosol microphysical effects, particularly the different aerosol compositions inferred by their absorptive properties. In terms of the sensitivity of cloud-droplet number concentration (Nd) to NCCN, the fraction of CCN that converted to cloud droplets (Nd∕NCCN) for the weakly (strongly) absorptive regime is 0.69 (0.54). The measured ACIr values in the weakly absorptive regime arerelatively higher, indicating that clouds have greater microphysicalresponses to aerosols, owing to the favorable thermodynamic condition. Thereduced ACIr values in the strongly absorptive regime are due to the cloud-layer heating effect induced by strong light-absorbing aerosols. Consequently, we expect larger shortwave radiative cooling effects from clouds in the weakly absorptive regime than those in the strongly absorptive regime. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are common pollutants present in atmospheric aerosols and other environmental mixtures. They are of particular air quality and human health concerns as many of them are carcinogenic toxins. They also affect absorption of solar radiation by aerosols, therefore contributing to the radiative forcing of climate. For environmental chemistry studies, it is advantageous to quantify PAH components using the same analytical technics that are commonly applied to characterize a broad range of polar analytes present in the same environmental mixtures. Liquid chromatography coupled with photodiode array and high‐resolution mass spectrometric detection (LC‐PDA‐HRMS) is a method of choice for comprehensive characterization of chemical composition and quantification of light absorption properties of individual organic compounds present in the environmental samples. However, quantification of non‐polar PAHs by this method is poorly established because of their imperfect ionization in electrospray ionization (ESI) technique. This tutorial article provides a comprehensive evaluation of the quantitative analysis of 16 priority pollutant PAHs in a standard reference material using the LC–MS platform coupled with the ESI source. Results are further corroborated by the quantitation experiments using an atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI) method, which is more sensitive for the PAH detection. The basic concepts and step‐by‐step practical guidance for the PAHs quantitative characterization are offered based on the systematic experiments, which include (1) Evaluation effects of different acidification levels by formic acid on the (+)ESI‐MS detection of PAHs. (2) Comparison of detection limits in ESI+ versus APPI+ experiments. (3) Investigation of the PAH fragmentation patterns in MS2experiments at different collision energies. (4) Calculation of wavelength dependent mass absorption coefficient (MACλ) of the standard mixture and its individual PAHs using LC‐PDA data. (5) Assessment of the minimal injected mass required for accurate quantification ofMACλof the standard mixture and of a multi‐component environmental sample.

    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Aerosols have significant and complex impacts on regional climate in East Asia. Cloud‐aerosol‐precipitation interactions (CAPI) remain most challenging in climate studies. The quantitative understanding of CAPI requires good knowledge of aerosols, ranging from their formation, composition, transport, and their radiative, hygroscopic, and microphysical properties. A comprehensive review is presented here centered on the CAPI based chiefly, but not limited to, publications in the special section named EAST‐AIRcpc concerning (1) observations of aerosol loading and properties, (2) relationships between aerosols and meteorological variables affecting CAPI, (3) mechanisms behind CAPI, and (4) quantification of CAPI and their impact on climate. Heavy aerosol loading in East Asia has significant radiative effects by reducing surface radiation, increasing the air temperature, and lowering the boundary layer height. A key factor is aerosol absorption, which is particularly strong in central China. This absorption can have a wide range of impacts such as creating an imbalance of aerosol radiative forcing at the top and bottom of the atmosphere, leading to inconsistent retrievals of cloud variables from space‐borne and ground‐based instruments. Aerosol radiative forcing can delay or suppress the initiation and development of convective clouds whose microphysics can be further altered by the microphysical effect of aerosols. For the same cloud thickness, the likelihood of precipitation is influenced by aerosols: suppressing light rain and enhancing heavy rain, delaying but intensifying thunderstorms, and reducing the onset of isolated showers in most parts of China. Rainfall has become more inhomogeneous and more extreme in the heavily polluted urban regions.

    more » « less