An official website of the United States government
Why do some mathematics lessons captivate high school students and others not? This study explores this question by comparing how the content unfolds in the lessons that students rated highest with respect to their aesthetic affordances (e.g., using terms like “intriguing,” “surprising”) with those the same students rated lowest with respect to their aesthetic affordances (e.g., “just ok,” “dull”). Using a framework that interprets the unfolding content across a lesson as a mathematical story, we examine how some lessons can provoke curiosity or enable surprise. We identify eight characteristics that distinguish captivating lessons and show how some, such as the average number of questions under consideration at any point in the lesson, are strongly related to student aesthetic experiences. In addition, the lessons that students described as more interesting included more instances of misdirection, such as when students’ false assumptions provide opportunities for surprising results. These findings point to the characteristics of future lesson designs that could enable more students to experience curiosity and wonder in secondary mathematics classrooms.
more »
« less
"Oh! That's Interesting!"; Captivating students who hate mathematics with mathematical ideas
The positive relationship between students’ attitudes toward mathematics and mathematics achievement is well documented. Yet there is a worsening problem of low appeal of mathematics especially at the secondary level. Therefore, in this paper we focus on three high school students who report a strong dislike of mathematics. By analyzing student surveys, interviews, and lesson observation data, we examined how some mathematical lessons improved these students’ experiences (i.e., their aesthetic dimensions). We found that while student preferences varied, each student was interested in lessons that centered them as sense-makers and in which the content unfolded with suspense. Such lessons led to positive aesthetic responses such as surprise, curiosity, and satisfaction. Thus, lessons can be designed in which even students with the most negative views of mathematics can find mathematical concepts interesting.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1652513
- PAR ID:
- 10506695
- Editor(s):
- Lamberg, T.; Moss, D.
- Publisher / Repository:
- Annual meeting of the Psychology of Mathematics Education - North American Chapter
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Psychology of Mathematics Education - North American Chapter
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Location:
- Reno, NV
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Olanoff, D.; Johnson, K.; & Spitzer, S. (Ed.)How does the design of lessons impact the types of questions teachers and students ask during enacted high school mathematics lessons? In this study, we present data that suggests that lessons designed with the mathematical story framework to elicit a specific aesthetic response (“MCLEs”) having a positive influence on the types of teacher and student questions they ask during the lesson. Our findings suggest that when teachers plan and enact lessons with the mathematical story framework, teachers and students are more likely to ask questions that explore mathematical relationships and focus on meaning making. In addition, teachers are less likely to ask short recall or procedural questions in MCLEs. These findings point to the role of lesson design in the quality of questions asked by teachers and students.more » « less
-
Olanoff, D.; Johnson, K.; & Spitzer, S. (Ed.)In this study, we explore the relationships between the types of student exclamations in an enacted lesson (e.g., “Wow!”) and the varying dramatic tensions created by the unfolding content. By analyzing student exclamations in six specially-designed high school mathematics lessons, we explore how the dynamic tension between revelations of mathematical ideas at the moment and what is yet to be known connects with the aesthetic pull to react by the student. As students work through novel problems with limited information, their joys and frustrations are expressed in the form of exclamations.more » « less
-
Secondary students do not often have positive experiences with mathematics. To address this challenge, this paper shares findings of a design-based research project in which a mathematical story framework was used to design mathematically captivating lesson experiences (“MCLEs”). We provide evidence that designing lessons as mathematical stories shows promise. That is, students reported improved experiences in MCLEs when compared to randomly-selected lessons. The MCLEs also impacted the students’ descriptions of their experience.more » « less
-
Mathematical mindset theory (Boaler, 2015) indicates student achievement in mathematics has the potential to improve, through the use of, student engagement, collaborative groups, and open-ended problem sets that allow students to discover their own understanding of mathematics. This presentation explores how and when I used methods of mathematical mindsets in my classroom, when it appeared that these types of lessons were not appropriate, and student reactions to lessons using mathematical mindsets versus lessons that did not incorporate this theoretical framework. Lessons learned are also explored.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Proceeding:
- The DOI is not currently available.
