Apache Mesos, a two-level resource scheduler, provides resource sharing across multiple users in a multi-tenant clustered environment. Computational resources (i.e., CPU, memory, disk, etc.) are distributed according to the Dominant Resource Fairness (DRF) policy. Mesos frameworks (users) receive resources based on their current usage and are responsible for scheduling their tasks within the allocation. We have observed that multiple frameworks can cause fairness imbalance in a multi-user environment. For example, a greedy framework consuming more than its fair share of resources can deny resource fairness to others. The user with the least Dominant Share is considered first by the DRF module to get its resource allocation. However, the default DRF implementation, in Apache Mesos' Master allocation module, does not consider the overall resource demands of the tasks in the queue for each user/framework. This lack of awareness can lead to poor performance as users without any pending task may receive more resource offers, and users with a queue of pending tasks can starve due to their high dominant shares. In a multi-tenant environment, the characteristics of frameworks and workloads must be understood by cluster managers to be able to define fairness based on not only resource share but also resource demand and queue wait time. We have developed a policy driven queue manager, Tromino, for an Apache Mesos cluster where tasks for individual frameworks can be scheduled based on each framework's overall resource demands and current resource consumption. Dominant Share and demand awareness of Tromino and scheduling based on these attributes can reduce (1) the impact of unfairness due to a framework specific configuration, and (2) unfair waiting time due to higher resource demand in a pending task queue. In the best case, Tromino can significantly reduce the average waiting time of a framework by using the proposed Demand-DRF aware policy.
more »
« less
Not All Tasks Are Created Equal: Adaptive Resource Allocation for Heterogeneous Tasks in Dynamic Workflows
Users running dynamic workflows in distributed systems usually have inadequate expertise to correctly size the allocation of resources (cores, memory, disk) to each task due to the difficulty in uncovering the obscure yet important correlation between tasks and their resource consumption. Thus, users typically pay little attention to this problem of allocation sizing and either simply apply an error-prone upper bound of resource allocation to all tasks, or delegate this responsibility to underlying distributed systems, resulting in substantial waste from allocated yet unused resources. In this paper, we will first show that tasks performing different work may have significantly different resource consumption. We will then show that exploiting the heterogeneity of tasks is a desirable way to reveal and predict the relationship between tasks and their resource consumption, reduce waste from resource misallocation, increase tasks' consumption efficiency, and incentivize users' cooperation. We have developed two info-aware allocation strategies capitalizing on this characteristic and will show their effectiveness through simulations on two modern applications with dynamic workflows and five synthetic datasets of resource consumption. Our results show that info-aware strategies can cut down up to 98.7% of the total waste incurred by a best-effort strategy, and increase the efficiency in resource consumption of each task on average anywhere up to 93.9%.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1931348
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10356914
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- WORKS Workshop on Workflows at Supercomputing
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 17 to 24
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Both energy-efficiency and real-time performance are critical requirements in many embedded systems applications such as self-driving car, robotic system, disaster response, and security/safety control. These systems entail a myriad of real-time tasks, where each task itself is a parallel task that can utilize multiple computing units at the same time. Driven by the increasing demand for parallel tasks, multi-core embedded processors are inevitably evolving to many-core. Existing work on real-time parallel tasks mostly focused on real-time scheduling without addressing energy consumption. In this paper, we address hard real-time scheduling of parallel tasks while minimizing their CPU energy consumption on multicore embedded systems. Each task is represented as a directed acyclic graph (DAG) with nodes indicating different threads of execution and edges indicating their dependencies. Our technique is to determine the execution speeds of the nodes of the DAGs to minimize the overall energy consumption while meeting all task deadlines. It incorporates a frequency optimization engine and the dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS) scheme into the classical real-time scheduling policies (both federated and global) and makes them energy-aware. The contributions of this paper thus include the first energy-aware online federated scheduling and also the first energy-aware global scheduling of DAGs. Evaluation using synthetic workload through simulation shows that our energy-aware real-time scheduling policies can achieve up to 68% energy-saving compared to classical (energy-unaware) policies. We have also performed a proof of concept system evaluation using physical hardware demonstrating the energy efficiency through our proposed approach.more » « less
-
Improving energy efficiency has become necessary to enable sustainable computational science. At the same time, scientific workflows are key in facilitating distributed computing in virtually all domain sciences. As data and computational requirements increase, I/O-intensive workflows have become prevalent. In this work, we evaluate the ability of twopopular energy-aware workflow scheduling algorithms to provide effective schedules for this class of workflow applications, that is, schedules that strike a good compromise between workflow execution time and energy consumption. These two algorithms make decisions based on a widely used power consumption model that simply assumes linear correlation to CPU usage. Previous work has shown this model to be inaccurate, in particular for modeling power consumption of I/O-intensive workflow executions, and has proposed an accurate model. We evaluate the effectiveness of the two aforementioned algorithms based on this accurate model. We find that, when making their decisions, these algorithms can underestimate power consumption by up to 360{\%}, which makes it unclear how well these algorithm would fare in practice. To evaluate the benefit of using the more accurate power consumption model in practice, we propose a simple scheduling algorithm that relies on this model to balance the I/O load across the available compute resources. Experimental results show that this algorithm achieves more desirable compromises between energy consumption and workflow execution time than the two popular algorithms.more » « less
-
Scientific breakthroughs in biomolecular methods and improvements in hardware technology have shifted from a single long-running simulation to a large set of shorter simulations running simultaneously, called an ensemble. In an ensemble, each independent simulation is usually coupled with several analyses that apply identical or distinct algorithms on data produced by the corresponding simulation. Today, In situ methods are used to analyze large volumes of data generated by scientific simulations at runtime. This work studies the execution of ensemble-based simulations paired with In situ analyses using in-memory staging methods. Because simulations and analyses forming an ensemble typically run concurrently, deploying an ensemble requires efficient co-location-aware strategies, making sure the data flow between simulations and analyses that form an In situ workflow is efficient. Using an ensemble of molecular dynamics In situ workflows with multiple simulations and analyses, we first show that collecting traditional metrics such as makespan, instructions per cycle, memory usage, or cache miss ratio is not sufficient to characterize the complex behaviors of ensembles. Thus, we propose a method to evaluate the performance of ensembles of workflows that captures resource usage (efficiency), resource allocation, and component placement. Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed method can effectively capture the performance of different component placements in an ensemble. By evaluating different co-location scenarios, our performance indicator demonstrates improvements of up to four orders of magnitude when co-locating simulation and coupled analyses within a single computational host.more » « less
-
We consider a large-scale service system where incoming tasks have to be instantaneously dispatched to one out of many parallel server pools. The user-perceived performance degrades with the number of concurrent tasks and the dispatcher aims at maximizing the overall quality of service by balancing the load through a simple threshold policy. We demonstrate that such a policy is optimal on the fluid and diffusion scales, while only involving a small communication overhead, which is crucial for large-scale deployments. In order to set the threshold optimally, it is important, however, to learn the load of the system, which may be unknown. For that purpose, we design a control rule for tuning the threshold in an online manner. We derive conditions that guarantee that this adaptive threshold settles at the optimal value, along with estimates for the time until this happens. In addition, we provide numerical experiments that support the theoretical results and further indicate that our policy copes effectively with time-varying demand patterns. Summary of Contribution: Data centers and cloud computing platforms are the digital factories of the world, and managing resources and workloads in these systems involves operations research challenges of an unprecedented scale. Due to the massive size, complex dynamics, and wide range of time scales, the design and implementation of optimal resource-allocation strategies is prohibitively demanding from a computation and communication perspective. These resource-allocation strategies are essential for certain interactive applications, for which the available computing resources need to be distributed optimally among users in order to provide the best overall experienced performance. This is the subject of the present article, which considers the problem of distributing tasks among the various server pools of a large-scale service system, with the objective of optimizing the overall quality of service provided to users. A solution to this load-balancing problem cannot rely on maintaining complete state information at the gateway of the system, since this is computationally unfeasible, due to the magnitude and complexity of modern data centers and cloud computing platforms. Therefore, we examine a computationally light load-balancing algorithm that is yet asymptotically optimal in a regime where the size of the system approaches infinity. The analysis is based on a Markovian stochastic model, which is studied through fluid and diffusion limits in the aforementioned large-scale regime. The article analyzes the load-balancing algorithm theoretically and provides numerical experiments that support and extend the theoretical results.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- https://doi.org/10.1109/WORKS54523.2021.00008
