An official website of the United States government
Full waveform inversion (FWI) and distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) are powerful tools with potential to improve how seismic site characterization is performed. FWI is able to provide true 2D or 3D images of the subsurface by inverting stress wave recordings collected over a wide variety of scales. DAS can be used to efficiently collect high-resolution stress wave recordings from long and complex fiber optic arrays and is well-suited for large-scale site characterization projects. Due to the relative novelty of combining FWI and DAS, there is presently little published literature regarding the application of FWI to DAS data for near-surface (depths < 30 m) site characterization. We perform 2D FWI on DAS data collected at a well-characterized site using four different, site-specific 1D and 2D starting models. We discuss the unique benefits and challenges associated with inverting DAS data compared to traditional geophone data. We examine the impacts of using the various starting models on the final 2D subsurface images. We demonstrate that while the inversions performed using all four starting models are able to fit the major features of the DAS waveforms with similar misfit values, the final subsurface images can be quite different from one another at depths greater than about 10 m. As such, the best representation(s) of the subsurface are evaluated based on: (1) their agreement with borehole lithology logs that were not used in the development of the starting models, and (2) consistency at shallow depths between the final inverted images derived from multiple starting models. Our results demonstrate that FWI applied to DAS data has significant potential as a tool for near-surface site characterization while also emphasizing the significant impact that starting model selection can have on FWI results.
more »
« less
Using convolutional neural networks to develop starting models for near-surface 2-D full waveform inversion
SUMMARY Non-invasive subsurface imaging using full waveform inversion (FWI) has the potential to fundamentally change near-surface (<30 m) site characterization by enabling the recovery of high-resolution (metre-scale) 2-D/3-D maps of subsurface elastic material properties. Yet, FWI results are quite sensitive to their starting model due to their dependence on local-search optimization techniques and inversion non-uniqueness. Starting model dependence is particularly problematic for near-surface FWI due to the complexity of the recorded seismic wavefield (e.g. dominant surface waves intermixed with body waves) and the potential for significant spatial variability over short distances. In response, convolutional neural networks (CNNs) are investigated as a potential tool for developing starting models for near-surface 2-D elastic FWI. Specifically, 100 000 subsurface models were generated to be representative of a classic near-surface geophysics problem; namely, imaging a two-layer, undulating, soil-over-bedrock interface. A CNN has been developed from these synthetic models that is capable of transforming an experimental wavefield acquired using a seismic source located at the centre of a linear array of 24 closely spaced surface sensors directly into a robust starting model for FWI. The CNN approach was able to produce 2-D starting models with seismic image misfits that were significantly less than the misfits from other common starting model approaches, and in many cases even less than the misfits obtained by FWI with inferior starting models. The ability of the CNN to generalize outside its two-layered training set was assessed using a more complex, three-layered, soil-over-bedrock formation. While the predictive ability of the CNN was slightly reduced for this more complex case, it was still able to achieve seismic image and waveform misfits that were comparable to other commonly used starting models, despite not being trained on any three-layered models. As such, CNNs show great potential as tools for rapidly developing robust, site-specific starting models for near-surface elastic FWI.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2120155
- PAR ID:
- 10412842
- Publisher / Repository:
- Oxford University Press
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Geophysical Journal International
- Volume:
- 231
- Issue:
- 1
- ISSN:
- 0956-540X
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- p. 72-90
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Sinkhole collapse may result in significant property damage and even loss of life. Early detection of sinkhole attributes (buried voids, raveling zones) is critical to limit the cost of remediation. One of the most promising ways to obtain subsurface imaging is 3D seismic full-waveform inversion. For demonstration, a recently developed 3D Gauss-Newton full-waveform inversion (3D GN-FWI) method is used to detect buried voids, raveling soils, and characterize variable subsurface soil/rock layering. It is based on a finite-difference solution of 3D elastic wave equations and Gauss-Newton optimization. The method is tested first on a data set constructed from the numerical simulation of a challenging synthetic model and subsequently on field data collected from two separate test sites in Florida. For the field tests, receivers and sources are placed in uniform 2D surface grids to acquire the seismic wavefields, which then are inverted to extract the 3D subsurface velocity structures. The inverted synthetic results suggest that the approach is viable for detecting voids and characterizing layering. The field seismic results reveal that the 3D waveform analysis identified a known manmade void (plastic culvert), unknown natural voids, raveling, as well as laterally variable soil/rock layering including rock pinnacles. The results are confirmed later by standard penetration tests, including depth to bedrock, two buried voids, and a raveling soil zone. Our study provides insight into the application of the 3D seismic FWI technique as a powerful tool in detecting shallow voids and other localized subsurface features.more » « less
-
Understanding subsurface conditions is critical to creating and maintaining resilient infrastructure systems, such as dams and levees. Seismic geophysical tools can be very effective for site characterization of these structures as they directly measure the elastic moduli and can provide insight into both the soil properties and groundwater conditions. Full waveform inversion (FWI) is one processing option for seismic geophysics that seeks to overcome some of the limitations in the traditional approaches by using the full time-domain recording of the wavefield to develop 2D or 3D profiles of shear wave velocity. In addition to providing characterization data, FWI can also potentially be used as a monitoring tool for dams and levees to assess how elastic moduli are changing with time and to infer how these changes might relate to changes in the hydromechanical properties of the soil. This study seeks to explore the use of seismic FWI as both a characterization and monitoring tool through numerical simulations of seismic surveys on a hypothetical levee with a low velocity anomaly in the foundation. The simulations are used to assess both the spatial resolution and the ability of the simulations to detect changes in properties that might be related to softening of the foundation or development of internal erosion failure modes. The findings from the study will be used to highlight potential benefits and challenges to using seismic FWI for characterization and monitoring of dams and levees.more » « less
-
SUMMARY Full-waveform inversion (FWI) methods rely on accurate numerical simulation of wave propagation in the analysed medium. Acoustic or elastic wave equations are often used to model seismic wave propagation. These types of simulations do not account for intrinsic attenuation effects due to material anelasticity, and thus correction techniques have been utilized in practice to partially compensate the anelasticity. These techniques often only consider the waveform amplitude correction based on averaging of overall amplitude response over the entire data set, and ignore the phase correction. Viscoelastic wave equations account for the anelastic response in both waveform amplitude and phase, and are therefore a more suitable alternative. In this study, we present a novel 3-D Gauss–Newton viscoelastic FWI (3-D GN-VFWI) method. To address the main challenge of the Gauss–Newton optimization, we develop formulas to compute the Jacobian efficiently by the convolution of virtual sources and backward wavefields. The virtual sources are obtained by directly differentiating the viscoelastic wave equations with respect to model parameters. In order to resolve complex 3-D structures with reasonable computational effort, a homogeneous attenuation (Q factor) is used throughout the analysis to model the anelastic effects. Synthetic and field experiments are performed to demonstrate the utility of the method. The synthetic results clearly demonstrate the ability of the method in characterizing a challenging velocity profile, including voids and reverse velocity layers. The field experimental results show that method successfully characterizes the complex substructure with two voids and undulating limestone bedrock, which are confirmed by invasive tests. Compared to 3-D elastic FWI results, the presented viscoelastic method produces more accurate results regarding depths of the voids and bedrock. This study suggests that the improvement of imaging accuracy would warrant the widespread use of viscoelastic wave equations in FWI problems. To our best knowledge, this is the first reported study on 3-D GN-VFWI at any scale. This study provides the new theory and formulation for the use of Gauss–Newton optimization on the 3-D viscoelastic problem.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)SUMMARY Estimation of ambient seismic source distributions (e.g. location and strength) can aid studies of seismic source mechanisms and subsurface structure investigations. One can invert for the ambient seismic (noise) source distribution by applying full-waveform inversion (FWI) theory to seismic (noise) crosscorrelations. This estimation method is especially applicable for seismic recordings without obvious body-wave arrivals. Data pre-processing procedures are needed before the inversion, but some pre-processing procedures commonly used in ambient noise tomography can bias the ambient (noise) source distribution estimation and should not be used in FWI. Taking this into account, we propose a complete workflow from the raw seismic noise recording through pre-processing procedures to the inversion. We present the workflow with a field data example in Hartoušov, Czech Republic, where the seismic sources are CO2 degassing areas at Earth’s surface (i.e. a fumarole or mofette). We discuss factors in the processing and inversion that can bias the estimations, such as inaccurate velocity model, anelasticity and array sensitivity. The proposed workflow can work for multicomponent data across different scales of field data.more » « less
