skip to main content


Title: PBE-CC: Congestion Control via Endpoint-Centric, Physical-Layer Bandwidth Measurements
Cellular networks are becoming ever more sophisticated and over-crowded, imposing the most delay, jitter, and throughput damage to end-to-end network flows in today’s internet. We therefore ar- gue for fine-grained mobile endpoint-based wireless measurements to inform a precise congestion control algorithm through a well- defined API to the mobile’s cellular physical layer. Our proposed congestion control algorithm is based on Physical-Layer Bandwidth measurements taken at the Endpoint (PBE-CC), and captures the latest 5G New Radio innovations that increase wireless capacity, yet create abrupt rises and falls in available wireless capacity that the PBE-CC sender can react to precisely and rapidly. We imple- ment a proof-of-concept prototype of the PBE measurement module on software-defined radios and the PBE sender and receiver in C. An extensive performance evaluation compares PBE-CC head to head against the cellular-aware and wireless-oblivious congestion control protocols proposed in the research community and in deployment, in mobile and static mobile scenarios, and over busy and idle networks. Results show 6.3% higher average throughput than BBR, while simultaneously reducing 95th percentile delay by 1.8×.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1617161
NSF-PAR ID:
10212188
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Annual conference of the ACM Special Interest Group on Data Communication on the applications, technologies, architectures, and protocols for computer communi- cation (SIGCOMM)
Page Range / eLocation ID:
451 to 464
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. The rapid growth of mobile data traffic is straining cellular networks. A natural approach to alleviate cellular networks congestion is to use, in addition to the cellular interface, secondary interfaces such as WiFi, Dynamic spectrum and mmWave to aid cellular networks in handling mobile traffic. The fundamental question now becomes: How should traffic be distributed over different interfaces, taking into account different application QoS requirements and the diverse nature of radio interfaces. To this end, we propose the Discounted Rate Utility Maximization (DRUM) framework with interface costs as a means to quantify application preferences in terms of throughput, delay, and cost. The flow rate allocation problem can be formulated as a convex optimization problem. However, solving this problem requires non-causal knowledge of the time-varying capacities of all radio interfaces. To this end, we propose an online predictive algorithm that exploits the predictability of wireless connectivity for a small look-ahead window w. We show that, under some mild conditions, the proposed algorithm achieves a constant competitive ratio independent of the time horizon T. Furthermore, the competitive ratio approaches 1 as the prediction window increases. We also propose another predictive algorithm based on the "Receding Horizon Control" principle from control theory that performs very well in practice. Numerical simulations serve to validate our formulation, by showing that under the DRUM framework: the more delay-tolerant the flow, the less it uses the cellular network, preferring to transmit in high rate bursts over the secondary interfaces. Conversely, delay-sensitive flows consistently transmit irrespective of different interfaces' availability. Simulations also show that the proposed online predictive algorithms have a near-optimal performance compared to the offline prescient solution under all considered scenarios. 
    more » « less
  2. Cellular networks with D2D links are increasingly being explored for mission-critical applications (e.g., real-time control and AR/VR) which require predictable communication reliability. Thus it is critical to control interference among concurrent transmissions in a predictable manner to ensure the required communication reliability. To this end, we propose a Unified Cellular Scheduling (UCS) framework that, based on the Physical-Ratio-K (PRK) interference model, schedules uplink, downlink, and D2D transmissions in a unified manner to ensure predictable communication reliability while maximizing channel spatial reuse. UCS also provides a simple, effective approach to mode selection that maximizes the communication capacity for each involved communication pair. UCS effectively uses multiple channels for high throughput as well as resilience to channel fading and external interference. Leveraging the availability of base stations (BSes) as well as high-speed, out-of-band connectivity between BSes, UCS effectively orchestrates the functionalities of BSes and user equipment (UE) for light-weight control signaling and ease of incremental deployment and integration with existing cellular standards. We have implemented UCS using the open-source, standards-compliant cellular networking platform OpenAirInterface, and we have validated the UCS design and implementation using the USRP B210 software-defined radios in the ORBIT wireless testbed. We have also evaluated UCS through high-fidelity, at-scale simulation studies; we observe that UCS ensures predictable communication reliability while achieving a higher channel spatial reuse rate than existing mechanisms, and that the distributed UCS framework enables a channel spatial reuse rate statistically equal to that in the state-of-the-art centralized scheduling algorithm iOrder. 
    more » « less
  3. Full-duplex (FD) wireless is an attractive communication paradigm with high potential for improving network capacity and reducing delay in wireless networks. Despite significant progress on the physical layer development, the challenges associated with developing medium access control (MAC) protocols for heterogeneous networks composed of both legacy half-duplex (HD) and emerging FD devices have not been fully addressed. Therefore, we focus on the design and performance evaluation of scheduling algorithms for infrastructure-based heterogeneous HD-FD networks (composed of HD and FD users). We first show that centralized GreedyMaximal Scheduling (GMS) is throughput-optimal in heterogeneous HD-FD networks. We propose the Hybrid-GMS (H-GMS) algorithm, a distributed implementation of GMS that combines GMS and a queue-based random-access mechanism. We prove that H-GMS is throughputoptimal. Moreover, we analyze the delay performance of H-GMS by deriving lower bounds on the average queue length. We further demonstrate the benefits of upgrading HD nodes to FD nodes in terms of throughput gains for individual nodes and the whole network. Finally, we evaluate the performance of HGMS and its variants in terms of throughput, delay, and fairness between FD and HD users via extensive simulations. We show that in heterogeneous HD-FD networks, H-GMS achieves 16–30× better delay performance and improves fairness between HD and FD users by up to 50% compared with the fully decentralized Q-CSMA algorithm. 
    more » « less
  4. Abstract—Full-duplex (FD) wireless is an attractive communication paradigm with high potential for improving network capacity and reducing delay in wireless networks. Despite significant progress on the physical layer development, the challenges associated with developing medium access control (MAC) protocols for heterogeneous networks composed of both legacy half-duplex (HD) and emerging FD devices have not been fully addressed. Therefore, we focus on the design and performance evaluation of scheduling algorithms for infrastructure-based heterogeneous HD-FD networks (composed of HD and FD users). We first show that centralized Greedy Maximal Scheduling (GMS) is throughput-optimal in heterogeneous HD-FD networks. We propose the Hybrid-GMS (H-GMS) algorithm, a distributed implementation of GMS that combines GMS and a queue-based random-access mechanism. We prove that H-GMS is throughputoptimal. Moreover, we analyze the delay performance of H-GMS by deriving lower bounds on the average queue length. We further demonstrate the benefits of upgrading HD nodes to FD nodes in terms of throughput gains for individual nodes and the whole network. Finally, we evaluate the performance of HGMS and its variants in terms of throughput, delay, and fairness between FD and HD users via extensive simulations. We show that in heterogeneous HD-FD networks, H-GMS achieves 16–30× better delay performance and improves fairness between HD and FD users by up to 50% compared with the fully decentralized Q-CSMA algorithm. 
    more » « less
  5. Full-duplex (FD) wireless is an attractive communication paradigm with high potential for improving network capacity and reducing delay in wireless networks. Despite significant progress on the physical layer development, the challenges associated with developing medium access control (MAC) protocols for heterogeneous networks composed of both legacy half-duplex (HD) and emerging FD devices have not been fully addressed. In [1], we focused on the design and performance evaluation of scheduling algorithms for heterogeneous HD-FD networks and presented the distributed Hybrid-Greedy Maximal Scheduling (H-GMS) algorithm. H-GMS combines the centralized Greedy Maximal Scheduling (GMS) and a distributed queue-based random-access mechanism, and is throughput-optimal. In this paper, we analyze the delay performance of H-GMS by deriving two lower bounds on the average queue length. We also evaluate the fairness and delay performance of H-GMS via extensive simulations. We show that in heterogeneous HD-FD networks, H-GMS achieves$16-30\times$ better delay performance and improves fairness between FD and HD users by up to 50% compared with the fully decentralized Q-CSMA algorithm. 
    more » « less