skip to main content


Title: Frictional Ignition of Metals in High Pressure Oxygen: A Critical Reassessment of NASA Test Data
In this paper we develop a material index for selecting alloys resistant to frictional ignition in high pressure oxygen environments. A previous ignition-resistance metric proposed by NASA WSTF varies strongly and unpredictably with test conditions, thus limiting its usefulness. The material index developed here incorporates key material properties that strongly influence ignition behaviors, including friction coefficient, ignition temperature, and thermal effusivity. Finite element simulations were used to compute ignition temperatures for 15 alloys based on published frictional ignition data from NASA White Sands Testing Facility (WSTF). These values were used with the material index to construct property diagrams for ranking the materials based on their intrinsic frictional ignition resistance. The results demonstrate that nickel-based superalloys with low iron content are less likely to ignite under frictional heating than ferrous alloys and nickel-based superalloys with high content iron. The material index is then used to predict material performance outside of the test conditions, highlighting the effect of ambient temperature on nominal ignition resistance. We conclude by developing an empirical relation between ignition temperature and enthalpy of oxidation which can guide design of new ignition-resistant alloys.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2004913
NSF-PAR ID:
10454089
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
AIAA Scitech 2023
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Gamma-prime strengthened Co–Al–W-based superalloys offer a unique combination of weldability, mechanical strength, creep resistance, and environmental resistance at temperature—leading many to consider the system as an alternative to nickel-base superalloys for future generation turbine engine hardware. However, little information exists regarding the deformation processing required to turn these novel alloys into useable product forms with appropriate microstructure refinement. Supersolvus thermomechanical processing sequences were successfully demonstrated using right-cylindrical upset specimens for two wrought γ′-strengthened cobalt-base superalloys at industrially relevant temperatures and deformation rates. Hot flow behavior and microstructure evolution were quantitatively characterized and compared to available information on a legacy nickel-base system, Waspaloy. Further, density functional theory was used to explore the compositional dependency of the intrinsic material properties influencing single-phase hot working behavior of model Ni–Al binary and Co–Al–W ternary systems. The apparent similarity in the supersolvus thermomechanical processing behavior of Co–Al–W-base systems and their two-phase γ–γ′ Ni-base counterparts suggests conventional pathways, models, and equipment may be leveraged to speed transition and implementation of wrought Co–Al–W-base alloys for components where their properties may be advantageous. 
    more » « less
  2. Nickel-based superalloys (Ni-alloys) are widely used in flight-critical aeroengine components because of their excellent material properties at high temperatures such as yield strength, ductility, and creep resistance. However, these desirable high-temperature properties also make Ni-alloys very difficult to machine. This paper provides an overview and benchmarking of various constitutive models to provide the process modeling community with an objective comparison between various calibrated material models, to increase the accuracy of process model predictions for machining of Ni-alloys. Various studies involving the Johnson-Cook model and the calibration of its constants in finite element simulations are discussed. Significant discrepancies exist between researchers' approaches to calibrating constitutive models. Moreover, this paper provides a comprehensive overview of pedigreed physical material properties for a range of Ni-alloys. In this context, the variation of thermal properties and thermally induced stresses over machining temperature regimes are modeled for a variety of Ni-alloys. The chemical compositions and applications for a range of relevant Ni-alloys are also explored. Overall, this manuscript identifies the need for more comprehensive analysis and process-specific characterization of thermomechanical properties for difficult-to-machine Ni-alloys to improve machining performance and aeroengine component quality. 
    more » « less
  3. This study investigates the application of electroless nickel deposition on additively manufactured stainless steel samples. Current additive manufacturing (AM) technologies produce metal components with a rough surface. Rough surfaces generally exhibit fatigue characteristics, increasing the probability of initiating a crack or fracture to the printed part. For this reason, the direct use of as-produced parts in a finished product cannot be actualized, which presents a challenge. Post-processing of the AM parts is therefore required to smoothen the surface. This study analyzes chempolish (CP) and electropolish (EP) surface finishing techniques for post-processing AM stainless steel components CP has a great advantage in creating uniform, smooth surfaces regardless of size or part geometry EP creates an extremely smooth surface, which reduces the surface roughness to the sub-micrometer level.

    In this study, we also investigate nickel deposition on EP, CP, and as-built AM components using electroless nickel solutions. Electroless nickel plating is a method of alloy treatment designed to increase manufactured component’s hardness and surface resistance to the unrelenting environment. The electroless nickel plating process is more straightforward than its counterpart electroplating. We use low-phosphorus (2–5% P), medium-phosphorus (6–9% P), and high-phosphorus (10–13% P). These Ni deposition experiments were optimized using the L9 Taguchi design of experiments (TDOE), which compromises the prosperous content in the solution, surface finish, plane of the geometry, and bath temperature. The pre- and post-processed surface of the AM parts was characterized by KEYENCE Digital MicroscopeVHX-7000 and Phenom XL Desktop SEM. The experimental results show that electroless nickel deposition produces uniform Ni coating on the additively manufactured components up to 20 μm per hour. Mechanical properties of as-built and Ni coated AM samples were analyzed by applying a standard 10 N scratch test. Nickel coated AM samples were up to two times scratch resistant compared to the as-built samples. This study suggests electroless nickel plating is a robust viable option for surface hardening and finishing AM components for various applications and operating conditions. 

    more » « less
  4. Selective laser melting (SLM) is one of the most widely used additive manufacturing technologies. Fabricating nickel-based superalloys with SLM has garnered significant interest from the industry and the research community alike due to the excellent high temperature properties and thermal stability exhibited by the alloys. Haynes-282 alloy, a γ′-phase strengthened Ni-based superalloy, has shown good high temperature mechanical properties comparable to alloys like R-41, Waspaloy, and 263 alloy but with better fabricability. A study and comparison of the effect of different heat-treatment routes on microstructure and mechanical property evolution of Haynes-282 fabricated with SLM is lacking in the literature. Hence, in this manuscript, a thorough investigation of microstructure and mechanical properties after a three-step heat treatment and hot isostatic pressing (HIP) has been conducted. In-situ heat-treatment experiments were conducted in a transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to study γ′ precipitate evolution. γ′ precipitation was found to start at 950 °C during in-situ heat-treatment. Insights from the in-situ heat-treatment were used to decide the aging heat-treatment for the alloy. The three-step heat-treatment was found to increase yield strength (YS) and ultimate tensile strength (UTS). HIP process enabled γ′ precipitation and recrystallization of grains of the as-printed samples in one single step. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Additive manufacturing promises a major transformation of the production of high economic value metallic materials, enabling innovative, geometrically complex designs with minimal material waste. The overarching challenge is to design alloys that are compatible with the unique additive processing conditions while maintaining material properties sufficient for the challenging environments encountered in energy, space, and nuclear applications. Here we describe a class of high strength, defect-resistant 3D printable superalloys containing approximately equal parts of Co and Ni along with Al, Cr, Ta and W that possess strengths in excess of 1.1 GPa in as-printed and post-processed forms and tensile ductilities of greater than 13% at room temperature. These alloys are amenable to crack-free 3D printing via electron beam melting (EBM) with preheat as well as selective laser melting (SLM) with limited preheat. Alloy design principles are described along with the structure and properties of EBM and SLM CoNi-base materials.

     
    more » « less