The line crack models, including linear elastic fracture mechanics (LEFM), cohesive crack model (CCM), and extended finite element method (XFEM), rest on the century-old hypothesis of constancy of materials’ fracture energy. However, the type of fracture test presented here, named the gap test, reveals that, in concrete and probably all quasibrittle materials, including coarse-grained ceramics, rocks, stiff foams, fiber composites, wood, and sea ice, the effective mode I fracture energy depends strongly on the crack-parallel normal stress, in-plane or out-of-plane. This stress can double the fracture energy or reduce it to zero. Why hasn’t this been detected earlier? Because the crack-parallel stress in all standard fracture specimens is negligible, and is, anyway, unaccountable by line crack models. To simulate this phenomenon by finite elements (FE), the fracture process zone must have a finite width, and must be characterized by a realistic tensorial softening damage model whose vectorial constitutive law captures oriented mesoscale frictional slip, microcrack opening, and splitting with microbuckling. This is best accomplished by the FE crack band model which, when coupled with microplane model M7, fits the test results satisfactorily. The lattice discrete particle model also works. However, the scalar stress–displacement softening law of CCM and tensorial models with a single-parameter damage law are inadequate. The experiment is proposed as a standard. It represents a simple modification of the three-point-bend test in which both the bending and crack-parallel compression are statically determinate. Finally, a perspective of various far-reaching consequences and limitations of CCM, LEFM, and XFEM is discussed.
Gap Test of Crack-Parallel Stress Effect on Quasibrittle Fracture and Its Consequences
Abstract In the standard fracture test specimens, the crack-parallel normal stress is negligible. However, its effect can be strong, as revealed by a new type of experiment, briefly named the gap test. It consists of a simple modification of the standard three-point-bend test whose main idea is to use plastic pads with a near-perfect yield plateau to generate a constant crack-parallel compression and install the end supports with a gap that closes only when the pads yield. This way, the test beam transits from one statically determinate loading configuration to another, making evaluation unambiguous. For concrete, the gap test showed that moderate crack-parallel compressive stress can increase up to 1.8 times the Mode I (opening) fracture energy of concrete, and reduce it to almost zero on approach to the compressive stress limit. To model it, the fracture process zone must be characterized tensorially. We use computer simulations with crack-band microplane model, considering both in-plane and out-of-plane crack-parallel stresses for plain and fiber-reinforced concretes, and anisotropic shale. The results have broad implications for all quasibrittle materials, including shale, fiber composites, coarse ceramics, sea ice, foams, and fone. Except for negligible crack-parallel stress, the line crack models are shown to be inapplicable. Nevertheless, as an approximation ignoring stress tensor history, the crack-parallel stress effect may be introduced parametrically, by a formula. Finally we show that the standard tensorial strength models such as Drucker–Prager cannot reproduce these effects realistically.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2029641
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10248502
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Journal of Applied Mechanics
- Volume:
- 87
- Issue:
- 7
- ISSN:
- 0021-8936
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
more » « less
-
more » « less
Abstract Whereas various simplistic microplane models of limited applicability, defined by stress–strain curves on the microplane, can function as either explicit or implicit, the explicit‐to‐implicit conversion of realistic versatile microplane models for plain or fiber‐reinforced concrete, shale and composites has remained a challenge for quarter century. The reason is that these realistic models use microplane stress–strain boundaries defined by inequalities. Here, we show how the conversion can be easily achieved on the microplane level and then transferred to a tangent stiffness tensor or an inelastic stiffness tensor to be used in Newton–Raphson iterations within a loading step. To ensure convergence, a minor adjustment in the M7 algorithm is introduced to achieve continuity. Power‐law convergence, almost quadratic in most cases, is also demonstrated. Seven examples of crack‐band finite element simulations of challenging laboratory tests document nearly identical implicit and explicit results, as well as good match of test data. Three of them, including the vertex effect in compression‐torsion tests, pure Mode II shear fracture, and the “gap test” of the crack‐parallel compression effect on Mode I load‐deflection curve, have not been reproduced by other models before. The coding of implicit M7 subroutine, usable in, for example, UMAT of ABAQUS, is posted for a free download.
-
Abstract The recently conceived gap test and its simulation revealed that the fracture energy Gf (or Kc, Jcr) of concrete, plastic-hardening metals, composites, and probably most materials can change by ±100%, depending on the crack-parallel stresses σxx, σzz, and their history. Therefore, one must consider not only a finite length but also a finite width of the fracture process zone, along with its tensorial damage behavior. The data from this test, along with ten other classical tests important for fracture problems (nine on concrete, one on sandstone), are optimally fitted to evaluate the performance of the state-of-art phase-field, peridynamic, and crack band models. Thanks to its realistic boundary and crack-face conditions as well as its tensorial nature, the crack band model, combined with the microplane damage constitutive law in its latest version M7, is found to fit all data well. On the contrary, the phase-field models perform poorly. Peridynamic models (both bond based and state based) perform even worse. The recent correction in the bond-associated deformation gradient helps to improve the predictions in some experiments, but not all. This confirms the previous strictly theoretical critique (JAM 2016), which showed that peridynamics of all kinds suffers from several conceptual faults: (1) It implies a lattice microstructure; (2) its particle–skipping interactions are a fiction; (4) it ignores shear-resisted particle rotations (which are what lends the lattice discrete particle model (LDPM) its superior performance); (3) its representation of the boundaries, especially the crack and fracture process zone faces, is physically unrealistic; and (5) it cannot reproduce the transitional size effect—a quintessential characteristic of quasibrittleness. The misleading practice of “verifying” a model with only one or two simple tests matchable by many different models, or showcasing an ad hoc improvement for one type of test while ignoring misfits of others, is pointed out. In closing, the ubiquity of crack-parallel stresses in practical problems of concrete, shale, fiber composites, plastic-hardening metals, and materials on submicrometer scale is emphasized.more » « less
-
Modeling of rock inhomogeneity and anisotropy by explicit and implicit representation of microcracksFracture patterns experienced under a dynamic uniaxial compressive load are highly sensitive to rock microstructural defects due to its brittleness and the absence of macroscopic stress concentration points. We propose two different approaches for modeling rock microstructural defects and inhomogeneity. In the explicit realization approach, microcracks with certain statistics are incorporated in the computational domain. In the implicit realization approach, fracture strength values are sampled using a Weibull probability distribution. We use the Mohr-Coulomb failure criterion to define an effective stress in the context of an interfacial damage model. This model predicts crack propagation at angles ±ɸch = ±(45 − ɸ/2) relative to the direction of compressive load, where ɸ is the friction angle. By using appropriate models for fracture strength anisotropy, we demonstrate the interaction of rock weakest plane and ɸch. Numerical results demonstrate the greater effect of strength anisotropy on fracture pattern when an explicit approach is employed. In addition, the density of fractures increases as the angle of the weakest planes approaches ±ɸch. The fracture simulations are performed by an h-adaptive asynchronous spacetime discontinuous Galerkin (aSDG) method that can accommodate crack propagation in any directions.more » « less
-
LEGOs are one of the most popular toys and are known to be useful as instructional tools in STEM education. In this work, we used LEGO structures to demonstrate the energetic size effect on structural strength. Many material's fexural strength decreases with increasing structural size. We seek to demonstrate this effect in LEGO beams. Fracture experiments were performed using 3-point bend beams built of 2 X 4 LEGO blocks in a periodic staggered arrangement. LEGO wheels were used as rollers on either ends of the specimens which were weight compensated by adding counterweights. [1] Specimens were loaded by hanging weights at their midspan and the maximum sustained load was recorded. Specimens with a built-in defect (crack) of half specimen height were considered. Beam height was varied from two to 32 LEGO blocks while keeping the in-plane aspect ratio constant. The specimen thickness was kept constant at one LEGO block. Slow-motion videos and sound recordings of fractures were captured to determine how the fracture originated and propagated through the specimen. Flexural stress was calculated based on nominal specimen dimensions and fracture toughness was calculated following ASTM E-399 standard expressions from Srawley (1976). [2] The results demonstrate that the LEGO beams indeed exhibit a size effect on strength. For smaller beams the Uexural strength is higher than for larger beams. The dependence of strength on size is similar to that of Bažant’s size effect law [3] . Initiation of failure occurs consistently at the built-in defect. The staggered arrangement causes persistent crack branching which is more pronounced in larger specimens. The results also show that the apparent fracture toughness increases as the specimen size decreases. Further ongoing investigations consider the effects of the initial crack length on the size effect and the fracture response. The present work demonstrates that LEGO structures can serve as an instructional tool. We demonstrate principles of non-linear elastic fracture mechanics and highlight the importance of material microstructure (architecture) in fracture response. The experimental method is reproducible in a classroom setting without the need for complex facilities. This work was partially supported by the National Science Foundation (NSF) under the award #1662177 and the School of Mechanical Engineering at Purdue University. The authors acknowledge the support of Dr. Thomas Siegmund and Glynn Gallaway. [1] Khalilpour, S., BaniAsad, E. and Dehestani, M., 2019. A review on concrete fracture energy and effective parameters. Cement and Concrete research, 120, pp.294-321. [2] Srawley, J.E., 1976, January. Wide range stress intensity factor expressions for ASTM E 399 standard fracture toughness specimens. In Conf. of Am. Soc. for Testing and Mater., Committee E-24 (No. E-8654). [3] Bažant, Z.P., 1999. Size effect on structural strength: a review. Archive of applied Mechanics, 69(9), pp.703-725.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4047215
