skip to main content

Title: A Probabilistic Approach for Estimating the Environmental Impact of Novel Product Concepts
Global concerns about climate change and resource management have escalated the need for sustainable consumer products. In light of this, sustainable design methodologies that supplement the product design process are needed. Current research focuses on developing sustainable design curricula, adapting classical design methods to accommodate environmental sustainability, and sustainability tools that are applicable during the early design phase. However, concurrent work suggests that sustainability-marketed and innovative products still lack a reduction of environmental impact compared to conventional products. Life cycle assessment (LCA) has proven to be an exceptional tool used to assess the environmental impact of a realized product. However, LCA is a reactive tool that does not proactively reduce the environmental impact of novel product concepts. Here we develop a novel methodology, the PeeP method, using historical product LCA data with kernel density estimation to provide an estimated environmental impact range for a given product design. The PeeP method is tested using a series of case studies exploring four different products. Results suggest that probability density estimations developed through this method reflect the environmental impact of the product at both the product and component level. In the context of sustainable design research, the PeeP method is a viable methodology for assessing product design environmental impact prior to product realization. Our methodology can allow designers to identify high-impact components and reduce the cost of product redesign in practice.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
ASME International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers in Engineering Conference
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Sustainability of the adhesives prepared from fossil-based materials has become a growing concern. Thus, replacement of petroleum-based materials by ones derived from renewable resources is pursued as a sustainable strategy for reducing their carbon footprint. Biobased latexes can be widely used as waterborne adhesives if their performance and properties are competitive to those currently available in the market. This work aims to evaluate the performance of latex adhesives with higher biobased content recently developed in our group. For this purpose, plant oil-based vinyl monomers HOSBM and CMM (derived from high oleic soybean oil and camelina oil, respectively) in combination with methyl methacrylate (MMA) and butyl acrylate (BA) were copolymerized using miniemulsion to yield latexes to be tested as adhesives. The MMA (“rigid” fragment) content was kept at 55 wt%, while BA (within remaining 45 wt% of the “soft” fragments) has been gradually replaced by either CMM or HOSBM. The effect of partial substitution of the BA by CMM or HOSBM on adhesive properties was assessed using peel testing (ASTM D 1876-08) on the multiple substrates. Presence of plant oil-based fragments in latex copolymers improves adhesives peel strength on most substrates. Plant oil-based latexes with the maximum content of CMM or HOSBM (up to 45wt %) and their optimal adhesive performance were determined on various carpet and paperboard substrates. Additionally, Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) method was used as a tool to evaluate the environmental performance of the synthesized latex adhesives as well as identify the hotspots in the synthesis of these plant-derived adhesives in their early design stages. LCA of plant oil-based monomers can explain to which extent the sustainability of the biobased latex adhesives can be improved. The authors thank the NSF Industry and University Cooperative Research Center for Bioplastic and Biocomposites for financial support. Thanks to NSF CB2 (1916564) 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract As the building sector faces global challenges that affect urban supplies of food, water and energy, multifaceted sustainability solutions need to be re-examined through the lens of built environments. Aquaponics, a strategy that combines recirculating aquaculture with hydroponics to optimize fish and plant production, has been recognized as one of "ten technologies which could change our lives" by merit of its potential to revolutionize how we feed urban populations. To holistically assess the environmental performance of urban aquaponic farms, impacts generated by aquaponic systems must be combined with impacts generated by host envelopes. This paper outlines the opportunities and challenges of using life cycle assessment (LCA) to evaluate and design urban aquaponic farms. The methodology described here is part of a larger study of urban integration of aquaponics conducted by the interdisciplinary research consortium CITYFOOD. First, the challenges of applying LCA in architecture and agriculture are outlined. Next, the urban aquaponic farm is described as a series of unit process flows. Using the ISO 14040:2006 framework for developing an LCA, subsequent LCA phases are described, focusing on scenario-specific challenges and tools. Particular attention is given to points of interaction between growing systems and host buildings that can be optimized to serve both. Using a hybrid LCA framework that incorporates methods from the building sector as well as the agricultural sector, built environment professionals can become key players in interdisciplinary solutions for the food-water-energy nexus and the design of sustainable urban food systems. 
    more » « less
  3. Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) has long been utilized for decision making about the sustainability of products. LCA provides information about the total emissions generated for a given functional unit of a product, which is utilized by industries or consumers for comparing two products with regards to environmental performance. However, many existing LCAs utilize data that is representative of an average system with regards to life cycle stage, thus providing an aggregate picture. It has been shown that regional variation may lead to large variation in the environmental impacts of a product, specifically dealing with energy consumption, related emissions and resource consumptions. Hence, improving the reliability of LCA results for decision making with regards to environmental performance needs regional models to be incorporated for building a life cycle inventory that is representative of the origin of products from a certain region. In this work, we present the integration of regionalized data from process systems models and other sources to build regional LCA models and quantify the spatial variations per unit of biodiesel produced in the state of Indiana for environmental impact. In order to include regional variation, we have incorporated information about plant capacity for producing biodiesel from North and Central Indiana. The LCA model built is a cradle-to-gate. Once the region-specific models are built, the data were utilized in SimaPro to integrate with upstream processes to perform a life cycle impact assessment (LCIA). We report the results per liter of biodiesel from northern and central Indiana facilities in this work. The impact categories studied were global warming potential (kg CO2 eq) and freshwater eutrophication (kg P eq). While there were a lot of variations at individual county level, both regions had a similar global warming potential impact and the northern region had relatively lower eutrophication impacts. 
    more » « less
  4. ACS (Ed.)
    High functionality of new adhesives based on vinyl monomers from plant oils (POBMs) can be controlled by physico-chemical properties of latexes synthesized from POBMs. This research aims to improve the performance and sustainability of POBM-based latex adhesives. Elaborating on this concept, camelina (CMM) and high oleic soybean oil-based (HOSBM) monomers were incorporated into latex copolymers to evaluate adhesives performance on multiple substrates. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) method was used as a tool to evaluate the environmental performance of the synthesized biobased latex adhesives. Latex adhesives were synthesized from combination of methyl methacrylate (MMA), butyl acrylate (BA) and POBMs at various monomer ratios. The MMA content in monomer mixture was kept at 55 wt%, while BA (within remaining 45 wt% of the feed) has been gradually replaced by POBM in monomer feed, yielding feasible latex adhesive formulations. Latex adhesives performance was evaluated using peel testing (ASTM D 1876-08) on the multiple substrates. Presence of HOSBM and CMM fragments in latex copolymers improves adhesives peel strength on most substrates. It was found that performance of POBM-based adhesives can be improved by varying adhesive consumption. It was shown that the incorporation of POBMs into latex copolymers enhances hardness of the latex films upon formation of latex networks. LCA results demonstrated a positive environmental impact when BA was replaced with POBM leading to a lower toxicity for latex adhesives overall. To address the hotspots pinpointed by conducting the initial LCA a number of strategies were implemented. The environmental performance of the biobased adhesive was improved by synthesizing POBM using 2-Methyl-tetrahydrofuran – an environmentally friendly alternative of widely used solvent tetrahydrofuran. Additionally, monomer washing step was improved by replacing dichloromethane with hexane, a solvent with a relatively lower environmental impact. Finally, comparison of the several monomers used for synthesis of the adhesive showed that POBM had the lowest negative impact on the environment as well as human health in various categories. In summary, the obtained experimental data demonstrate plant-oil based latexes environmental benefits and potential as adhesives as well as their utility for usage on multiple substrates. 
    more » « less
  5. Life cycle impact assessment (LCA) provides a better understanding of the energy, water, and material input and evaluates any production system’s output impacts. LCA has been carried out on various crops and products across the world. Some countries, however, have none or only a few studies. Here, we present the results of a literature review, following the PRISMA protocol, of what has been done in LCA to help stakeholders in these regions to understand the environmental impact at different stages of a product. The published literature was examined using the Google Scholar database to synthesize LCA research on agricultural activities, and 74 studies were analyzed. The evaluated papers are extensively studied in order to comprehend the various impact categories involved in LCA. The study reveals that tomatoes and wheat were the major crops considered in LCA. The major environmental impacts, namely, human toxicity potential and terrestrial ecotoxicity potential, were the major focus. Furthermore, the most used impact methods were CML, ISO, and IPCC. It was also found that studies were most often conducted in the European sector since most models and databases are suited for European agri-food products. The literature review did not focus on a specific region or a crop. Consequently, many studies appeared while searching using the keywords. Notwithstanding such limitations, this review provides a valuable reference point for those practicing LCA. 
    more » « less