skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Review of Root-Mean-Square Error Calculation Methods for Large Deployable Mesh Reflectors
In the design of a large deployable mesh reflector, high surface accuracy is one of ultimate goals since it directly determines overall performance of the reflector. Therefore, evaluation of surface accuracy is needed in many cases of design and analysis of large deployable mesh reflectors. The surface accuracy is usually specified as root-mean-square error, which measures deviation of a mesh geometry from a desired working surface. In this paper, methods of root-mean-square error calculation for large deployable mesh reflectors are reviewed. Concept of reflector gain, which describes reflector performance, and its relationship with the root-mean-square error is presented. Approaches to prediction or estimation of root-mean-square error in preliminary design of a large deployable mesh reflector are shown. Three methods of root-mean-square error calculation for large deployable mesh reflectors, namely, the nodal deviation root-mean-square error, the best-fit surface root-mean-square error, and the direct root-mean-square error, are presented. Concept of effective region is introduced. An adjusted calculation of root-mean-square error is suggested when the concept of effective region is involved. Finally, these reviewed methods of root-mean-square error calculation are applied to surface accuracy evaluation of a two-facet mesh geometry, a center-feed mesh reflector, and an offset-feed mesh reflector for demonstration and comparison.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2104237 2335692
PAR ID:
10429979
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Editor(s):
Ghenaiet, Adel
Date Published:
Journal Name:
International Journal of Aerospace Engineering
Volume:
2022
ISSN:
1687-5966
Page Range / eLocation ID:
1 to 18
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Large deployable mesh reflectors are crucial in space applications due to their lightweight and efficient storage characteristics. However, achieving high surface accuracy and managing the significant thermal effects experienced during on-orbit operations remain challenges in deployable mesh reflector design. This paper presents an innovative dynamic thermal modeling methodology for large deployable mesh reflectors, effectively addressing these obstacles. The proposed method considers a comprehensive set of radiation factors including solar, Earth, Albedo, and reflector emissions. This allows for a detailed analysis of dynamic thermal behavior of the reflector, thereby accurately capturing the impact of thermal strains of cable members on surface accuracy. Simulations of a 101-node center-feed parabolic reflecting surface of a deployable mesh reflector indicate that the proposed method can reveal non-uniform temperature distributions, unlike traditional methods that presuppose uniformity. Additionally, the proposed method has proven effective in accurately predicting the root-mean-square error increase of the reflector, typically unobserved in traditional thermal modeling techniques. 
    more » « less
  2. Large deployable mesh reflectors play a critical role in satellite communications, Earth observation, and deep-space exploration, offering high-gain antenna performance through precisely shaped reflective surfaces. Traditional dynamic modeling approaches—such as wave-based and finite element methods—often struggle to accurately capture the complex behavior of three-dimensional reflectors due to oversimplifications of cable members. To address these challenges, this paper proposes a novel spatial discretization framework that systematically decomposes cable member displacements into boundary-induced and internal components in a global Cartesian coordinate system. The framework derives a system of ordinary differential equations for each cable member by enforcing the Lagrange’s equations, capturing both longitudinal and transverse internal displacement of the cable member. Numerical simulations of a two-dimensional cable-network structure and a center-feed parabolic deployable mesh reflector with 101 nodes illustrate the improved accuracy of the proposed method in predicting vibration characteristics across a broad frequency range. Compared to standard finite element analysis, the proposed method more effectively identifies both low- and high-frequency modes and offers robust convergence and accurate prediction for both frequency and transient responses of the structure. This enhanced predictive capability underscores the significance of incorporating internal cable member displacements for reliable dynamic modeling of large deployable mesh reflectors, ultimately informing better design, control, and on-orbit performance of future space-based reflector systems. 
    more » « less
  3. null (Ed.)
    Abstract The ability to deploy a planar surface to a desired convex profile can enhance foldable or morphing airfoils, deployable antennae and reflectors, and other applications where a specific profile geometry is desired from a planar sheet. A model using a system of rigid links joined by torsional springs of tailorable stiffness is employed to create an approximate curved surface when two opposing tip loads are applied. The physical implementation of the model uses compliant torsion bars as the torsion springs. A multidimensional optimization algorithm is presented to minimize the error from the rigid-link approximation and account for additional manufacturing and stress considerations in the torsion bars. A proof is presented to show that equal torsion spring spacing along the horizontal axis of deployed parabolic profiles will result in minimizing the area between the model’s rigid-link approximation and smooth curve. The model is demonstrated through the physical construction of a deployable airfoil surface and a metallic deployable parabolic reflector. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Abstract The ability to deploy a planar surface to a desired convex profile with a simple actuation can enhance foldable or morphing airfoils, deployable antennae and reflectors, and other applications where a specific profile geometry is desired from a planar sheet. A model using a system of rigid links joined by torsional springs of tailorable stiffness is employed to create an approximate curved surface when two opposing tip loads are applied. A system of equations describing the shape of the surface during deployment is developed. The physical implementation of the model uses compliant torsion bars as the torsion springs. A multidimensional optimization algorithm is presented to place joints to minimize the error from the rigid-link approximation and account for additional manufacturing and stress considerations in the torsion bars. A proof is presented to show that equal torsion spring spacing along the horizontal axis of deployed parabolic profiles will result in minimizing the area between the model’s rigid-link approximation and smooth curve. The model is demonstrated through the physical construction of a deployable airfoil surface and a metallic deployable parabolic reflector. 
    more » « less
  5. We have demonstrated the fabrication of a monolithic, 5 m diameter, aluminum reflector with 17.4 µm root-mean-square surface error. The reflector was designed to avoid the problem of pickup due to scattering from panel gaps in a large, millimeter-wavelength telescope that will be used for measurements of the cosmic microwave background. 
    more » « less