skip to main content

Title: Strength of fine-coarse mixtures in rubble pile asteroids
Several lines of evidence indicate that most of the smaller asteroids (< 1 km) consist of granular material loosely bound together primarily by self-gravity; these are commonly called rubble piles. While the strength of these rubble piles is valuable information on their origin and fate, it is still debated in the literature. We report on a laboratory measurement campaign on fine-coarse mixtures of simulated asteroid regolith. In a series of table-top measurements, we have determined sample compression and shear strengths for various fine-fractions within coarse-grained samples. We used confined setups (less than 10cm in length) to measure the strength of the material in constricted environments such as an asteroid’s core and unconfined setups (greater than 10cm in length) to simulate open environments such as the surface of an asteroid. Using CI Orgeuil high fidelity asteroid soil simulant, we performed three measurement types to determine the strength of our samples: shear yield, which in turn provided values for the Angle of Internal Friction (AIF), bulk cohesion, and tensile strength of the samples; compression strength, which allowed to calculate the Young’s Modulus (YM); and the Angle Of Repose (AOR). From the AOR, we determined the coefficient of friction of each sample. Samples of regolith were created by measuring percentage by volume amounts of both coarse and fine grains into the measurement container. We prepared coarse grains in two size distributions, mm-sized and cm-sized. The fine fraction was composed of grains sieved between 100 and 250 μm. For compression and AOR measurements, we find that the strength of the coarse grain samples increases with the addition of a fine fraction. However, we find that the increase of the fine fraction in a sample of coarse grains does not consistently increase the sample shear strength. With increasing fine fractions, the AIF and bulk cohesion of the mixed samples decrease (until a point of saturation). This could be indicative of the fine grains acting as a lubricant as the larger grains move across each other, aiding rolling and reducing interlocking strength. Our findings suggest that in the case of the surface of an asteroid, the presence of fine grains does indeed increase the strength of coarse regolith material. However, fine grains in the regolith sublayers or the asteroid interior will reduce material strength due to grain interlocking and ease disruption. Therefore, rubble piles that are depleted in fine grains will have higher internal strength compared to those composed of grain size distributions that include sub-mm sized particles.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
AAS/Division for Planetary Sciences Meeting Abstracts
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Bulletin of the AAS
Page Range / eLocation ID:
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Introduction: With the capture of the first high- resolution, in-situ images of Near-Earth Objects (NEOs) a couple of decades ago [1–4], the ubiquity of regolith and the granular nature of small objects in the Solar System became apparent. Benefiting from an increased access to high computing power, new numerical studies emerged, modeling granular structures forming and evolving as small bodies in the Solar System [5–7]. Now adding laboratory studies on granular material strength for asteroid and other small body applications [8,9], we are steadily progressing in our understanding of how regolith is shaping the interiors and surfaces of these worlds. In addition, our ever-more powerful observation capabilities are uncovering interesting dust-related phenomena in the outer skirts of our Solar System, in the form of activity at large heliocentric distances and rings [10–12]. We find that our recent progress in understanding the behavior of granular material in small body environments also has applications to the more distant worlds of Centaurs and Trans-Neptunian Objects (TNOs). Internal Strength: We currently deduce internal friction of rubble piles from the observation of large numbers of small asteroids and their rotation rates, combined with the associated numerical simulations [13,14]. In the laboratory, we study internal friction of simulant materials using shear strength measurements [8]. Combining observations, modeling, and laboratory work, the picture emerges of rubble pile interiors being composed of coarse grains in the mm to cm range. The irregular shapes of the grains lead to mechanical interlocking, thus generating the internal friction required to match observations of the asteroid population [8,9]. We find that the presence of a fine fraction in the confined interior of a rubble pile actually leads weaker internal strength [9]. Surface Strength: Deducing surface regolith strength for NEOs is usually performed via average slope measurements [15–17] or, most notably, observing the outcome of an impact of known energy [18]. In the laboratory, we measure the angle of repose of simulant material via pouring tests, as well as its bulk cohesion using shear strength measurements [8]. In some cases, this allows us to infer grain size ranges for various regions of the surface and subsurface of pictured NEOs, beyond the resolution of their in-situ images. Surface Activity: The Rosetta mission revealed that a number of activity events on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko were linked to active surface geology, most notably avalanches and cliff collapses [19]. In addition, the role of regolith strength in asteroid disruption patterns has been inferred from numerical simulations of rotating rubble piles [20]. By studying strength differences in simulant samples, it becomes apparent that a difference in cohesion between a surface and its subsurface layer can lead to activity events with surface mass shedding, without the presence of volatiles sublimating as a driver [8]. We show that such differences in surface strength can be brought upon by a depletion in fine grains or a change in composition (e.g. depletion in water ice) and could account for regular activity patterns on small bodies, independently of their distance to the Sun. This is of particular interest to the study of Centaur activity and a potential mechanism for feeding ring systems. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    Most small asteroids are defined as “rubble piles” or bodies with zero tensile strength and large bulk porosity. The cohesive forces that hold them together act at the grain scale, and their magnitude is often estimated from similar materials when used in simulations. Improving the accuracy of predictions of asteroid strengths requires suitable laboratory measurements of relevant materials, as well as increasing the availability of materials from sample return. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is well suited for force measurements relative to particle–particle interactions. In this work, we use AFM force measurements to evaluate the cohesive forces that act between micron-sized grains. We investigate the effect of the sizes of the interacting grains of JSC-1 lunar simulant using three sample sizes (<45, 75–125, and 125–250μm) and three spherical AFM tip diameters (2μm, 15μm, and 45μm). In all cases, adhesion forces were larger at ambient relative humidity (RH), where the water layer on the surface of the grains is more prominent, creating a larger meniscus between the tip and the grain upon contact. We observed weaker adhesion with larger grain/tip size, which can be attributed to the changing contact area between the samples and the tips. We expect that our approach will pave the way to a better understanding of regolith surface properties such as adhesion and cohesion and provide suitable input for models that can be used to predict the evolution of asteroids and their particle behaviors.

    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    We present the results of a series of laboratory low-speed impacts (< 4 m s−1) of centimeter-sized spherical projectiles into simulated dry and icy regolith samples. The target material was comprised of JSC-1 (Johnson Space Center) lunar simulant grains in the size range 100–250μm, mixed with similar-sized water ice grains. Impacts were performed under vacuum, either at room temperature for JSC-1 samples or at cryogenic temperatures (<150 K) for icy mixtures. We measured the ejecta masses from a collection plate and impact crater dimensions from post-impact crater photographs. We find that both the ejecta masses and crater diameters followed trends predicted by established scaling laws, albeit with different fitting parameters, and we were able to fit a strength regimeπscaling to our measured crater diameters. The water ice in our target material took two forms: grains mixed with the regolith grains and frost from air condensation coating regolith grains. In both cases, the presence of water ice in the sample led to lower ejected masses and smaller crater sizes. In addition, our measured crater sizes were several orders of magnitude larger than expected for impacts into solid rock or water ice. Using our measured scaling parameters, we applied our findings to a planetary context for the study of secondary craters on icy moons, as well as eroding collisions occurring in Saturn’s rings. We found that the deviation of our measurements from solid targets and from commonly used scaling parameters allowed us to reconcile our measurements with the models in both cases.

    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Mantle xenoliths from the Southern Alps, New Zealand, provide insight into the origin of mantle seismic anisotropy related to the Australian‐Pacific plate boundary. Most xenoliths from within 100 km lateral distance of the Alpine Fault are coarse grained, but a small number are finer grained protomylonites. The protomylonites contain connected networks of fine grains with a different crystallographic preferred orientation (CPO) to coarse porphyroclasts in the same xenolith, suggesting that protomylonites and coarse‐grained samples record different deformation kinematics. The CPOs of fine grains in protomylonites have monoclinic symmetry, with the 2‐fold rotation axis normal to a plane that contains olivine [010] and orthopyroxene [100] maxima, suggesting that the protomylonite deformation involved significant simple shear. Some coarse‐grained samples contain unconnected lenses and layers of fine grains with the same CPO as the coarse grains. Microstructures suggest that these fine grains formed by subgrain rotation recrystallization and that protomylonites may represent an up‐strain progression of this microstructure, where the connectivity of fine grains has allowed them to localize shear and develop a new Alpine Fault CPO. The samples tell us about the state of the mantle at 25 Ma, in the early history of the plate boundary. If this suite of samples is representative of the mantle beneath the Alpine Fault in the present day, then we can interpret the complex seismic anisotropy patterns in the lithospheric mantle as representative of blocks containing variably rotated older CPOs juxtaposed by narrow shear zones associated with Alpine Fault deformation.

    more » « less
  5. Abstract

    Frictional sliding along grain boundaries in brittle shear zones can result in the fragmentation of individual grains, which ultimately can impact slip dynamics. During deformation at small scales, stick–slip motion can occur between grains when existing force chains break due to grain rearrangement or failure, resulting in frictional sliding of granular material. The rearrangement of the grains leads to dilation of the granular package, reducing the shear stress and subsequently leading to slip. Here, we conduct physical experiments employing HydroOrbs, an elasto-plastic material, to investigate grain comminution in granular media under simple shear conditions. Our findings demonstrate that the degree of grain comminution is dependent on both the normal force and the size of the grains. Using the experimental setup, we benchmark Discrete Element Method (DEM) numerical models, which are capable of simulating the movement, rotation, and fracturing of elasto-plastic grains subjected to simple shear. The DEM models successfully replicate both grain comminution patterns and horizontal force fluctuations observed in our physical experiments. They show that increasing normal forces correlate with higher horizontal forces and more fractured grains. The ability of our DEM models to accurately reproduce experimental results opens up new avenues for investigating various parameter spaces that may not be accessible through traditional laboratory experiments, for example, in assessing how internal friction or cohesion affect deformation in granular systems.

    more » « less