skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: Building a semi-analytic Black Hole seeding model using IllustrisTNG host galaxies
Abstract A major open question in astrophysics is the mechanisms by which massive black holes (BHs) form in the early Universe, which pose constraints on seeding models. We study BH formation and evolution in a flexible model combining the cosmological IllustrisTNG (TNG) simulations with semi-analytic modeling in post-processing. We identify our TNG model hosts based on various criteria including a minimum gas mass of 107–109 M⊙, total host mass of 108.5–1010.5 M⊙, and a maximum gas metallicity of 0.01–0.1 Z⊙. Each potential host is assigned a BH seed with a probability of 0.01–1. The populations follow the TNG galaxy merger tree. This approach improves upon the predictive power of the simple TNG BH seeding prescription, narrowing down plausible seeding parameter spaces, and it is readily adaptable to other cosmological simulations. Several model realizations predict z ≲ 4 BH mass densities that are consistent with empirical data as well as the TNG BHs. However, high-redshift BH number densities can differ by factors of ∼ 10 to ≳ 100 between seeding parameters. In most model realizations, ≲ 105 M⊙ BHs substantially outnumber heavier BHs at high redshifts. Mergers between such BHs are prime targets for gravitational-wave detection with LISA. The z = 0 BH mass densities in most realizations of the model agree well with observations, but our strictest seeding criteria fail at high redshift. Our findings strongly motivate the need for better empirical constraints on high-z BHs, and they underscore the significance of recent AGN discoveries with JWST.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1909933 2307171
PAR ID:
10561352
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Oxford University Press
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
ISSN:
0035-8711
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; et al (, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society)
    ABSTRACT The origin of the ‘seeds’ of supermassive black holes (BHs) continues to be a puzzle, as it is currently unclear if the imprints of early seed formation could survive to today. We examine the signatures of seeding in the local Universe using five $$[18~\mathrm{Mpc}]^3$$BRAHMA simulation boxes run to $z=0$. They initialize $$1.5\times 10^5~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ BHs using different seeding models. The first four boxes initialize BHs as heavy seeds using criteria that depend on dense and metal-poor gas, Lyman–Werner radiation, gas spin, and environmental richness. The fifth box initializes BHs as descendants of lower mass seeds ($$\sim 10^3~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$) using a new stochastic seed model built in our previous work. In our simulations, we find that the abundances and properties of $$\sim 10^5-10^6~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ local BHs hosted in $$M_*\lesssim 10^{9}~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ dwarf galaxies, are sensitive to the assumed seeding criteria. This is for two reasons: (1) there is a substantial population of local $$\sim 10^5~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ BHs that are ungrown relics of early seeds from $$z\sim 5-10$$; (2) BH growth up to $$\sim 10^6~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ is dominated by mergers in our simulations all the way down to $$z\sim 0$$. As the contribution from gas accretion increases, the signatures of seeding start to weaken in more massive $$\gtrsim 10^6~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ BHs, and they are erased for $$\gtrsim 10^7~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ BHs. The different seed models explored here predict abundances of local $$\sim 10^6~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ BHs ranging from $$\sim 0.01-0.05~\mathrm{Mpc}^{-3}$$ with occupation fractions of $$\sim 20-100~{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$$ for $$M_*\sim 10^{9}~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ galaxies. These results highlight the potential for placing constraints on seeding models using local $$\sim 10^5-10^6~\rm {M}_{\odot }$$ BHs hosted in dwarf galaxies. Since merger dynamics and accretion physics impact the persistence of seeding signatures, and both high and low mass seed models can produce similar local BH populations, disentangling their roles will require combining high and low redshift constraints. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society)
    ABSTRACT The James Webb Space Telescope will have the power to characterize high-redshift quasars at z ≥ 6 with an unprecedented depth and spatial resolution. While the brightest quasars at such redshift (i.e. with bolometric luminosity $$L_{\rm bol}\geqslant 10^{46}\, \rm erg/s$$) provide us with key information on the most extreme objects in the Universe, measuring the black hole (BH) mass and Eddington ratios of fainter quasars with $$L_{\rm bol}= 10^{45}-10^{46}\, \rm erg\,s^{ -1}$$ opens a path to understand the build-up of more normal BHs at z ≥ 6. In this paper, we show that the Illustris, TNG100, TNG300, Horizon-AGN, EAGLE, and SIMBA large-scale cosmological simulations do not agree on whether BHs at z ≥ 4 are overmassive or undermassive at fixed galaxy stellar mass with respect to the MBH − M⋆ scaling relation at z = 0 (BH mass offsets). Our conclusions are unchanged when using the local scaling relation produced by each simulation or empirical relations. We find that the BH mass offsets of the simulated faint quasar population at z ≥ 4, unlike those of bright quasars, represent the BH mass offsets of the entire BH population, for all the simulations. Thus, a population of faint quasars with $$L_{\rm bol}= 10^{45}-10^{46}\, \rm erg\,s^{ -1}$$ observed by JWST can provide key constraints on the assembly of BHs at high redshift. Moreover, this will help constraining the high-redshift regime of cosmological simulations, including BH seeding, early growth, and co-evolution with the host galaxies. Our results also motivate the need for simulations of larger cosmological volumes down to z ∼ 6, with the same diversity of subgrid physics, in order to gain statistics on the most extreme objects at high redshift. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society)
    The physical origin of the seeds of supermassive black holes (SMBHs), with postulated initial masses ranging from ∼105 M⊙ to as low as ∼102 M⊙, is currently unknown. Most existing cosmological hydrodynamic simulations adopt very simple, ad hoc prescriptions for BH seeding and seed at unphysically high masses ∼105–106 M⊙. In this work, we introduce a novel sub-grid BH seeding model for cosmological simulations that is directly calibrated to high-resolution zoom simulations that explicitly resolve ∼103 M⊙ seeds forming within haloes with pristine, dense gas. We trace the BH growth along galaxy merger trees until their descendants reach masses of ∼104 or 105 M⊙. The results are used to build a new stochastic seeding model that directly seeds these descendants in lower resolution versions of our zoom region. Remarkably, we find that by seeding the descendants simply based on total galaxy mass, redshift and an environmental richness parameter, we can reproduce the results of the detailed gas-based seeding model. The baryonic properties of the host galaxies are well reproduced by the mass-based seeding criterion. The redshift-dependence of the mass-based criterion captures the combined influence of halo growth, dense gas formation, and metal enrichment on the formation of ∼103 M⊙ seeds. The environment-based seeding criterion seeds the descendants in rich environments with higher numbers of neighbouring galaxies. This accounts for the impact of unresolved merger dominated growth of BHs, which produces faster growth of descendants in richer environments with more extensive BH merger history. Our new seed model will be useful for representing a variety of low-mass seeding channels within next-generation larger volume uniform cosmological simulations. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; et al (, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society)
    ABSTRACT Recent systematic searches for massive black holes (BHs) in local dwarf galaxies led to the discovery of a population of faint active galactic nuclei (AGNs). We investigate the agreement of the BH and AGN populations in the Illustris, TNG, Horizon-AGN, EAGLE, and SIMBA simulations with current observational constraints in low-mass galaxies. We find that some of these simulations produce BHs that are too massive, and that the BH occupation fraction (OF) at z = 0 is not inherited from the simulation seeding modelling. The ability of BHs and their host galaxies to power an AGN depends on BH and galaxy subgrid modelling. The fraction of AGN in low-mass galaxies is not used to calibrate the simulations, and thus can be used to differentiate galaxy formation models. AGN fractions at z = 0 span two orders of magnitude at fixed galaxy stellar mass in simulations, similarly to observational constraints, but uncertainties and degeneracies affect both observations and simulations. The agreement is difficult to interpret due to differences in the masses of simulated and observed BHs, BH OF affected by numerical choices, and an unknown fraction of obscured AGN. Our work advocates for more thorough comparisons with observations to improve the modelling of cosmological simulations, and our understanding of BH and galaxy physics in the low-mass regime. The mass of BHs, their ability to efficiently accrete gas, and the AGN fraction in low-mass galaxies have important implications for the build-up of the entire BH and galaxy populations with time. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; (, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society)
    ABSTRACT JWST has revealed a large population of accreting black holes (BHs) in the early Universe. Recent work has shown that even after accounting for possible systematic biases, the high-z$$M_*{\!-\!}M_{\rm \rm bh}$$ relation can be above the local scaling relation by $$\gt 3\sigma$$. To understand the implications of these overmassive high-z BHs, we study the BH growth at $$z\sim 4{\!-\!}7$$ using the $$[18~\mathrm{Mpc}]^3$$BRAHMA cosmological simulations with systematic variations of heavy seed models that emulate direct collapse black hole (DCBH) formation. In our least restrictive seed model, we place $$\sim 10^5~{\rm M}_{\odot }$$ seeds in haloes with sufficient dense and metal-poor gas. To model conditions for direct collapse, we impose additional criteria based on a minimum Lyman Werner flux (LW flux $$=10~J_{21}$$), maximum gas spin, and an environmental richness criterion. The high-z BH growth in our simulations is merger dominated, with a relatively small contribution from gas accretion. The simulation that includes all the above seeding criteria fails to reproduce an overmassive high-z$$M_*{\!-\!}M_{\rm bh}$$ relation consistent with observations (by factor of $$\sim 10$$ at $$z\sim 4$$). However, more optimistic models that exclude the spin and environment based criteria are able to reproduce the observed relations if we assume $$\lesssim 750~\mathrm{Myr}$$ delay times between host galaxy mergers and subsequent BH mergers. Overall, our results suggest that current JWST observations may be explained with heavy seeding channels if their formation is more efficient than currently assumed DCBH conditions. Alternatively, we may need higher initial seed masses, additional contributions from lighter seeds to BH mergers, and / or more efficient modes for BH accretion. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Text Encoded Conversion
  • XML
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email