skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Physics-Informed Machine Learning for Accelerated Testing of Roll-to-Roll Printed Sensors
Roll-to-roll printing has significantly shortened the time from design to production of sensors and IoT devices, while being cost-effective for mass production. But due to less manufacturing tolerance controls available, properties such as sensor thickness, composition, roughness, etc., cannot be precisely controlled. Since these properties likely affect the sensor behavior, roll-to-roll printed sensors require validation testing before they can be deployed in the field. In this work, we improve the testing of Nitrate sensors that need to be calibrated in a solution of known Nitrate concentration for around 1–2 days. To accelerate this process, we observe the initial behavior of the sensors for a few hours, and use a physics-informed machine learning method to predict their measurements 24 hours in the future, thus saving valuable time and testing resources. Due to the variability in roll-to-roll printing, this prediction task requires models that are robust to changes in properties of the new test sensors. We show that existing methods fail at this task and describe a physics-informed machine learning method that improves the prediction robustness to different testing conditions (≈ 1.7× lower in real-world data and ≈ 5× lower in synthetic data when compared with the current state-of-the-art physics-informed machine learning method).  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1943364 1918483
PAR ID:
10404655
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
International Manufacturing Science and Engineering Conference
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract In the modern industrial setting, there is an increasing demand for all types of sensors. The demand for both the quantity and quality of sensors is increasing annually. Our research focuses on thin-film nitrate sensors in particular, and it seeks to provide a robust method to monitor the quality of the sensors while reducing the cost of production. We are researching an image-based machine learning method to allow for real-time quality assessment of every sensor in the manufacturing pipeline. It opens up the possibility of real-time production parameter adjustments to enhance sensor performance. This technology has the potential to significantly reduce the cost of quality control and improve sensor quality at the same time. Previous research has proven that the texture of the topical layer (ion-selective membrane (ISM) layer) of the sensor directly correlates with the performance of the sensor. Our method seeks to use the correlation so established to train a learning-based system to predict the performance of any given sensor from a still photo of the sensor active region, i.e. the ISM. This will allow for the real-time assessment of every sensor instead of sample testing. Random sample testing is both costly in time and labor, and therefore, it does not account for all of the individual sensors. Sensor measurement is a crucial portion of the data collection process. To measure the performance of the sensors, the sensors are taken to a specialized lab to be measured for performance. During the measurement process, noise and error are unavoidable; therefore, we generated credibility data based on the performance data to show the reliability of each sensor performance signal at each sample time. In this paper, we propose a machine learning based method to predict sensor performance using image features extracted from the non-contact sensor images guided by the credibility data. This will eliminate the need to test every sensor as it is manufactured, which is not practical in a high-speed roll-to-roll setting, thus truely enabling a certify as built framework. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Roll-to-Roll (R2R) printing techniques are promising for high-volume continuous production of substrate-based products, as opposed to sheet-to-sheet (S2S) approach suited for low-volume work. However, meeting the tight alignment tolerance requirements of additive multi-layer printed electronics specified by device resolution that is usually at micrometer scale has become a major challenge in R2R flexible electronics printing, preventing the fabrication technology from being transferred from conventional S2S to high-speed R2R production. Print registration in a R2R process is to align successive print patterns on the flexible substrate and to ensure quality printed devices through effective control of various process variables. Conventional model-based control methods require an accurate web-handling dynamic model and real-time tension measurements to ensure control laws can be faithfully derived. For complex multistage R2R systems, physics-based state-space models are difficult to derive, and real-time tension measurements are not always acquirable. In this paper, we present a novel data-driven model predictive control (DD-MPC) method to minimize the multistage register errors effectively. We show that the DD-MPC can handle multi-input and multi-output systems and obtain the plant model from sensor data via an Eigensystem Realization Algorithm (ERA) and Observer Kalman filter identification (OKID) system identification method. In addition, the proposed control scheme works for systems with partially measurable system states. 
    more » « less
  3. Paper-based analytical devices (PADs) offer a low-cost, user-friendly platform for rapid point-of-use testing. Without scalable fabrication methods, however, few PADs make it out of the academic laboratory and into the hands of end users. Previously, wax printing was considered an ideal PAD fabrication method, but given that wax printers are no longer commercially available, alternatives are needed. Here, we present one such alternative: the air-gap PAD. Air-gap PADs consist of hydrophilic paper test zones, separated by “air gaps” and affixed to a hydrophobic backing with double-sided adhesive. The primary appeal of this design is its compatibility with roll-to-roll equipment for large-scale manufacturing. In this study, we examine design considerations for air-gap PADs, compare the performance of wax-printed and air-gap PADs, and report on a pilot-scale roll-to-roll production run of air-gap PADs in partnership with a commercial test-strip manufacturer. Air-gap devices performed comparably to their wax-printed counterparts in Washburn flow experiments, a paper-based titration, and a 12-lane pharmaceutical screening device. Using roll-to-roll manufacturing, we produced 2700 feet of air-gap PADs for as little as $0.03 per PAD. 
    more » « less
  4. Thermal ablation of materials is a complex phenomenon that involves physical and chemical processes for the thermal protection of systems. However, due to the extreme thermal conditions and moving boundaries, predicting temperature and heat flux at the ablative material is quite challenging. A physics-informed neural network is a promising technique for many such inverse problems, including the prediction of unsteady heat flux. However, traditional physics-informed machine learning algorithms struggle with heat flux predictions in thermal ablation problems due to moving boundary conditions and lack of temperature data in the inaccessible domain. This study presents a hybrid approach, where an artificial neural network (ANN) is used for the accessible domain of the material and a physics-based numerical solution (PNS) technique is used in the inaccessible domain of the material, to find heat flux at the ablative surface. Temperature data at the accessible sensor points are used to train the ANN model. The heat flux at the ablative boundary was iteratively obtained from the numerical solution of the energy equation in the inaccessible domain by matching the ANN-predicted temperature at the last accessible sensor point. Our results indicate that this hybrid methodology significantly outperforms traditional physics-informed machine learning techniques, achieving excellent accuracy in predicting the temperature profiles and heat fluxes under complex conditions for both constant and variable heat flux and properties. By addressing the limitations of conventional physics-informed machine learning methods, our approach provides a robust and reliable solution for modeling the intricate dynamics of ablative processes. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract Roll-to-roll (R2R) printing techniques are promising for high-volume continuous production of substrate-based electronic products, as opposed to the sheet-to-sheet approach suited for low-volume work. However, one of the major challenges in R2R flexible electronics printing is achieving tight alignment tolerances, as specified by the device resolution (usually at micrometer level), for multi-layer printed electronics. The alignment of the printed patterns in different layers, known as registration, is critical to product quality. Registration errors are essentially accumulated positional or dimensional deviations caused by un-desired variations in web tensions and web speeds. Conventional registration control methods rely on model-based feedback controllers, such as PID control, to regulate the web tension and the web speed. However, those methods can not guarantee that the registration error always converges to zero due to lagging problems. In this paper, we propose a Spatial-Terminal Iterative Learning Control (STILC) method combined with PID control to enable the registration error to converge to zero iteratively, which achieves unprecedented control in the creation, integration and manipulation of multi-layer microstructures in R2R processes. We simulate the registration error generation and accumulation caused by axis mismatch between roller and motor that commonly exists in R2R systems. We show that the STILC-PID hybrid control method can eliminate the registration error completely after a reasonable number of iterations. We also compare the performances of STILC with a constant-value basis and a cosine-form basis. The results show that the control model with a cosine-form basis provides a faster convergence speed for R2R registration error elimination. 
    more » « less