Title: Sublimation of Snow
Abstract Snow is a vital part of water resources, and sublimation may remove 10%–90% of snowfall from the system. To improve our understanding of the physics that govern sublimation rates, as well as how those rates might change with the climate, we deployed an array of four towers with over 100 instruments from NCAR’s Integrated Surface Flux System from November 2022 to June 2023 in the East River watershed, Colorado, in conjunction with the U.S. Department of Energy’s Surface Atmosphere Integrated Field Laboratory (SAIL) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)’s Study of Precipitation, the Lower Atmosphere and Surface for Hydrometeorology (SPLASH) campaigns. Mass balance observations, snow pits, particle flux sensors, and terrestrial lidar scans of the evolving snowfield demonstrated how blowing snow influences sublimation rates, which we quantified with latent heat fluxes measured by eddy-covariance systems at heights 1–20 m above the snow surface. Detailed temperature profiles at finer resolutions highlighted the role of the stable boundary layer. Four-stream radiometers indicated the important role of changing albedo in the energy balance and its relationship to water vapor losses. Collectively, these observations span scales from seconds to seasons, from boundary layer turbulence to valley circulation to mesoscale meteorology. We describe the field campaign, highlights in the observations, and outreach and education products we are creating to facilitate cross-disciplinary dialogue and convey relevant findings to those seeking to better understand Colorado River snow and streamflow.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2139836
PAR ID:
10558088
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
AMS
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society
Volume:
105
Issue:
6
ISSN:
0003-0007
Page Range / eLocation ID:
E975 to E990
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. na (Ed.)
    Abstract. Snow sublimation plays a fundamental role in the winter water balance. To date, few studies have quantified sublimation in tundra and boreal forest snow by direct measurements. Continuous latent heat data collected with eddy covariance (EC) measurements from 2010–2021 were used to calculate snow sublimation at six locations in northern Alaska: three Arctic tundra sites at distinct topographical and vegetation communities in the Imnavait Creek watershed on the North Slope underlain by continuous permafrost, and three lowland boreal forest/taiga sites in discontinuous permafrost in interior Alaska near Fairbanks. Mean surface sublimation rates range from 0.08–0.15 mm d−1 and 15–27 mm yr−1 at the six sites, representing, on average, 21 % of the measured solid precipitation and 8 %–16 % of the cumulative annual water vapor flux to the atmosphere (evaporation plus sublimation). The mean daily sublimation rates of the lowland boreal forest sites are higher than those of the tundra sites, but the longer snow cover period of the tundra sites leads to greater mean annual sublimation rates. We examined the potential controls, drivers, and trends of the sublimation rates by using meteorological data collected in conjunction with EC measurements. This research improves our understanding of how site conditions affect sublimation rates and highlights the fact that sublimation is a substantial component of the winter hydrologic cycle. In addition, the study contributes to the sparse literature on tundra and boreal sublimation measurements, and the measured rates are comparable to sublimation estimates in other northern climates. 
    more » « less
  2. Abstract Understanding the role of snow sublimation in the alpine water balance is critical to predicting future water resource availability. During winter 2022–23, the Sublimation of Snow campaign in Colorado’s East River watershed used 12 eddy covariance (EC) instruments (2–20-m height) to measure sublimation and micrometeorology on the valley floor. ECs measured 33–42 mm of snow water equivalent sublimated (8%–10% of seasonal peak snow accumulation). Midwinter sublimation was driven by blowing snow and springtime sublimation by positive net radiation. During blowing snow, EC water vapor fluxes increased with height between 3 and 10 m, on average by 26% and by up to 200% during individual events (positive vertical turbulent flux divergence). During nonblowing snow conditions, fluxes decreased with height between 3 and 20 m, on average by 36% (negative vertical turbulent flux divergence). Estimates of transport terms in a water vapor conservation equation suggest that positive divergence arose from blowing snow sublimation and negative divergence arose from vertical water vapor advection, although horizontal advection remains unquantified, limiting our conclusions. We found that keeping one instrument functional over the entire winter is more important than having instruments at multiple heights. Seasonal uncertainty in measured total sublimation due to instrument height is estimated at ±12% due to blowing snow sublimation and water vapor advection; however, for shorter deployments, this uncertainty may be larger. The optimal instrument height for estimating total sublimation, 10 m at our site, is likely to vary by location, and further work is needed to understand the role of advection. Significance StatementMountain snowpacks act as water reservoirs for populations worldwide, and snow sublimation, which is rarely measured, removes water from those reservoirs. A recent measurement campaign offered the unique opportunity to compare sublimation measurements from 12 instruments, which reveal that sublimation estimates vary both across a winter season and with instrument height. Sublimation rates are higher during times with blowing snow compared to times without. During blowing snow, higher instruments (above 5 m) measure 26% more sublimation than lower instruments. Otherwise, higher instruments (above 10 m) measure 36% less sublimation. This work concludes that when measuring alpine sublimation, instrument height can introduce uncertainty, particularly if instruments are deployed for short periods of time. To best estimate total sublimation, instruments should be deployed over an entire winter season. 
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Sublimation is an important yet uncertain component of the water balance in snow-dominated regions. Models that parameterize sublimation as a function of temperature show that sublimation has increased over recent decades, and this has been identified as a possible reason for declining Colorado River streamflow. However, sublimation increases with wind speed and water vapor gradients and cannot be well explained by temperature alone. Thus, we hypothesize that most accumulation season sublimation occurs during distinct weather events. To test this hypothesis, we combined two years of meteorological observations spanning site-to-synoptic scales from three field campaigns in a Colorado mountain valley and identified the events that produced the mostsublimation, classifying them by duration and intensity. We found that approximately 60% of winter sublimation occurred during a small number of discrete events (14% of the season). These events coincided with either short sunny, dry periods or long storm events that brought new snowfall followed by blowing snow. Using these classified events and synoptic-scale reanalysis, we trained a random forest classifier to estimate long sublimation event occurrences and test whether they increased over the past four decades. The model performed well (average precision = 0.73; balanced accuracy = 79%), and results were most strongly associated with winter mean 500-hPa wind speed and total observed precipitation. Event occurrence varied considerably year to year with no significant long-term trend. In all, our findings show that accurately representing seasonal sublimation requires capturing discrete events driven by identifiable synoptic and local meteorological conditions. 
    more » « less
  4. Sublimation is an important yet uncertain component of the water balance in snow- dominated regions. Models that parameterize sublimation as a function of temperature show that sublimation has increased over recent decades, and this has been identified as a possible reason for declining Colorado River streamflow. However, sublimation increases with wind speed and water vapor gradients and cannot be well explained by temperature alone. Thus, we hypothesize that most accumulation season sublimation occurs during distinct weather events. To test this hypothesis, we combined two years of meteorological observations spanning site-to-synoptic scales from three field campaigns in a Colorado mountain valley and identified the events that produced the most sublimation, classifying them by duration and intensity. We found that approximately 60% of winter sublimation occurred during a small number of discrete events (14% of the season). These events coincided with either short sunny, dry periods or long storm events that brought new snowfall followed by blowing snow. Using these classified events and synoptic-scale reanalysis, we trained a random forest classifier to estimate long sublimation event occurrences and test whether they increased over the past four decades. The model performed well (average precision = 0.73; balanced accuracy = 79%) and results were most strongly associated with winter mean 500-hPa wind speed and total precipitation. Event occurrence varied considerably year to year with no significant long-term trend. In all, our findings show that accurately representing seasonal sublimation requires capturing discrete events driven by identifiable synoptic and local meteorological conditions. 
    more » « less
  5. Surface grids of the snow, ground, and vegetation surfaces derived from the six terrestrial scanning lidars that were deployed on three flux towers near Crested Butte, Colorado for the SOS (Sublimation of Snow) campaign. The data were collected to support the analysis of snow depth, snow surface variability, snow redistributions, and sublimation particularly from blowing snow. 
    more » « less