An official website of the United States government
The visual control of locomotion has been modeled for individual pedestrian behavior; however, this approach has not been applied to collective human behavior, where spontaneous pattern formation is often observed. We hypothesize that an empirical visual model of human locomotion will reproduce the emergent pattern of lanes and stripes observed in crossing flows, when two groups of pedestrians walk through each other at crosswalks or intersections. Mullick, et al. (2022) manipulated the crossing angle between two groups and found an invariant property: stripe orientation is perpendicular to the mean walking direction (i.e. 90˚ to the bisectrix of the crossing angle). Here we determine the combination of model components required to simulate human-like stripes: (i) steering to a goal (Fajen & Warren, 2003), (ii) collision avoidance with opponents (Bai, 2022; Veprek & Warren, VSS 2023), and (iii) alignment with neighbors (Dachner, et al., 2022), together called the SCruM (Self-organized Collective Motion) model. We performed multi-agent simulations of the data from Mullick et al. (2022), using fixed parameters and initial conditions from the dataset. There were two sets of participants (N=36, 38) with 18 or 19 per group. Crossing angle varied from 60˚ to 180˚ (30˚ intervals), with ~17 trials per condition. The minimal model necessary to reproduce stripe formation consists of the goal and collision avoidance components. Mean stripe orientation did not differ from 90˚ to the bisectrix (BF10 < 0.01, decisive). However, the SD of heading during crossing was significantly larger than the human data (p<0.001), whereas the SD of speed was significantly smaller (p<0.001). Thus, the ratio of heading/speed adjustments is lower than previously found, implying the need to reparameterize model components for walking in groups. In sum, steering to a goal and collision avoidance are sufficient to explain stripe formation in crossing flows, while alignment is unnecessary.
more »
« less
Analysis of emergent patterns in crossing flows of pedestrians reveals an invariant of ‘stripe’ formation in human data
When two streams of pedestrians cross at an angle, striped patterns spontaneously emerge as a result of local pedestrian interactions. This clear case of self-organized pattern formation remains to be elucidated. In counterflows, with a crossing angle of 180°, alternating lanes of traffic are commonly observed moving in opposite directions, whereas in crossing flows at an angle of 90°, diagonal stripes have been reported. Naka (1977) hypothesized that stripe orientation is perpendicular to the bisector of the crossing angle. However, studies of crossing flows at acute and obtuse angles remain underdeveloped. We tested the bisector hypothesis in experiments on small groups (18-19 participants each) crossing at seven angles (30° intervals), and analyzed the geometric properties of stripes. We present two novel computational methods for analyzing striped patterns in pedestrian data: (i) an edge-cutting algorithm, which detects the dynamic formation of stripes and allows us to measure local properties of individual stripes; and (ii) a pattern-matching technique, based on the Gabor function, which allows us to estimate global properties (orientation and wavelength) of the striped pattern at a time T . We find an invariant property: stripes in the two groups are parallel and perpendicular to the bisector at all crossing angles. In contrast, other properties depend on the crossing angle: stripe spacing (wavelength), stripe size (number of pedestrians per stripe), and crossing time all decrease as the crossing angle increases from 30° to 180°, whereas the number of stripes increases with crossing angle. We also observe that the width of individual stripes is dynamically squeezed as the two groups cross each other. The findings thus support the bisector hypothesis at a wide range of crossing angles, although the theoretical reasons for this invariant remain unclear. The present results provide empirical constraints on theoretical studies and computational models of crossing flows.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1849446
- PAR ID:
- 10418883
- Editor(s):
- Fu, Feng
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- PLOS Computational Biology
- Volume:
- 18
- Issue:
- 6
- ISSN:
- 1553-7358
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- e1010210
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Nicolas, A; Bain, N; Douin, A; Ramos, O; Furno, A (Ed.)Crossing flows of pedestrians result in collective motions containing self-organized lanes or stripes. Over a wide range of crossing angles, stripe orientation is observed to be perpendicular to the mean walking direction. Here, we test the behavioral components needed to reproduce the lanes and stripes in human data using an empirical, vision-based pedestrian model (Visual SCruM). We examine combinations of (i) steering toward a goal, (ii) collision avoidance, and (iii) alignment (both with and without visual occlusion). The minimal model sufficient to reproduce perpendicular stripes was the combination of a common goal and collision avoidance, although the addition of alignment with occlusion better approximated human heading adjustments. However, the model overestimated the variation in heading and underestimated the variation in speed, suggesting that recalibration of the collision avoidance component is needed.more » « less
-
Romero, V; Segundo-Ortin, M; Wagman, J; Nonaka, T (Ed.)Where does the organization in behavior come from? Ecological psychology seeks to explain adaptive behavior as self-organized, emerging from the dynamics of agent-environment interactions, without assuming such organization a priori. This chapter offers an accessible introduction to the behavioral dynamics approach to modeling perception and action, applied to the case of human locomotion and crowd behavior. Most models of such behavior are ‘omniscient’, presuming accurate knowledge of the environmental state, but we find that information-based ‘visual’ models more closely capture human data. At the individual level, a locomotor trajectory emerges from an agent’s interactions with goals and obstacles, as attractors and repellers appear, shift, and bifurcate. At the dyad level, pedestrian interactions governed by visual control laws yield coordinated movements such as interception, collision avoidance, and following. At the collective level, these local interactions generate human ‘flocking’, crowd bifurcations, and patterns of lanes and stripes in crossing flows of pedestrians. By adopting an empirical, bottom-up, information-based approach, behavioral dynamics helps explain individual and collective behavior as resulting from a process of self-organized pattern formation, without appealing to internal plans or external commands.more » « less
-
We study the modulational dynamics of striped patterns formed in the wake of a planar directional quench. Such quenches, which move across a medium and nucleate pattern-forming instabilities in their wake, have been shown in numerous applications to control and select the wavenumber and orientation of striped phases. In the context of the prototypical complex Ginzburg–Landau and Swift–Hohenberg equations, we use a multiple-scale analysis to derive a one-dimensional viscous Burgers’ equation, which describes the long-wavelength modulational and defect dynamics in the direction transverse to the quenching motion, that is, along the quenching line. We show that the wavenumber selecting properties of the quench determine the nonlinear flux parameter in the Burgers’ modulation equation, while the viscosity parameter of the Burgers’ equation is naturally determined by the transverse diffusivity of the pure stripe state. We use this approximation to accurately characterize the transverse dynamics of several types of defects formed in the wake, including grain boundaries and phase-slips.more » « less
-
Recent statistics reveal an alarming increase in accidents involving pedestrians (especially children) crossing the street. A common philosophy of existing pedestrian detection approaches is that this task should be undertaken by the moving cars themselves. In sharp departure from this philosophy, we propose to enlist the help of cars parked along the sidewalk to detect and protect crossing pedestrians. In support of this goal, we propose ADOPT: a system for Alerting Drivers to Occluded Pedestrian Traffic. ADOPT lays the theoretical foundations of a system that uses parked cars to: (1) detect the presence of a group of crossing pedestrians – a crossing cohort; (2) predict the time the last member of the cohort takes to clear the street; (3) send alert messages to those approaching cars that may reach the crossing area while pedestrians are still in the street; and, (4) show how approaching cars can adjust their speed, given several simultaneous crossing locations. Importantly, in ADOPT all communications occur over very short distances and at very low power. Our extensive simulations using SUMO-generated pedestrian and car traffic have shown the effectiveness of ADOPT in detecting and protecting crossing pedestrians.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1010210
