skip to main content


Title: Evaluation of autoconversion and accretion enhancement factors in general circulation model warm-rain parameterizations using ground-based measurements over the Azores
Abstract. A great challenge in climate modeling is how to parameterizesubgrid cloud processes, such as autoconversion and accretion in warm-rainformation. In this study, we use ground-based observations and retrievalsover the Azores to investigate the so-called enhancement factors,Eauto and Eaccr, which are often used in climate modelsto account for the influence of subgrid variance of cloud and precipitationwater on the autoconversion and accretion processes. Eauto andEaccr are computed for different equivalent model grid sizes. Thecalculated Eauto values increase from 1.96 (30 km) to 3.2(180 km), and the calculated Eaccr values increase from 1.53(30 km) to 1.76 (180 km). Comparing the prescribed enhancement factors inMorrison and Gettleman (2008, MG08) to the observed ones, we found that ahigher Eauto (3.2) at small grids and lower Eaccr (1.07)are used in MG08, which might explain why most of the general circulation models (GCMs) producetoo-frequent precipitation events but with too-light precipitation intensity. Theratios of the rain to cloud water mixing ratio (qr/qc) at Eaccr=1.07 andEaccr=2.0 are 0.063 and 0.142, respectively, from observations,further suggesting that the prescribed value of Eaccr=1.07 used inMG08 is too small to simulate precipitation intensity correctly. BothEauto and Eaccr increase when the boundary layer becomesless stable, and the values are larger in precipitating clouds (CLWP>75 gm−2) than those in non-precipitating clouds (CLWP<75 gm−2). Therefore, the selection of Eauto andEaccr values in GCMs should be regime- and resolution-dependent.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1700728
NSF-PAR ID:
10293662
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics
Volume:
18
Issue:
23
ISSN:
1680-7324
Page Range / eLocation ID:
17405 to 17420
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Abstract. One of the challenges inrepresenting warm rain processes in global climate models (GCMs) is relatedto the representation of the subgrid variability of cloud properties, such ascloud water and cloud droplet number concentration (CDNC), and the effectthereof on individual precipitation processes such as autoconversion. Thiseffect is conventionally treated by multiplying the resolved-scale warm rainprocess rates by an enhancement factor (Eq) which is derived fromintegrating over an assumed subgrid cloud water distribution. The assumedsubgrid cloud distribution remains highly uncertain. In this study, we derivethe subgrid variations of liquid-phase cloud properties over the tropicalocean using the satellite remote sensing products from Moderate ResolutionImaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS) and investigate the correspondingenhancement factors for the GCM parameterization of autoconversion rate. Wefind that the conventional approach of using only subgrid variability ofcloud water is insufficient and that the subgrid variability of CDNC, as wellas the correlation between the two, is also important for correctlysimulating the autoconversion process in GCMs. Using the MODIS data whichhave near-global data coverage, we find that Eq shows a strongdependence on cloud regimes due to the fact that the subgrid variability ofcloud water and CDNC is regime dependent. Our analysis shows a significantincrease of Eq from the stratocumulus (Sc) to cumulus (Cu) regions.Furthermore, the enhancement factor EN due to the subgrid variation ofCDNC is derived from satellite observation for the first time, and resultsreveal several regions downwind of biomass burning aerosols (e.g., Gulf ofGuinea, east coast of South Africa), air pollution (i.e., East China Sea),and active volcanos (e.g., Kilauea, Hawaii, and Ambae, Vanuatu), where theEN is comparable to or even larger than Eq, suggesting an importantrole of aerosol in influencing the EN. MODIS observations suggest thatthe subgrid variations of cloud liquid water path (LWP) and CDNC aregenerally positively correlated. As a result, the combined enhancementfactor, including the effect of LWP and CDNC correlation, is significantlysmaller than the simple product of EqEN. Given the importanceof warm rain processes in understanding the Earth's system dynamics and watercycle, we conclude that more observational studies are needed to provide abetter constraint on the warm rain processes in GCMs.

     
    more » « less
  2. Abstract

    The impact of giant sea salt aerosols released from breaking waves on rain formation in marine boundary layer clouds is studied using large-eddy simulations (LES). We perform simulations of marine cumuli and stratocumuli for various concentrations of cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) and giant CCN (GCCN). Cloud microphysics are modeled with a Lagrangian method that provides key improvements in comparison to previous LES of GCCN that used Eulerian bin microphysics. We find that GCCN significantly increase precipitation in stratocumuli. This effect is strongest for low and moderate CCN concentrations. GCCN are found to have a smaller impact on precipitation formation in cumuli. These conclusions are in agreement with field measurements. We develop a simple parameterization of the effect of GCCN on precipitation, accretion, and autoconversion rates in marine stratocumuli.

    Significance Statement

    Breaking sea waves release salt particles into the atmosphere. Cloud droplets formed on these salt particles can grow larger than droplets formed on other smaller particles. Therefore, sea salt particles can be important for rain formation over oceans. To investigate this effect, we performed idealized computer simulations of stratocumulus and cumulus clouds. Sea salt particles were modeled with an unprecedented precision thanks to the use of an emerging modeling method. In our simulations sea salt particles significantly enhance rain formation in stratocumuli, but not in cumuli. Our study has implications for climate models, because stratocumuli are important for Earth’s energy budget and for rain enhancement experiments.

     
    more » « less
  3. Abstract Airborne vertically profiling Doppler radar data and output from a ∼1-km-grid-resolution numerical simulation are used to examine how relatively small-scale terrain ridges (∼10–25 km apart and ∼0.5–1.0 km above the surrounding valleys) impact cross-mountain flow, cloud processes, and surface precipitation in deep stratiform precipitation systems. The radar data were collected along fixed flight tracks aligned with the wind, about 100 km long between the Snake River Plain and the Idaho Central Mountains, as part of the 2017 Seeded and Natural Orographic Wintertime clouds: the Idaho Experiment (SNOWIE). Data from repeat flight legs are composited in order to suppress transient features and retain the effect of the underlying terrain. Simulations closely match observed series of terrain-driven deep gravity waves, although the simulated wave amplitude is slightly exaggerated. The deep waves produce pockets of supercooled liquid water in the otherwise ice-dominated clouds (confirmed by flight-level observations and the model) and distort radar-derived hydrometeor trajectories. Snow particles aloft encounter several wave updrafts and downdrafts before reaching the ground. No significant wavelike modulation of radar reflectivity or model ice water content occurs. The model does indicate substantial localized precipitation enhancement (1.8–3.0 times higher than the mean) peaking just downwind of individual ridges, especially those ridges with the most intense wave updrafts, on account of shallow pockets of high liquid water content on the upwind side, leading to the growth of snow and graupel, falling out mostly downwind of the crest. Radar reflectivity values near the surface are complicated by snowmelt, but suggest a more modest enhancement downwind of individual ridges. Significance Statement Mountains in the midlatitude belt and elsewhere receive more precipitation than the surrounding lowlands. The mountain terrain often is complex, and it remains unclear exactly where this precipitation enhancement occurs, because weather radars are challenged by beam blockage and the gauge network is too sparse to capture the precipitation heterogeneity over complex terrain. This study uses airborne profiling radar and high-resolution numerical simulations for four winter storms over a series of ridges in Idaho. One key finding is that while instantaneous airborne radar transects of the cross-mountain flow, vertical drafts, and reflectivity contain much transient small-scale information, time-averaged transects look very much like the model transects. The model indicates substantial surface precipitation enhancement over terrain, peaking over and just downwind of individual ridges. Radar observations suggest less enhancement, but the radar-based assessment is uncertain. The second key conclusion is that, even though orographic gravity waves are felt all the way up into the upper troposphere, the orographic precipitation enhancement is due to processes very close to the terrain. 
    more » « less
  4. null (Ed.)
    Abstract. In the current global climate models (GCMs), the nonlinearity effect ofsubgrid cloud variations on the parameterization of warm-rain process, e.g.,the autoconversion rate, is often treated by multiplying the resolved-scalewarm-rain process rates by a so-called enhancement factor (EF). In thisstudy, we investigate the subgrid-scale horizontal variations andcovariation of cloud water content (qc) and cloud droplet numberconcentration (Nc) in marine boundary layer (MBL) clouds based on thein situ measurements from a recent field campaign and study the implicationsfor the autoconversion rate EF in GCMs. Based on a few carefully selectedcases from the field campaign, we found that in contrast to the enhancingeffect of qc and Nc variations that tends to make EF > 1, the strong positive correlation between qc and Nc results in asuppressing effect that tends to make EF < 1. This effect isespecially strong at cloud top, where the qc and Nc correlation canbe as high as 0.95. We also found that the physically complete EF thataccounts for the covariation of qc and Nc is significantly smallerthan its counterpart that accounts only for the subgrid variation ofqc, especially at cloud top. Although this study is based on limitedcases, it suggests that the subgrid variations of Nc and itscorrelation with qc both need to be considered for an accuratesimulation of the autoconversion process in GCMs. 
    more » « less
  5. Abstract. There has been a growing concern that most climate models predict precipitation that is too frequent, likely due to lack of reliable subgrid variabilityand vertical variations in microphysical processes in low-level warm clouds.In this study, the warm-cloud physics parameterizations in the singe-columnconfigurations of NCAR Community Atmospheric Model version 6 and 5 (SCAM6and SCAM5, respectively) are evaluated using ground-based and airborneobservations from the Department of Energy (DOE) Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) Aerosol and Cloud Experiments in the EasternNorth Atlantic (ACE-ENA) field campaign near the Azores islands during2017–2018. The 8-month single-column model (SCM) simulations show that both SCAM6 and SCAM5 cangenerally reproduce marine boundary layer cloud structure, majormacrophysical properties, and their transition. The improvement in warm-cloud properties from the Community Atmospheric Model 5 and 6 (CAM5 to CAM6) physics can be found through comparison with the observations. Meanwhile, both physical schemes underestimate cloud liquidwater content, cloud droplet size, and rain liquid water content butoverestimate surface rainfall. Modeled cloud condensation nuclei (CCN)concentrations are comparable with aircraft-observed ones in the summer but areoverestimated by a factor of 2 in winter, largely due to the biases in thelong-range transport of anthropogenic aerosols like sulfate. We also testthe newly recalibrated autoconversion and accretion parameterizations thataccount for vertical variations in droplet size. Compared to theobservations, more significant improvement is found in SCAM5 than in SCAM6.This result is likely explained by the introduction of subgrid variationsin cloud properties in CAM6 cloud microphysics, which further suppresses thescheme's sensitivity to individual warm-rain microphysical parameters. Thepredicted cloud susceptibilities to CCN perturbations in CAM6 are within areasonable range, indicating significant progress since CAM5 which produces anaerosol indirect effect that is too strong. The present study emphasizes theimportance of understanding biases in cloud physics parameterizations bycombining SCM with in situ observations.

     
    more » « less