An official website of the United States government
Abstract Understanding how the early stages of sexual signal diversification proceed is critically important because these microevolutionary dynamics directly shape species trajectories and impact macroevolutionary patterns. Unfortunately, studying this is challenging because signals involve complex interactions between behavior, morphology, and physiology, much of which can only be measured in real-time. In Hawaii, male Pacific field cricket song attracts both females and a deadly parasitoid fly. Over the past two decades, there has been a marked increase in signal variation in Hawaiian populations of these crickets, including novel male morphs with distinct mating songs. We capitalize on this rare opportunity to track changes in morph composition over time in a population with three novel morphs, investigating how mate and parasitoid attraction (components of sexual and natural selection) may shape signal evolution. We find dramatic fluctuation in morph proportions over the three years of the study, including the arrival and rapid increase of one novel morph. Natural and sexual selection pressures act differently among morphs, with some more attractive to mates and others more protected from parasitism. Collectively, our results suggest that differential protection from parasitism among morphs, rather than mate attraction, aligns with recent patterns of phenotypic change in the wild.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on June 26, 2025
Cooperative breeding in songbirds promotes female song but slows the evolution of song elaboration
Bird song has historically been characterized as a primarily male behavior that evolves through sexual selection pressures involved in mate attraction. More recently, researchers showed that female song is far more prevalent in songbirds than previously thought, raising new questions about how other social functions of birdsong and sexual selection pressures on females might affect song evolution. Certain breeding systems, particularly cooperative breeding, are hypothesized to change social dynamics and sexual selection pressures on males and females and may thus influence song evolution in both. Here, we construct a large-scale database synthesizing species-level information on the presence of female song, the characteristics of presumably male song, social variables, and breeding systems, and we perform comparative phylogenetic analyses. Our results suggest that cooperative breeding and female song co-occur significantly more than expected and exhibit co-evolutionary dynamics; in particular, cooperative breeding appears to decrease the likelihood that female song is lost. Notably, we find evidence that these trends might be linked to certain social features associated with cooperative breeding, including social bond stability, but not others, such as increased group size. In addition, we observe that song repertoire size appears to evolve more slowly in cooperative breeding lineages. Overall, our findings demonstrate that cooperative breeding may have complex and sex-specific effects on song evolution, maintaining female song while slowing the rate of male song elaboration, suggesting that song in cooperatively breeding species could function in ways that differ from the traditional mate-attraction paradigm and that lesser-studied functions of songs may be evolutionarily consequential.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10533924
- Publisher / Repository:
- bioRxiv
- Date Published:
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Institution:
- bioRxiv
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
AbstractWhile there are many studies documenting female mating preferences across taxa, male mate choice remains relatively understudied. Male mate choice often develops when there is variation in female quality and thus the fitness benefits of mating with particular females. Specifically, males tend to prefer females with traits that confer direct fitness benefits such as large body size, which may be linked with high fecundity. Prior work has shown that females of the strawberry poison frog,Oophaga pumilio, prefer males bearing certain coloration (most often the female’s own color), and that this preference can be learned through maternal imprinting. Females have been shown to prefer larger males as well. Here we test whether similar mate preferences for color and size exist in males of this species using two-way choice tests on captive bred maleO. pumilio. In each test focal males were placed in an arena with two stimulus females: either both of the same size but differing in color, or both of the same color but differing in size. We found only weak evidence for behavioral biases toward particular colors and no evidence for biases toward larger females, suggesting that males ofO. pumiliodo not predictably choose mates based on these female traits. Despite several aspects of their natural history that suggest males have reasons to be choosy, our findings suggest that the cost of mate rejection may outweigh any fitness benefits derived from being selective of mates. Studies of additional populations, ideally conducted on wild individuals, are needed to better understand the range of conditions under which males may exhibit mate choice and the types of traits on which they base these choices. Significance statementTo fully understand the fitness landscapes and evolutionary trajectories that result from sexual selection, we need to understand when and how the mate preferences of the two sexes act and interact. While female mate choice has been widely studied, male mate choice remains poorly understood. To help bridge this gap, we studied male mate preferences in the strawberry poison frogOophaga pumilio, a small brightly colored frog for which female preferences for male color and size have been well-documented. We found no evidence that maleO. pumilioexhibit mate preferences based on female size and little evidence for male mate preferences based on female color. This is surprising given that larger females are often more fecund, maleO. pumilioare known to exhibit color-based behavioral biases in the context of male-male competition, and both sexes provide parental care.more » « less
-
Oscine songbirds learn vocalizations that function in mate attraction and territory defense. Sexual selection pressures on these learned songs could accelerate speciation. The Eastern and Spotted towhees are sister species that diverged recently (0.28 Ma) but now have partially overlapping ranges with evidence of some hybridization; widespread community-science recordings of these species, including songs within their zone of overlap and from potential hybrids, enable us to investigate whether song differentiation might facilitate their reproductive isolation. Here, we quantify 16 song features to analyze geographic variation in Spotted and Eastern towhee songs and test for species-level differences. We then use random-forest models to measure how accurately their songs can be classified by species, both within and outside the zone of overlap. While no single song feature reliably distinguishes the two species, a random-forest model trained on 16 features accurately classified 89.5% of songs; interestingly, species classification was less accurate in the zone of overlap. Finally, our analysis of the limited publicly available genetic data from each species supports the hypothesis that they are reproductively isolated. Together, our results suggest that, in combination, small variations in song features may contribute to these sister species’ ability to recognize their species-specific songs.more » « less
-
Abstract Divergence of sexual signals between populations can lead to speciation, yet opportunities to study the immediate aftermath of novel signal evolution are rare. The recent emergence and spread of a new mating song, purring, in Hawaiian populations of the Pacific field cricket (Teleogryllus oceanicus) allows us to investigate population divergence soon after the origin of a new signal. Male crickets produce songs with specialized wing structures to attract mates from afar (calling) and entice them to mate when found (courtship). However, in Hawaii, these songs also attract an eavesdropping parasitoid fly (Ormia ochracea) that kills singing males. The novel purring song, produced with heavily modified wing morphology, attracts female crickets but not the parasitoid fly, acting as a solution to this conflict between natural and sexual selection. We've recently observed increasing numbers of purring males across Hawaii. In this integrative field study, we investigated the distribution of purring and the proportion of purring males relative to other morphs in six populations on four islands and compared a suite of phenotypic traits (wing morphology, calling song and courtship song) that make up this novel signal across populations of purring males. We show that purring is found in varying proportions across five, and is locally dominant in four, Hawaiian populations. We also show that calling songs, courtship songs and wing morphology of purring males differ geographically. Our findings demonstrate the rapid pace of evolution in island populations and provide insights into the emergence and divergence of new sexual signals over time.more » « less
-
The dark-eyed junco (Junco hyemalis) has experienced rapid phenotypic diversification within the last 18,000 years, resulting in several subspecies that reside in partially overlapping regions across North America. These subspecies have distinct plumage and morphology. If members of a subspecies disproportionately mate with one another, we would expect genetic differences to accumulate between the subspecies. In parallel, their learned songs could also accumulate changes. If song is used by individuals to recognize members of their own subspecies during mate selection, which would prevent the production of less fit hybrid offspring between subspecies, then song differences might co-localize with subspecies boundaries. Here, we quantify 10 song features to explore subspecies-level song variation using song recordings from community-science databases. We build a machine learning classifier to measure how accurately the subspecies’ songs can be distinguished from one another. Here, we show that songs of dark-eyed junco subspecies exhibit significant song-feature differences. However, these differences do not necessarily lead to distinguishability between subspecies. Notably, we find that subspecies pairs with adjacent ranges that do not hybridize have much more distinguishable songs, and also more evidence for genetic differentiation, than pairs that are known to hybridize. Thus, song distinguishability appears to have predictive power about which subspecies will hybridize, suggesting that song might play a role in reinforcing certain subspecies boundaries more than others. Finally, we analyze subspecies-level song differences alongside available genetic data and geographic coordinates to characterize the current evolutionary landscape of the dark-eyed junco subspecies complex. We observe geographic signal in the song and genetic data, indicating that individuals who share a range are more likely to share song characteristics and be genetically similar. This study illuminates the existence of subspecies-level song differences in the dark-eyed junco and provides further clarity on the role learned song plays in reinforcing reproductive boundaries between dark-eyed junco subspecies.more » « less
