skip to main content


Title: Facilitation strength across environmental and beneficiary trait gradients in stream communities
Abstract

Ecosystem engineers modify habitats in ways that facilitate other community members by ameliorating harsh conditions. The strength of such facilitation is predicted to be influenced by both beneficiary traits and abiotic context. One key trait of animals that could control the strength of facilitation is beneficiary body size because it should determine how beneficiaries fit within and exploit stress ameliorating habitat modifications. However, few studies have measured how beneficiary body size relates to facilitation strength along environmental gradients.

We examined how the strength of facilitation by net‐spinning caddisflies on invertebrate communities in streams varied along an elevation gradient and based on traits of the invertebrate beneficiaries. We measured whether use of silk retreats as habitat concentrated invertebrate density and biomass compared to surrounding rock surface habitat and whether the use of retreat habitat varied across body sizes of community members along the gradient.

We found that retreats substantially concentrated the densities of a diversity of taxa including eight different Orders, and this effect was greatest at high elevations. Caddisfly retreats also concentrated invertebrate biomass more as elevation increased. Body size of invertebrates inhabiting retreats was lower than that of surrounding rock habitats at low elevation sites, however, body size between retreats and rocks converged at higher elevation sites. Additionally, the body size of invertebrates found in retreats varied within and across taxa. Specifically, caddisfly retreats functioned as a potential nursery for taxa with large maximal body sizes. However, the patterns of this taxon‐specific nursery effect were not influenced by elevation unlike the patterns observed based on community‐level body size.

Collectively, our results indicate that invertebrates use retreats in earlier life stages or when they are smaller in body size independent of life stage. Furthermore, our analysis suggests that facilitation strength intensifies as elevation increases within stream invertebrate communities.

Further consideration of how trait variation and environmental gradients interact to determine the strength and direction of biotic interactions will be important as species ranges and environmental conditions continue to shift.

 
more » « less
NSF-PAR ID:
10441860
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Wiley-Blackwell
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Animal Ecology
Volume:
92
Issue:
10
ISSN:
0021-8790
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: p. 2005-2015
Size(s):
["p. 2005-2015"]
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Chi Fru, Ernest ; Chik, Alex ; Colwell, Fredrick ; Dittrich, Maria ; Engel, Annette ; Keenan, Sarah ; Meckenstock, Rainer ; Omelon, Christopher ; Purkamo, Lotta ; Weisener, Chris (Ed.)

    Roots are common features in basaltic lava tube caves on the island of Hawai‘i. For the past 50 years, new species of cave-adapted invertebrates, including cixiid planthoppers, crickets, thread-legged bugs, and spiders, have been discovered from root patches in lava tubes on different volcanoes and across variable climatic conditions. Assessing vegetation on the surface above lava tube passages, as well as genetic characterization of roots from within lava tubes, suggest that most roots belong to the native pioneer tree, ‘ōhi‘a lehua (Metrosideros polymorpha). Planthoppers are the primary consumers of sap at the base of the subsurface food web. However, root physicochemistry and rhizobiome microbial diversity and functional potential have received little attention. This study focuses on characterizing the ‘ōhi‘a rhizobiome, accessed from free-hanging roots inside lava tubes. Using these results, we can begin to evaluate the development and evolution of plant-microbe-invertebrate relationships.

    We explored lava tubes formed in flows of differing elevations and ages, from about 140 to 3000 years old, on Mauna Loa, Kīlauea, and Hualālai volcanoes on Hawai‘i Island. Invertebrate diversity was evaluated from root galleries and non-root galleries, in situ fluid physicochemistry was measured, and root and bare rock fluids (e.g., water, sap) were collected to determine major ion concentrations, as well as non-purgeable organic carbon (NPOC) and total nitrogen (TN) content. To verify root identity, DNA was extracted, and three sets of primers were used. After screening for onlyMetrosiderosspp., the V4 region of the 16S rRNA gene was sequenced and taxonomy was assigned.

    Root fluids were viscous and ranged in color from clear to yellow to reddish orange. Root fluids had 2X to 10X higher major ion concentrations compared to rock water. The average root NPOC and TN concentrations were 192 mg/L and 5.2 mg/L, respectively, compared to rock water that had concentrations of 6.8 mg/L and 1.8 mg/L, respectively. Fluids from almost 300 root samples had pH values that ranged from 2.2 to 5.6 (average pH 4.63) and were lower than rock water (average pH 6.39). Root fluid pH was comparable to soil pH from montane wet forests dominated by ‘ōhi‘a (Selmants et al. 2016), which can grow in infertile soil with pH values as low as 3.6. On Hawai‘i, rain water pH averages 5.2 at sea level and systematically decreases with elevation to pH 4.3 at 2500 m (Miller and Yoshinaga 2012), but root fluid pH did not correlate with elevation, temperature, relative humidity, inorganic and organic constituents, or age of flow. Root fluid acidity is likely due to concentrated organic compounds, sourced as root exudates, and this habitat is acidic for the associated invertebrates.

    From 62 root samples, over 66% were identified to the genusMetrosideros. A few other identifications of roots from lava tube systems where there had been extensive clear-cutting and ranching included monkey pod tree, coconut palm,Ficusspp., and silky oak.

    The 16S rRNA gene sequence surveys revealed that root bacterial communities were dominated by few groups, including Burkholderiaceae, as well as Acetobacteraceae, Sphingomonadaceae, Acidobacteriaceae, Gemmataceae, Xanthobacteraceae, and Chitinophagaceae. However, most of the reads could not be classified to a specific genus, which suggested that the rhizobiome harbor novel diversity. Diversity was higher from wetter climates. The root communities were distinct from those described previously from ‘ōhi‘a flowers and leaves (Junker and Keller 2015) and lava tube rocky surfaces (Hathaway et al. 2014) where microbial groups were specifically presumed capable of heterotrophy, methanotrophy, diazotrophy, and nitrification. Less can be inferred for the rhizobiome metabolism, although most taxa are likely aerobic heterotrophs. Within the Burkholderiaceae, there were high relative abundances of sequences affiliated with the genusParaburkholderia, which includes known plant symbionts, as well as the acidophilic generaAcidocellaandAcidisomafrom the Acetobacteraceae, which were retrieved predominately from caves in the oldest lava flows that also had the lowest root pH values. It is likely that the bacterial groups are capable of degrading exudates and providing nutritional substrates for invertebrate consumers that are not provided by root fluids (i.e., phloem) alone.

    As details about the biochemistry of ‘ōhi‘a have been missing, characterizing the rhizobiome from lava tubes will help to better understand potential plant-microbe-invertebrate interactions and ecological and evolutionary relationships through time. In particular, the microbial rhizobiome may produce compounds used by invertebrates nutritionally or that affect their behavior, and changes to the rhizobiome in response to environmental conditions may influence invertebrate interactions with the roots, which could be important to combat climate change effects or invasive species introductions.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Wetlands are critical components of freshwater biodiversity and provide ecosystem services, but human activities have resulted in large‐scale loss of these habitats across the globe. To offset this loss, mitigation wetlands are frequently constructed, but their ability to replicate the functions of natural wetlands remains uncertain. Further, monitoring of mitigation wetlands is limited and often focuses exclusively on vegetation and physical characteristics.

    Wetland fauna are assumed to be present if suitable habitat restoration is achieved, but this assumption is rarely tested. We used the macroinvertebrate community as a proxy for wetland function to compare recently created mitigation wetlands, natural wetlands impacted but not destroyed by road construction activity, and unimpacted reference wetlands along a highway corridor in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Unlike most other studies of invertebrate communities in created wetlands which have occurred in warm climates, our study area has a cold temperate climate with short growing seasons.

    We estimated macroinvertebrate taxonomic richness and used linear models to test for effects of wetland design features (wetland age, isolation, depth, vegetation, size, andpH) on invertebrate richness. We also used non‐metric multidimensional scaling to visualise differences in community composition among wetland types and used indicator species analysis to determine which taxa were causing observed differences.

    Taxonomic richness of macroinvertebrates was lower in created wetlands than impacted or reference wetlands, whereas richness was similar in impacted and reference wetlands. Wetland age was positively correlated with taxonomic richness. The amount of aquatic vegetation in wetlands had the greatest influence on taxonomic richness, so that recently created wetlands with little vegetation had the simplest invertebrate communities. Community composition of invertebrates in created wetlands also differed from community composition in reference and impacted wetlands. Most notably, created wetlands lacked some passive dispersers that were common in other wetland types, although we found no relationship between taxonomic richness and wetland isolation.

    Overall, constructed wetlands had diminished and altered macroinvertebrate communities relative to reference and impacted wetlands, suggesting that periods in excess of 5 years may be required for wetland mitigation projects in cold temperate climates to attain full functionality.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    A widely examined predictive model of invertebrate community dynamics in glacial‐melt streams describes longitudinal changes in community structure with changing water temperature and channel stability with increasing distance from glaciers. Previous studies conducted in Europe, Greenland, New Zealand, and South America have supported the predictions of the invertebrate model and contributed to its refinement. However, none has evaluated if the model fits invertebrate community dynamics over a full range of distances from the glacier and water temperature conditions within glacial‐melt streams in southeast Tibet.

    We sampled invertebrates and measured water temperature, specific conductivity, turbidity, and associated glacier‐related variables within 14 sites in three subalpine glacial‐melt catchments in southeastern Tibet's Three Parallel Rivers region during 2010, 2011, 2013, and 2015. Our sites encompassed a temperature gradient from the upstream metakryal sites (maximum summer water temperature <2°C) to the furthest downstream site (maximum summer temperature >10°C) near the Mekong River.

    We evaluated the relationships of invertebrate community structure with in situ water temperature and channel stability which are the focal habitat variables in the invertebrate model. The additional habitat variables of distance from the glacier, glacier size, conductivity, and turbidity were evaluated to see if these were more important determinants of community structure than in situ water temperature and channel stability.

    Minimum and in situ water temperatures were positively correlated with distance from the glacier but Pfankuch Channel Stability Index bottom scores were not. Thus, the physical template within our study area differed from the expected template of the invertebrate model.

    Similar to the invertebrate model, in situ water temperature by itself or combined with Pfankuch index best explained five invertebrate response variables. In contrast with the invertebrate model, conductivity and turbidity best explained invertebrate taxa richness, density, and the site scores of the first and second detrended correspondence analysis axes of relative abundance.

    The invertebrate model predicts that only Diamesinae will occur in metakryal sites. However, in our metakryal sites we frequently captured 13 taxa (two Nemouridae morphotypes, Diamesinae, Orthocladiinae,Rhyacophila,Epeorus, Taeniopterygidae,Baetis,Capnia, Simuliidae, Limnephilidae,Himalopsyche, and Collembola).

    Invertebrate‐habitat relationships and taxa occurrence trends in glacial‐melt catchments in southeast Tibet differed from the invertebrate model predictions. Our findings highlight the need to develop a regional version of the invertebrate model applicable to Asian glacial‐melt streams with unstable stream channels throughout their catchments and that do not freeze in the winter.

     
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    While many species distributions are shifting poleward or up in elevation in response to a changing climate, others are shifting their habitats along localized gradients in environmental conditions as abiotic conditions become more stressful. Whether species are moving across regional or local environmental gradients in response to climate change, range‐shifting species become embedded in established communities of competitors and predators. The consequences of these shifts for both resident and shifting species are often unknown, as it can be difficult to isolate the effects of multiple species interactions.

    Using a model system of insects in high‐elevation ponds in the Rocky Mountains of Colorado, we sought to disentangle the effects of predation and intraguild interactions on the survival and development of a semi‐permanent pond resident caddisflyLimnephilus externusand the habitat‐shifting caddisAsynarchus nigriculusthat is being forced into semi‐permanent ponds as temporary ponds dry too quickly to complete development.

    We conducted a manipulative in‐situ pond cage experiment in whichL. externusandA. nigriculuscaddisfly larvae in single‐species treatments and together were exposed to the presence/absence of predatoryDytiscusdiving beetle larvae. This approach allowed us to isolate the effects of intraguild interactions and predation on the survival and development of both the resident and habitat‐shifting species.

    We found that intraguild interactions had strong negative effects on the resident and habitat‐shifting species. Intraguild interactions reduced the survival of the residentL. externusand increased the variation in survival of the shiftingA. nigriculus. However,Dytiscuspredators reduced these negative effects, stabilizing the community by increasingL. externussurvival and reducing variation inA. nigriculussurvival. We also found that intraguild interactions reducedL. externusbiomass but resulted in increasedA. nigriculusdevelopment.A. nigriculusdevelopment was also increased by predation.

    Our results show that strong intraguild interactions between resident and shifting species are likely to have negative consequences for both species. However, the presence of predators reduces these negative consequences of the habitat shift on both the resident and the shifting.

     
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Drying intermittent stream networks often have permanent water refuges that are important for recolonisation. These habitats may be hotspots for interactions between fishes and invertebrates as they become isolated, but densities and diversity of fishes in these refuges can be highly variable across time and space.

    Insect emergence from streams provides energy and nutrient subsidies to riparian habitats. The magnitude of such subsidies may be influenced by in‐stream predators such as fishes.

    We examined whether benthic macroinvertebrate communities, emerging adult insects, and algal biomass in permanent grassland stream pools differed among sites with naturally varying densities of fishes. We also manipulated fish densities in a mesocosm experiment to address how fishes might affect colonisation during recovery from hydrologic disturbance.

    Fish biomass had a negative impact on invertebrate abundance, but not biomass or taxa richness, in natural pools. Total fish biomass was not correlated with total insect emergence in natural pools, but orangethroat darter (Etheostoma spectabile) biomass was inversely correlated with emerging Chironomidae biomass and individual midge body size. The interaction in our models between predatory fish biomass and date suggested that fishes may also delay insect emergence from natural pools, altering the timing of aquatic–terrestrial subsidies.

    There was an increase over time in algal biomass (chlorophyll‐a) in mesocosms, but this did not differ among fish density treatments. Regardless, fish presence in mesocosms reduced the abundance of colonising insects and total invertebrate biomass. Mesocosm invertebrate communities in treatments without fishes were characterised by more Chironomidae, Culicidae, and Corduliidae.

    Results suggest that fishes influence invertebrates in habitats that represent important refuges during hydrologic disturbance, hot spots for subsidy exports to riparian food webs, and source areas for colonists during recovery from hydrologic disturbance. Fish effects in these systems include decreasing invertebrate abundance, shifting community structure, and altering patterns of invertebrate emergence and colonisation.

     
    more » « less