Title: Resident perceptions of riverbank erosion and shoreline protection: a mixed-methods case study from Bangladesh
Abstract Riverbank erosion is a common hazard in Bangladesh, posing a significant threat to homes, properties, and livelihoods. In recent years, the government of Bangladesh has intensified efforts to mitigate riverbank erosion by hardening shorelines, including the building of concrete revetments, but the local dynamics of these interventions are not well documented. To address this, we present results from a study of community-level response to a 2-mile long concrete revetment recently constructed in the administrative district of Ramgati, in the lower Meghna River basin of Bangladesh. Our study combines quantitative analysis of data from a household survey with qualitative data from semi-structured interviews to assess resident perceptions of the new revetment and its effect on the landscape of riverbank erosion hazard. The study finds, firstly, that hazard awareness is widespread but may be influenced by livelihood factors related to the dynamics of displacement and resettlement. Second, we find that that the negative impacts of riverbank erosion vary spatially. Hazard perception in Ramgati is significantly influenced by the physical location of the household, with those residing closer to the river and in unprotected zones north and south of the revetment expressing much greater worry that they will lose their homes, and believing that this will happen much sooner than residents further away or in the zone now protected by the embankment. As an empirically grounded case study, our findings add to the literature on riverbank erosion in Bangladesh and perception studies focused on water-based hazards in similar settings globally. more »« less
Popke, Jeff; Rahman, Mizanur
(, Frontiers in Water)
Mazzonlini, Maurizio
(Ed.)
Delta regions represent unique settings characterized by a combination of dynamic hydrological environments and livelihood opportunity. They are sites of intensive human activity and infrastructure development aimed at managing the environment and ameliorating hazards such as riverbank erosion. In this paper, we present a case study from the Meghna River delta highlighting livelihood dynamics in the context of riverbank erosion and the recent construction of a protective concrete revetment. To account for the hydrological, socioeconomic, and infrastructural dynamics of the delta environment, we characterize our setting as a hydrosocial territory, and we draw from interviews with local residents to document key dimensions of delta life within the Meghna estuary. Our findings show that the delta environment provides opportunity for local residents, but that riverbank erosion has led to significant displacement and is a source of anxiety for many. We also find that both the nature of the hazard and the limited extent of the new embankment have led to an uneven hydrosocial territory characterized by social and spatial inequality. Despite ongoing challenges, our study shows that riverside dwellers are active agents who manage to craft unique hybrid livelihoods from within the Meghna floodplains.
This study investigates coastal erosion, revetment as a shoreline protection strategy, and human perceptions of revetments in the Lower Meghna estuary of the Bangladesh where new revetments were recently constructed. Questions addressed were: (1) How do rates of shoreline change vary over the period 2011–2019? (2) Did new revetments effectively halt erosion and what were the magnitudes of erosion change? (3) How have erosion rates changed for shorelines within 1 km of revetments, and (4) How do households perceive revetments? High-resolution Planet Lab imagery was used to quantify shoreline change rates. Analysis of household survey data assessed human perceptions of the revetment’s desirability and efficacy. Results revealed high rates of erosion for 2011–2019 with declining erosion after 2013. New revetments effectively halted erosion for protected shorelines. Significant spatial trends for erosion rates existed for shorelines adjacent to revetments. Survey respondents overwhelmingly had positive attitudes about a desire for revetment protection; however, upstream respondents expressed a strong majority perception that revetment acts to make erosion worse. Highlights of the research include integration of remote sensing with social science methods, the timing of the social survey shortly after revetment construction, and results showing significant erosion change upstream and downstream of new revetments.
Carrico, Amanda; Donato, Katharine M.
(, ICPSR - Interuniversity Consortium for Political and Social Research)
The Bangladesh Environment and Migration Survey (BEMS) collects detailed retrospective information about migration trips in southwest Bangladesh, including the first, last, and second-to-last to internal destinations, India, and other international destinations. BEMS collects information about the year, origin, destination, and duration of all trips. Furthermore, BEMS includes information on migration and livelihood histories, socioeconomic conditions, agricultural resources and practices, disasters and perceptions about environment, and self-reported health.</p> Dataset 1 is a household-level file with information about household composition, economic and migratory activity of household members, land ownership/usage, business ownership, household environmental perceptions, environmental conditions, agricultural activities, and physical and psychological health/well-being of household members. Dataset 2 is an individual-level file containing details of internal and international migration trips, as well as measures of economic and social activity during those trips. It also contains information provided by household heads, spouses, and other migrants in the household. Dataset 3 is an individual-level data file that provides general demographic information and brief migration history for each member of a surveyed household. It also includes health information for the head of household and spouse.</p> The purpose of the Bangladesh Environment and Migration Survey (BEMS) is to understand patterns and processes of contemporary internal and international migration in Bangladesh. The project derives from a multi-disciplinary research effort that will generate data on the characteristics and behavior of Bangladeshi migrants and non-migrants and the communities in which they live, and examine whether and how environmental stressors (e.g., salinity, riverbank erosion) affect patterns of migration in this region. The household ethnosurvey is administered to self-identified household heads and spouses in randomly selected households. After gathering social, demographic, and economic information on households and their members, interviewers will collect basic information on each person's first, 2nd to last, and last (or most recent) internal and international migration trips. From household heads and spouses, they will compile migration histories and administer a detailed series of questions about a selection of these trips, focusing on economic livelihoods, methods of moving, connections to other migrants, and use of health and school services. In addition to detailed migration histories, the BEMS will collect information about household wealth, physical conditions of households and communities, and perceptions of environmental conditions. It will also gather some self-reported health information about household members, such as recent illnesses, use of health services, height and weight, and diet. The BEMS is closely modeled on the sampling design and ethnosurvey used in the Mexican Migration Project. The BEMS data were collected in 20 research sites from a random sample of 200 households in each site in 2019. BEMS data include a total of 4,000 households in communities broadly covering the southwest region of Bangladesh. Households in southwest Bangladesh. Smallest Geographic Unit: Administrative region For more information about this study, please visit the ISEE Bangladesh project website.</p>
We examined whether floods and cyclones, the shocks that are transient in nature, affect interregional migration differently compared to riverbank erosion that causes loss of lands and thus generates permanent shocks. We tracked Household Income and Expenditure Survey 2000 participants in nine coastal districts of Bangladesh and collected further information in 2015. Our analyses suggest that both transient and permanent shocks induce households to migrate, but the effect is higher for the latter category. Using a difference-in-differences setting, we find that migrants’ income and expenditure increase relative to their counterparts, indicating that facilitating migration may improve welfare in disaster-prone countries.
This is the data used to create the published study of the same name published in the Journal of Hydrology in 2022 (10.1016/j.jconhyd.2022.104068). Shallow (<30 m) reducing groundwater commonly contains abundant dissolved arsenic (As) in Bangladesh. We hypothesize that dissolved As in iron (Fe)-rich groundwater discharging to rivers is trapped onto Fe(III)-oxyhydroxides which precipitate in shallow riverbank sediments under the influence of tidal fluctuations. Therefore, the goal of this study is to compare the calculated mass of sediment-bound As that would be sequestered from dissolved groundwater As that discharges through riverbanks of the Meghna River to the observed mass of As trapped within riverbank sediments. To calculate groundwater discharge, a Boussinesq aquifer analytical groundwater flow model was developed and constrained by cyclical seasonal fluctuations in hydraulic heads and river stages observed at three sites along a 13 km reach in central Bangladesh. At all sites, groundwater discharges to the river year-round but most of it passes through an intertidal zone created by ocean tides propagating upstream from the Bay of Bengal in the dry season. The annualized groundwater discharge per unit width at the three sites ranges from 173 to 891 m2/yr (average 540 m2/yr). Assuming that riverbanks have been stable since the Brahmaputra River avulsed far away from this area 200 years ago and dissolved As is completely trapped within riverbank sediments, the mass of accumulated sediment As can be calculated by multiplying groundwater discharge by ambient aquifer As concentrations measured in 1969 wells. Across all sites, the range of calculated sediment As concentrations in the riverbank is 78–849 mg/kg, which is higher than the observed concentrations (17–599 mg/kg). This discovery supports the hypothesis that the dissolved As in groundwater discharge to the river is sufficient to account for the observed buried deposits of As along riverbanks.
Rahman, Mizanur, Popke, Jeff, and Crawford, Thomas W. Resident perceptions of riverbank erosion and shoreline protection: a mixed-methods case study from Bangladesh. Retrieved from https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10391501. Natural Hazards 114.3 Web. doi:10.1007/s11069-022-05489-3.
Rahman, Mizanur, Popke, Jeff, & Crawford, Thomas W. Resident perceptions of riverbank erosion and shoreline protection: a mixed-methods case study from Bangladesh. Natural Hazards, 114 (3). Retrieved from https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10391501. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-022-05489-3
@article{osti_10391501,
place = {Country unknown/Code not available},
title = {Resident perceptions of riverbank erosion and shoreline protection: a mixed-methods case study from Bangladesh},
url = {https://par.nsf.gov/biblio/10391501},
DOI = {10.1007/s11069-022-05489-3},
abstractNote = {Abstract Riverbank erosion is a common hazard in Bangladesh, posing a significant threat to homes, properties, and livelihoods. In recent years, the government of Bangladesh has intensified efforts to mitigate riverbank erosion by hardening shorelines, including the building of concrete revetments, but the local dynamics of these interventions are not well documented. To address this, we present results from a study of community-level response to a 2-mile long concrete revetment recently constructed in the administrative district of Ramgati, in the lower Meghna River basin of Bangladesh. Our study combines quantitative analysis of data from a household survey with qualitative data from semi-structured interviews to assess resident perceptions of the new revetment and its effect on the landscape of riverbank erosion hazard. The study finds, firstly, that hazard awareness is widespread but may be influenced by livelihood factors related to the dynamics of displacement and resettlement. Second, we find that that the negative impacts of riverbank erosion vary spatially. Hazard perception in Ramgati is significantly influenced by the physical location of the household, with those residing closer to the river and in unprotected zones north and south of the revetment expressing much greater worry that they will lose their homes, and believing that this will happen much sooner than residents further away or in the zone now protected by the embankment. As an empirically grounded case study, our findings add to the literature on riverbank erosion in Bangladesh and perception studies focused on water-based hazards in similar settings globally.},
journal = {Natural Hazards},
volume = {114},
number = {3},
author = {Rahman, Mizanur and Popke, Jeff and Crawford, Thomas W.},
}
Warning: Leaving National Science Foundation Website
You are now leaving the National Science Foundation website to go to a non-government website.
Website:
NSF takes no responsibility for and exercises no control over the views expressed or the accuracy of
the information contained on this site. Also be aware that NSF's privacy policy does not apply to this site.
An official website of the United States government
