skip to main content


Title: Comparison between a Linear Regression and an Artificial Neural Network Model to Detect and Localize Damage in the Powder Mill Bridge
This paper evaluates the ability of two different data-driven models to detect and localize simulated structural damage in an in-service bridge for long-term structural health monitoring (SHM). Strain gauge data collected over 4 years is used to characterize the undamaged state of the bridge. The Powder Mill Bridge in Barre, Massachusetts, U.S., which has been instrumented with strain gauges since its opening in 2009, is used as a case study, and the strain gauges used in this study are located at 26 different stations throughout the bridge superstructure. A linear regression (LR) model and an artificial neural network (ANN) model are evaluated based on the following criteria: (a) the ability to accurately predict the strain at each location in the undamaged state of the bridge; (b) the ability to detect simulated structural damage to the bridge superstructure; and (c) the ability to localize simulated structural damage. Both the LR and the ANN models were able to predict the strain at the 26 stations with an average error of less than 5%, indicating that both methodologies were effective in characterizing the undamaged state of the bridge. A calibrated finite element model was then used to simulate damage to the Powder Mill Bridge for three damage scenarios: fascia girder corrosion, girder fracture, and deck delamination. The LR model proved to be just as effective as the ANN model at detecting and localizing damage. A recommended protocol is thus presented for integrating data-driven models into bridge asset management systems.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1640693
NSF-PAR ID:
10186152
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Transportation research record
ISSN:
0361-1981
Page Range / eLocation ID:
036119812092063
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. null (Ed.)
    Structural health monitoring (SHM) activities are essential for achieving a realistic characterisation of bridge structural performance levels throughout the service life. These activities can help detect structural damage before the potential occurrence of component- or system-level structural failures. In addition to their application at discrete times, SHM systems can also be installed to provide long-term accurate and reliable data continuously throughout the entire service life of a bridge. Owing to their superior accuracy and long-term durability compared to traditional strain gages, fiber optic sensors are ideal in extracting accurate real-time strain and temperature data of bridge components. This paper presents a statistical damage detection and localisation approach to evaluate the performance of prestressed concrete bridge girders using fiber Bragg grating sensors. The presented approach employs Artificial Neural Networks to establish a relationship between the strain profiles recorded at different sensor locations across the investigated girder. The approach is capable of detecting and localising the presence of damage at the sensor location without requiring detailed loading information; accordingly, it can be suitable for long-term monitoring activities under normal traffic loads. Experimental laboratory data obtained from the structural testing of a large-scale prestressed concrete bridge girder is used to illustrate the approach. 
    more » « less
  2. Damage diagnosis has been a challenging inverse problem in structural health monitoring. The main difficulty is characterizing the unknown relation between the measurements and damage patterns (i.e., damage indicator selection). Such damage indicators would ideally be able to identify the existence, location, and severity of damage. Therefore, this procedure requires complex data processing algorithms and dense sensor arrays, which brings computational intensity with it. To address this limitation, this paper introduces convolutional neural network (CNN), which is one of the major breakthroughs in image recognition, to the damage detection and localization problem. The CNN technique has the ability to discover abstract features and complex classifier boundaries that are able to distinguish various attributes of the problem. In this paper, a CNN topology was designed to classify simulated damaged and healthy cases and localize the damage when it exists. The performance of the proposed technique was evaluated through the finite-element simulations of undamaged and damaged structural connections. Samples were trained by using strain distributions as a consequence of various loads with several different crack scenarios. Completely new damage setups were introduced to the model during the testing process. Based on the findings of the proposed study, the damage diagnosis and localization were achieved with high accuracy, robustness, and computational efficiency. 
    more » « less
  3. Gaur, L. ; Solanki, A. ; Jain, V. ; Khazanchi, D. (Ed.)
    This chapter extends application of a framework proposed by the authors (73, 74) for automated damage detection using strain measurements to study feasibility of using sensors that can measure accelerations, tilts, and displacements. The study utilized three-dimensional (3D) finite element models of double track, riveted, steel truss span, and girder bridge span under routine train loads. The chapter also includes three instrumentation schemes for each bridge span (65) to investigate the applicability of the framework to other bridge systems and sensor networks. Connection damage was simulated by reducing rotational spring stiffness at member ends and various responses were extracted for each damage scenario. The methodology utilizes Supervised Machine Learning to automatically determine damage location (DL) and intensity (DI). Simulated experiments showed that DLs and DIs were detected accurately for both spans with various structural responses and using different instrumentation plans. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract

    Among many structural assessment methods, the change of modal characteristics is considered a well‐accepted damage detection method. However, the presence of environmental or operational variations may pollute the baseline and prevent a dependable assessment of the change. In recent years, the use of machine learning algorithms gained interest within structural health community, especially due to their ability and success in the elimination of ambient uncertainty. This paper proposes an end‐to‐end architecture to detect damage reliably by employing machine learning algorithms. The proposed approach streamlines (a) collection of structural response data, (b) modal analysis using system identification, (c) learning model, and (d) novelty detection. The proposed system aims to extract latent features of accessible modal parameters such as natural frequencies and mode shapes measured at undamaged target structure under temperature uncertainty and to reconstruct a new representation of these features that is similar to the original using well‐established machine learning methods for damage detection. The deviation between measured and reconstructed parameters, also known as novelty index, is the essential information for detecting critical changes in the system. The approach is evaluated by analyzing the structural response data obtained from finite element models and experimental structures. For the machine learning component of the approach, both principal component analysis (PCA) and autoencoder (AE) are examined. While mode shapes are known to be a well‐researched damage indicator in the literature, to our best knowledge, this research is the first time that unsupervised machine learning is applied using PCA and AE to utilize mode shapes in addition to natural frequencies for effective damage detection. The detection performance of this pipeline is compared to a similar approach where its learning model does not utilize mode shapes. The results demonstrate that the effectiveness of the damage detection under temperature variability improves significantly when mode shapes are used in the training of learning algorithm. Especially for small damages, the proposed algorithm performs better in discriminating system changes.

     
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    The mechanical properties of fiber reinforced polymer matrix composites are known to gradually deteriorate as fatigue damage accumulates under cyclic loading conditions. While the steady degradation in elastic stiffness throughout fatigue life is a well-established and studied concept, it remains difficult to continuously monitor such structural changes during the service life of many dynamic engineering systems where composite materials are subjected to random and unexpected loading conditions. Recently, laser induced graphene (LIG) has been demonstrated to be a reliable, in-situ strain sensing and damage detection component in fiberglass composites under both quasi-static and dynamic loading conditions. This work investigates the potential of exploiting the piezoresistive properties of LIG interlayered fiberglass composites in order to formulate cumulative damage parameters and predict both damage progression and fatigue life using artificial neural networks (ANNs) and conventional phenomenological models. The LIG interlayered fiberglass composites are subjected to tension–tension fatigue loading, while changes in their elastic stiffness and electrical resistance are monitored through passive measurements. Damage parameters that are defined according to changes in electrical resistance are found to be capable of accurately describing damage progression in LIG interlayered fiberglass composites throughout fatigue life, as they display similar trends to those based on changes in elastic stiffness. These damage parameters are then exploited for predicting the fatigue life and future damage state of fiberglass composites using both trained ANNs and phenomenological degradation and accumulation models in both specimen-to-specimen and cycle-to-cycle schemes. When used in a specimen-to-specimen scheme, the predictions of a two-layer Bayesian regularized ANN with 40 neurons in each layer are found to be at least 60% more accurate than those of phenomenological degradation models, displaying R2 values greater than 0.98 and root mean square error (RMSE) values smaller than 10−3. A two-layer Bayesian regularized ANN with 25 neurons in each layer is also found to yield accurate predictions when used in a cycle-to-cycle scheme, displaying R2 values greater than 0.99 and RMSE values smaller than 2 × 10−4 once more than 30% of the initial measurements are used as inputs. The final results confirm that piezoresistive LIG interlayers are a promising tool for achieving accurate and continuous fatigue life predictions in multifunctional composite structures, specifically when coupled with machine learning algorithms such as ANNs. 
    more » « less