skip to main content


Title: Development of a Free-Flight Wind Test Facility Featuring a GNSS Simulator to Achieve Immersive Drone Testing
Weather, winds, thermals, and turbulence pose an ever-present challenge to small UAS. These challenges become magnified in rough terrain and especially within urban canyons. As the industry moves towards Beyond Visual Line of Sight (BVLOS) and fully autonomous operations, resilience to weather perturbations will be key. As the human decision-maker is removed from the in-situ environment, producing control systems that are robust will be paramount to the preservation of any Airspace System. Safety requirements and regulations require quantifiable performance metrics to guarantee a safe aerial environment with ever- increasing traffic. In this regards, the effect of wind and weather disturbances on a UAS and its ability to reject these disturbances present some unique concerns. Currently, drone manufacturers and operators rely on outdoor testing during windy days (or in windy locations) and onboard logging to evaluate and improve the flight worthiness, reliability and perturbation rejection capability of their vehicles. Waiting for the desired weather or travelling to a windier location is cost- and time-inefficient. Moreover, the conditions found on outdoor test sites are difficult to quantify and repeatability is non-existent. To address this situation, a novel testing methodology is proposed, combining artificial wind generation thanks to a multi-fan array wind generator (windshaper), coherent GNSS signal generation and accurate tracking of the test subject thanks to motion capture cameras. In this environment, the drone being tested can fly freely, follow missions and experience wind perturbations whilst staying in a modest indoor volume. By coordinating the windshaper, the motion tracking feedback and the position emulated by the GNSS signal generator with the drone’s mission profile, it was demonstrated that outdoor flight conditions can be reliably recreated in a controlled and repeatable environment. Specifically, thanks to real-time update of the position simulated by the GNSS signal generator, it was possible to demonstrate that the drone’s perception of the situation is similar to a corresponding mission being executed outdoor. In this work, the drone was subjected to three distinct flight cases: (1) hover in 2 m s−1 wind, (2) forward flight at 2 m s−1 without wind and (3) forward flight at 2 m s−1 with 2 m s−1 headwind. In each case, it could be demonstrated that by using indoor GNSS signal simulation and wind generation, the drone displays the characteristics of a 20 m move forward, while actually staying stationary in the test volume, within ±1 m. Further development of this methodology opens the door for fully integrated hardware-in- the-loop simulation of drone flight operations.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2132799
NSF-PAR ID:
10393933
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
AIAA SCITECH 2022 Forum
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. With space more accessible than ever, academic institutions like the University of Colorado (CU) Boulder have exhibited that CubeSats (compact, homogeneous, rectangular satellites with masses below 14 [kg]) can be leveraged for remarkable space missions capable of making significant advances to both scientific and technological fields. One such CubeSat project is the NSF-funded Space Weather Atmospheric Reconfigurable Multiscale Experiment (SWARM-EX), which will launch three 3U CubeSats into a “swarm” that will demonstrate autonomous formation flying capabilities while simultaneously studying the spatial and temporal variability of ion-neutral interactions in the equatorial Ionosphere-Thermosphere region. Although the small stature of CubeSats and their standardized deployer options help to lower unit development cost and facilitate launch opportunities, the physical size limits of CubeSats prove to be a double-edged sword vis-à-vis sustaining a stable power state while hosting instruments with high power demands and often strict pointing requirements. For SWARM-EX, this issue is magnified by the mission’s ambitious goals; to comply with mission requirements, a SWARM-EX spacecraft is required to concurrently (1) point the science instruments no more than 30° off ram when they are operational, (2) point the GNSS patch antenna no more than 30° off zenith when the spacecraft are separated by ≤ 10 [km], (3) point the X-Band patch antenna no more than 18° off boresight from the ground station during downlink, (4) maximize the differential ballistic coefficient during differential drag maneuvers, and (5) maximize solar array power generation at all times. Consequently, advanced CubeSat Missions like SWARM-EX require innovative systems engineering solutions to remain power-positive during on-orbit operations. Through a combination of intricate pointing profiles, orbital simulations, a comprehensive and coordinated ConOps, battery state of charge simulation tools, and expertise from previous CubeSat missions, the SWARM-EX team has conceived a plan to successfully meet all these mission requirements; it is the aim of the authors to illuminate these strategies as a case study. 
    more » « less
  2. We present a model-based approach to estimate the vertical profile of horizontal wind velocity components using motion perturbations of a multirotor unmanned aircraft system (UAS) in both hovering and steady ascending flight. The state estimation framework employed for wind estimation was adapted to a set of closed-loop rigid body models identified for an off-the-shelf quadrotor. The quadrotor models used for wind estimation were characterized for hovering and steady ascending flight conditions ranging between 0 and 2 m/s. The closed-loop models were obtained using system identification algorithms to determine model structures and estimate model parameters. The wind measurement method was validated experimentally above the Virginia Tech Kentland Experimental Aircraft Systems Laboratory by comparing quadrotor and independent sensor measurements from a sonic anemometer and two SoDAR instruments. Comparison results demonstrated quadrotor wind estimation in close agreement with the independent wind velocity measurements. However, horizontal wind velocity profiles were difficult to validate using time-synchronized SoDAR measurements. Analysis of the noise intensity and signal-to-noise ratio of the SoDARs proved that close-proximity quadrotor operations can corrupt wind measurement from SoDARs, which has not previously been reported. 
    more » « less
  3. A reliable command and control (C2) data link is required for unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) operations in order to monitor the status and support the control of UAS. A practical realization of the C2 communication and mission data links for commercial UAS operations is via LTE/5G networks. While the trajectory of each UAS directly determines the flight distance and mission cost in terms of energy dissipation, it also has a strong correlation to the quality of the communication link provided by a serving base station, where quality is defined as the achieved signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) required to maintain the control link of the UAS. Due to signal interference and the use of RF spectrum resources, the trajectory of a UAS not only determines the communication link quality it will encounter, but also influences the link quality of other UAS in its vicinity. Therefore, effective UAS traffic management must plan the trajectory for a group of UAS taking into account the impact to the interference levels of other base stations and UAS communication links. In this paper, an SINR Aware Predictive Planning (SAPP) framework is presented for trajectory planning of UAS leveraging 4G/5G communication networks in a simulated environment. The goal is to minimize flight distance while ensuring a minimum required link quality for C2 communications between UAS and base stations. The predictive control approach is proposed to address the challenges of the time varying SINR caused by the interference from other UAS’s communication. Experimental results show that the SAPP framework provides more than 3dB improvements on average for UAS communication parameters compared to traditional trajectory planning algorithms while still achieving shortest path trajectories and collision avoidance. 
    more » « less
  4. Building insulation materials can affect indoor air by (i) releasing primary volatile organic compounds (VOCs) from building enclosure cavities to the interior space, (ii) mitigating exposure to outdoor pollutants through reactive deposition (of oxidants, e.g. , ozone) or filtration (of particles) in infiltration air, and (iii) generating secondary VOCs and other gas-phase byproducts resulting from oxidant reactions. This study reports primary VOC emission fluxes, ozone (O 3 ) reaction probabilities ( γ ), and O 3 reaction byproduct yields for eight common, commercially available insulation materials. Fluxes of primary VOCs from the materials, measured in a continuous flow reactor using proton transfer reaction-time of flight-mass spectrometry, ranged from 3 (polystyrene with thermal backing) to 61 (cellulose) μmol m −2 h −1 (with total VOC mass emission rates estimated to be between ∼0.3 and ∼3.3 mg m −2 h −1 ). Major primary VOC fluxes from cellulose were tentatively identified as compounds likely associated with cellulose chemical and thermal decomposition products. Ozone-material γ ranged from ∼1 × 10 −6 to ∼30 × 10 −6 . Polystyrene with thermal backing and polyisocyanurate had the lowest γ , while cellulose and fiberglass had the highest. In the presence of O 3 , total observed volatile byproduct yields ranged from 0.25 (polystyrene) to 0.85 (recycled denim) moles of VOCs produced per mole of O 3 consumed, or equivalent to secondary fluxes that range from 0.71 (polystyrene) to 10 (recycled denim) μmol m −2 h −1 . Major emitted products in the presence of O 3 were generally different from primary emissions and were characterized by yields of aldehydes and acetone. This work provides new data that can be used to evaluate and eventually model the impact of “hidden” materials ( i.e. , those present inside wall cavities) on indoor air quality. The data may also guide building enclosure material selection, especially for buildings in areas of high outdoor O 3 . 
    more » « less
  5. Ice-rich permafrost is ground that is frozen all year round for two or more years and contains particularly large amounts of water that will be released upon thawing. This ice is the element of Arctic landscapes most susceptible to climate warming. Nearly 50% of the Arctic has ice-rich permafrost. For example, the upper 4-5 meters of the land along Alaska's northern coast contains an estimated 77% ice. Thawing of ice-rich permafrost affects entire arctic ecosystems and makes the ground unstable to build upon. This dataset consists of an orthomosaic and digital surface model (DSM) derived from drone surveys on 29 August 2021 at the Navigating the New Arctic, Ice-rich Permafrost Systems project field sites, in collaboration with the PermaSense project, in the Prudhoe Bay Oilfields. 2,463 digital images were acquired from a DJI Phantom 4 Real-Time Kinematic (DJI P4RTK) quadcopter with a DJI D-RTK 2 Mobile Base Station. The mapped area was around 232 hectares (ha). The drone system was flown at 100 meters (m) above ground level (agl) and flight speeds varied from 7–8 meters/second (m/s). The orientation of the camera was set to 90 degrees (i.e. looking straight down). The along-track overlap and across-track overlap of the mission were set at 80% and 70%, respectively. All images were processed in the software Pix4D Mapper (v. 4.6.4) using the standard 3D Maps workflow and the accurate geolocation and orientation calibration method to produce the orthophoto mosaic and digital surface model at spatial resolutions of 5 and 10 centimeters (cm), respectively. A Leica Viva differential global positioning system (GPS) provided ground control for the mission and the data were post-processed to WGS84 UTM Zone 6 North in Ellipsoid Heights (meters). Elevation information derived over waterbodies is noisy and does not represent the surface elevation of the feature. 
    more » « less