skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Multi-dimensional wind fragility functions for wood utility poles
Risk assessment and life cycle cost analysis of electric power systems facilitate analysis and efficient management of compound risks from wind hazards and asset deteriorations. Fragility functions are key components for these analyses as they provide the probability of failure of poles given the hazard intensity. Despite a number of efforts that analyzed the wind fragility of utility wood poles, impacts of key design variables on the likelihood of failure of poles have not been yet characterized. This paper, for the first time, provides a set of multi-dimensional fragility models that are functions of key factors including class, age, and height of poles, number and diameter of conductors, span length, and wind speed and direction. Unlike existing generic pole fragility models, this new class of fragility functions is able to accurately represent various configurations of power distribution systems. Therefore, it can reliably support decisions for installation of new or replacement of existing damaged or decayed poles. The generated fragility models are also used to investigate impacts of design variables. For example, results indicate that when height is considered as a covariate for the fragility function, the likelihood of failure of wood poles for a given height increases with class number. However, if height is treated as an uncertain variable, and therefore, excluded as a covariate from the fragility model, lower classes of poles may have higher failure probability as they are often used for higher clearance limits.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1762918
PAR ID:
10100652
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Engineering structures
Volume:
183
ISSN:
0141-0296
Page Range / eLocation ID:
937-948
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract Climate-change-imposed challenges in the form of heightened frequency and intensity of weather events exert additional pressure on securing the imperative continuous and reliable power supply, leading to increased power outages. This research proposes a comprehensive framework for enhancing the resilience of electric power networks (EPNs) through reliability-based risk assessment, promoting predictions and proactive decisions. The presented research discusses weather phenomena, their association with climate change, and their projected impacts. The numerical weather prediction model, WRF 3.4.1, with a 4 km resolution cell grid, gives a more accurate projection of high winds’ frequency and intensity. The simulation period from 2086 to 2099 is based on a reference control period spanning from 2000 to 2013, with adjustments made to background conditions using climate model output consistent with projections for the late century, a pseudo-global warming (PGW) technique. The presented research focuses on the wooden power distribution poles. The reliability assessment approach employs fragility development and analysis against wind scenarios through advanced modeling techniques and statistical analysis used to mimic historical and projected wind scenarios and to allow numerous factors on both the demand and capacity sides and their inherent uncertainties to be considered. The annual probability of failure is obtained by performing a mathematical convolution of the fragility and the hazard curves, showing the reflection of the effects of climate change on the annual probability of failure. Scaling these results to a system-level resilience assessment will facilitate the flexible energy design strategies integration and allow smoother net-zero standards incorporation and adaptation to the changing environmental conditions. This understanding will allow the decision-makers to evaluate the critical locations within a distribution line and plan to address the vulnerabilities by hardening the assets or implementing modern microgrid techniques or distributed energy resource integration. 
    more » « less
  2. Gaw, N; Pardalos, PM; Gahrooei, MR (Ed.)
    This paper reviews a set of Bayesian model updating methodologies for quantification of uncertainty in multi-modal models for estimating failure probabilities in rare hazard events. Specifically, a two-stage Bayesian regression model is proposed to fuse an analytical capacity model with experimentally observed capacity data to predict failure probability of residential building roof systems under severe wind loading. The ultimate goals are to construct fragility models accounting for uncertainties due to model inadequacy (epistemic uncertainty) and lack of experimental data (aleatory uncertainty) in estimating failure (exceedance) probabilities and number of damaged buildings in building portfolios. The proposed approach is illustrated on a case study involving a sample residential building portfolio under scenario hurricanes to compare the exceedance probability and aggregate expected loss to determine the most cost-effective wind mitigation options. 
    more » « less
  3. In recent decades, blackouts have shown an increasing prevalence of power outages due to extreme weather events such as hurricanes. Precisely assessing the spatiotemporal outages in distribution networks, the most vulnerable part of power systems, is critical to enhancing power system resilience. The Sequential Monte Carlo (SMC) simulation method is widely used for spatiotemporal risk analysis of power systems during extreme weather hazards. However, it is found here that the SMC method can lead to large errors as it repeatedly samples the failure probability from the time-invariant fragility functions of system components in time-series analysis, particularly overestimating damages under evolving hazards with high-frequency sampling. To address this issue, a novel hazard resistance-based spatiotemporal risk analysis (HRSRA) method is proposed. This method converts the failure probability of a component into a hazard resistance and uses it as a time-invariant value in time-series analysis. The proposed HRSRA provides an adaptive framework for incorporating high-spatiotemporal-resolution meteorology models into power outage simulations. By leveraging the geographic information system data of the power system and a physics-based hurricane wind field model, the superiority of the proposed method is validated using real-world time-series power outage data from Puerto Rico, including data collected during Hurricane Fiona in 2022. 
    more » « less
  4. Frequency and intensity of hydrological hazards have increased. Consequently, riverine bridges are suffering damage due to flooding. Fragility functions are used to estimate such damage conditioned on hazard intensity. However, flood fragility functions are limited for riverine bridges, and generally lack for masonry bridges. This paper presents a methodology to derive flood fragility functions for masonry arch bridges accounting for component failure modes. Demand and capacity of bridge components are derived from existing analytical expressions, and account for aleatory uncertainties via Monte Carlo simulations. The methodology is illustrated using a UK masonry bridge, which collapsed due to winter flood-induced scour. The investigated bridge is divided into its components (e.g., arches, pier) and a scour fragility function is derived for the arch, based on a lognormal cumulative distribution fitting to the derived failure probability data. Future research will develop scour fragility functions for other bridge components. 
    more » « less
  5. This paper studies theCox model with time-varying coefficients for cause-specific hazard functions when the causes of failure are subject to missingness. Inverse probability weighted and augmented inverse probability weighted estimators are investigated. The latter is considered as a two-stage estimator by directly utilizing the inverse probability weighted estimator and through modeling available auxiliary variables to improve efficiency. The asymptotic properties of the two estimators are investigated. Hypothesis testing procedures are developed to test the null hypotheses that the covariate effects are zero and that the covariate effects are constant. We conduct simulation studies to examine the finite sample properties of the proposed estimation and hypothesis testing procedures under various settings of the auxiliary variables and the percentages of the failure causes that are missing. These simulation results demonstrate that the augmented inverse probability weighted estimators are more efficient than the inverse probability weighted estimators and that the proposed testing procedures have the expected satisfactory results in sizes and powers. The proposed methods are illustrated using the Mashi clinical trial data for investigating the effect of randomization to formula-feeding versus breastfeeding plus extended infant zidovudine prophylaxis on death due to mother-to-child HIV transmission in Botswana. 
    more » « less