Introduced by Sadeh et al., the K-star-graph private information retrieval (PIR) problem, so-labeled because the storage graph is a star-graph with K leaf nodes, is comprised of K messages that are stored separately (one-each) at K dedicated servers, and a universal server that stores all K messages, for a total of K + 1 servers. While it is one of the simplest PIR settings to describe, the capacity CK of K-star-graph PIR is open for K ≥ 4. We study the critical K = 4 setting, for which prior work establishes the bounds 2/5 ≤ C4 ≤ 3/7. As our main contribution, we characterize the exact capacity of 4-star-graph PIR as C4 = 5/12, thus improving upon both the prior lower- bound as well as the prior upper-bound. The main technical challenge resides in the new converse bound, whose non-trivial structure is deduced indirectly from the achievable schemes that emerge from the study of a finer tradeoff between the download costs from the dedicated servers versus the universal server. A sharp characterization of this tradeoff is also obtained for K = 4.
more »
« less
The M/M/k with Deterministic Setup Times
Capacity management, whether it involves servers in a data center, or human staff in a call center, or doctors in a hospital, is largely about balancing a resource-delay tradeoff. On the one hand, one would like to turn off servers when not in use (or send home staff that are idle) to save on resources. On the other hand, one wants to avoid the considerable setup time required to turn an ''off'' server back ''on.'' This paper aims to understand the delay component of this tradeoff, namely, what is the effect of setup time on average delay in a multi-server system? Surprisingly little is known about the effect of setup times on delay. While there has been some work on studying the M/M/k with Exponentially-distributed setup times, these works provide only iterative methods for computing mean delay, giving little insight as to how delay is affected by k , by load, and by the setup time. Furthermore, setup time in practice is much better modeled by a Deterministic random variable, and, as this paper shows, the scaling effect of a Deterministic setup time is nothing like that of an Exponentially-distributed setup time. This paper provides the first analysis of the M/M/k with Deterministic setup times. We prove a lower bound on the effect of setup on delay, where our bound is highly accurate for the common case where the setup time is much higher than the job service time. Our result is a relatively simple algebraic formula which provides insights on how delay scales with the input parameters. Our proof uses a combination of renewal theory, martingale arguments and novel probabilistic arguments, providing strong intuition on the transient behavior of a system that turns servers on and off.
more »
« less
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10394264
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Proceedings of the ACM on Measurement and Analysis of Computing Systems
- Volume:
- 6
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 2476-1249
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1 to 45
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
more » « less
We consider large-scale load balancing systems where processing time distribution of tasks depend on both task and server types. We analyze the system in the asymptotic regime where the number of task and server types tend to infinity proportionally to each other. In such heterogeneous setting, popular policies like Join Fastest Idle Queue (JFIQ), Join Fastest Shortest Queue (JFSQ) are known to perform poorly and they even shrink the stability region. Moreover, to the best of our knowledge, in this setup, finding a scalable policy with provable performance guarantee has been an open question prior to this work. In this paper, we propose and analyze two asymptotically delay-optimal dynamic load balancing approaches: (a) one that efficiently reserves the processing capacity of each server for good tasks and route tasks under the Join Idle Queue policy; and (b) a speed-priority policy that increases the probability of servers processing tasks at a high speed. Introducing a novel analytical framework and using the mean-field method and stochastic coupling arguments, we prove that both policies above achieve asymptotic zero queueing, whereby the probability that a typical task is assigned to an idle server tends to 1 as the system scales.
-
In the parallel paging problem, there are p processors that share a cache of size k. The goal is to partition the cache among the processors over time in order to minimize their average completion time. For this long-standing open problem, we give tight upper and lower bounds of ⇥(log p) on the competitive ratio with O(1) resource augmentation. A key idea in both our algorithms and lower bounds is to relate the problem of parallel paging to the seemingly unrelated problem of green paging. In green paging, there is an energy-optimized processor that can temporarily turn off one or more of its cache banks (thereby reducing power consumption), so that the cache size varies between a maximum size k and a minimum size k/p. The goal is to minimize the total energy consumed by the computation, which is proportional to the integral of the cache size over time. We show that any efficient solution to green paging can be converted into an efficient solution to parallel paging, and that any lower bound for green paging can be converted into a lower bound for parallel paging, in both cases in a black-box fashion. We then show that, with O(1) resource augmentation, the optimal competitive ratio for deterministic online green paging is ⇥(log p), which, in turn, implies the same bounds for deterministic online parallel paging.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)In the parallel paging problem, there are $\pP$ processors that share a cache of size $k$. The goal is to partition the cache among the \procs over time in order to minimize their average completion time. For this long-standing open problem, we give tight upper and lower bounds of $\Theta(\log \p)$ on the competitive ratio with $O(1)$ resource augmentation. A key idea in both our algorithms and lower bounds is to relate the problem of parallel paging to the seemingly unrelated problem of green paging. In green paging, there is an energy-optimized processor that can temporarily turn off one or more of its cache banks (thereby reducing power consumption), so that the cache size varies between a maximum size $k$ and a minimum size $k/\p$. The goal is to minimize the total energy consumed by the computation, which is proportional to the integral of the cache size over time. We show that any efficient solution to green paging can be converted into an efficient solution to parallel paging, and that any lower bound for green paging can be converted into a lower bound for parallel paging, in both cases in a black-box fashion. We then show that, with $O(1)$ resource augmentation, the optimal competitive ratio for deterministic online green paging is $\Theta(\log \p)$, which, in turn, implies the same bounds for deterministic online parallel paging.more » « less
-
Data center operators generally overprovision IT and cooling capacities to address unexpected utilization increases that can violate service quality commitments. This results in energy wastage. To reduce this wastage, we introduce HCP (Holistic Capacity Provisioner), a service latency aware management system for dynamically provisioning the server and cooling capacity. Short-term load prediction is used to adjust the online server capacity to concentrate the workload onto the smallest possible set of online servers. Idling servers are completely turned off based on a separate long-term utilization predictor. HCP targets data centers that use chilled air cooling and varies the cooling provided commensurately, using adjustable aperture tiles and speed control of the blower fans in the air handler. An HCP prototype supporting a server heterogeneity is evaluated with real-world workload traces/requests and realizes up to 32% total energy savings while limiting the 99th-percentile and average latency increases to at most 6.67% and 3.24%, respectively, against a baseline system where all servers are kept online.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1145/3570617
