skip to main content


Title: A new species of the Ordovician horseshoe crab Lunataspis
Abstract Horseshoe crabs as a group are renowned for their morphological conservatism punctuated by marked shifts in morphology associated with the occupation of non-marine environments and have been suggested to exhibit a consistent developmental trajectory throughout their evolutionary history. Here, we report a new species of horseshoe crab from the Ordovician (Late Sandbian) of Kingston, Ontario, Canada, from juvenile and adult material. This new species provides critical insight into the ontogeny and morphology of the earliest horseshoe crabs, indicating that at least some Palaeozoic forms had freely articulating tergites anterior to the fused thoracetron and an opisthosoma comprising 13 segments.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1943082
PAR ID:
10406035
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Geological Magazine
Volume:
160
Issue:
1
ISSN:
0016-7568
Page Range / eLocation ID:
167 to 171
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Horseshoe crabs (Chelicerata: Xiphosura) are generally considered to exhibit a highly conserved morphology throughout their evolutionary history and are one of the archetypal ‘living fossil’ groups. This narrative has been challenged in recent years, with numerous lines of evidence indicate that horseshoe crabs have been an evolutionarily dynamic lineage, exhibiting several shifts into non-marine environments and associated peaks in rates of evolutionary change. Nevertheless, marine forms are still characterized by a relatively limited morphological variability for most of their evolutionary history, as evidenced by a consistent developmental trajectory shared between species over 250million years. Attempts to ascertain when horseshoe crabs adopted this ontogenetic trajectory are hindered by the sparse early Paleozoic record of the group; only two species, both assigned to the genus Lunataspis, have been described from the Ordovician, and no Silurian species are known. A new, highly aberrant horseshoe crab from the Late Ordovician Big Hill Lagerstätte, Michigan, provides evidence of early morphological experimentation within the group, indicating that even marine lineages were variable early on in their evolutionary history. The new species represents a distinct genus characterized by a greatly elongated prosomal carapace and is represented by two available specimens (with a third held in a private collection), all of which preserve the same highly unusual carapace shape, indicating the unusual morphology to be a genuine characteristic of the species. Geometric morphometric analysis places the new species in an unoccupied region of morphospace distinct to that of other horseshoe crabs, confirming early morphological experimentation within the clade. Interestingly, while the prosoma is markedly different to any other horseshoe crab species known, the thoracetron is similar to that of Lunataspis. Taken in combination with the known ontogeny of Lunataspis borealis, which exhibits the characteristic xiphosurid development of the thoracetron but a more eurypterid-like ontogenetic trajectory of the prosoma, the new species indicates that developmental canalization occurred within the horseshoe crab lineage, with the thoracetron canalizing prior to the prosoma. 
    more » « less
  2. Farms for eastern oyster Crassostrea virginica , which are commonly located along shallow estuarine shores of the eastern USA, use a range of farm equipment and require regular access to care for and harvest oyster livestock. In some cases, these farms are located in areas used by Atlantic horseshoe crabs Limulus polyphemus as they come ashore during spring to spawn. The sandy shores of the Delaware Bay host the largest spawning aggregations of this species in the world. Limited studies have examined interactions between horseshoe crabs and intertidal oyster farms, and concern has been raised about the horseshoe crab’s ability to traverse oyster farms to reach spawning habitat. This study examines potential farm interactions with horseshoe crabs in Delaware Bay during the 2018 and 2019 crab spawning season. Our studies included a range of experiments and surveys during high and low tide to observe crab abundance and behavior at rack-and-bag oyster farm and non-farm sites. In all cases, results indicated that crabs can successfully traverse rack-and-bag farms and reach spawning beaches. Crabs do not differentially use farm versus non-farm areas, and crab behavior is relatively unaltered by farm gear. These results provide important context for developing frameworks for managing ecological interactions among farms and wildlife species of concern. 
    more » « less
  3. A key aspect of geoscience education initiatives is creating engaging programs that inspire future generations to care about the past, present, and future of our planet. Here, we present a lesson plan designed for 6-12 grade students that uses horseshoe crab (Xiphosura) paleobiology as a tool to teach students about paleoecology, phylogenetics and the scientific process. Framed as a criminal investigation, students are placed in groups and briefed as “fossil detectives”, who are tasked with identifying horseshoe crabs and determining their evolutionary and ecological affinities. Students are provided with a guidebook, evidence bags, and a phylogenetic poster with missing blanks for five horseshoe crabs, ranging in age from Ordovician to modern. Students use the fossil evidence bags of associated biota and guidebooks to determine the locality, age, identity, and paleoenvironmental affinity of each xiphosuran suspect. With this newfound data, paired with morphological observations, students then place each of the five horseshoe crab suspects within a time-scaled phylogeny poster. Afterwards, students are prompted to use logical reasoning skills to determine the minimum number of times horseshoe crabs have explored non-marine environments and which common ancestors likely made this transition on the phylogenetic tree. A pre- and post-test are also being developed to measure the outcomes of this lesson plan. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract Aim

    Adult body size often exhibits patterns across large‐scale environmental gradients, creating ecogeographic clines. However, the form of body size clines varies across taxonomic groups, with linear and non‐linear patterns in body size observed in nature. Non‐linear body size clines have received less study, and questions remain about how environmental gradients interact to produce non‐linear clines. We examined the body size of the American horseshoe crab (Limulus polyphemus), a widely distributed marine arthropod, and evaluated the hypothesis that temperature and active season length can interact multiplicatively to result in a dome‐shaped distribution.

    Location

    Fourteen states in the United States of America and three Mexican states, representing the entire geographic range of the species.

    Methods

    We compiled environmental data and body size measurements from more than 49,000 individual horseshoe crabs. For each location, we extracted from the literature or calculated from raw data the mean male prosoma width and the mean female prosoma width. We applied a general additive modelling (GAM) approach to characterize the body size cline, test a hypothesis regarding temperature and season length, and explore evidence for the influence of additional environmental factors.

    Results

    Model results indicate temperature and season length could act multiplicatively to produce dome‐shaped clines, and these findings align with and quantify previous anecdotal reports of a strong dome‐shaped body size cline across latitude for horseshoe crabs.

    Main Conclusions

    Active season length appears to become relatively more influential on horseshoe crab body size in the northern part of their range, while temperature effects per se appear to dominate in southern latitudes. For horseshoe crabs, the pattern of size variation is consistent with the predictions of Optimal Resource Allocation models, but more study is needed to elucidate mechanistic underpinnings. Considering climate change projections, results from our study suggest future shifts in horseshoe crab body sizes.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Crabs are a large subtaxon of the Arthropoda, the most diverse and species-rich metazoan group. Several outstanding questions remain regarding crab diversification, including about the genomic capacitors of physiological and morphological adaptation, that cannot be answered with available genomic resources. Physiologically and ecologically diverse Anomuran porcelain crabs offer a valuable model for investigating these questions and hence genomic resources of these crabs would be particularly useful. Here, we present the first two genome assemblies of congeneric and sympatric Anomuran porcelain crabs, Petrolisthes cinctipes and Petrolisthes manimaculis from different microhabitats. Pacific Biosciences high-fidelity sequencing led to genome assemblies of 1.5 and 0.9 Gb, with N50s of 706.7 and 218.9 Kb, respectively. Their assembly length difference can largely be attributed to the different levels of interspersed repeats in their assemblies: The larger genome of P. cinctipes has more repeats (1.12 Gb) than the smaller genome of P. manimaculis (0.54 Gb). For obtaining high-quality annotations of 44,543 and 40,315 protein-coding genes in P. cinctipes and P. manimaculis, respectively, we used RNA-seq as part of a larger annotation pipeline. Contrarily to the large-scale differences in repeat content, divergence levels between the two species as estimated from orthologous protein-coding genes are moderate. These two high-quality genome assemblies allow future studies to examine the role of environmental regulation of gene expression in the two focal species to better understand physiological response to climate change, and provide the foundation for studies in fine-scale genome evolution and diversification of crabs.

     
    more » « less