skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Complex Technologies and Ignorant Expertise: The Communicative Value of Not Knowing but Figuring it Out
Workplaces are increasingly full of complex technologies embedded in dynamic infrastructures demanding workers to assess and understand unanticipated problems. In order to comprehensively appraise the role of technological complexity and the uncertainties it affords in a complex, high-stakes setting, we interviewed and observed members of three interdisciplinary STEM laboratories. Findings revealed that organizational members navigated uncertainty by cultivatingignorant expertise(i.e.,not knowing but figuring it out). This form of expertise emerged as a combination of two practices: the practice of emergent troubleshooting and the practice of negotiating new practices. In discussing these findings, we offer three key takeaways. We demonstrate that ignorant expertise: (a) operates as a dialectic of hesitancy and boldness and is mobilized through ignorant yet knowledgeable actions; (b) is communicatively performed through think-out-loud and storytelling techniques, and developing interpersonal rapport with organizational members; and (c) establishes technological complexity as a catalyst for organizing processes.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1926139
PAR ID:
10543248
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
SAGE Publications
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Management Communication Quarterly
Volume:
39
Issue:
3
ISSN:
0893-3189
Format(s):
Medium: X Size: p. 407-434
Size(s):
p. 407-434
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Fankhauser, Sarah (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT The 2011 reportVision and Change: A Call to Action(V&C) resulted from a national effort to rethink biology curriculum.V&Coutlines core concepts and core competencies for biology undergraduates and promotes evidence-based pedagogy, undergraduate research, and inclusive practices. However, it is unclear how much biology educators know aboutV&Cand what motivates educators’ development of their teaching philosophy and practices. We leveraged the Promoting Active Learning and Mentoring (PALM) Network, a group that introduced evidence-based instructional practices (EBIPs) to instructors through mentoring, journal clubs, and a community of practice, to investigate how muchV&Chas influenced educator knowledge and motivation. Through focus groups, 16 mentors and 22 fellows were asked about their motivations to join PALM, familiarity withV&C, how they learned aboutV&C, and how PALM and/orV&Cshaped the development of their teaching philosophies and strategies. We found that the teaching philosophies and practices of these educators align strongly withV&Cprinciples.V&Cprovided expectancy (established value), while PALM contributed to greater instructor self-efficacy in EBIPs, overall resulting in reformed teaching philosophies and practices. This model highlights the importance of mentorship and community to successfully drive biology education reform. 
    more » « less
  2. van_Oers, Monique M (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT Venturia canescensis a parasitoid wasp that harbors a domesticated endogenous virus (DEV) and parasitizes host insects likeEphestia kuehniella. TheV. canescensDEV evolved from an alphanudivirus and produces virus-like particles (VLPs) in females that protect wasp eggs from a host immune defense called encapsulation. In contrast, very few DEV genes required for VLP formation and function have been identified. In this study, we characterized fiveV. canescensDEV genes of unknown function that all nudiviruses encode. Three of these genes are single copy (OrNVorf18-like,OrNVorf61-like, andOrNVorf76-like), whileOrNVorf41-likehas expanded into a six-member family andOrNVorf47-likehas expanded into a three-member family. Sequence analysis indicated all of these genes retain essential motifs present in nudivirus homologs, while transmission electron microscopy (TEM) studies characterized the timing of VLP formation during the wasp pupal stage. RNA interference (RNAi) assays identifiedOrNVorf18-like,OrNVorf61-like,OrNVorf41-like-1,andOrNVorf41-like-2as genes that are required for normal VLP formation. Knockdown ofOrNVorf47-likefamily members did not affect VLP formation but did disable binding of VLPs toV. canescenseggs and protection against encapsulation. Disabled formation of VLPs in response to RNAi knockdown ofOrNVorf18-like,OrNVorf61-like,OrNVorf41-like-1,andOrNVorf41-like-2also resulted in wasp eggs being encapsulated. In contrast, knockdown ofOrNVorf76-likehad no effect on VLP assembly, egg binding, or encapsulation. Altogether, reported results significantly advance our understanding ofV. canescensVLP (VcVLP) formation and function. IMPORTANCEUnderstanding howV. canescenscoopted an alphanudivirus to produce VcVLPs is of interest to the study of virus evolution. Our results show that three nudivirus core genes have essential functions in VcVLP formation, while one is essential for the novel function of binding to wasp eggs and protection from encapsulation, which is the most important immune defense of insects against parasitoids. 
    more » « less
  3. Hockett, Kevin Loren (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT Rhizopus microsporusis a necrotrophic post-harvest pathogen that causes significant economic losses in the agricultural sector. To explore alternatives to conventional management strategies for the mitigation of post-harvest infections, we investigated the potential of two previously identified endophyticBacillus velezensisstrains as biological control agents. Throughin vitroandin vivoexperiments, we examined the mechanisms of biocontrol displayed by twoB. velezensisstrains (KV10 and KV15) against threeR. microsporusstrains (W2-50, W2-51, and W2-58).In vitroassays assessed co-cultivability and the inhibitory effects ofB. velezensisagainstR. microsporus. The results demonstrated strain-specific antifungal activity with a reduction in fungal growth across treatments. Further analysis revealed that volatile organic compounds produced byB. velezensiscontributed to its antifungal properties. To evaluate the biocontrol efficacyin vivo, tomato fruits were inoculated withR. microsporusand subsequently treated withB. velezensis. The results support the strain-specific reduction in tomato spoilage, yielding various spoilage rates observed across treatments. Our findings highlight the potential ofB. velezensisas a promising biocontrol agent for the management ofR. microsporuspost-harvest infections in tomatoes. Further research is warranted to optimize the applicationof B. velezensisas a sustainable and environmentally friendly approach for controlling post-harvest diseases in tomatoes.IMPORTANCEOur study shows the significance of improving sustainable agriculture by offering an alternative to the use of chemical fungicides in post-harvest applications. Opportunistic fungal pathogens likeRhizopus microsporuscan have detrimental effects on post-harvest commodities like tomatoes. Post-harvest fungal infections are mainly controlled by chemical fungicides that pose health risks to humans and the environment. Utilizing biocontrol agents provides an environmentally safe alternative. Understanding the mechanisms of biocontrol employed by beneficial bacteria likeBacillus velezensison fungal pathogens gives insight into safer, more environmentally friendly alternatives to protect food crops. Our results suggest that targeted microbial solutions can mitigate post-harvest losses. 
    more » « less
  4. The evolutionary onset of animal biomineralization in the late Ediacaran (ca555–538 Ma) is marked by the global appearance of enigmatic tubular fossils with unresolved phylogenetic relationships. Among these,Corumbella wernerifrom the Tamengo Formation (Corumbá Group, Brazil) has been variously interpreted as affiliated with cnidarians or bilaterians. Using synchrotron imaging and machine learning, we analysed new specimens ofC. wernerito reconstruct their original skeletal organization. Our findings reveal thatCorumbella’s tubes were originally conico-cylindrical. Large individuals ofCorumbella, including less compacted specimens, and compression experiments with modern annelid tubes all indicate that previous reconstructions of a quadrate outline and midline features were misled by taphonomic artefacts. We also show that the wall ofCorumbellais composed of a single layer of ring-shaped elements. Unlike the fourfold symmetry of scyphozoans or the complex cataphract-like structures of Cambrian bilaterians (e.g. halkieriids, tommotiids and wiwaxiids),Corumbelladisplays structural similarities with other late Ediacaran corumbellomorphs, such asCostatubus. These taxa exhibit a distinctive barrel-on-barrel tube construction, with modular elements stacked on each other rather than nested. Our findings redefineCorumbella’s morphology and phylogenetic affinities, contributing to a broader understanding of early biomineralizing metazoans and their ecological roles in the Ediacaran biosphere. 
    more » « less
  5. Svensson, Sarah L (Ed.)
    ABSTRACT In starvingBacillus subtilisbacteria,the initiation of two survival programs—biofilm formation and sporulation—is controlled by the same phosphorylated master regulator, Spo0A~P. Its gene,spo0A,is transcribed from two promoters, Pvand Ps,that are, respectively, regulated by RNA polymerase (RNAP) holoenzymes bearing σAand σH. Notably, transcription is directly autoregulated by Spo0A~P binding sites known as 0A1, 0A2, and 0A3 box, located in between the two promoters. It remains unclear whether, at the onset of starvation, these boxes activate or repressspo0Aexpression, and whether the Spo0A~P transcriptional feedback plays a role in the increase inspo0Aexpression. Based on the experimental data of the promoter activities under systematic perturbation of the promoter architecture, we developed a biophysical model of transcriptional regulation ofspo0Aby Spo0A~P binding to each of the 0A boxes. The model predicts that Spo0A~P binding to its boxes does not affect the RNAP recruitment to the promoters but instead affects the transcriptional initiation rate. Moreover, the effects of Spo0A~P binding to 0A boxes are mainly repressive and saturated early at the onset of starvation. Therefore, the increase inspo0Aexpression is mainly driven by the increase in RNAP holoenzyme levels. Additionally, we reveal that Spo0A~P affinity to 0A boxes is strongest at 0A3 and weakest at 0A2 and that there are attractive forces between the occupied 0A boxes. Our findings, in addition to clarifying how the sporulation master regulator is controlled, offer a framework to predict regulatory outcomes of complex gene-regulatory mechanisms. IMPORTANCECell differentiation is often critical for survival. In bacteria, differentiation decisions are controlled by transcriptional master regulators under transcriptional feedback control. Therefore, understanding how master regulators are transcriptionally regulated is required to understand differentiation. However, in many cases, the underlying regulation is complex, with multiple transcription factor binding sites and multiple promoters, making it challenging to dissect the exact mechanisms. Here, we address this problem for theBacillus subtilismaster regulator Spo0A. Using a biophysical model, we quantitatively characterize the effect of individual transcription factor binding sites on eachspo0Apromoter. Furthermore, the model allows us to identify the specific transcription step that is affected by transcription factor binding. Such a model is promising for the quantitative study of a wide range of master regulators involved in transcriptional feedback. 
    more » « less