CONTEXT: To promote circularity in agricultural systems, the utilization of aquatic vegetation for ecological
wastewater treatment is a potential mechanism to capture and upcycle nutrients. Agricultural wastewater is an excellent growing medium for aquatic plants like duckweed, offering opportunities for wastewater treatment and conversion of harvested biomass into bio-based products, including protein-rich livestock feed, which can potentially replace conventional soil-based crops such as alfalfa.
OBJECTIVE: We hypothesize that nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) loadings to the Chesapeake Bay Watershed (CBW) can be reduced via replacing alfalfa cultivation with manure-grown duckweed by: a) reducing excess manure application on agricultural fields; b) reducing synthetic fertilizer application on alfalfa croplands; and c) decreasing the release of fixed N back into the environment from the decomposition of alfalfa crop residue.
METHODS: This study developed an optimization framework to identify locations where alfalfa-to-duckweed
replacement could be theoretically employed to minimize N and P loads into the CBW. A relative effectiveness (RE) indicator representing landscape-specific nutrient delivery capacity was included within the framework. Using county-level data on alfalfa yields, cropping area, and nutrient inputs from alfalfa croplands and
dairy manure, we identified alfalfa cultivation areas that could be removed and replaced with full or partial
duckweed cultivation and land conservation for optimal benefits.
more »
« less
Creating a Circular Nitrogen Bioeconomy in Agricultural Systems through Nutrient Recovery and Upcycling by Microalgae and Duckweed: Past Efforts and Future Trends
Highlights Aquatic vegetation-based nutrient recovery offers an alternate approach for treating agricultural wastewater. Microalgae and duckweed can upcycle waste nutrients into valuable bio-based products. Producing feed, fertilizer, and fuel from manure-grown aquatic vegetation promotes a circular N-bioeconomy. Abstract . The massive amounts of nutrients that are currently released into the environment as waste have the potential to be recovered and transformed from a liability into an asset through photosynthesis, industry insight, and ecologically informed engineering design aimed at circularity. Fast-growing aquatic plant-like vegetation such as microalgae and duckweed have the capacity to enable local communities to simultaneously treat their own polluted water and retain nutrients that underlie the productivity of modern agriculture. Not only are they highly effective at upcycling waste nutrients into protein-rich biomass, microalgae and duckweed also offer excellent opportunities to substitute or complement conventional synthetic fertilizers, feedstocks in biorefineries, and livestock feed while simultaneously reducing the energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions that would otherwise be required for their production and transport to farms. Integrated systems growing microalgae or duckweed on manure or agricultural runoff, and subsequent reuse of the harvested biomass to produce animal feed, soil amendments, and biofuels, present a sustainable approach to advancing circularity in agricultural systems. This article provides a review of past efforts toward advancing the circular nitrogen bioeconomy using microalgae- and duckweed-based technologies to treat, recover, and upcycle nutrients from agricultural waste. The majority of the work with microalgae- and duckweed-based wastewater treatment has been concentrated on municipal and industrial effluents, with <50% of studies focusing on agricultural wastewater. In terms of scale, more than 91% of the microalgae-based studies and 58% of the duckweed-based studies were conducted at laboratory-scale. While the range of nutrient removals achieved using these technologies depends on various factors such as species, light, and media concentrations, 65% to 100% of total N, 82% to 100% of total P, 98% to 100% of NO3-, and 96% to 100% of NH3/NH4+ can be removed by treating wastewater with microalgae. For duckweed, removals of 75% to 98% total N, 81% to 93% total P, 72% to 98% NH3/NH4+, and 57% to 92% NO3- have been reported. Operating conditions such as hydraulic retention time, pH, temperature, and the presence of toxic nutrient levels and competing species in the media should be given due consideration when designing these systems to yield optimum benefits. In addition to in-depth studies and scientific advancements, policies encouraging supply chain development, market penetration, and consumer acceptance of these technologies are vitally needed to overcome challenges and to yield substantial socio-economic and environmental benefits from microalgae- and duckweed-based agricultural wastewater treatment. Keywords: Circular bioeconomy, Duckweed, Manure treatment, Microalgae, Nitrogen, Nutrient recycling, Wastewater treatment.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2033717
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10369082
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of the ASABE
- Volume:
- 65
- Issue:
- 2
- ISSN:
- 2769-3287
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 327 to 346
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Removing excessive nitrate (NO3−) from wastewater has increasingly become an important research topic in light of the growing concerns over the related environmental problems and health issues. In particular, catalytic/electrocatalytic approaches are attractive for NO3− removal, because NO3− from wastewater can be converted to N2 and released back to the atmosphere using renewable H2 or electricity, closing the loop of the global N cycle. However, achieving high product selectivity towards the desirable N2 has proven challenging in the direct NO3−-to-N2 reaction. In this presentation, we will report our finding on unique and ultra-high electrochemical NO3−-to-NO2−activity on an oxide-derived silver electrode (OD-Ag). Up to 98% selectivity and 95% faradaic efficiency of NO2− were observed and maintained under a wide potential window. Benefiting from overcoming the rate-determining barrier of NO3−-to-NO2−during nitrate reduction, further reduction of accumulated NO2− to NH4+ can be well regulated by the cathodic potential on OD-Ag to achieve a faradaic efficiency of 89%. These indicated the potential controllable pathway to the key nitrate reduction products (NO2−or NH4+) on OD-Ag. DFT computations provided insights into the unique NO2−selectivity on Ag electrodes compared with Cu, showing the critical role of a proton-assisted mechanism. Based on the ultra-high NO3−-to-NO2−activity on OD-Ag, we designed a novel electrocatalytic-catalytic combined process for denitrifying real-world NO3−-containing agricultural wastewater, leading to 95+% of NO3− conversion to N2 with minimal NOX gases. In addition to the wastewater treatment process to N2 and electrochemical synthesis of NH3, NO2− derived from electrocatalytic NO3− conversion can serve as a reactive platform for distributed production of various nitrogen products. Our new research progress along this direction will be briefly presented.more » « less
-
Increasingly, circularity indicators for material, energy, and water systems guide circular economy design. While indicators for products made from recycled carbon-based materials are somewhat common, peer indicators for waste nitrogen-derived products are limited. It is important, however, to develop such indicators to guide emerging technologies that transform waste nitrogen into products. In this study, we summarize the nitrogen circularity indicator literature, emphasizing the agricultural and wastewater sectors. Next, we use the Material Circularity Indicator (MCI) developed by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, to quantify the circularity of products made from waste nitrogen in swine manure. We considered four test cases using different technologies to recover nitrogen from the manure. Our analysis indicates that technologies that seem to increase circularity on the surface may not yield a substantial increase in MCI results. Finally, we discuss the strengths and weaknesses of using the MCI for product-level analysis and further developments.more » « less
-
The nitrogen cycle plays a key role biological, energy, environment, and industrial processes. Breaking natural nitrogen cycle is leading to accumulation of reactive nitrogen chemicals in water and atmosphere, therefore, better management of N-cycle has emerged as an urgent research need in energy and environmental science. Removing excessive nitrate (NO3−) from wastewater has increasingly become an important research topic in light of the growing concerns over the related environmental problems and health issues. In particular, catalytic/electrocatalytic approaches are attractive for NO3− removal, because NO3− from wastewater can be converted to N2 and released back to the atmosphere using renewable H2 or electricity, closing the loop of the global N cycle. However, achieving high product selectivity towards the desirable N2 has proven challenging in the direct NO3−-to-N2 reaction. In this presentation, we will report our finding on unique and ultra-high electrochemical NO3−-to-NO2−activity on an oxide-derived silver electrode (OD-Ag). Up to 98% selectivity and 95% faradaic efficiency of NO2− were observed and maintained under a wide potential window. Benefiting from overcoming the rate-determining barrier of NO3−-to-NO2−during nitrate reduction, further reduction of accumulated NO2− to NH4+ can be well regulated by the cathodic potential on OD-Ag to achieve a faradaic efficiency of 89%. These indicated the potential controllable pathway to the key nitrate reduction products (NO2−or NH4+) on OD-Ag. DFT computations provided insights into the unique NO2−selectivity on Ag electrodes compared with Cu, showing the critical role of a proton-assisted mechanism. Based on the ultra-high NO3−-to-NO2−activity on OD-Ag, we designed a novel electrocatalytic-catalytic combined process for denitrifying real-world NO3−-containing agricultural wastewater, leading to 95+% of NO3− conversion to N2 with minimal NOx gases. Importantly, NO2− derived from nitrate may serve as a crucial reactive platform for distributed production of various nitrogen products, such as NO, NH2OH, NH3, and urea.more » « less
-
In a circular nutrient economy, nitrogen and phosphorous are removed from waste streams and captured as valuable fertilizer products, to more sustainably reuse the resources in closed-loops and simultaneously protect receiving aquatic environments from harmful N and P emissions. For nutrient reclamation to be competitive with the existing practices of N fixation and P mining, the methods of recovery must achieve at least comparable energy consumption. This study employed the Gibbs free energy of separation to quantify the minimum energy required to recover various N and P fertilizer products from waste streams of fresh and hydrolyzed urine, greywater, domestic wastewater, and secondary treated wastewater effluent. The comparative advantages in theoretical energy intensities for N and P recovery from nutrient-dense waste streams, such as fresh and hydrolyzed urine, were assessed against the other more dilute sources. For example, compared to reclaiming the nutrients from treated wastewater effluent at centralized wastewater treatment plants, the minimum energy required to recover 1.0 M NH 3(aq) from source-separated hydrolyzed urine can be ≈40–68% lower, whereas recovering KH 2 PO 4(s) from diverted fresh urine can, in principle, be ≈13–34% less energy intensive. The study also evaluated the efficiencies required by separation techniques for the energy demand of N and P recovery to be lower than the current production approaches of the Haber–Bosch process and phosphate rock mining. For instance, the most energetically favorable ammoniacal nitrogen and orthophosphate reclamation schemes, which target hydrolyzed and fresh urine, respectively, require energy efficiencies >7% and >39%. This study highlights that strategic selection of waste stream and fertilizer product can enable the most expedient recovery of nutrients and realize a circular economy model for N and P management.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.13031/ja.14891
