An official website of the United States government
Abstract Ectomycorrhizal (ECM) fungi have long been thought to reduce litter decomposition in nitrogen (N)‐limited ecosystems by outcompeting saprotrophs for litter N (a phenomenon known as the ‘Gadgil effect’). However, recent research has called the generality of this effect into question, by demonstrating that ECM fungi can increase or decrease organic matter decomposition in different forests. The ecological factors driving such variation in the size and direction of ECM fungal effects on decomposition remain unclear.Here, we tested the hypothesis that ECM fungi would suppress decomposition of N‐poor, recalcitrant litter more in forests with lower N‐availability by exacerbating saprotrophic N limitation. We conducted an in situ ECM fungal and root reduction experiment (via soil trenching) in nine pine forests across three US states, which varied in soil and litter N content, climate and pine host (Pinus muricatain California,P. elliottiiin Florida and P.resinosain Minnesota). In each site, we decomposed needle litter from (1) a pine species native to that site and (2) a common litter,P. strobus, for 1 year.Contrary to our expectations, ECM fungi either stimulated (California) or had no effect on (Florida and Minnesota) pine needle decomposition. Across sites, ECM fungal stimulation of decomposition did increase with total soil N content, but was unrelated to inorganic N availability. Furthermore, despite previous work suggesting that competition for N structures ECM fungal–saprotroph interactions, trenching effects on decomposition did not differ between pine litter types, despite large differences in initial litter C:N ratios, recalcitrance and net litter N immobilization.Synthesis. Taken together, our results add to a growing body of evidence that the ‘Gadgil effect’ is not universal, even in the N‐poor litter of temperate pine forests where it was first described and is often invoked. Furthermore, the inconsistency of relationships between trenching effects with different metrics of decomposer N supply and demand calls into question the central role of N in structuring fungal interguild interactions.
more »
« less
Mycorrhizal fungi modify decomposition: a meta‐analysis
Summary It has been proposed that ectomycorrhizal fungi can reduce decomposition while arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi may enhance it. These phenomena are known as the ‘Gadgil effect’ and ‘priming effect’, respectively. However, it is unclear which one predominates globally.We evaluated whether mycorrhizal fungi decrease or increase decomposition, and identified conditions that mediate this effect. We obtained decomposition data from 43 studies (97 trials) conducted in field or laboratory settings that controlled the access of mycorrhizal fungi to substrates colonized by saprotrophs.Across studies, mycorrhizal fungi promoted decomposition of different substrates by 6.7% overall by favoring the priming effect over the Gadgil effect. However, we observed significant variation among studies. The substrate C : N ratio and absolute latitude influenced the effect of mycorrhizal fungi on decomposition and contributed to the variation. Specifically, mycorrhizal fungi increased decomposition at low substrate C : N and absolute latitude, but there was no discernable effect at high values. Unexpectedly, the effect of mycorrhizal fungi was not influenced by the mycorrhizal type.Our findings challenge previous assumptions about the universality of the Gadgil effect but highlight the potential of mycorrhizal fungi to negatively influence soil carbon storage by promoting the priming effect.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2308342
- PAR ID:
- 10610868
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley-Blackwell
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- New Phytologist
- Volume:
- 242
- Issue:
- 6
- ISSN:
- 0028-646X
- Format(s):
- Medium: X Size: p. 2763-2774
- Size(s):
- p. 2763-2774
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract Identifying the primary controls of particulate (POM) and mineral‐associated organic matter (MAOM) content in soils is critical for determining future stocks of soil carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) across the globe. However, drivers of these soil organic matter fractions are likely to vary among ecosystems in response to climate, soil type and the composition of local biological communities.We tested how soil factors, climate and plant–fungal associations influenced the distribution and concentrations of C and N in MAOM and POM in seven temperate forests in the National Ecological Observatory Network (NEON) across the eastern United States. Samples of upper mineral horizon soil within each forest were collected in plots representing a gradient of dominant tree–mycorrhizal association, allowing us to test how plant and microbial communities influenced POM and MAOM across sites differing in climate and soil conditions.We found that concentrations of C and N in soil organic matter were primarily driven by soil mineralogy, but the relative abundance of MAOM versus POM C was strongly linked to plot‐level mycorrhizal dominance. Furthermore, the effect of dominant tree mycorrhizal type on the distribution of N among POM and MAOM fractions was sensitive to local climate: in cooler sites, an increasing proportion of ectomycorrhizal‐associated trees was associated with lower proportions of N in MAOM, but in warmer sites, we found the reverse. As an indicator of soil carbon age, we measured radiocarbon in the MAOM fraction but found that within and across sites, Δ14C was unrelated to mycorrhizal dominance, climate, or soil factors, suggesting that additional site‐specific factors may be primary determinants of long‐term SOM persistence.Synthesis. Our results indicate that while soil mineralogy primarily controls SOM C and N concentrations, the distribution of SOM among density fractions depends on the composition of vegetation and microbial communities, with these effects varying across sites with distinct climates. We also suggest that within biomes, the age of mineral‐associated soil carbon is not clearly linked to the factors that control concentrations of MAOM C and N.more » « less
-
Summary Rising atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations (CO2) and atmospheric nitrogen (N) deposition have contrasting effects on ectomycorrhizal (EM) and arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) symbioses, potentially mediating forest responses to environmental change.In this study, we evaluated the cumulative effects of historical environmental change on N concentrations and δ15N values in AM plants, EM plants, EM fungi, and saprotrophic fungi using herbarium specimens collected in Minnesota, USA from 1871 to 2016. To better understand mycorrhizal mediation of foliar δ15N, we also analyzed a subset of previously published foliar δ15N values from across the United States to parse the effects of N deposition and CO2rise.Over the last century in Minnesota, N concentrations declined among all groups except saprotrophic fungi. δ15N also declined among all groups of plants and fungi; however, foliar δ15N declined less in EM plants than in AM plants. In the analysis of previously published foliar δ15N values, this slope difference between EM and AM plants was better explained by nitrogen deposition than by CO2rise.Mycorrhizal type did not explain trajectories of plant N concentrations. Instead, plants and EM fungi exhibited similar declines in N concentrations, consistent with declining forest N status despite moderate levels of N deposition.more » « less
-
Abstract Fungal necromass is increasingly recognized as a key component of soil carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) cycling. However, how C and N loss from fungal necromass during decomposition is impacted by global change factors such as anthropogenic N addition and changes to soil C supply (e.g. via changing root exudation and rhizosphere priming) remains unclear and understudied relative to plant tissues.To address these gaps, we conducted a year‐long decomposition experiment with four species of fungal necromass incubated across four forested sites in plots that had received inorganic N and/or labile C fertilization for two decades in Minnesota, USA.We found that necromass chemistry was the primary driver of C and N loss from fungal necromass as well as the response to fertilization. Specifically, N addition suppressed late‐stage decomposition, but this effect was weaker in melanin‐rich necromass, contrary to the hypothesis based on plant litter dynamics that N addition should suppress the decomposition of more complex organic molecules. Labile C addition had no effect on either the early or late stages of necromass decomposition.Nitrogen release from necromass also varied among species, with N‐poor necromass having lower N release after controlling for differences in mass loss via regression. The relatively minor effects of N fertilization on the proportion of initial necromass N released suggest that N demand by decomposers is the primary control on N loss during fungal necromass decomposition.Synthesis. Together, our results stress the importance of the afterlife effects of fungal chemical composition to forest soil C and N cycles. Further, they demonstrate that C and N release from this critical pool can be reduced by ongoing anthropogenic N addition.more » « less
-
Abstract Fungi represent a rapidly cycling pool of carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) in soils. Understanding of how this pool impacts soil nutrient availability and organic matter fluxes is hindered by uncertainty regarding the dynamics and drivers of fungal necromass decomposition.Here we assessed the generality of common models for predicting mass loss during fungal necromass decomposition and linked the resulting parameters to necromass substrate chemistry. We decomposed 28 different types of fungal necromass in laboratory microcosms over a 90‐day period, measuring mass loss on all types, and N release on a subset of types. We characterised the initial chemistry of each necromass type using: (a) fibre analysis methods commonly used for plant tissues, (b) initial melanin and nitrogen (N) concentrations and (c) Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy to assess the presence of bonds associated with common biomolecules.We found universal support for an asymptotic model of decomposition, which assumes that fungal necromass consists of an exponentially decomposing ‘fast’ pool, and a ‘slow’ pool that decomposes at a rate approaching zero. The strongest predictor of the fast pool decay rate (k) was the proportion of cell soluble components, though initial N concentration also predictedk, albeit more weakly. The size of the slow pool was best predicted by the acid non‐hydrolysable fraction, which was positively correlated with melanin‐associated aromatics. Nitrogen dynamics varied by necromass type, ranging from net N release to net immobilisation. The maximum quantity of N immobilised was inversely related to cell soluble contents andk, as positively related to FTIR spectra associated with cell wall polysaccharides.Collectively, our results indicate that the decomposition of fungal necromass in soils can be described as having two distinct stages that are driven by different components of substrate C chemistry, with implications for rates of N availability and organic matter accumulation in soils. A freePlain Language Summarycan be found within the Supporting Information of this article.more » « less
