skip to main content

Explore Research Products in the NSF-PAR

Title: Predicting Farms’ Donations to Food Banks using the Analytic Hierarchical Process and Dempster Shafer Theory
We present an analysis of factors contributing to the annual level of donation of sweet potatoes in 2010-2016 to a North Carolina food bank. Our approach follows that of Su et al., who used the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Dempster-Shafer theory (DST) to assess annual grain security in China for 1997-2007. We first identified the indices (or factors or criteria) that influence the level of donation and their “directions:” positive (the more the better), negative, or non-directional (average is best). We divided the range of each index into degrees (intervals) then applied AHP to get weights for the indices. To apply DST, we defined a frame of discernment that would generate focal elements that could be assigned to degrees of the indices. Then, using the index weights, we defined a BPA (basic probability function) for each year. Since for each year we had multiple pieces of possibly conflicting evidence, we used Dempster’s rule to combine each BPA with itself several times. In the resulting BPA, the focal element with greatest mass was taken as the prediction for the donation level for that year. We partitioned the range of the donation data into degrees to compare observations with the focal elements in the BPA. Predicted donation degrees matched observed degrees reasonably well if degree boundaries are well chosen. Analysis of apparent anomalies suggested a more sophisticated approach and the need to involve other information sources. This approach allows one to experiment in a principled way (and without assumptions about probability distributions) with the relative importance of the multiple factors that affect the predicted quantity and so to understand how these factors together contribute to that quantity. It is suggested for gaining preliminary insight, which may be exploited in the application of more rigid analytic techniques.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1735258
NSF-PAR ID:
10196702
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
IEEE SoutheastCon 2020
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ( , PLOS ONE)
    Silva, Daniel de (Ed.)
    Biodiversity loss is a global ecological crisis that is both a driver of and response to environmental change. Understanding the connections between species declines and other components of human-natural systems extends across the physical, life, and social sciences. From an analysis perspective, this requires integration of data from different scientific domains, which often have heterogeneous scales and resolutions. Community science projects such as eBird may help to fill spatiotemporal gaps and enhance the resolution of standardized biological surveys. Comparisons between eBird and the more comprehensive North American Breeding Bird Survey (BBS) have found these datasets can produce consistent multi-year abundance trends for bird populations at national and regional scales. Here we investigate the reliability of these datasets for estimating patterns at finer resolutions, inter-annual changes in abundance within town boundaries. Using a case study of 14 focal species within Massachusetts, we calculated four indices of annual relative abundance using eBird and BBS datasets, including two different modeling approaches within each dataset. We compared the correspondence between these indices in terms of multi-year trends, annual estimates, and inter-annual changes in estimates at the state and town-level. We found correspondence between eBird and BBS multi-year trends, but this was not consistent across all species and diminished at finer, inter-annual temporal resolutions. We further show that standardizing modeling approaches can increase index reliability even between datasets at coarser temporal resolutions. Our results indicate that multiple datasets and modeling methods should be considered when estimating species population dynamics at finer temporal resolutions, but standardizing modeling approaches may improve estimate correspondence between abundance datasets. In addition, reliability of these indices at finer spatial scales may depend on habitat composition, which can impact survey accuracy. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ( , Frontiers in Water)
    Introduction Integrated water management (IWM) involves a range of policies, actions, and organizational processes that go beyond traditional hydrology to consider multifaceted aspects of complex water resource systems. Due to its transdisciplinary nature, IWM comprises input from diverse stakeholders, each with unique perceptions, values, and experiences. However, stakeholders from differing backgrounds may disagree on best practices and collective paths forward. As such, successful IWM must address key governance principles (e.g., information flow, collective decision-making, and power relations) across social and institutional scales. Here, we sought to demonstrate how network structure impacts shared decision-making within IWM. Methods We explored a case study in Houston, Texas, USA, where decision-making stakeholders from various sectors and levels of governance engaged in a participatory modeling workshop to improve adoption of nature-based solutions (NBS) through IWM. The stakeholders used fuzzy cognitive mapping (FCM) to define an IWM model comprising multifaceted elements and their interrelationships, which influenced the adoption of NBS in Houston. We applied grounded theory and inductive reasoning to categorize tacit belief schemas regarding how stakeholders viewed themselves within the management system. We then used FCM-based modeling to explore how unique NBS policies would translate into more (or less) NBS adoption. Finally, we calculated specific network metrics (e.g., density, hierarchy, and centrality indices) to better understand the structure of human-water relations embedded within the IWM model. We compared the tacit assumptions about stakeholder roles in IWM against the quantitative degrees of influence and collectivism embedded within the stakeholder-defined model. Results and discussion Our findings revealed a mismatch between stakeholders' external belief statements about IWM and their internal assumptions through cognitive mapping and participatory modeling. The case study network was characterized by a limited degree of internal coordination (low density index), high democratic potential (low hierarchy index), and high-efficiency management opportunities (high centrality index), which transcended across socio-institutional scales. These findings contrasted with several of the belief schemas described by stakeholders during the group workshop. We describe how ongoing partnership with the stakeholders resulted in an opportunity for adaptive learning, where the NBS planning paradigm began to shift toward trans-scale collaboration aimed at high-leverage management opportunities. We emphasize how network analytics allowed us to better understand the extent to which key governance principles drove the behavior of the IWM model, which we leveraged to form deeper stakeholder partnerships by identifying hidden opportunities for governance transformation. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; ; ; ( , Remote Sensing)
    null (Ed.)
    The southern Appalachian forests have been threatened by several large-scale disturbances, such as wildfire and infestation, which alter the forest ecosystem structures and functions. Hemlock Woolly Adelgid (Adelges tsugae Annand, HWA) is a non-native pest that causes widespread foliar damage and eventual mortality, resulting in irreversible tree decline in eastern (Tsuga canadensis) and Carolina (T. caroliniana) hemlocks throughout the eastern United States. It is important to monitor the extent and severity of these disturbances over space and time to better understand their implications in the biogeochemical cycles of forest landscapes. Using all available Landsat images, we investigate and compare the performance of Tasseled Cap Transformation (TCT)-based indices, Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI), and Disturbance Index (DI) in capturing the spectral-temporal trajectory of both abrupt and gradual forest disturbances (e.g., fire and hemlock decline). For each Landsat pixel, the temporal trajectories of these indices were fitted into a time series model, separating the inter-annual disturbance patterns (low frequency) and seasonal phenology (high frequency) signals. We estimated the temporal dynamics of disturbances based on the residuals between the observed and predicted values of the model, investigated the performance of all the indices in capturing the hemlock decline intensity, and further validated the results with the number of individual dead hemlocks identified from high-resolution aerial images. Our results suggested that the overall performance of NDVI, followed by TCT wetness, was most accurate in detecting both the disturbance timing and hemlock decline intensity, explaining over 90% of the variability in the number of dead hemlocks. Despite the overall good performance of TCT wetness in characterizing the disturbance regime, our analysis showed that this index has some limitations in characterizing disturbances due to its recovery patterns following infestation. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ( , Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences)
    Abstract. We developed a new approach for mapping landslide hazards by combiningprobabilities of landslide impacts derived from a data-driven statisticalapproach and a physically based model of shallow landsliding. Ourstatistical approach integrates the influence of seven site attributes (SAs) onobserved landslides using a frequency ratio (FR) method. Influential attributesand resulting susceptibility maps depend on the observations of landslidesconsidered: all types of landslides, debris avalanches only, or source areasof debris avalanches. These observational datasets reflect the detection ofdifferent landslide processes or components, which relate to differentlandslide-inducing factors. For each landslide dataset, a stability index (SI) is calculated as a multiplicative result of the frequency ratios for all attributes and is mapped across our study domain in the North Cascades National Park Complex (NOCA), Washington, USA. A continuous function is developed to relate local SI values to landslide probability based on a ratio of landslide and non-landslide grid cells. The empirical model probability derived from the debris avalanche source area dataset is combined probabilistically with a previously developed physically based probabilistic model. A two-dimensional binning method employs empirical andphysically based probabilities as indices and calculates a joint probabilityof landsliding at the intersections of probability bins. A ratio of thejoint probability and the physically based model bin probability is used asa weight to adjust the original physically based probability at each gridcell given empirical evidence. The resulting integrated probability oflandslide initiation hazard includes mechanisms not captured by the infinite-slope stability model alone. Improvements in distinguishing potentiallyunstable areas with the proposed integrated model are statisticallyquantified. We provide multiple landslide hazard maps that land managers canuse for planning and decision-making, as well as for educating the publicabout hazards from landslides in this remote high-relief terrain. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ( , Space Weather)
    Abstract

    Since the middle of the last decade, UCSD has incorporated magnetic field data in its Institute for Space‐Earth Environmental Research interplanetary scintillation tomographic analysis. These data are extrapolated upward from the solar surface using the Current Sheet Source Surface model (Zhao & Hoeksema, 1995,https://doi.org/10.1029/94JA02266) to provide predictions of the interplanetary field in RTN coordinates. Over the years this technique has become ever more sophisticated, and allows different types of magnetogram data (SOLIS, Global Oscillation Network Group, etc.,) to be incorporated in the field extrapolations. At Earth, these fields can be displayed in a variety of ways, including Geocentric Solar Magnetospheric (GSM) Bx, By, and Bzcoordinates. Displayed daily, the Current Sheet Source Surface model‐derived GSM Bzshows a significant positive correlation with the low‐resolution (few day variation) in situ measurements of the Bzfield. The nano‐Tesla variations of Bzmaximize in spring and fall as Russell and McPherron (1973,https://doi.org/10.1029/JA078i001p00092) have shown. More significantly, we find that the daily variations are correlated with geomagnetic Kp and Dst index variations, and that a decrease from positive to negative Bzhas a high correlation with minor‐to‐moderate geomagnetic storm activity, as defined by NOAA Space Weather Prediction Center planetary Kp values. Here we provide an 11‐year study of the predicted Bzfield, from the extrapolation of the Global Oscillation Network Group‐magnetograms. We provide a skill‐score analysis of the technique's geomagnetic storm prediction capability, which allows forecasts of moderate enhanced geomagnetic storm activity. UCSD and the Korean Space Weather Center currently operate a website that predicts this low‐resolution GSM Bzfield component variation several days in advance.

     
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email