skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Computational Design of Additively Manufactured Curvilinear Scaffolds for Bone Repair
This work introduces a computational method for designing ceramic scaffolds fabricated via direct ink writing (DIW) for maximum bone growth, whereby the deposited rods are curvilinear. A mechanobiological model of bone adaptation is used to compute bone growth into the scaffold, taking into account the shape of the defect, the applied loading, and the density distribution of bone in which the scaffold is implanted. The method ensures smooth, continuously varying rod contours are produced which are ideal for the DIW process. The method uses level sets of radial basis functions to fully define the scaffold geometry with a small number of design variables, minimizing the optimization’s computational cost. Effective elastic and diffusive properties of the scaffold as a function of the scaffold design and the bone density are obtained from previously constructed surrogates. These property surrogates are in turn used to perform bone adaptation simulations of the scaffold-bone system. Design sensitivities of the bone ingrowth within the scaffold are efficiently obtained using a finite difference scheme implemented in parallel. A demonstration of the methodology on a scaffold implanted in a pig mandible is presented. The scaffold is optimized to maximize bone ingrowth with geometric constraints to conform to the manufacturing process.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1727591
PAR ID:
10396286
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference
Volume:
86229
Page Range / eLocation ID:
V03AT03A007
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    Abstract This work introduces a computational method for designing bone scaffolds for maximum bone growth. A mechanobiological model of bone adaptation is used to compute the bone growth, taking into account the shape of the defect, the applied loading, and the existing density distribution of the bone in which the scaffold has been implanted. Numerical homogenization and a geometry projection technique are used to efficiently obtain surrogates of the effective elastic and diffusive properties of the scaffold as a function of the scaffold design and the bone density. These property surrogates are in turn used to perform bone adaptation simulations of the scaffold–bone system for a sampling of scaffold designs. Surrogates of the bone growth in the scaffold at the end of the simulated time and of the strain energy of the scaffold at implantation time are subsequently constructed from these simulations. Using these surrogates, we optimize the design of a scaffold implanted in a rabbit femur to maximize volume bone growth into the scaffold while ensuring a minimum stiffness at implantation. The results of the optimization demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method by showing that maximizing bone growth with a constraint on structural compliance renders scaffold designs with better bone growth than what would be obtained by only minimizing compliance. 
    more » « less
  2. Mears, Laine (Ed.)
    Bone scaffolds are essential in regenerative medicine treatments for bone defects, fractures, and disease. Despite the popularity in bone scaffold research, many challenges still remain including mechanical strength. This study focuses on compression analysis of 10 novel bone scaffold designs with each design created using Rhino 7 with the Grasshopper extension. This coding software took existing scaffold design equations and converted them into 3D models utilizing code based on previous studies. The equations were created by combining and manipulating popular equations used for bone scaffold fabrication. The scaffold models were 3D printed using SimuBone, a PLA biomaterial known for its bone-like properties and printability. The results concluded that Design 6 had the highest compression modulus and mass/density, while Design 9 had a moderate compression modulus and mass/density. Design 8 had the lowest compression modulus and Design 2 had the lowest mass/density. Additionally, Design 6 exhibits the highest stiffness but increased weight, and Design 8 performs the worst in these categories. Therefore, Design 2 was the most optimal for balancing stiffness, mass, and density. The evolution of failure between all 10 designs was also analyzed. This concluded that Design 9 and Design 6 had the highest strength with minimal collapse. Design 8 had the lowest strength with little to no collapse, while Design 2 had medium compression strength with significant collapse. Although Design 2 was found to have significant collapse, it is still considered the most optimal scaffold within this study due to having the best overall mass/density ratio and stiffness modulus with a moderate compression strength. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Recent advances in materials and manufacturing processes have allowed the fabrication of intricate implant surfaces to facilitate bony attachment. However, refinement and evaluation of these new design strategies are hindered by the cost and complications of animal studies, particularly during early iterations in the development process. To address this problem, we have previously constructed and validated an ex-vivo bone bioreactor culture system that can maintain the viability of bone samples for an extended period ex-vivo. In this study, we investigated the mineralization of a titanium wire mesh scaffold under both static and dynamic culturing using our ex vivo bioreactor system. Thirty-six cancellous bone cores were harvested from bovine metatarsals at the time of slaughter and divided into five groups under the following conditions: Group 1) Isolated bone cores placed in static culture, Group 2) Unloaded bone cores placed in static culture in contact with a fiber-mesh metallic scaffold, Group 3) Bone cores placed in contact with a fiber-mesh metallic scaffold under the constant pressure of 150 kPa, Group 4) Bone core placed in contact with a fiber-mesh metallic scaffold and exposed to cyclic loading with continuous perfusion flow of media within the ex-vivo culture system and Group 5) Bone core evaluated on Day 0 to serve as a positive control for comparison with all other groups at weeks 4 and 7. Bone samples within Groups 1–4 were incubated for 4 and 7 weeks and then evaluated using histological examination (H&E) and the Live-Dead assay (Life Technologies). Matrix deposits on the metallic scaffolds were examined with scanning electron microscopy (SEM), while the chemical composition of the matrix was measured using energy-dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDX). We found that the viability of bone cores was maintained after seven weeks of loading in our ex vivo system. In addition, SEM images revealed crystallite-like structures on the dynamically loaded metal coupons (Group 4), corresponding to the initial stages of mineralization. EDX results further confirmed the presence of carbon at the interface and calcium phosphates in the matrix. We conclude that a bone bioreactor can be used as an alternate tool for in-vivo bone ingrowth studies of new implant surfaces or coatings. 
    more » « less
  4. This work proposes a gradient-based method to design bone implants using triply-periodic minimal surfaces (TPMS) of spatially varying thickness to maximize bone in-growth. Bone growth into the implant is estimated using a finite element based mechanobiological model considering the magnitude and frequency of in-vivo loads, as well as the density distribution of the surrounding bone. The wall thicknesses of the implant unit cells are determined via linear interpolation of the thicknesses over a user defined grid of control points, avoiding mesh dependency and providing control over the sensitivity computation costs. The TPMS structure is modeled as a homogenized material to reduce computational cost. Local properties of the implant are determined at run-time on an element-by-element basis using a pre-constructed surrogate model of the TPMS’s physical and geometric properties as a function of the local wall thickness and the density of in-grown bone. Design sensitivities of the bone growth within the implant are computed using the direct sensitivity method. The methodology is demonstrated on a cementless hip, optimizing the implant for bone growth subject to wall thickness constraints to ensure manufacturability and allow cell infiltration. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract Metastatic cancer in bones is incurable, which causes significant mobility and mortality to the patients. In this work, we investigate the role of interstitial fluid flow on cancer cells' growth within the interconnected pores of human bone. In-vitro experiments were carried out in a bio-reactor which includes bone-like scaffold specimens. A pump is used to maintain a laminar flow condition inside the bioreactor to resemble fluid flow in bones. The scaffold specimens are harvested after 23 days in the bioreactor. The scaffold specimen is scanned with Micro-CT under the resolution of 70 micrometers. We created a full-scale 3D computational model of the scaffold based on the micro-CT data using the open-source software Seg3D and Meshmixer. Based on the geometrical models, we generated the computational grids using the commercial software Gridgen. We performed Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations with the immersed boundary method (Gilmanov, Le, Sotiropoulos, JCP 300, 1, 2015) to investigate the flow patterns inside the pores of the scaffolds. The results reveal a non-uniform flow distribution in the vicinity of the scaffold. The flow velocity and the shear stress distributions inside the scaffold are shown to be convoluted and very sensitive to the pore sizes. Our future work will further quantify these distributions and correlate them to cancer cells' growth observed in the experiments. 
    more » « less