skip to main content

Title: Aquatic macroinvertebrate community responses to wetland mitigation in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem

Wetlands are critical components of freshwater biodiversity and provide ecosystem services, but human activities have resulted in large‐scale loss of these habitats across the globe. To offset this loss, mitigation wetlands are frequently constructed, but their ability to replicate the functions of natural wetlands remains uncertain. Further, monitoring of mitigation wetlands is limited and often focuses exclusively on vegetation and physical characteristics.

Wetland fauna are assumed to be present if suitable habitat restoration is achieved, but this assumption is rarely tested. We used the macroinvertebrate community as a proxy for wetland function to compare recently created mitigation wetlands, natural wetlands impacted but not destroyed by road construction activity, and unimpacted reference wetlands along a highway corridor in the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem. Unlike most other studies of invertebrate communities in created wetlands which have occurred in warm climates, our study area has a cold temperate climate with short growing seasons.

We estimated macroinvertebrate taxonomic richness and used linear models to test for effects of wetland design features (wetland age, isolation, depth, vegetation, size, andpH) on invertebrate richness. We also used non‐metric multidimensional scaling to visualise differences in community composition among wetland types and used indicator species analysis to determine which taxa were causing observed differences.

Taxonomic richness of macroinvertebrates was lower in created wetlands than impacted or reference wetlands, whereas richness was similar in impacted and reference wetlands. Wetland age was positively correlated with taxonomic richness. The amount of aquatic vegetation in wetlands had the greatest influence on taxonomic richness, so that recently created wetlands with little vegetation had the simplest invertebrate communities. Community composition of invertebrates in created wetlands also differed from community composition in reference and impacted wetlands. Most notably, created wetlands lacked some passive dispersers that were common in other wetland types, although we found no relationship between taxonomic richness and wetland isolation.

Overall, constructed wetlands had diminished and altered macroinvertebrate communities relative to reference and impacted wetlands, suggesting that periods in excess of 5 years may be required for wetland mitigation projects in cold temperate climates to attain full functionality.

more » « less
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Freshwater Biology
Page Range / eLocation ID:
p. 942-953
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Ecological communities are structured by a combination of local processes like habitat filtering and species interactions, and regional forces driven by the dispersal of organisms between localities on a landscape. Previous studies suggest that the position of local communities within a dispersal network can greatly influence the relative influence of these two sets of processes on community assembly. However, the majority of previous investigations have used models or inferences based on observational data to investigate these hypotheses, while experiments directly addressing this question have been rare.

    We experimentally investigated the relative influence of local and regional processes in structuring benthic invertebrate communities using artificial streams. We manipulated three factors—source pool for the macroinvertebrate community (headwater vs. mainstem) as a surrogate of network location, habitat complexity (high vs. low) in the flume, and dispersal (high vs. low)—and followed changes in macroinvertebrate community structure for 8 weeks.

    Previous research suggests that because headwater (HW) streams are isolated within river networks,HWs are less influenced by regional processes relative to more well‐connected mainstems (MSs). We therefore predicted (i) that flumes colonised from aHWsource community would respond more strongly to our dispersal treatment than those colonised byMScommunities becauseMSwere already largely structured through dispersal‐driven processes, and (ii) that bothHWandMScommunities would respond to manipulations of local habitat, indicating that responses to the dispersal treatment were a direct result of dispersal driven dynamics rather than specific affinity for conditions in the flumes.

    Both of our predictions were strongly supported by the results of the experiment. For flumes withHWsource pools, the high dispersal treatment had significantly higher diversity than low dispersal flumes. However, this difference only occurred in flumes withHWsource pools and did not occur in flumes withMSsources. There was also strong evidence of community composition inHWflumes shifting significantly towards the macroinvertebrate composition in our experimental dispersal treatment. The major effect of experimental dispersal was to introduce new species in fairly low abundances as would be expected from dispersal via drift over a relatively short time. BothMSandHWcolonised flumes showed highly significant signals of habitat filtering, though the influence of specific habitat differed between the source types.

    These results support the hypothesis that dispersal driven processes are a more important structuring force in well‐connected areas of networks by experimentally demonstrating the responsiveness of previously isolated communities to experimentally induced dispersal. They also demonstrate that this responsiveness is not due to an inherent difference in habitat affinity since source communities from bothHWs andMSs responded to manipulation of habitat variables. This experiment only simulated one type of dispersal process in streams—drifting—and did not include simulated dispersal from other sources, nor did it include population dynamics given the relatively short duration of the experiment. Nevertheless, the sensitivity of previously isolated communities to one type of simulated dispersal is a powerful indication of the mechanisms that structure these systems.

    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Wetlands are especially vulnerable to invasive plants because seasonal movements of sediments, water, nutrients, and debris from adjacent terrestrial habitats create ecological conditions suitable for invasion.Lonicera maackiiis a relatively abundant and broadly distributed invasive shrub in the eastern U.S.A., yet few studies have simultaneously tested for effects of its leaf litter on multiple trophic levels within wetland food webs.

    Hatching success, hatchling survival, and hatchling size of tadpoles (Acris crepitans) were assessed using a laboratory mesocosm experiment with no‐leaf, native‐leaf, andL. maackii‐leaf treatments. In the field, short‐term (c. 3 week) and long‐term (c. 2 years) mesocosm experiments assessed the initial and persistent impacts, respectively, ofL. maackiion measures of primary productivity, invertebrate abundance and community structure, and oviposition preference and larval survival of Cope's gray treefrog (Hyla chrysoscelis).

    Exposure of eggs toL. maackiileaves reduced body size at hatching and larval survival of newly hatchedA. crepitans. In short‐term experiments,Lmaackiileaves reduced dissolved oxygen levels, filamentous algal biomass, and macroinvertebrate abundance, and altered macroinvertebrate community structure. In long‐term experiments, duckweed cover was 15× times greater in mesocosms withL. maackiileaf additions. Oviposition by a local population ofH. chrysosceliswas 10× lower in both short‐ and long‐term mesocosms withL. maackiipresent.

    Although ecological impacts ofL. maackiihave been reported for terrestrial systems, our study is the first to demonstrate the simultaneous effects of its leaves on multiple trophic levels within replicated experimental wetlands. The relatively rapid decomposition ofL. maackiileaves, and associated pulse of phenolic compounds, is the most likely proximate mechanism of the bottom‐up effects we observed. The mechanisms, timing, and significance of effects is predicted to vary among natural wetlands.

    Our study demonstrates multiple ecological impacts of a terrestrial invasive shrub within experimental wetlands. Detailed studies on the specific mechanisms, and their spatial and temporal variability in natural systems, will elucidate management strategies and improve the efficiency of wetland conservation efforts.

    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Drying intermittent stream networks often have permanent water refuges that are important for recolonisation. These habitats may be hotspots for interactions between fishes and invertebrates as they become isolated, but densities and diversity of fishes in these refuges can be highly variable across time and space.

    Insect emergence from streams provides energy and nutrient subsidies to riparian habitats. The magnitude of such subsidies may be influenced by in‐stream predators such as fishes.

    We examined whether benthic macroinvertebrate communities, emerging adult insects, and algal biomass in permanent grassland stream pools differed among sites with naturally varying densities of fishes. We also manipulated fish densities in a mesocosm experiment to address how fishes might affect colonisation during recovery from hydrologic disturbance.

    Fish biomass had a negative impact on invertebrate abundance, but not biomass or taxa richness, in natural pools. Total fish biomass was not correlated with total insect emergence in natural pools, but orangethroat darter (Etheostoma spectabile) biomass was inversely correlated with emerging Chironomidae biomass and individual midge body size. The interaction in our models between predatory fish biomass and date suggested that fishes may also delay insect emergence from natural pools, altering the timing of aquatic–terrestrial subsidies.

    There was an increase over time in algal biomass (chlorophyll‐a) in mesocosms, but this did not differ among fish density treatments. Regardless, fish presence in mesocosms reduced the abundance of colonising insects and total invertebrate biomass. Mesocosm invertebrate communities in treatments without fishes were characterised by more Chironomidae, Culicidae, and Corduliidae.

    Results suggest that fishes influence invertebrates in habitats that represent important refuges during hydrologic disturbance, hot spots for subsidy exports to riparian food webs, and source areas for colonists during recovery from hydrologic disturbance. Fish effects in these systems include decreasing invertebrate abundance, shifting community structure, and altering patterns of invertebrate emergence and colonisation.

    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Although most lotic ecosystems experience frequent and sometimes large disturbances, opportunities are uncommon to study primary succession in streams. Exceptions include new stream channels arising from events such as glacial retreat, volcanism, and catastrophic landslides. In 1980, the eruption and massive landslide at Mount St. Helens (WA, U.S.A.) created an entire landscape with five new catchments undergoing primary succession. We asked if riparian and lotic assemblages at early successional stages (36 years after the eruption) showed predictable change along longitudinal gradients within catchments, and whether assemblages were similar among five replicate catchments.

    In July 2016, we collected environmental data and characterised riparian, algal, and benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages at 21 stream reaches distributed within and among five neighbouring catchments. We evaluated patterns of richness, abundance, biomass, multivariate taxonomic community structure, and functional traits both longitudinally and among catchments.

    We found minimal evidence that longitudinal gradients had developed within catchments at 36 years post‐eruption. Increases in diatom and macroinvertebrate richness with downstream distance were the only biological responses with longitudinal trends. Conversely, we documented substantial variation in community structure of riparian plants, soft‐bodied algae, diatoms, and macroinvertebrates at the among‐catchment scale. Among‐catchment differences consistently separated two eastern catchments from three western catchments, and these two groups also differed in stream water chemistry, water temperature, and geomorphology.

    Overall, we documented greater diversity in the young catchments than predicted by ecologists in the years immediately following the eruption, yet functional traits indicate that these catchments are still in relatively early stages of succession. Variation at the among‐catchment scale is likely to be driven in part by hydrological source variation, with the two eastern catchments showing environmental signatures associated with glacial ice‐melt and the three western catchments probably fed primarily by springs from groundwater aquifers. Contemporary flow disturbance regimes also varied among catchments and successional trajectories were probably reset repeatedly in streams experiencing more frequent disturbance.

    Similar to new stream channels formed following glacial retreat, our results support a tolerance model of succession in streams. However, contrasting abiotic templates among Mount St. Helens catchments appear to be driving different successional trajectories of riparian plant, algal, and macroinvertebrate assemblages among neighbouring small catchments sharing the same catastrophic disturbance history.

    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Understanding changes in macroinvertebrate communities is important because they play a large role in stream ecosystem functioning, and they are an important food resource for fish. Beaver‐induced changes to stream morphology could alter macroinvertebrate communities, which in turn could affect food webs and ecosystem function. However, studies investigating the effects of North American beaver activities on macroinvertebrates are rare in the inter‐mountain west, an area with high potential for beaver‐assisted restoration.

    The aim of this study was to quantify differences in the macroinvertebrate community between unaltered segments of streams and within beaver ponds in north‐eastern Utah, U.S.A. We assessed macroinvertebrate species richness, biomass, density, functional feeding group composition, mobility group composition, and macroinvertebrate habitat characteristics to test the hypothesis that macroinvertebrate communities will differ among habitat types (undammed stream segments and beaver ponds) in beaver‐occupied streams.

    Beaver pond communities significantly differed from lotic reach communities in many ways. Beaver ponds were less diverse with 25% fewer species. Although there was variability among streams, in general, beaver ponds had 75% fewer individuals and 90% lower total macroinvertebrate biomass compared to lotic reaches.

    Regarding functional feeding groups, beaver ponds contained more engulfers, while lotic reaches contained more scrapers, filterers, and gatherers. For mobility groups, beaver ponds had more sprawlers, while lotic reaches had more clingers. Swimmers were also more prevalent in lotic reaches, although this is probably due to the abundance ofBaetiswithin lotic reaches. More beaver pond taxa were classified as lentic‐dwelling insects, while more lotic reach taxa were categorised as preferring lotic habitats.

    The creation of ponds by beavers fundamentally altered the macroinvertebrate community in north‐eastern Utah streams. Such changes to stream macroinvertebrate communities suggest that recolonisation of beavers across North America may be altering stream functioning and food webs. Our study highlights the need to further investigate the effects of beaver recolonisation on stream communities.

    more » « less