skip to main content

Title: Extensive paraphyly in the typical owl family (Strigidae)

The typical owl family (Strigidae) comprises 194 species in 28 genera, 14 of which are monotypic. Relationships within and among genera in the typical owls have been challenging to discern because mitochondrial data have produced equivocal results and because many monotypic genera have been omitted from previous molecular analyses. Here, we collected and analyzed DNA sequences of ultraconserved elements (UCEs) from 43 species of typical owls to produce concatenated and multispecies coalescent-based phylogenetic hypotheses for all but one genus in the typical owl family. Our results reveal extensive paraphyly of taxonomic groups across phylogenies inferred using different analytical approaches and suggest the genera Athene, Otus, Asio, Megascops, Bubo, and Strix are paraphyletic, whereas Ninox and Glaucidium are polyphyletic. Secondary analyses of protein-coding mitochondrial genes harvested from off-target sequencing reads and mitochondrial genomes downloaded from GenBank generally support the extent of paraphyly we observe, although some disagreements exist at higher taxonomic levels between our nuclear and mitochondrial phylogenetic hypotheses. Overall, our results demonstrate the importance of taxon sampling for understanding and describing evolutionary relationships in this group, as well as the need for additional sampling, study, and taxonomic revision of typical owl species. Additionally, our findings highlight how both divergence and convergence in morphological characters have obscured our understanding of the evolutionary history of typical owls, particularly those with insular distributions.

more » « less
Award ID(s):
Author(s) / Creator(s):
 ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  ;  
Publisher / Repository:
Oxford University Press
Date Published:
Journal Name:
The Auk
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract

    Alopoglossidae is a family of Neotropical lizards composed of 23 species allocated in two genera (AlopoglossusandPtychoglossus). There is a lack of knowledge about the phylogenetic relationships and systematics of this family. Published phylogenies that include alopoglossid species have very low taxon coverage within the family, and are usually based on limited character sampling. Considering these shortcomings, we infer the phylogenetic relationships of Alopoglossidae—including all but one species in the family—based on the combined analyses of DNA sequences and morphological characters. We use four loci (the mitochondrial12S,16SandND4; the nuclear C‐mos) and a matrix of 143 phenotypic characters from scutellation, tongue morphology, hemipenis morphology, and osteology. The dataset is analyzed with Maximum Parsimony, with four alternative weighting schemes: three under Extended Implied Weighting, and one with equal weighting. The respective resulting topologies are compared in a sensitivity analysis framework. Our analyses support the paraphyly ofPtychoglossus, withAlopoglossusnested within it. We provide an updated classification for the family, wherePtychoglossusBoulenger, 1890 is considered a junior synonym ofAlopoglossusBoulenger, 1885.

    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    The diverse, largely Neotropical subtribe Euptychiina is widely regarded as one of the most taxonomically challenging groups among all butterflies. Over the last two decades, morphological and molecular studies have revealed widespread paraphyly and polyphyly among genera, and a comprehensive, robust phylogenetic hypothesis is needed to build a firm generic classification to support ongoing taxonomic revisions at the species level. Here, we generated a dataset that includes sequences for up to nine nuclear genes and the mitochondrial COI ‘barcode’ for a total of 1280 specimens representing 449 described and undescribed species of Euptychiina and 39 out‐groups, resulting in the most complete phylogeny for the subtribe to date. In combination with a recently developed genomic backbone tree, this dataset resulted in a topology with strong support for most branches. We recognize eight major clades that each contain two or more genera, together containing all but seven Euptychiina genera. We provide a summary of the taxonomy, diversity and natural history of each clade, and discuss taxonomic changes implied by the phylogenetic results. We describe nine new genera to accommodate 38 described species:LazulinaWillmott, Nakahara & Espeland,gen.n.,SauronaHuertas & Willmott,gen.n.,ArgentariaHuertas & Willmott,gen.n.,TaguaibaFreitas, Zacca & Siewert,gen.n.,XenovenaMarín & Nakahara,gen.n.,DeltayaWillmott, Nakahara & Espeland,gen.n.,ModicaZacca, Casagrande & Willmott,gen.n.,OccultaNakahara & Willmott,gen.n., andTricoNakahara & Espeland,gen.n.We also synonymizeNubilaViloria, Andrade & Henao, 2019 (syn.n.) withSplendeuptychiaForster, 1964,MacrocissiaViloria, Le Crom & Andrade, 2019 (syn.n.) withSatyrotaygetisForster, 1964, andRudyphthimoidesViloria, 2022 (syn.n.) withMalaveriaViloria & Benmesbah, 2020. Overall, we revised the generic placement of 79 species (74 new generic combinations and five revised combinations), and as a result all but six described species of Euptychiina are accommodated within 70 named, monophyletic genera. For all newly described genera, we provide illustrations of representative species, drawings of wing venation and male and (where possible) female genitalia, and distribution maps, and summarize the natural history of the genus. For three new monotypic genera,Occultagen.n.,Tricogen.n.andXenovenagen.n.we provide a taxonomic revision with a review of the taxonomy of each species and data from examined specimens. We provide a revised synonymic list for Euptychiina containing 460 valid described species, 53 subspecies and 255 synonyms, including several new synonyms and reinstated species.

    more » « less
  3. Abstract

    Relationships among spider families that lack support through other lines of evidence (e.g., morphology) have recently been uncovered through molecular phylogenetics. One such group is the “marronoid” clade, which contains about 3,400 described species in 9 families. Marronoids run the gamut of life history strategies, with social species, species producing a variety of silk types, and species occurring in a range of extreme environments. Despite recognition of the ecological variability in the group, there remains uncertainty about family- level relationships, leaving diverse ecologies without an evolutionary context. The phylogenies produced to date have relatively low nodal support, there are few defined morphological synapomorphies, and the internal relationships of many families remain unclear. We use 93 exemplars from all marronoid families and ultraconserved element loci captured in silico from a combination of 48 novel low-coverage whole genomes and genomic data from the Sequence Read Archive (SRA) to produce a 50% occupancy matrix of 1,277 loci from a set of ultraconserved element probes. These loci were used to infer a phylogeny of the marronoid clade and to evaluate the familial relationships within the clade, and were combined with single-locus (Sanger) legacy data to further increase taxonomic sampling. Our results indicate a clearly defined and well-supported marronoid clade and provide evidence for both monophyly and paraphyly within the currently defined families of the clade. We propose taxonomic changes in accordance with the resulting phylogenetic hypothesis, including elevating Cicurinidae (restored status) and Macrobunidae (new rank).

    more » « less
  4. Hylexetasteswoodcreepers are endemic to theterra firmeforests of the Amazon basin. Currently, most taxonomic sources recognize two species ofHylexetastes(H. perrotiiandH. stresemanni), each divided into three subspecies. Some authors maintain that theH. perrotiisubspecies should be elevated to full species status. In particular,Hylexetastes perrotii brigidaiis endemic to the eastern Amazon, the second Amazonian area of endemism (Xingu) most affected by deforestation and habitat degradation. Consequently, the taxonomic status ofH. p. brigidaiis of particular concern for conservation. Thus far, only morphological characters have been evaluated for the taxonomic delimitation of species and subspecies ofHylexetastes. We present a molecular phylogenetic analysis of all subspecies to help delimitHylexetastesinterspecific limits. Fragments of two mitochondrial (CytbandND2) and three nuclear genes (FGB5, G3PDHandMUSK) from 57Hylexetastesspecimens were sequenced. An ecological niche model was estimated to describe more accurately the potential distributions of taxa and to evaluate their vulnerability to ongoing deforestation. Phylogenetic analyses support the paraphyly of the polytypicH. perrotiias currently delimited and the elevation ofHylexetastes perrotii uniformisto full species rank, as well as the presence of three evolutionary significant units (ESUs) within this newly delimited species, including one grouping allH. p. brigidaispecimens. Alternatively, under lineage‐based species concepts, our results support at least five evolutionary species inHylexetastes:H. stresemanni,H. undulatus,H. perrotii,H. uniformisandH. brigidai. Each of these taxa andESUs are distributed in different interfluvial areas of the Amazon basin, which have different degrees of disturbance. Because they occupy the most heavily impacted region among allHylexetastesESUs, regular assessments of the conservation statuses ofH. p. brigidaiand bothH. uniformisESUs are paramount.

    more » « less
  5. The infraorder Astacidea, comprising marine clawed lobsters and freshwater crayfish, include some of the most recognizable decapod crustaceans, many being harvested commercially for human consumption and aquaculture. While molecular analyses have elucidated relationships among extant lineages, the composition and placement of several fossil groups within Astacidea remain poorly resolved, with several conflicting phylogenetic hypotheses and taxonomic classifications being proposed in previous works. Among these controversial groups, Erymoidea have variably been placed in Astacidea or Glypheidea, a largely extinct infraorder of predominantly pseudochelate marine lobsters. Cladistic relationships of Stenochiroidea have also been problematic, having been regarded as ancestral to freshwater crayfish (Astacida) or extant marine lobsters (Nephropidae). Failure to reach a consensus regarding these groups can be at least partially attributed to the prevalence of morphological convergence and limited taxon sampling. To clarify evolutionary relationships among fossil and extant taxa, a Bayesian phylogenetic analysis of morphological and molecular data (mitochondrial genes: 12S, 16S and COI; nuclear genes: 18S, 28S and H3) was performed that included extensive taxon sampling of all currently recognized families of Astacidea as well as representatives of several potential sister groups. To overcome error introduced by homoplasy, relationships among extant taxa, as revealed by previous molecular analyses, were used to identify morphological characters with potentially robust phylogenetic signal. The resulting phylogeny places erymids within Glypheidea and supports a sister relationship between Astacidea and Glaessnericarididae. Stenochiroidea was found to be polyphyletic, with most genera forming a clade sister to Nephropidae; Pseudastacus is moved to Protastacidae, which resolves as the sister taxon to freshwater crayfish. The relationships among living and fossil taxa presented here provide new insight into the origins and evolutionary histories of the major lineages of marine clawed lobsters and freshwater crayfish. 
    more » « less