skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Analysis of Driver Behavior in Mixed Autonomous and Non-autonomous Traffic Flows
Autonomous vehicles are expected to improve road safety and efficiency in future transportation systems. A driving simulator study was designed to identify driving styles and the cooperation between human drivers and other AVs. The study captured driver’s following behavior in a fully autonomous driving environment at unsignalized intersections. Participants were asked to make a series of maneuvers (straight through intersection, left turn, and right turn) in two different speed conditions (30, 40 mph) and two different traffic density conditions (with or without other traffic). Analysis of Variance showed that drivers had a significantly larger deviation (defined as the area between two trajectories) during left turn maneuvers when they were traveling at higher speeds. Moreover, the first turning operation had smaller deviation than the second turning operation. The findings have implications for the design of driver-assistance guidance systems in future mixed autonomous and non-autonomous traffic flows.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1739085
PAR ID:
10388282
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting
Volume:
66
Issue:
1
ISSN:
2169-5067
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1447 to 1451
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Zonta, Daniele; Su, Zhongqing; Glisic, Branko (Ed.)
    With the rapid development of smart cities, interest in vehicle automation continues growing. Autonomous vehicles are becoming more and more popular among people and are considered to be the future of ground transportation. Autonomous vehicles, either with adaptive cruise control (ACC) or cooperative adaptive cruise control (CACC), provide many possibilities for smart transportation in a smart city. However, traditional vehicles and autonomous vehicles will have to share the same road systems until autonomous vehicles fully penetrate the market over the next few decades, which leads to conflicts because of the inconsistency of human drivers. In this paper, the performance of autonomous vehicles with ACC/CACC and traditional vehicles in mixed driver environments, at a signalized intersection, were evaluated using the micro-simulator VISSIM. In the simulation, the vehicles controlled by the ACC/CACC and Wiedemann 99 (W99) model represent the behavior of autonomous vehicles and human driver vehicles, respectively. For these two different driver environments, four different transport modes were comprehensively investigated: full light duty cars, full trucks, full motorcycles, and mixed conditions. In addition, ten different seed numbers were applied to each model to avoid coincidence. To evaluate the driving behavior of the human drivers and autonomous vehicles, this paper will compare the total number of stops, average velocity, and vehicle delay of each model at the signalized traffic intersection based on a real road intersection in Minnesota. 
    more » « less
  2. Zonta, Daniele; Su, Zhongqing; Glisic, Branko (Ed.)
    Recent developments in autonomous vehicle (AV) or connected AVs (CAVs) technology have led to predictions that fully self-driven vehicles could completely change the transportation network over the next decades. However, at this stage, AVs and CAVs are still in the development stage which requires various trails in the field and machine learning through autonomous driving miles on real road networks. Until the complete market adoption of autonomous technology, a long transition period of coexistence between conventional and autonomous cars would exist. It is important to study and develop the expected driving behavior of future autonomous cars and the traffic simulation platforms provide an opportunity for researchers and technology developers to implement and assess the different behaviors of self-driving vehicle technology before launching it to the actual ground. This study utilizes PTV VISSIM microsimulation platform to evaluate the mobility performance of unmanned vehicles at a 4-way signalized traffic intersection. The software contains three different AV-ready driving logics such as AV-cautious, AV-normal, and AV-aggressive which were tested against the performance of the conventional vehicles, and the results of the study revealed that the overall network operational performance improves with the progressive introduction of AVs using AV-normal, and AV-aggressive driving behaviors while the AV-cautious driving behavior stays conservative and deteriorates the traffic performance. 
    more » « less
  3. Adults aged 65 years and older are the fastest growing age group worldwide. Future autonomous vehicles may help to support the mobility of older individuals; however, these cars will not be widely available for several decades and current semi-autonomous vehicles often require manual takeover in unusual driving conditions. In these situations, the vehicle issues a takeover request in any uni-, bi- or trimodal combination of visual, auditory, or tactile alerts to signify the need for manual intervention. However, to date, it is not clear whether age-related differences exist in the perceived ease of detecting these alerts. Also, the extent to which engagement in non-driving-related tasks affects this perception in younger and older drivers is not known. Therefore, the goal of this study was to examine the effects of age on the ease of perceiving takeover requests in different sensory channels and on attention allocation during conditional driving automation. Twenty-four younger and 24 older adults drove a simulated SAE Level 3 vehicle under three conditions: baseline, while performing a non-driving-related task, and while engaged in a driving-related task, and were asked to rate the ease of detecting uni-, bi- or trimodal combinations of visual, auditory, or tactile signals. Both age groups found the trimodal alert to be the easiest to detect. Also, older adults focused more on the road than the secondary task compared to younger drivers. Findings may inform the development of next-generation of autonomous vehicle systems to be safe for a wide range of age groups. 
    more » « less
  4. Driving in foggy conditions poses high risks to road users due to the reduction of visibility, affecting the drivers’ vision and perception, and making changes in driving behavior, which is one of the most important factors affecting vehicular emissions and fuel consumption. This study analyzes the PTV VISSIM traffic microsimulation outputs for exhaust emissions and fuel consumption of vehicles simulated under adverse weather conditions. This weather-dependent simulation is developed by using the advanced psychophysical car-following model “Wiedemann’s 99,” to flexibly control the driving behavior parameters in various driving conditions. Results show that vehicles under foggy conditions consume more fuel and produce more emissions in comparison with clear sky conditions and other scenarios. With the transition of current cities to smart sustainable cities and by introducing automated vehicles (AVs) to the traditional traffic network and gradually increasing their penetration rate, negative environmental impacts of driving under foggy conditions will be reduced, and improvement in overall mobility of a shared network of autonomous and human-driven is observable. 
    more » « less
  5. This paper explores the challenges in developing an inexpensive on-bicycle sensing system to track vehicles at a traffic intersection. In particular, opposing traffic with vehicles that can travel straight or turn left are considered. The estimated vehicle trajectories can be used for collision prevention between bicycles and left-turning vehicles. A compact solid-state 2-D low-density Lidar is mounted at the front of a bicycle to obtain distance measurements from vehicles. Vehicle tracking can be achieved by clustering based approaches for assigning measurement points to individual vehicles, introducing a correction term for position measurement refinement, and by exploiting data association and interacting multiple model Kalman filtering approaches for multi-target tracking. The tracking performance of the developed system is evaluated by both simulation and experimental results. Two types of scenarios that involve straight driving and left turning vehicles are considered. Experimental results show that the developed system can successfully track cars in these scenarios accurately in spite of the low measurement density of the sensor. 
    more » « less