An official website of the United States government
The recent framework for tiered spectrum sharing in the 3.5 GHz band establishes rules in which multiple firms called Environment Sensing Capability operators (ESCs) may measure spectrum occupancy and sell these measurements to other firms to help facilitate spectrum access. Motived by this we consider a scenario in which two spectrum access firms (SAs) seeks to access a shared band of spectrum and must in turn purchase spectrum measurements from one of two ESCs. Given the measurements they purchase, the SA firms then compete on price to serve customers in a shared band of spectrum. We study how differences in the quality and price of the spectrum measurements impact the resulting market equilibrium between the SAs and find that having different qualities of measurements available to different SAs can lead to better economic welfare.
more »
« less
Spot Markets for Spectrum Measurements
The recent framework for spectrum sharing in the 3.5 GHz band allows for Environment Sensing Capability operators (ESCs) to measure spectrum occupancy so as to enable commercial use of this spectrum when federal incumbent users are not present. Each ESC will contract with one or more Spectrum Access Systems (SASs) to provide spectrum occupancy data. Commercial firms using the band will in turn contract with a SAS to determine when it can access the spectrum. Initially, the decisions of which ESC and SAS to partner with will likely be based on long-term contracts. In this paper, we consider an alternative framework, in which an ESC sells its spectrum management information via a spot market so that from periodto- period a commercial user can select a different ESC from which to acquire spectrum measurements. We develop a game theoretic model to analyze such a market and show that using such a spot market may better enable multiple commercial firms to operate in a given spectrum band. We also show that this increased competition may not benefit consumer surplus unless firms adopt a non-stationary strategy profile.
more »
« less
- PAR ID:
- 10178794
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- IEEE DySPAN
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 1 to 10
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
null (Ed.)The Citizens Broadband Radio Service (CBRS) recently adopted in the U.S. enables commercial users to share spectrum with incumbent federal users. This sharing can be assisted by Environmental Sensing Capability operators (ESCs), that monitor the spectrum occupancy to determine when the use of the spectrum will not harm incumbents. An important aspect of the CBRS is that it enables two tiers of spectrum access by commercial users. The higher tier corresponds to a spectrum access (SA) firm that purchases a priority access license (PAL) in a competitive auction. The PAL holder obtains dedicated licensed access to a portion of the spectrum when the incumbent is not present. The lower tier, referred to as generalized Authorized Access (GAA), does not request a PAL and is similar to unlicensed access, in which multiple firms share a portion of the spectrum. Entry and investment in such a market introduces a number of new dimensions. Should an entrant bid for a PAL? How does the availability of a PAL impact their investment decisions? We develop a game-theoretic model to study these issues in which entrant SAs may bid in a PAL auction and decide on their investment levels and then compete downstream for customers.more » « less
-
Dynamic spectrum sharing has emerged as a promising solution to address the spectrum scarcity challenge. Currently, the FCC has designated several Spectrum Access Systems (SAS) administrators to deploy their SAS that coordinates the usage of the certificated shared band(s) such as the 3.55-3.7 GHz CBRS band. The SAS ensures that the incumbent’s access to the shared band is guaranteed while also granting commercial users access rights when the incumbents are not present. However, explicitly sharing the spectrum band(s) information among participants raises privacy concerns. Certain participants, such as curious SAS administrators, have the ability to deduce the confidential operational patterns of the incumbents through the Environmental Sensing Capability (ESC) or Incumbent Informing Capability (IIC) notifications. Additionally, a curious SAS administrator may obtain the client’s operational information of other SAS administrators throughout the process of inter-SAS coordination. We propose Pri-Share, a novel privacy-preserving spectrum sharing paradigm that tailors the threshold-based private set union (PSU) and homomorphic encryption (HE) techniques to address the aforementioned privacy problems. Specifically, it enables all parties to jointly compute a unified spectrum allocation plan to resolve the potential conflicts between different parties while safeguarding the confidentiality of each stakeholder’s spectrum requirements and usage. Pri-Share also ensures that while a curious participant might ascertain the usage of a particular spectrum band, they are unable to deduce the precise identity of the party utilizing it. Besides, Pri-Share adheres to the key spectrum allocation regulations outlined by FCC (part 96), such as assurance of access rights for various priority levels. Our implementation result shows that Pri-Share can be achieved with notable computational and communication efficiency,more » « less
-
In 2020, the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) adopted rules to expand unlicensed operations in the 6 GHz band, opening up access to 1200MHz of spectrum to be shared by heterogeneous public and private network operators. This spectrum is anticipated to significantly expand access to much-needed mid-band spectrum for mobile and fixed broadband wireless uses. To manage the co-existence of these unlicensed users with legacy systems such as commercial microwave point-to-point links, the FCC’s rules provide for a mix of interference mitigation strategies, including geo-location (geo-fencing) to restrict unlicensed users in certain locations, different power limits for indoor and outdoor operations, and coordination of spectrum use via Automated Frequency Coordination (AFC) systems. Akin to the role of the Spectrum Access Systems (SAS) operating in the CBRS 3.5 GHz band, the AFCs are tasked with enabling automated spectrum sharing between unlicensed devices and incumbent users. When operating outdoors, unlicensed devices (Standard Power Access Points) are required to communicate to an AFC certain relevant operating details that the AFC uses to then provide operational parameters to the unlicensed devices (e.g., available channels) such that no harmful interference is caused to protected incumbents. Unlike the SAS, the multiple AFCs do not coordinate their activities and so are unable to take account of aggregate interference levels. Additionally, the AFCs spectrum sharing and co-existence solutions are based on interference models and regulatory rules that may prove to be too conservative and a poor fit for some actual usage scenarios. Spectrum Consumption Models (SCMs), an IEEE-standards-based approach for describing the RF requirements of radios in a spectrum space and Spectrum Access Agreements (SAAs) that make use of SCMs provide a viable toolset for examining the efficiency and efficacy of the existing FCC 6GHz rules framework. In this paper, we review the 6 GHz rules and show how they could be implemented within a SCM framework. We also show how greater use of the 6GHz spectrum could be possible if more information was exchanged with an AFC using the standards-based framework of SCMs. We explore the policy and economic impacts of enabling this flexibility. For example, this approach could lead to higher computational costs for an AFC, which would need to be balanced with the benefits of increased spectrum utilization. Through the application of our 6GHz simulation platform and the SCM/SAA framework, we are able to suggest efficiency-enhancing reforms to the existing 6GHz FCC rules. We support those recommendations with an analysis of the economic and regulatory implications on key stakeholders in this important new band for wireless services.more » « less
-
As part of its ongoing efforts to meet the increased spectrum demand, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has recently opened up 150 MHz in the 3.5 GHz band for shared wireless broadband use. Access and operations in this band, aka Citizens Broadband Radio Service (CBRS), will be managed by a dynamic spectrum access system (SAS) to enable seamless spectrum sharing between secondary users (SU s) and incumbent users. Despite its benefits, SAS’s design requirements, as set by FCC, present privacy risks to SU s, merely because SU s are required to share sensitive operational information (e.g., location, identity, spectrum usage) with SAS to be able to learn about spectrum availability in their vicinity. In this paper, we propose TrustSAS, a trustworthy framework for SAS that synergizes state-of-the-art cryptographic techniques with blockchain technology in an innovative way to address these privacy issues while complying with FCC’s regulatory design requirements. We analyze the security of our framework and evaluate its performance through analysis, simulation and experimentation. We show that TrustSAS can offer high security guarantees with reasonable overhead, making it an ideal solution for addressing SU s’ privacy issues in an operational SAS environment.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Conference Paper:
- https://doi.org/10.1109/DySPAN.2019.8935666
