skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: A Survey of Policy Issues in Spectrum Sharing in the 12 GHz Band
When considering spectrum sharing, the concept of regulatory certainty drives regulators to consider worst-case scenarios to evaluate potential impacts to incumbents. If a second use will never interfere, then all is good. However, in scenarios where the worst case is unlikely to occur, it means alternate uses may not be considered, the alternate use may have unnecessary limitations, or the incumbent may lose access to the band if the new use is deemed in the public interest. This paper reviews the recent his- tory and discourse associated with spectrum sharing in the 12 GHz band. The paper examines socioeconomic considerations of the band. Finally, opportunities for future policy research with a focus on developing a dynamic policy framework for coexistence be- tween services in the band are presented.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2245910
PAR ID:
10520582
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Publisher / Repository:
IEEE
Date Published:
ISBN:
979-8-3503-1764-0
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
Dynamic Spectrum Policy Commercial Spectrum Allocation Spectrum Sharing Rural Digital Access
Format(s):
Medium: X
Location:
Washington, DC, USA
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Spectrum sharing between terrestrial 5G and incumbent networks in the satellite bands presents a promising avenue to satisfy the ever-increasing bandwidth demand of the next-generation wireless networks. However, protecting incumbent operations from harmful interference poses a fundamental challenge in accommodating terrestrial broadband cellular networks in the satellite bands. State-of-the-art spectrum-sharing policies usually consider several worst-case assumptions and ignore site-specific contextual factors in making spectrum-sharing decisions, and thus, often results in under-utilization of the shared band for the secondary licensees. To address such limitations, this paper introduces CAT3S (Context-Aware Terrestrial-Satellite Spectrum Sharing) framework that empowers the coexisting terrestrial 5G network to maximize utilization of the shared satellite band without creating harmful interference to the incumbent links by exploiting the contextual factors. CAT3S consists of the following two components: (i) context-acquisition unit to collect and process essential contextual information for spectrum sharing and (ii) context-aware base station (BS) control unit to optimize the set of operational BSs and their operation parameters (i.e., transmit power and active beams per sector). To evaluate the performance of the CAT3S, a realistic spectrum coexistence case study over the 12 GHz band is considered. Experiment results demonstrate that the proposed CAT3S achieves notably higher spectrum utilization than state-of-the-art spectrum-sharing policies in different weather contexts. 
    more » « less
  2. In 2020, the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) adopted rules to expand unlicensed operations in the 6 GHz band, opening up access to 1200MHz of spectrum to be shared by heterogeneous public and private network operators. This spectrum is anticipated to significantly expand access to much-needed mid-band spectrum for mobile and fixed broadband wireless uses. To manage the co-existence of these unlicensed users with legacy systems such as commercial microwave point-to-point links, the FCC’s rules provide for a mix of interference mitigation strategies, including geo-location (geo-fencing) to restrict unlicensed users in certain locations, different power limits for indoor and outdoor operations, and coordination of spectrum use via Automated Frequency Coordination (AFC) systems. Akin to the role of the Spectrum Access Systems (SAS) operating in the CBRS 3.5 GHz band, the AFCs are tasked with enabling automated spectrum sharing between unlicensed devices and incumbent users. When operating outdoors, unlicensed devices (Standard Power Access Points) are required to communicate to an AFC certain relevant operating details that the AFC uses to then provide operational parameters to the unlicensed devices (e.g., available channels) such that no harmful interference is caused to protected incumbents. Unlike the SAS, the multiple AFCs do not coordinate their activities and so are unable to take account of aggregate interference levels. Additionally, the AFCs spectrum sharing and co-existence solutions are based on interference models and regulatory rules that may prove to be too conservative and a poor fit for some actual usage scenarios. Spectrum Consumption Models (SCMs), an IEEE-standards-based approach for describing the RF requirements of radios in a spectrum space and Spectrum Access Agreements (SAAs) that make use of SCMs provide a viable toolset for examining the efficiency and efficacy of the existing FCC 6GHz rules framework. In this paper, we review the 6 GHz rules and show how they could be implemented within a SCM framework. We also show how greater use of the 6GHz spectrum could be possible if more information was exchanged with an AFC using the standards-based framework of SCMs. We explore the policy and economic impacts of enabling this flexibility. For example, this approach could lead to higher computational costs for an AFC, which would need to be balanced with the benefits of increased spectrum utilization. Through the application of our 6GHz simulation platform and the SCM/SAA framework, we are able to suggest efficiency-enhancing reforms to the existing 6GHz FCC rules. We support those recommendations with an analysis of the economic and regulatory implications on key stakeholders in this important new band for wireless services. 
    more » « less
  3. This paper explores reconfigurable intelligent surfaces (RIS) for mitigating cross-system interference in spectrum sharing applications. Unlike conventional reflect-only RIS that can only adjust the phase of the incoming signal, a hybrid RIS is considered that can configure the phase and modulus of the impinging signal by absorbing part of the signal energy. We investigate two spectrum sharing scenarios: (1) Spectral coexistence of radar and communication systems, where a convex optimization problem is formulated to minimize the Frobenius norm of the channel matrix from the communication base station to the radar receiver, and (2) Spectrum sharing in device-to-device (D2D) communications, where a max-min scheme that optimizes the worst-case signal-to-interference-plus-noise ratio (SINR) among the D2D links is formulated, and then solved through fractional programming. Numerical results show that with a sufficient number of elements, the hybrid RIS can in many cases completely eliminate the interference, unlike a conventional non-absorptive RIS. 
    more » « less
  4. This paper introduces ASCENT (context-Aware Spectrum Coexistence DEsigN and ImplemenTation) toolset, an advanced context-aware terrestrial-satellite spectrum sharing toolset designed for researchers, policymakers, and regulators. It serves two essential purposes: (a) evaluating the potential for harmful interference to primary users in satellite bands and (b) facilitating the analysis, design, and implementation of diverse regulatory policies on spectrum usage and sharing. Notably, ASCENT implements a closed-loop feedback system that allows dynamic adaptation of policies according to a wide range of contextual factors (e.g., weather, buildings, summer/winter foliage, etc.) and feedback on the impact of these policies through realistic simulation. Specifically, ASCENT comprises the following components– (i) interference evaluation tool for evaluating interference at the incumbents in a spectrum sharing environment while taking the underlying contexts; (ii) dynamic spectrum access (DSA) framework for providing context-aware instructions to adapt networking parameters and control secondary terrestrial network’s access to the shared spectrum band according to context-aware prioritization; (iii) Context broker to acquire essential and relevant contexts from external context information providers; and (iv) DSA Database to store dynamic and static contexts and the regulator’s policy information. The closed-loop feedback system of ASCENT is implemented by integrating these components in a modular software architecture. A case study of sharing the lower 12 GHz Ku-band (12.2-12.7 GHz) with the 5G terrestrial cellular network is considered, and the usability of ASCENT is demonstrated by dynamically changing exclusion-zone’s radius in different weather conditions. 
    more » « less
  5. This paper introduces ASCENT (context Aware Spectrum Coexistence Design and Implementation) toolset, an advanced context-aware terrestrial satellite spectrum sharing toolset designed for researchers, policymakers, and regulators. It serves two essential purposes (a) evaluating the potential for harmful interference to primary users in satellite bands and (b) facilitating the analysis, design, and implementation of diverse regulatory policies on spectrum usage and sharing. Notably, ASCENT implements a closed-loop feedback system that allows dynamic adaptation of policies according to a wide range of contextual factors (e.g., weather, buildings, summer/winter foliage, etc.) and feedback on the impact of these policies through realistic simulation. Specifically, ASCENT comprises the following components (i) interference evaluation tool for evaluating interference at the incumbents in a spectrum-sharing environment while taking the underlying contexts, (ii) dynamic spectrum access (DSA) framework for providing context-aware instructions to adapt networking parameters and control secondary terrestrial network's access to the shared spectrum band according to context aware prioritization, (iii) Context broker to acquire essential and relevant contexts from external context information providers; and (iv) DSA Database to store dynamic and static contexts and the regulator's policy information. The closed-loop feedback system of ASCENT is implemented by integrating these components in a modular software architecture. A case study of sharing the lower 12 GHz Ku band (12.2-12.7 GHz) with the 5G terrestrial cellular network is considered, and the usability of ASCENT is demonstrated by dynamically changing exclusion zone's radius in different weather conditions. 
    more » « less