An official website of the United States government
Highlights Aquatic vegetation-based nutrient recovery offers an alternate approach for treating agricultural wastewater. Microalgae and duckweed can upcycle waste nutrients into valuable bio-based products. Producing feed, fertilizer, and fuel from manure-grown aquatic vegetation promotes a circular N-bioeconomy. Abstract . The massive amounts of nutrients that are currently released into the environment as waste have the potential to be recovered and transformed from a liability into an asset through photosynthesis, industry insight, and ecologically informed engineering design aimed at circularity. Fast-growing aquatic plant-like vegetation such as microalgae and duckweed have the capacity to enable local communities to simultaneously treat their own polluted water and retain nutrients that underlie the productivity of modern agriculture. Not only are they highly effective at upcycling waste nutrients into protein-rich biomass, microalgae and duckweed also offer excellent opportunities to substitute or complement conventional synthetic fertilizers, feedstocks in biorefineries, and livestock feed while simultaneously reducing the energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions that would otherwise be required for their production and transport to farms. Integrated systems growing microalgae or duckweed on manure or agricultural runoff, and subsequent reuse of the harvested biomass to produce animal feed, soil amendments, and biofuels, present a sustainable approach to advancing circularity in agricultural systems. This article provides a review of past efforts toward advancing the circular nitrogen bioeconomy using microalgae- and duckweed-based technologies to treat, recover, and upcycle nutrients from agricultural waste. The majority of the work with microalgae- and duckweed-based wastewater treatment has been concentrated on municipal and industrial effluents, with <50% of studies focusing on agricultural wastewater. In terms of scale, more than 91% of the microalgae-based studies and 58% of the duckweed-based studies were conducted at laboratory-scale. While the range of nutrient removals achieved using these technologies depends on various factors such as species, light, and media concentrations, 65% to 100% of total N, 82% to 100% of total P, 98% to 100% of NO3-, and 96% to 100% of NH3/NH4+ can be removed by treating wastewater with microalgae. For duckweed, removals of 75% to 98% total N, 81% to 93% total P, 72% to 98% NH3/NH4+, and 57% to 92% NO3- have been reported. Operating conditions such as hydraulic retention time, pH, temperature, and the presence of toxic nutrient levels and competing species in the media should be given due consideration when designing these systems to yield optimum benefits. In addition to in-depth studies and scientific advancements, policies encouraging supply chain development, market penetration, and consumer acceptance of these technologies are vitally needed to overcome challenges and to yield substantial socio-economic and environmental benefits from microalgae- and duckweed-based agricultural wastewater treatment. Keywords: Circular bioeconomy, Duckweed, Manure treatment, Microalgae, Nitrogen, Nutrient recycling, Wastewater treatment.
more »
« less
Developing product level indicators to advance the nitrogen circular economy
Increasingly, circularity indicators for material, energy, and water systems guide circular economy design. While indicators for products made from recycled carbon-based materials are somewhat common, peer indicators for waste nitrogen-derived products are limited. It is important, however, to develop such indicators to guide emerging technologies that transform waste nitrogen into products. In this study, we summarize the nitrogen circularity indicator literature, emphasizing the agricultural and wastewater sectors. Next, we use the Material Circularity Indicator (MCI) developed by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, to quantify the circularity of products made from waste nitrogen in swine manure. We considered four test cases using different technologies to recover nitrogen from the manure. Our analysis indicates that technologies that seem to increase circularity on the surface may not yield a substantial increase in MCI results. Finally, we discuss the strengths and weaknesses of using the MCI for product-level analysis and further developments.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2033793
- PAR ID:
- 10471672
- Publisher / Repository:
- Elsevier
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Resources, Conservation and Recycling
- Volume:
- 198
- Issue:
- C
- ISSN:
- 0921-3449
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 107167
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
CONTEXT: To promote circularity in agricultural systems, the utilization of aquatic vegetation for ecological wastewater treatment is a potential mechanism to capture and upcycle nutrients. Agricultural wastewater is an excellent growing medium for aquatic plants like duckweed, offering opportunities for wastewater treatment and conversion of harvested biomass into bio-based products, including protein-rich livestock feed, which can potentially replace conventional soil-based crops such as alfalfa. OBJECTIVE: We hypothesize that nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) loadings to the Chesapeake Bay Watershed (CBW) can be reduced via replacing alfalfa cultivation with manure-grown duckweed by: a) reducing excess manure application on agricultural fields; b) reducing synthetic fertilizer application on alfalfa croplands; and c) decreasing the release of fixed N back into the environment from the decomposition of alfalfa crop residue. METHODS: This study developed an optimization framework to identify locations where alfalfa-to-duckweed replacement could be theoretically employed to minimize N and P loads into the CBW. A relative effectiveness (RE) indicator representing landscape-specific nutrient delivery capacity was included within the framework. Using county-level data on alfalfa yields, cropping area, and nutrient inputs from alfalfa croplands and dairy manure, we identified alfalfa cultivation areas that could be removed and replaced with full or partial duckweed cultivation and land conservation for optimal benefits.more » « less
-
Abstract Waste from the human food system includes a large quantity of nutrients that pose environmental and human health risks. If these nutrients can be captured and repurposed, they could potentially offset synthetic fertilizer demands. This study reviews several technologies—including anaerobic digestion, hydrothermal carbonization (HTC), and composting—that can be used to process wastes from the human food system. This study also assesses the quantity of nutrient resources that are available from wastes, including food waste, biosolids, manure, and yard waste. Three geographic scales were analyzed. At a national level in the United States, up to 27% of nitrogen and 33% of phosphorus demands for agriculture could be met with wastes from the human food system, primarily from food waste and biosolids. Some rural localities have a greater potential for circular economies of nutrients in the food system, with the potential to meet 100% of nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer demands using waste nutrients, as in the case of Athens County, Ohio. Benefits of offsetting synthetic fertilizer use with waste nutrients include reduced greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, with up to 64% reduction in GHG emissions per unit of nitrogen fertilizer produced with HTC.more » « less
-
The built environment requires extraction and consumption of enormous quantities of raw materials, water, and energy. While these materials remain in use for several years or decades, growing global populations and aging infrastructure are driving widespread generation of one of the largest and most challenging waste streams to manage. There is growing interest from communities in integrating circular economy (CE) strategies in the context of construction & demolition (C&D) material management. Many approaches for doing so focus on small-scale CE applications like individual products, materials, or projects. However, greater understanding is needed at the city-scale given communities’ complex position at the frontlines of local development, resource consumption, and waste management. This study summarizes the development of an evaluative framework for community-based C&D circularity at a city or regional level. The framework expands upon a mixed methods approach called the Circularity Assessment Protocol (CAP), which integrates aspects of urban metabolism, geospatial analysis, and qualitative research methods to examine plastic waste management in communities. To advance convergent CE research, here, we aim to adapt the CAP framework to C&D. We describe our adaptation of the CAP to C&D through a conceptual review describing research, methods, and strategies related to seven elements of a local CE context: C&D Analytics, Building Material and Design, Community, Use, Collection, End-of-Cycle, and C&D Emissions. This work describes a novel yet preliminary conceptualization for developing a baseline understanding of circular C&D material management and a holistic examination of barriers, affordances, and opportunities for improving city-wide circularity.more » « less
-
A growing global meat demand requires a decrease in the environmental impacts of meat production. Cultured meat (CM) can potentially address multiple challenges facing animal agriculture, including those related to animal welfare and environmental impacts, but existing cost analyses suggest it is hard for CM to match the relatively low costs of conventionally produced meat. This study analyzes literature reports to contextualize CM’s protein and calorie use efficiencies, comparing CM to animal meat products’ feed conversion ratios, areal productivities, and nitrogen management. Our analyses show that CM has greater protein and energy areal productivities than conventional meat products, and that waste nitrogen from spent media is critical to CM surpassing the nitrogen use efficiency of meat produced in swine and broiler land-applied manure systems. The CM nutrient management costs, arising from wastewater treatment and land application, are estimated to be more expensive than in conventional meat production. Overall, this study demonstrates that nitrogen management will be a key aspect of sustainability in CM production, as it is in conventional meat systems.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2023.107167
