skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


  • NSF Public Access
  • Search Results
  • The Importance of Situational Awareness in Future Construction Work: Toward the Effects of Faulty Robot, Trust, and Time Pressure
Title: The Importance of Situational Awareness in Future Construction Work: Toward the Effects of Faulty Robot, Trust, and Time Pressure
Introducing robots to future construction sites will impose extra uncertainties and necessitate workers’ situational awareness (SA) of them. While previous literature has suggested that system errors, trust changes, and time pressure may affect SA, the linkage between these factors and workers’ SA in the future construction industry is understudied. Therefore, this study aimed to fill the research gap by simulating a future bricklaying worker-robot collaborative task where participants experienced robot errors and time pressure during the interaction. The results indicated that robot errors significantly impacted subjects’ trust in robots. However, under time pressure in time-critical construction tasks, workers tended to recover their reduced trust in the faulty robots (sometimes over-trust) and reduce their situational awareness. The contributions of this study lie in providing insights into the importance of SA in future jobsites and the need for investigating effective strategies for better preparing future workers.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2128970
PAR ID:
10469125
Author(s) / Creator(s):
Publisher / Repository:
Reston, VA: American Society of Civil Engineers
Date Published:
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; (, Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering)
    With the construction sector primed to incorporate such advanced technologies as artificial intelligence (AI), robots, and machines, these advanced tools will require a deep understanding of human–robot trust dynamics to support safety and productivity. Although other disciplines have broadly investigated human trust-building with robots, the discussion within the construction domain is still nascent, raising concerns because construction workers are increasingly expected to work alongside robots or cobots, and to communicate and interact with drones. Without a better understanding of how construction workers can appropriately develop and calibrate their trust in their robotic counterparts, the implementation of advanced technologies may raise safety and productivity issues within these already-hazardous jobsites. Consequently, this study conducted a systematic review of the human–robot trust literature to (1) understand human–robot trust-building in construction and other domains; and (2) establish a roadmap for investigating and fostering worker–robot trust in the construction industry. The proposed worker–robot trust-building roadmap includes three phases: static trust based on the factors related to workers, robots, and construction sites; dynamic trust understood via measuring, modeling, and interpreting real-time trust behaviors; and adaptive trust, wherein adaptive calibration strategies and adaptive training facilitate appropriate trust-building. This roadmap sheds light on a progressive procedure to uncover the appropriate trust-building between workers and robots in the construction industry. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; (, Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting)
    The integration of robots, particularly drones, into future construction sites introduces new safety challenges requiring enhanced situational awareness (SA) among workers. To address these challenges, this study explores the effectiveness of an AI-driven assistant designed to inform workers about dynamic environmental changes via auditory and visual channels. A mixed-reality bricklaying experiment was developed, simulating worker-drone interactions across three interaction levels: coexistence, cooperation, and collaboration. One hundred five construction-background students participated in tasks with and without the AI assistant, during which their eye-tracking data, productivity, and subjective perceptions were collected. Results indicated that the AI assistant significantly expedited workers’ awareness of approaching drones but concurrently reduced bricklaying productivity. Although participants reported high perceived usefulness and low distraction by the AI assistant itself, findings revealed a trade-off: improved SA toward drones came at the cost of decreased task performance, likely due to increased attentional shifts toward drones. Furthermore, the effectiveness of the assistant varied depending on the interaction level with drones. This study highlights both the opportunities and challenges of applying AI-driven informational systems in future construction environments, offering critical insights for designing human-centered AI technologies that balance safety enhancement with productivity maintenance. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; (, Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering)
    Because current construction activities are safety-critical and physically demanding, the incorporation of such autonomous technologies as robots and drones via worker–robot teaming has drawn interest from researchers and practitioners alike. However, this teaming relationship may impose additional safety concerns for future jobsites due to workers’ inappropriate trust—overtrust and/or distrust—in robots. The literature has highlighted that trust is a complicated and dynamic concept that fluctuates over time, highlighting the need to continuously understand workers’ trust levels in real-time by collecting and interpreting workers’ psychophysiological signals. Consequently, deep learning (DL) has been deployed in various projects to identify trust-related psychophysiological patterns and to predict trust. However, current implementations suffer from three limitations: (1) focusing only on static settings, (2) manually extracting features, and (3) disregarding the trust continuum. Therefore, this study presents a DL model that automatically extracts important features from multiple psychophysiological signals and predicts workers’ increasing or decreasing trust within such dynamic workplaces as construction sites. The developed model can achieve accuracy, recall, precision, and 𝐹⁢1 score all above 70%. This study also provides insights into a cost-effective strategy to prioritize data with high importance to trust prediction. Thus, the primary innovations of this research are (1) the consideration of the dynamic nature of construction sites, variability among workers, and trust continuum during model development; and (2) how pivotal knowledge about workers’ real-time trust can be harnessed to facilitate the development of human-centered robots in the future. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; (, European Council on Computing in Construction)
    Recent advances in construction automation increased the need for cooperation between workers and robots, where workers have to face both success and failure in human-robot collaborative work, ultimately affecting their trust in robots. This study simulated a worker-robot bricklaying collaborative task to examine the impacts of blame targets (responsibility attributions) on trust and trust transfer in multi-robots-human interaction. The findings showed that workers’ responsibility attributions to themselves or robots significantly affect their trust in the robot. Further, in a multi-robots-human interaction, observing one robot’s failure to complete the task will affect the trust in the other devices, aka., trust transfer. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; (, IISE Transactions on Occupational Ergonomics and Human Factors)
    Background: The increasing prevalence of robots in industrial environments is attributed in part to advancements in collaborative robot technologies, enabling robots to work in close proximity to humans. Simultaneously, the rise of teleoperation, involving remote robot control, poses unique opportunities and challenges for human-robot collaboration (HRC) in diverse and distributed workspaces. Purpose: There is not yet a comprehensive understanding of HRC in teleoperation, specifically focusing on collaborations involving the teleoperator, the robot, and the local or onsite workers in industrial settings, here referred to as teleoperator-robot-human collaboration (tRHC). We aimed to identify opportunities, challenges, and potential applications of tRHC through insights provided from industry stakeholders, thereby supporting effective future industrial implementations. Methods: Thirteen stakeholders in robotics, specializing in different domains (i.e., safety, robot manufacturing, aerospace/automotive manufacturing, and supply chains), completed semi-structured interviews that focused on exploring diverse aspects relevant to tRHC. The interviews were then transcribed and thematic analysis was applied to group responses into broader categories, which were further compared across stakeholder industries. Results We identified three main categories and 13 themes from the interviews. These categories include Benefits, Concerns, and Technical Challenges. Interviewees highlighted accessibility, ergonomics, flexibility, safety, time & cost saving, and trust as benefits of tRHC. Concerns raised encompassed safety, standards, trust, and workplace optimization. Technical challenges consisted of critical issues such as communication time delays, the need for high dexterity in robot manipulators, the importance of establishing shared situational awareness among all agents, and the potential of augmented and virtual reality in providing immersive control interfaces. Conclusions: Despite important challenges, tRHC could offer unique benefits, facilitating seamless collaboration among the teleoperator, teleoperated robot(s), and onsite workers across physical and geographic boundaries. To realize such benefits and address the challenges, we propose several research directions to further explore and develop tRHC capabilities. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email