skip to main content


Title: The Impact of Batch Deep Reinforcement Learning on Student Performance: A Simple Act of Explanation Can Go A Long Way
While Reinforcement learning (RL), especially Deep RL (DRL), has shown outstanding performance in video games, little evidence has shown that DRL can be successfully applied to human-centric tasks where the ultimate RL goal is to make the \textit{human-agent interactions} productive and fruitful. In real-life, complex, human-centric tasks, such as education and healthcare, data can be noisy and limited. Batch RL is designed for handling such situations where data is \textit{limited yet noisy}, and where \textit{building simulations is challenging}. In two consecutive empirical studies, we investigated Batch DRL for pedagogical policy induction, to choose student learning activities in an Intelligent Tutoring System. In Fall 2018 (F18), we compared the Batch DRL policy to an Expert policy, but found no significant difference between the DRL and Expert policies. In Spring 2019 (S19), we augmented the Batch DRL-induced policy with \textit{a simple act of explanation} by showing a message such as \textit{"The AI agent thinks you should view this problem as a Worked Example to learn how some new rules work."}. We compared this policy against two conditions, the Expert policy, and a student decision making policy. Our results show that 1) the Batch DRL policy with explanations significantly improved student learning performance more than the Expert policy; and 2) no significant differences were found between the Expert policy and student decision making. Overall, our results suggest that \textit{pairing simple explanations with the Batch DRL policy} can be an important and effective technique for applying RL to real-life, human-centric tasks.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2013502
PAR ID:
10525761
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Springer
Date Published:
Journal Name:
International journal of artificial intelligence in education
Volume:
33
Issue:
4
ISSN:
1560-4292
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    In recent years, Reinforcement learning (RL), especially Deep RL (DRL), has shown outstanding performance in video games from Atari, Mario, to StarCraft. However, little evidence has shown that DRL can be successfully applied to real-life human-centric tasks such as education or healthcare. Different from classic game-playing where the RL goal is to make an agent smart, in human-centric tasks the ultimate RL goal is to make the human-agent interactions productive and fruitful. Additionally, in many real-life human-centric tasks, data can be noisy and limited. As a sub-field of RL, batch RL is designed for handling situations where data is limited yet noisy, and building simulations is challenging. In two consecutive classroom studies, we investigated applying batch DRL to the task of pedagogical policy induction for an Intelligent Tutoring System (ITS), and empirically evaluated the effectiveness of induced pedagogical policies. In Fall 2018 (F18), the DRL policy is compared against an expert-designed baseline policy and in Spring 2019 (S19), we examined the impact of explaining the batch DRL-induced policy with student decisions and the expert baseline policy. Our results showed that 1) while no significant difference was found between the batch RL-induced policy and the expert policy in F18, the batch RL-induced policy with simple explanations significantly improved students’ learning performance more than the expert policy alone in S19; and 2) no significant differences were found between the student decision making and the expert policy. Overall, our results suggest that pairing simple explanations with induced RL policies can be an important and effective technique for applying RL to real-life human-centric tasks. 
    more » « less
  2. Most existing policy learning solutions require the learning agents to receive high-quality supervision signals, e.g., rewards in reinforcement learning (RL) or high-quality expert demonstrations in behavioral cloning (BC). These quality supervisions are either infeasible or prohibitively expensive to obtain in practice. We aim for a unified framework that leverages the available cheap weak supervisions to perform policy learning efficiently. To handle this problem, we treat the weak supervision'' as imperfect information coming from a peer agent, and evaluate the learning agent's policy based on a correlated agreement'' with the peer agent's policy (instead of simple agreements). Our approach explicitly punishes a policy for overfitting to the weak supervision. In addition to theoretical guarantees, extensive evaluations on tasks including RL with noisy reward, BC with weak demonstrations, and standard policy co-training (RL + BC) show that our method leads to substantial performance improvements, especially when the complexity or the noise of the learning environments is high. 
    more » « less
  3. We propose a novel parameterized skill-learning algorithm that aims to learn transferable parameterized skills and synthesize them into a new action space that supports efficient learning in long-horizon tasks. We propose to leverage off-policy Meta-RL combined with a trajectory-centric smoothness term to learn a set of parameterized skills. Our agent can use these learned skills to construct a three-level hierarchical framework that models a Temporally-extended Parameterized Action Markov Decision Process. We empirically demonstrate that the proposed algorithms enable an agent to solve a set of difficult long-horizon (obstacle-course and robot manipulation) tasks. 
    more » « less
  4. Reinforcement learning (RL) has shown its viability to learn when an agent interacts continually with the environment to optimize a policy. This work presents a memristor-based deep reinforcement learning (Mem-DRL) system for on-chip training, where the learning process takes place in a dynamic cartpole environment. Memristor device variability is taken into account to make the study more realistic. The proposed system utilized an analog ReLu module to reduce analog to digital converter usage. The analog Mem-DRL system consumed 191 times less energy than an optimized digital FP16 computing system. Our Mem-DRL system reduced the ADC usages by 40%, which led to reduced the overall system energy by 42%. Mem-DRL is 2.4 times faster than the FP16 system and performs 9.27 GOPS during DRL training. The system exhibited an energy efficiency of 23.8 TOPS/W. 
    more » « less
  5. Reinforcement learning (RL) has demonstrated its superiority in solving sequential decision-making problems. However, heavy dependence on immediate reward feedback impedes the wide application of RL. On the other hand, imitation learning (IL) tackles RL without relying on environmental supervision by leveraging external demonstrations. In practice, however, collecting sufficient expert demonstrations can be prohibitively expensive, yet the quality of demonstrations typically limits the performance of the learning policy. To address a practical scenario, in this work, we propose Self-Adaptive Imitation Learning (SAIL), which, provided with a few demonstrations from a sub-optimal teacher, can perform well in RL tasks with extremely delayed rewards, where the only reward feedback is trajectory-wise ranking. SAIL bridges the advantages of IL and RL by interactively exploiting the demonstrations to catch up with the teacher and exploring the environment to yield demonstrations that surpass the teacher. Extensive empirical results show that not only does SAIL significantly improve the sample efficiency, but it also leads to higher asymptotic performance across different continuous control tasks, compared with the state-of-the-art. 
    more » « less