skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


This content will become publicly available on August 1, 2026

Title: Solution evaluation strategies used by first-year physics students
One expected outcome of physics instruction is that students develop quantitative reasoning skills, including strategies for evaluating solutions to problems. Examples of well-known “canonical” evaluation strategies include special case analysis, unit analysis, and checking for reasonable numbers. We report on responses from three tasks in different physics contexts prompting students in an introductory calculus-based physics sequence to evaluate expressions for various quantities: the velocity of a block at the bottom of an incline with friction, the final velocities of two masses involved in an elastic collision, and the electric field due to three point charges. Responses from written ( N = 5 8 0 ) and interview ( N = 1 8 ) data were analyzed using modified grounded theory and phenomenology. We also employed the analytical framework of epistemic frames. Students’ evaluation strategies were classified into three broad categories: consulting external sources, checking through computation, and comparing to the physical world. Some of the evaluation strategies observed in our data, including canonical as well as noncanonical strategies, have been reported in prior research on evaluation, albeit sometimes with different names and with varying levels of generalizability. We note four major, general observations prompted by our results. First, most students did not evaluate solutions to physics problems using an approach that an expert would consider an evaluation strategy. Second, many students used evaluation strategies that emphasized computation. Third, many students used evaluation strategies that are not canonical but are nonetheless useful. Fourth, the relative prevalence of different strategies was highly dependent on the task context. We conclude with remarks including implications for classroom instruction.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1912087 1405726
PAR ID:
10636703
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Publisher / Repository:
American Physical Society
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Physical Review Physics Education Research
Volume:
21
Issue:
2
ISSN:
2469-9896
Page Range / eLocation ID:
020114
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. We present a joint analysis of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) lensing power spectra measured from the Data Release 6 of the Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT) and PR4, cross-correlations between the ACT and lensing reconstruction and galaxy clustering from unWISE, and the unWISE clustering auto-spectrum. We obtain 1.5% constraints on the matter density fluctuations at late times parametrized by the best constrained parameter combination S 8 3 x 2 pt σ 8 ( Ω m / 0.3 ) 0.4 = 0.815 ± 0.012 . The commonly used S 8 σ 8 ( Ω m / 0.3 ) 0.5 parameter is constrained to S 8 = 0.816 ± 0.015 . In combination with baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) measurements we find σ 8 = 0.815 ± 0.012 . We also present sound-horizon-independent estimates of the present day Hubble rate of H 0 = 66.4 3.7 + 3.2 km s 1 Mpc 1 from our large scale structure data alone and H 0 = 64.3 2.4 + 2.1 km s 1 Mpc 1 in combination with uncalibrated supernovae from . Using parametric estimates of the evolution of matter density fluctuations, we place constraints on cosmic structure in a range of high redshifts typically inaccessible with cross-correlation analyses. Combining lensing cross- and autocorrelations, we derive a 3.3% constraint on the integrated matter density fluctuations above z = 2.4 , one of the tightest constraints in this redshift range and fully consistent with a Λ cold dark matter ( Λ CDM ) model fit to the primary CMB from . Finally, combining with primary CMB observations and using the extended low redshift coverage of these combined datasets we derive constraints on a variety of extensions to the Λ CDM model including massive neutrinos, spatial curvature, and dark energy. We find in flat Λ CDM m ν < 0.12 eV at 95% confidence using the large scale structure data, BAO measurements from Sloan Digital Sky Survey, and primary CMB observations. 
    more » « less
  2. We report the results of the first search for Standard Model and baryon-number-violating two-body decays of the neutral B mesons to Λ 0 and Ω c ( * ) 0 using 711 fb 1 of data collected at the ϒ ( 4 S ) resonance with the Belle detector at the KEKB asymmetric-energy e + e collider. We observe no evidence of signal from any such decays and set 95% confidence-level upper limits on the products of B 0 and B ¯ 0 branching fractions for these two-body decays with B ( Ω c 0 π + Ω ) in the range between 9.5 × 10 8 and 31.2 × 10 8 . Published by the American Physical Society2024 
    more » « less
  3. Cosmic shear, galaxy clustering, and the abundance of massive halos each probe the large-scale structure of the Universe in complementary ways. We present cosmological constraints from the joint analysis of the three probes, building on the latest analyses of the lensing-informed abundance of clusters identified by the South Pole Telescope (SPT) and of the auto- and cross-correlation of galaxy position and weak lensing measurements ( 3 × 2 pt ) in the Dark Energy Survey (DES). We consider the cosmological correlation between the different tracers and we account for the systematic uncertainties that are shared between the large-scale lensing correlation functions and the small-scale lensing-based cluster mass calibration. Marginalized over the remaining Λ cold dark matter ( Λ CDM ) parameters (including the sum of neutrino masses) and 52 astrophysical modeling parameters, we measure Ω m = 0.300 ± 0.017 and σ 8 = 0.797 ± 0.026 . Compared to constraints from primary cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies, our constraints are only 15% wider with a probability to exceed of 0.22 ( 1.2 σ ) for the two-parameter difference. We further obtain S 8 σ 8 ( Ω m / 0.3 ) 0.5 = 0.796 ± 0.013 which is lower than the measurement at the 1.6 σ level. The combined SPT cluster, DES 3 × 2 pt , and datasets mildly prefer a nonzero positive neutrino mass, with a 95% upper limit m ν < 0.25 eV on the sum of neutrino masses. Assuming a w CDM model, we constrain the dark energy equation of state parameter w = 1.1 5 0.17 + 0.23 and when combining with primary CMB anisotropies, we recover w = 1.2 0 0.09 + 0.15 , a 1.7 σ difference with a cosmological constant. The precision of our results highlights the benefits of multiwavelength multiprobe cosmology and our analysis paves the way for upcoming joint analyses of next-generation datasets. Published by the American Physical Society2025 
    more » « less
  4. The production yields of the orbitally excited charm-strange mesons D s 1 ( 1 + ) ( 2536 ) + and D s 2 * ( 2 + ) ( 2573 ) + were measured for the first time in proton-proton (pp) collisions at a center-of-mass energy of s = 13 TeV with the ALICE experiment at the LHC. The D s 1 + and D s 2 * + mesons were measured at midrapidity ( | y | < 0.5 ) in minimum-bias and high-multiplicity pp collisions in the transverse-momentum interval 2 < p T < 24 GeV / c . Their production yields relative to the D s + ground-state yield were found to be compatible between minimum-bias and high-multiplicity collisions, as well as with previous measurements in e ± p and e + e collisions. The measured D s 1 + / D s + and D s 2 * + / D s + yield ratios are described by statistical hadronization models and can be used to tune the parameters governing the production of excited charm-strange hadrons in Monte Carlo generators, such as 8. 
    more » « less
  5. We present spectroscopic confirmation of an ultra-massive galaxy (UMG) with log ( M / M ) = 10.98 ± 0.07 at z s p e c = 4.8947 in the Extended Groth Strip (EGS), based on deep observations of Ly α emission with Keck/DEIMOS. The ultra-massive galaxy (UMG-28740) is the most massive member in one of the most significant overdensities in the EGS, with four additional photometric members with log ( M / M ) > 10.5 within R p r o j 1 cMpc. Spectral energy distribution (SED) fitting using a large suite of star formation histories and two sets of high-quality photometry from ground- and space-based facilities consistently estimates the mass of this object to be log ( M / M ) 11 with a small standard deviation between measurements ( σ = 0.07 ). While the best-fit SED models agree on stellar mass, we find discrepancies in the estimated star formation rate for UMG-28740, resulting in either a star-forming or quiescent system. 𝐽 𝑊 𝑆 𝑇 /NIRCam photometry of UMG-28740 strongly favors a quiescent scenario, demonstrating the need for high-quality mid-IR observations. Assuming the galaxy to be quiescent, UMG-28740 formed the bulk of its stars at z > 10 and is quenching at z 8 , resulting in a high star formation efficiency at high redshift ( ϵ 0.2 at z 5 and ϵ 1 at z 8 ). As the most massive galaxy in its protocluster environment, UMG-28740 is a unique example of the impossibly early galaxy problem. 
    more » « less