skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: Decision-Based Approach to Account for Uncertainty in Estimating the Overtopping Hazard to Manage Risk for Dams
This paper describes and demonstrates an approach to improve the management of risks from small-probability events that can lead to large consequences. It applies a decision-based theory to account for limited information in estimating frequencies for rare events to large rockfill dam in Norway that is being assessed for rehabilitation. Uncertainties are considered specifically in estimating the overtopping hazard for the existing dam and for an elevated dam crest. Uncertainty in the estimates of the overtopping hazard curve means that smaller costs of dam failure and/or larger costs of rehabilitation may be justified. From a practical perspective, a cost of rehabilitation in this case that is nearly ten times larger could be justified when the uncertainty in the estimate of the hazard curve is considered. The value of perfect information about the hazard curve increases as the amount of information available decreases and as the cost of failure relative to the cost of rehabilitation decreases. In this case, the value of perfect information about the hazard curve is about 25 percent of the cost to raise the dam crest.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1636217
PAR ID:
10208802
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Editor(s):
Ching, J.; Li, D-Q.; Zhang, J.
Date Published:
Journal Name:
7th International Symposium on Geotechnical Safety and Risk (ISGSR)
Page Range / eLocation ID:
589-594
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. (, Multimodal and Tensor Data Analytics for Industrial Systems Improvement. Springer Optimization and Its Applications)
    Gaw, N; Pardalos, PM; Gahrooei, MR (Ed.)
    This paper reviews a set of Bayesian model updating methodologies for quantification of uncertainty in multi-modal models for estimating failure probabilities in rare hazard events. Specifically, a two-stage Bayesian regression model is proposed to fuse an analytical capacity model with experimentally observed capacity data to predict failure probability of residential building roof systems under severe wind loading. The ultimate goals are to construct fragility models accounting for uncertainties due to model inadequacy (epistemic uncertainty) and lack of experimental data (aleatory uncertainty) in estimating failure (exceedance) probabilities and number of damaged buildings in building portfolios. The proposed approach is illustrated on a case study involving a sample residential building portfolio under scenario hurricanes to compare the exceedance probability and aggregate expected loss to determine the most cost-effective wind mitigation options. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; ; ; (, Earthquake Spectra)
    Maintaining the functionality of wastewater networks is critical to individual well-being, business continuity, public health, and safety. However, seismic damage and loss assessments of wastewater networks traditionally use fragility functions based on median repair rates without considering relevant sources of uncertainty and correlations of damage when estimating potential damage states and pipe repairs. This study presents a probabilistic methodology to incorporate modeling uncertainty (e.g. model parameter and model class uncertainty) and spatial correlations (e.g. spatial auto- and cross-correlation) of pipe repairs. The methodology was applied to a case study backbone system of a wastewater network in Portland, OR, using the expected hazard intensity maps for multiple deterministic earthquake scenarios, including a moment magnitude M6.8 Portland Hills Fault and M8.1, M8.4, M8.7, and M9.0 Cascadia Subduction Zone (CSZ) events. As spatial-correlation models of pipeline damage were non-existent in the literature and local information on costs to repair the pipes was limited at the time of this study, correlation methods and repair costs were proposed to estimate lower and upper bounds of pipe damage and loss. The results show how the consideration of different levels of uncertainty and spatial correlation for pipe repair rate could lead to different probabilistic estimates of damage and loss at the system level of the wastewater network, even though the point estimates, such as the mean and median, remain essentially unaltered. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; (, Naval Research Logistics (NRL))
    Abstract Quantile is an important quantity in reliability analysis, as it is related to the resistance level for defining failure events. This study develops a computationally efficient sampling method for estimating extreme quantiles using stochastic black box computer models. Importance sampling has been widely employed as a powerful variance reduction technique to reduce estimation uncertainty and improve computational efficiency in many reliability studies. However, when applied to quantile estimation, importance sampling faces challenges, because a good choice of the importance sampling density relies on information about the unknown quantile. We propose an adaptive method that refines the importance sampling density parameter toward the unknown target quantile value along the iterations. The proposed adaptive scheme allows us to use the simulation outcomes obtained in previous iterations for steering the simulation process to focus on important input areas. We prove some convergence properties of the proposed method and show that our approach can achieve variance reduction over crude Monte Carlo sampling. We demonstrate its estimation efficiency through numerical examples and wind turbine case study. 
    more » « less
  4. ; (, United States Society on Dams)
    Earthquake-related failure modes for embankment dams are commonly evaluated through numerical simulations using finite element or finite difference approaches. This is especially true for liquefaction triggering or cyclic softening of fine-grained materials where advanced constitutive models are used to capture the dynamic response of the dam and the nonlinear behavior of the soil. Both liquefaction and cyclic softening can lead to significant strength loss, which can lead to large deformations within the dam, but these numerical tools often cannot capture these large deformations due to excessive mesh distortion and subsequent numerical errors. This leads to significant uncertainties in estimating potential crest settlement, which is often a critical value for risk assessments of dams. Hybrid numerical methods like the material point method (MPM) offer a promising alternative to model large deformations, but their application to dams is still limited and relatively little validation has been done on using MPM for post-earthquake stability analyses. This study focuses on applying MPM simulations to evaluate the post-earthquake stability of a hypothetical embankment dam and to examine potential deformations of a flowslide that occurred in Palu, Indonesia in 2018. The MPM program Anura3D is used for the analyses with modifications to allow for assigning residual strengths. The results from the Palu flowslide are compared with observations from the field to show that the MPM analyses are able to capture the extent of the slide, but underpredict the measured displacements in the central portion of the flowslide. The analyses for the embankment dam are compared with post-earthquake stability results from finite difference analyses using FLAC. The MPM analyses are able to capture the full deformation of the flowslide, while the FLAC analyses are halted due to excessive mesh deformation. These results demonstrate the potential of MPM to be used as a complement to existing numerical tools for evaluating the seismic response of dams, but additional work is needed to validate this approach using case histories with both large and small deformations. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; (, ICASP14 - 14th International Conference on Applications of Statistics and Probability in Civil Engineering)
    We assess the Value of Information (VoI) for inspecting components in systems managed by multiple agents, using game theory and Nash equilibrium analysis. We focus on binary systems made up by binary components which can be either intact or damaged. Agents taking maintenance actions are responsible for the repair costs of their own components, and the penalty for system failure is shared among all agents. The precision of inspection is also considered, and we identify the prior and posterior Nash equilibrium with perfect or imperfect inspections. The VoI is assessed for the individual agents as well as for the whole set of agents, and the analysis consider series, parallel and general systems. A negative VoI can trigger the phenomenon of Information Avoidance (IA), where rational agents prefer not to collect free information. We discuss whether it is possible that the VoI is negative for one or for all agents, for the agents with inspected or uninspected components, and for the total sum of VoIs. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email