skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Optimizing Speaker Diarization for the Classroom: Applications in Timing Student Speech and Distinguishing Teachers from Children
An important dimension of classroom group dynamics & collaboration is how much each person contributes to the discussion. With the goal of distinguishing teachers' speech from children's speech and measuring how much each student speaks, we have investigated how automatic speaker diarization can be built to handle real-world classroom group discussions. We examined key design considerations such as the level of granularity of speaker assignment, speech enhancement techniques, voice activity detection, and embedding assignment methods to find an effective configuration. The best speaker diarization system we found was based on the ECAPA-TDNN speaker embedding model and used Whisper automatic speech recognition to identify speech segments. The diarization error rate (DER) in challenging noisy spontaneous classroom data was around 34%, and the correlations of estimated vs. human annotations of how much each student spoke reached 0.62. The accuracy of distinguishing teachers' speech from children's speech was 69.17%. We evaluated the system for potential accuracy bias across people of different skin tones and genders and found that the accuracy did not show statistically significantly differences across either dimension. Thus, the presented diarization system has potential to benefit educational research and to provide teachers and students with useful feedback to better understand their classroom dynamics.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2019805 2046505
PAR ID:
10588540
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ; ; ;
Publisher / Repository:
Zenodo
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of educational data mining
ISSN:
2157-2100
Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
speaker diarization automatic speech recognition automatic classroom analysis group collaboration
Format(s):
Medium: X
Right(s):
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    Speech and language development in children is crucial for ensuring optimal outcomes in their long term development and life-long educational journey. A child’s vocabulary size at the time of kindergarten entry is an early indicator of learning to read and potential long-term success in school. The preschool classroom is thus a promising venue for monitoring growth in young children by measuring their interactions with teachers and classmates. Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) technologies provide the ability for ‘Early Childhood’ researchers for automatically analyzing naturalistic recordings in these settings. For this purpose, data are collected in a high-quality childcare center in the United States using Language Environment Analysis (LENA) devices worn by the preschool children. A preliminary task for ASR of daylong audio recordings would involve diarization, i.e., segmenting speech into smaller parts for identifying ‘who spoke when.’ This study investigates a Deep Learning-based diarization system for classroom interactions of 3-5-year-old children. However, the focus is on ’speaker group’ diarization, which includes classifying speech segments as being from adults or children from across multiple classrooms. SincNet based diarization systems achieve utterance level Diarization Error Rate of 19.1%. Utterance level speaker group confusion matrices also show promising, balanced results. These diarization systems have potential applications in developing metrics for adult-to-child or child-to-child rapid conversational turns in a naturalistic noisy early childhood setting. Such technical advancements will also help teachers better and more efficiently quantify and understand their interactions with children, make changes as needed, and monitor the impact of those changes. 
    more » « less
  2. Speech and language development are early indicators of overall analytical and learning ability in children. The preschool classroom is a rich language environment for monitoring and ensuring growth in young children by measuring their vocal interactions with teachers and classmates. Early childhood researchers are naturally interested in analyzing naturalistic vs controlled lab recordings to measure both quality and quantity of such interactions. Unfortunately, present-day speech technologies are not capable of addressing the wide dynamic scenario of early childhood classroom settings. Due to the diversity of acoustic events/conditions in such daylong audio streams, automated speaker diarization technology would need to be advanced to address this challenging domain for segmenting audio as well as information extraction. This study investigates alternate deep learning-based lightweight, knowledge-distilled, diarization solutions for segmenting classroom interactions of 3–5 years old children with teachers. In this context, the focus on speech-type diarization which classifies speech segments as being either from adults or children partitioned across multiple classrooms. Our lightest CNN model achieves a best F1-score of ∼76.0% on data from two classrooms, based on dev and test sets of each classroom. It is utilized with automatic speech recognition-based re-segmentation modules to perform child-adult diarization. Additionally, F1-scores are obtained for individual segments with corresponding speaker tags (e.g., adult vs child), which provide knowledge for educators on child engagement through naturalistic communications. The study demonstrates the prospects of addressing educational assessment needs through communication audio stream analysis, while maintaining both security and privacy of all children and adults. The resulting child communication metrics have been used for broad-based feedback for teachers with the help of visualizations. 
    more » « less
  3. Speech and language development are early indicators of overall analytical and learning ability in children. The preschool classroom is a rich language environment for monitoring and ensuring growth in young children by measuring their vocal interactions with teachers and classmates. Early childhood researchers are naturally interested in analyzing naturalistic vs. controlled lab recordings to measure both quality and quantity of such interactions. Unfortunately, present-day speech technologies are not capable of addressing the wide dynamic scenario of early childhood classroom settings. Due to the diversity of acoustic events/conditions in such daylong audio streams, automated speaker diarization technology would need to be advanced to address this challenging domain for segmenting audio as well as information extraction. This study investigates an alternate Deep Learning-based diarization solution for segmenting classroom interactions of 3-5 year old children with teachers. In this context, the focus on speech-type diarization which classifies speech segments as being either from adults or children partitioned across multiple classrooms. Our proposed ResNet model achieves a best F1-score of ∼78.0% on data from two classrooms, based on dev and test sets of each classroom. It is utilized with Automatic Speech Recognition-based resegmentation modules to perform child-adult diarization. Additionally, F1-scores are obtained for individual segments with corresponding speaker tags (e.g., adult vs. child), which provide knowledge for educators on child engagement through naturalistic communications. The study demonstrates the prospects of addressing educational assessment needs through communication audio stream analysis, while maintaining both security and privacy of all children and adults. The resulting child communication metrics have been used for broad-based feedback for teachers with the help of visualizations. 
    more » « less
  4. Speech and language development are early indicators of overall analytical and learning ability in children. The preschool classroom is a rich language environment for monitoring and ensuring growth in young children by measuring their vocal interactions with teachers and classmates. Early childhood researchers are naturally interested in analyzing naturalistic vs. controlled lab recordings to measure both quality and quantity of such interactions. Unfortunately, present-day speech technologies are not capable of addressing the wide dynamic scenario of early childhood classroom settings. Due to the diversity of acoustic events/conditions in such daylong audio streams, automated speaker diarization technology would need to be advanced to address this challenging domain for segmenting audio as well as information extraction. This study investigates an alternate Deep Learning-based diarization solution for segmenting classroom interactions of 3-5 year old children with teachers. In this context, the focus on speech-type diarization which classifies speech segments as being either from adults or children partitioned across multiple classrooms. Our proposed ResNet model achieves a best F1-score of ∼71.0% on data from two classrooms, based on dev and test sets of each classroom. Additionally, F1-scores are obtained for individual segments with corresponding speaker tags (e.g., adult vs. child), which provide knowledge for educators on child engagement through naturalistic communications. The study demonstrates the prospects of addressing educational assessment needs through communication audio stream analysis, while maintaining both security and privacy of all children and adults. The resulting child communication metrics have been used for broad-based feedback for teachers with the help of visualizations. 
    more » « less
  5. When dealing with overlapped speech, the performance of automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems substantially degrades as they are designed for single-talker speech. To enhance ASR performance in conversational or meeting environments, continuous speaker separation (CSS) is commonly employed. However, CSS requires a short separation window to avoid many speakers inside the window and sequential grouping of discontinuous speech segments. To address these limitations, we introduce a new multi-channel framework called “speaker separation via neural diarization” (SSND) for meeting environments. Our approach utilizes an end-to-end diarization system to identify the speech activity of each individual speaker. By leveraging estimated speaker boundaries, we generate a sequence of embeddings, which in turn facilitate the assignment of speakers to the outputs of a multi-talker separation model. SSND addresses the permutation ambiguity issue of talker-independent speaker separation during the diarization phase through location-based training, rather than during the separation process. This unique approach allows multiple non-overlapped speakers to be assigned to the same output stream, making it possible to efficiently process long segments—a task impossible with CSS. Additionally, SSND is naturally suitable for speaker-attributed ASR. We evaluate our proposed diarization and separation methods on the open LibriCSS dataset, advancing state-of-the-art diarization and ASR results by a large margin. 
    more » « less