skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Mobile or FPGA? A Comprehensive Evaluation on Energy Efficiency and a Unified Optimization Framework
Efficient deployment of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) on edge devices (i.e., FPGAs and mobile platforms) is very challenging, especially under a recent witness of the increasing DNN model size and complexity. Model compression strategies, including weight quantization and pruning, are widely recognized as effective approaches to significantly reduce computation and memory intensities, and have been implemented in many DNNs on edge devices. However, most state-of-the-art works focus on ad-hoc optimizations, and there lacks a thorough study to comprehensively reveal the potentials and constraints of different edge devices when considering different compression strategies. In this paper, we qualitatively and quantitatively compare the energy efficiency of FPGA-based and mobile-based DNN executions using mobile GPU and provide a detailed analysis. Based on the observations obtained from the analysis, we propose a unified optimization framework using block-based pruning to reduce the weight storage and accelerate the inference speed on mobile devices and FPGAs, achieving high hardware performance and energy-efficiency gain while maintaining accuracy.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2047516
PAR ID:
10357922
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
ACM Transactions on Embedded Computing Systems
ISSN:
1539-9087
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Model compression is an important technique to facilitate efficient embedded and hardware implementations of deep neural networks (DNNs), a number of prior works are dedicated to model compression techniques. The target is to simultaneously reduce the model storage size and accelerate the computation, with minor effect on accuracy. Two important categories of DNN model compression techniques are weight pruning and weight quantization. The former leverages the redundancy in the number of weights, whereas the latter leverages the redundancy in bit representation of weights. These two sources of redundancy can be combined, thereby leading to a higher degree of DNN model compression. However, a systematic framework of joint weight pruning and quantization of DNNs is lacking, thereby limiting the available model compression ratio. Moreover, the computation reduction, energy efficiency improvement, and hardware performance overhead need to be accounted besides simply model size reduction, and the hardware performance overhead resulted from weight pruning method needs to be taken into consideration. To address these limitations, we present ADMM-NN, the first algorithm-hardware co-optimization framework of DNNs using Alternating Direction Method of Multipliers (ADMM), a powerful technique to solve non-convex optimization problems with possibly combinatorial constraints. The first part of ADMM-NN is a systematic, joint framework of DNN weight pruning and quantization using ADMM. It can be understood as a smart regularization technique with regularization target dynamically updated in each ADMM iteration, thereby resulting in higher performance in model compression than the state-of-the-art. The second part is hardware-aware DNN optimizations to facilitate hardware-level implementations. We perform ADMM-based weight pruning and quantization considering (i) the computation reduction and energy efficiency improvement, and (ii) the hardware performance overhead due to irregular sparsity. The first requirement prioritizes the convolutional layer compression over fully-connected layers, while the latter requires a concept of the break-even pruning ratio, defined as the minimum pruning ratio of a specific layer that results in no hardware performance degradation. Without accuracy loss, ADMM-NN achieves 85× and 24× pruning on LeNet-5 and AlexNet models, respectively, --- significantly higher than the state-of-the-art. The improvements become more significant when focusing on computation reduction. Combining weight pruning and quantization, we achieve 1,910× and 231× reductions in overall model size on these two benchmarks, when focusing on data storage. Highly promising results are also observed on other representative DNNs such as VGGNet and ResNet-50. We release codes and models at https://github.com/yeshaokai/admm-nn. 
    more » « less
  2. Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) are pervasively used in a significant number of applications and platforms. To enhance the execution efficiency of large-scale DNNs, previous attempts focus mainly on client-server paradigms, relying on powerful external infrastructure, or model compression, with complicated pre-processing phases. Though effective, these methods overlook the optimization of DNNs on distributed mobile devices. In this work, we design and implement MeDNN, a local distributed mobile computing system with enhanced partitioning and deployment tailored for large-scale DNNs. In MeDNN, we first propose Greedy Two Dimensional Partition (GTDP), which can adaptively partition DNN models onto several mobile devices w.r.t. individual resource constraints. We also propose Structured Model Compact Deployment (SMCD), a mobile-friendly compression scheme which utilizes a structured sparsity pruning technique to further accelerate DNN execution. Experimental results show that, GTDP can accelerate the original DNN execution time by 1.86 – 2.44⇥ with 2 – 4 worker nodes. By utilizing SMCD, 26.5% of additional computing time and 14.2% of extra communication time are saved, on average, with negligible effect on the model accuracy. 
    more » « less
  3. Deep neural networks (DNNs) have experienced unprecedented success in a variety of cognitive tasks due to which there has been a move to deploy DNNs in edge devices. DNNs are usually comprised of multiply-and-accumulate (MAC) operations and are both data and compute intensive. In-memory computing (IMC) methodologies have shown significant energy efficiency and throughput benefits for DNN workloads by reducing data movement and eliminating memory reads. Weight pruning in DNNs can further improve the energy/throughput of DNN hardware through reduced storage and compute. Recent IMC works [1]–[3], [6] have not explored such sparse compression techniques unlike ASIC counterparts to enable storage benefits and compute skipping. A recent work [4] attempted to exploit this by compressing weights using a binary map and a custom compression format. This is sub-optimal because the implementation requires a complex routing mechanism (butterfly routing), additional compute to decode compressed weights and has limited flexibility in supporting different sparse encodings. Fig. 1 illustrates our motivations and the challenges for implementing weight compression in digital IMC designs and the need for a new methodology to enable sparse compute directly on compressed weights. In this work, we present a novel sparsity-integrated IMC (SP-IMC) macro in 28nm CMOS which, for the first time, utilizes three popular sparse compression formats, i.e., coordinate representation (COO), run length encoding (RL) and N:m sparsity [7] all along the matrix column direction with tunable precisions. SP-IMC stores and directly processes the sparse compressed weights in the macro, achieving higher storage density, reduction in re-write operations to the macro and higher overall energy efficiency. 
    more » « less
  4. It is appealing but challenging to achieve real-time deep neural network (DNN) inference on mobile devices because even the powerful modern mobile devices are considered “resource-constrained” when executing large-scale DNNs. It necessitates the sparse model inference via weight pruning, i.e., DNN weight sparsity, and it is desirable to design a new DNN weight sparsity scheme that can facilitate real-time inference on mobile devices while preserving a high sparse model accuracy. This paper designs a novel mobile inference acceleration framework GRIM that is General to both convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and that achieves Real-time execution and high accuracy, leveraging fine-grained structured sparse model Inference and compiler optimizations for Mobiles. We start by proposing a new fine-grained structured sparsity scheme through the Block-based Column-Row (BCR) pruning. Based on this new fine-grained structured sparsity, our GRIM framework consists of two parts: (a) the compiler optimization and code generation for real-time mobile inference; and (b) the BCR pruning optimizations for determining pruning hyperparameters and performing weight pruning. We compare GRIM with Alibaba MNN, TVM, TensorFlow-Lite, a sparse implementation based on CSR, PatDNN, and ESE (a representative FPGA inference acceleration framework for RNNs), and achieve up to 14.08× speedup. 
    more » « less
  5. Modern deep neural networks (DNNs) often require high memory consumption and large computational loads. In order to deploy DNN algorithms efficiently on edge or mobile devices, a series of DNN compression algorithms have been explored, including factorization methods. Factorization methods approximate the weight matrix of a DNN layer with the multiplication of two or multiple low-rank matrices. However, it is hard to measure the ranks of DNN layers during the training process. Previous works mainly induce low-rank through implicit approximations or via costly singular value decomposition (SVD) process on every training step. The former approach usually induces a high accuracy loss while the latter has a low efficiency. In this work, we propose SVD training, the first method to explicitly achieve low-rank DNNs during training without applying SVD on every step. SVD training first decomposes each layer into the form of its full-rank SVD, then performs training directly on the decomposed weights. We add orthogonality regularization to the singular vectors, which ensure the valid form of SVD and avoid gradient vanishing/exploding. Low-rank is encouraged by applying sparsity-inducing regularizers on the singular values of each layer. Singular value pruning is applied at the end to explicitly reach a low-rank model. We empirically show that SVD training can significantly reduce the rank of DNN layers and achieve higher reduction on computation load under the same accuracy, comparing to not only previous factorization methods but also state-of-the-art filter pruning methods. 
    more » « less