Abstract Deep penetration of energetic electrons (10s–100s of keV) to lowL‐shells (L < 4), as an important source of inner belt electrons, is commonly observed during geomagnetically active times. However, such deep penetration is not observed as frequently for similar energy protons, for which underlying mechanisms are not fully understood. To study their differential deep penetration, we conducted a statistical analysis using phase space densities (PSDs) ofµ = 10–50 MeV/G,K = 0.14 G1/2Re electrons and protons from multiyear Van Allen Probes observations. The results suggest systematic differences in electron and proton deep penetration: electron PSD enhancements at lowL‐shells occur more frequently, deeply, and faster than protons. Forµ = 10–50 MeV/G electrons, the occurrence rate of deep penetration events (defined as daily‐averaged PSD enhanced by at least a factor of 2 within a day atL < 4) is ∼2–3 events/month. For protons, only ∼1 event/month was observed forµ = 10 MeV/G, and much fewer events were identified forµ > 20 MeV/G. Leveraging dual‐Probe configurations, fast electron deep penetrations atL < 4 are revealed: ∼70% of electron deep penetration events occurred within ∼9 hr; ∼8%–13% occurred even within 3 hr, with lower‐µelectrons penetrating faster than higher‐µelectrons. These results suggest nondiffusive radial transport as the main mechanism of electron deep penetrations. In comparison, proton deep penetration happens at a slower pace. Statistics also show that the electron PSD radial gradient is much steeper than protons prior to deep penetration events, which can be responsible for these differential behaviors of electron and proton deep penetrations.
more »
« less
A Comparative Study of the Differential Deep Penetration of Energetic Electrons, Protons, and Heavy Ions Into the Low‐L Region
Abstract Energetic particle deep penetration into low L‐shells (L < 4) impacts the dynamics of the radiation belts and ring current. Previous studies reported that electrons penetrate more frequently, deeply, and faster than protons of similar energies, but underlying mechanisms are unclear. In this study, we compare heavy‐ion behavior with electrons and protons to further identify the underlying mechanisms. Using Van Allen Probes data, we show that electron deep penetration occurs most frequently and deeply, followed by O+ions, then He+ions, and finally protons. Most particle deep penetrations occur within several hours. Superposed epoch analysis shows that prior to deep penetration, electrons have the steepest phase space density radial gradients, followed by heavy ions and then protons for the sameμandK. Our study suggests that a combination of two or more mechanisms, such as convection electric field and plasma wave‐induced scattering, may be needed to fully explain particle deep penetration.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10634393
- Publisher / Repository:
- Wiley
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Geophysical Research Letters
- Volume:
- 52
- Issue:
- 14
- ISSN:
- 0094-8276
- Subject(s) / Keyword(s):
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract During active geomagnetic periods both electrons and protons in the outer radiation belt have been frequently observed to penetrate to lowL(<4). Previous studies have demonstrated systematic differences in the deep penetration of the two species of particles, most notably that the penetration of protons is observed less frequently than for electrons of the same energies. A recent study by Mei et al. (2023,https://doi.org/10.1029/2022GL101921) showed that the time‐varying convection electric field contributes to the deeper penetration of low‐energy electrons and that a radial diffusion‐convection model can be used to reproduce the storm‐time penetration of lower‐energy electrons to lowerL. In this study, we analyze and provide physical explanations for the different behaviors of electrons and protons in terms of their penetration depth to lowL. A radial diffusion‐convection model is applied for the two species with coefficients that are adjusted according to the mass‐dependent relativistic effects on electron and proton drift velocity, and the different loss mechanisms included for each species. Electromagnetic ion cyclotron (EMIC) wave scattering losses for 100s of keV protons during a specific event are modeled and quantified; the results suggest that EMIC waves interacting with protons of lower energies than electrons can contribute to prevent the inward transport of the protons.more » « less
-
Abstract Following the largest magnetic storm in 20 years (10 May 2024), REPTile‐2 on NASA's CIRBE satellite identified two new radiation belts containing 1.3–5 MeV electrons aroundL = 2.5–3.5 and 6.8–20 MeV protons aroundL = 2. The region aroundL = 2.5–3.5 is usually devoid of relativistic electrons due to wave‐particle interactions that scatter them into the atmosphere. However, these 1.3–5 MeV electrons in this new belt seemed unaffected until a magnetic storm on 28 June 2024, perturbed the region. The long‐lasting nature of this new electron belt has physical implications for the dependence of electron wave‐particle interactions on energy, plasma density, and magnetic field strength. The enhancement of protons aroundL = 2 exceeded an order of magnitude between 6.8 and 15 MeV forming a distinct new proton belt that appears even more stable. CIRBE, after a year of successful operation, malfunctioned 25 days before the super storm but returned to functionality 1 month after the storm, enabling these discoveries.more » « less
-
Abstract Deep penetration of outer radiation belt electrons to lowL(<3.5) has long been recognized as an energy‐dependent phenomenon but with limited understanding. The Van Allen Probes measurements have clearly shown energy‐dependent electron penetration during geomagnetically active times, with lower energy electrons penetrating to lowerL. This study aims to improve our ability to model this phenomenon by quantitatively considering radial transport due to large‐scale azimuthal electric fields (E‐fields) as an energy‐dependent convection term added to a radial diffusion Fokker‐Planck equation. We use a modified Volland‐Stern model to represent the enhanced convection field at lowerLto match the observations of storm time values ofE‐field. We model 10–400 MeV/G electron phase space density with an energy‐dependent radial diffusion coefficient and this convection term and show that the model reproduces the observed deep penetrations well, suggesting that time‐variant azimuthalE‐fields contribute preferentially to the deep penetration of lower‐energy electrons.more » « less
-
Abstract Field and laboratory observations strongly support the view that the development of electric fields in thunderstorms is caused by charge separation during rebounding collisions between ice crystals and graupels, followed by their gravitational separation. Although several plausible microphysical mechanisms have been proposed to explain the physics of charge separation, none have been found to be fully consistent with the experimental evidence, and a fresh approach is necessary. We propose a new mechanism for charge separation in ice‐ice collisions based on the fundamental molecular mechanism of charge transport in ice, involving the diffusion of H+ions (excess protons or positive ionic defects) via a proton hopping relay along the hydrogen‐bond network of ice and the trapping and release of H+ions fromL‐orientational defects. The collision of two ice particles leads to the formation of a transient crystalline ice bridge at the contact point, which is spontaneously driven by the tendency for ice sintering, permitting rapid H+diffusion between the two particles. Charge separation is achieved by the asymmetry in the concentrations of H+ions orL‐orientational defects between the two ice surfaces. The proposed H+transport mechanism successfully explains the direction and magnitude of charge transfer as well as its dependence on the relative growth rates of the two ice surfaces observed in laboratory studies. In addition, it offers a molecular‐level interpretation of the empirical rule that, during a collision, the faster‐growing ice surface is positively charged at the expense of negative charging of the slower‐growing or sublimating ice surface.more » « less
An official website of the United States government

