An official website of the United States government
Microservice architecture design requires the architect to meet the needs of multiple stakeholders and to address their needs for maintainability, scalability, and availability. In the microservice architecture context, a comprehensive performance and scalability assessment is a dynamic activity, which is focused on the detection of service level metric deviations from objectives using a defined operational profile. Root cause analysis is focused on the identification of the activated microservice components given the defined load profile. Therefore, performance issues are identified by detecting dynamic deviations from the expected behaviors of the service level metric.In contrast, microservice architecture assessment focus is on identifying implicit relations among microservice components. Architecture anti-patterns are identified by detecting deviations from the defined formal design patterns. As the ultimate objective of microservice architecture design is to build high-quality applications it would be expected that architecture refactoring based on the removal of architecture anti-patterns will result in meeting stakeholder needs of better scalability and availability.In this paper we present an empirical assessment of architecture anti-pattern detection in combination with the identification of performance issues using two state of the art tools: DV8 for architecture and PPTAM for performance. We make use of Train Ticket, i.e., a benchmark microservice system, and we observed the co-occurrence of architectural (Clique) and performance (Blob) anti-patterns, noting that high coupling shows much worse performance scores. We have found strong correlation between the normalized distance performance metric and architecture coupling values using several similarity metrics. Our empirical results show that operational profile based performance testing and analysis can be used to help prioritize architecture refactoring.
more »
« less
This content will become publicly available on March 31, 2026
Architecture and Performance Anti-patterns Correlation in Microservice Architectures
Microservice architecture design requires the architect to meet the needs of multiple stakeholders and to address their needs for maintainability, scalability, and availability. In the microservice architecture context, a comprehensive performance and scalability assessment is a dynamic activity, which is focused on the detection of service level metric deviations from objectives using a defined operational profile. Root cause analysis is focused on the identification of the activated microservice components given the defined load profile. Therefore, performance issues are identified by detecting dynamic deviations from the expected behaviors of the service level metric.In contrast, microservice architecture assessment focus is on identifying implicit relations among microservice components. Architecture anti-patterns are identified by detecting deviations from the defined formal design patterns. As the ultimate objective of microservice architecture design is to build high-quality applications it would be expected that architecture refactoring based on the removal of architecture anti-patterns will result in meeting stakeholder needs of better scalability and availability.In this paper we present an empirical assessment of architecture anti-pattern detection in combination with the identification of performance issues using two state of the art tools: DV8 for architecture and PPTAM for performance. We make use of Train Ticket, i.e., a benchmark microservice system, and we observed the co-occurrence of architectural (Clique) and performance (Blob) anti-patterns, noting that high coupling shows much worse performance scores. We have found strong correlation between the normalized distance performance metric and architecture coupling values using several similarity metrics. Our empirical results show that operational profile based performance testing and analysis can be used to help prioritize architecture refactoring.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10590982
- Publisher / Repository:
- IEEE
- Date Published:
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Microservice architecture, Performance evaluation, Antipattern detection
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Evolutionary design is a widely accepted practice for defining microservice boundaries. It is performed through a sequence of incremental refactoring tasks (we call it “microservice refactoring”), each restructuring only part of a microservice system (a.k.a., refactoring part) into well-defined services for improving the architecture in a controlled manner. Despite its popularity in practice, microservice refactoring suffers from insufficient methodological support. While there are numerous studies addressing similar software design tasks, i.e., software remodularization and microservitization, their approaches prove inadequate when applied to microservice refactoring. Our analysis reveals that their approaches may even degrade the entire architecture in microservice refactoring, as they only optimize the refactoring part in such applications, but neglect the relationships between the refactoring part and the remaining system. As the first response to the need, Micro2Micro is proposed to re-partition the refactoring part while optimizing three quality objectives including the interdependence between the refactoring and non-refactoring parts. In addition, it allows architects to intervene in the decision-making process by interactively incorporating their knowledge into the iterative search for optimal refactoring solutions. An empirical study on 13 open-source projects of different sizes shows that the solutions from Micro2Micro perform well and exhibit quality improvement with an average up to 45% to the original architecture. Users of Micro2Micro found the suggested solutions highly satisfactory. They acknowledge the advantages in terms of infusing human intelligence into decisions, providing immediate quality feedback, and quick exploration capability.more » « less
-
The emergence of database-as-a-service platforms has made deploying database applications easier than before. Now, developers can quickly create scalable applications. However, designing performant, maintainable, and accurate applications is challenging. Developers may unknowingly introduce anti-patterns in the application's SQL statements. These anti-patterns are design decisions that are intended to solve a problem, but often lead to other problems by violating fundamental design principles. In this paper, we present SQLCheck, a holistic toolchain for automatically finding and fixing anti-patterns in database applications. We introduce techniques for automatically (1) detecting anti-patterns with high precision and recall, (2) ranking the anti-patterns based on their impact on performance, maintainability, and accuracy of applications, and (3) suggesting alternative queries and changes to the database design to fix these anti-patterns. We demonstrate the prevalence of these anti-patterns in a large collection of queries and databases collected from open-source repositories. We introduce an anti-pattern detection algorithm that augments query analysis with data analysis. We present a ranking model for characterizing the impact of frequently occurring anti-patterns. We discuss how SQLCheck suggests fixes for high-impact anti-patterns using rule-based query refactoring techniques. Our experiments demonstrate that SQLCheck enables developers to create more performant, maintainable, and accurate applications.more » « less
-
We will demonstrate a prototype of sqlcheck, a holistic toolchain for automatically finding and fixing anti-patterns in database appli- cations. The advent of modern database-as-a-service platforms has made it easy for developers to quickly create scalable applications. However, it is still challenging for developers to design performant, maintainable, and accurate applications. This is because develop- ers may unknowingly introduce anti-patterns in the application’s SQL statements. These anti-patterns are design decisions that are intended to solve a problem, but often lead to other problems by violating fundamental design principles. sqlcheck leverages techniques for automatically: (1) detecting anti-patterns with high accuracy, (2) ranking them based on their impact on performance, maintainability, and accuracy of applica- tions, and (3) suggesting alternative queries and changes to the database design to fix these anti-patterns. We will demonstrate that sqlcheck enables developers to create more performant, maintain- able, and accurate applications. We will show the prevalence of these anti-patterns in a large collection of queries and databases collected from open-source repositories.more » « less
-
Field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) have largely been used in communication and high-performance computing and given the recent advances in big data and emerging trends in cloud computing (e.g., serverless [18]), FPGAs are increasingly being introduced into these domains (e.g., Microsoft’s datacenters [6] and Amazon Web Services [10]). To address these domains’ processing needs, recent research has focused on using FPGAs to accelerate workloads, ranging from analytics and machine learning to databases and network function virtualization. In this paper, we present an ongoing effort to realize a high-performance FPGA-as-a-microservice (FaaM) architecture for the cloud. We discuss some of the technical challenges and propose several solutions for efficiently integrating FPGAs into virtualized environments. Our case study deploying a multithreaded, multi-user compression as a microservice using the FaaM architecture indicate that microservices-based FPGA acceleration can sustain high-performance compared to straightforward implementation with minimal to no communication overhead despite the hardware abstraction.more » « less
