skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.


Title: Predicting Treatment Outcome in Spinal Cord Stimulation with EEG
Introduction: Back pain is one of the most common causes of pain in the United States. Spinal cord stimulation (SCS) is an intervention for patients with chronic back pain (CBP). However, SCS decreases pain in only 58% of patients and relies on self-reported pain scores as outcome measures. An SCS trial is temporarily implanted for seven days and helps to determine if a permanent SCS is needed. Patients that have a >50% reduction in pain from the trial stimulator makes them eligible for permanent implantation. However, self-reported measures reveal little on how mechanisms in the brain are altered. Other measurements of pain intensity, onset, medication, disabilities, depression, and anxiety have been used with machine learning to predict outcomes with accuracies <70%. We aim to predict long-term SCS responders at 6-months using baseline resting EEG and machine learning. Materials and Methods: We obtained 10-minutes of resting electroencephalography (EEG) and pain questionnaires from nine participants with CBP at two time points: 1) pre-trial baseline. 2) Six months after SCS permanent implant surgery. Subjects were designated as high or moderate responders based on the amount of pain relief provided by the long-term (post six months) SCS, and pain scored on a scale of 0-10 with 0 being no pain and 10 intolerable. We used the resting EEG from baseline to predict long-term treatment outcome. Resting EEG data was fed through a pipeline for classification and to map dipole sources. EEG signals were preprocessed using the EEGLAB toolbox. Independent component analysis and dipole fitting were used to linearly unmix the signal and to map dipole sources from the brain. Spectral analysis was performed to obtain the frequency distribution of the signal. Each power band, delta (1-4 Hz), theta (4-8 Hz), alpha (8-13 Hz), beta (13-30 Hz), and gamma (30-100 Hz), as well as the entire spectrum (1-100 Hz), were used for classification. Furthermore, dipole sources were ranked based on classification feature weights to determine the significance of specific regions in the brain. We used support vector machines to predict pain outcomes. Results and Discussion: We found higher frequency powerbands provide overall classification performance of 88.89%. Differences in power are seen between moderate and high responders in both the frontal and parietal regions for theta, alpha, beta, and the entire spectrum (Fig.1). This can potentially be used to predict patient response to SCS. Conclusions: We found evidence of decreased power in theta, alpha, beta, and entire spectrum in the anterior regions of the parietal cortex and posterior regions of the frontal cortex between moderate and high responders, which can be used for predicting treatment outcomes in long-term pain relief from SCS. Long-term treatment outcome prediction using baseline EEG data has the potential to contribute to decision making in terms of permanent surgery, forgo trial periods, and improve clinical efficiency by beginning to understand the mechanism of action of SCS in the human brain.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
1908299
PAR ID:
10296317
Author(s) / Creator(s):
; ; ;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Biomedical Engineering Society Annual Meeting
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ABSTRACT IMPACT: Understanding how spinal cord stimulation works and who it works best for will improve clinical trial efficacy and prevent unnecessary surgeries. OBJECTIVES/GOALS: Spinal cord stimulation (SCS) is an intervention for chronic low back pain where standard interventions fail to provide relief. However, estimates suggest only 58% of patients achieve at least 50% reduction in their pain. There is no non-invasive method for predicting relief provided by SCS. We hypothesize neural activity in the brain can fill this gap. METHODS/STUDY POPULATION: We tested SCS patients at 3 times points: baseline (pre-surgery), at day 7 during the trial period (post-trial), and 6 months after a permanent system had been implanted. At each time point participants completed 10 minutes of eyes closed, resting electroencephalography (EEG) and self-reported their pain. EEG was collected with the ActiveTwo system and a 128-electrode cap. Patients were grouped based on the percentage change of their pain from baseline to the final visit using a median split (super responders > average responders). Spectral density powerbands were extracted from resting EEG to use as input features for machine learning analyses. We used support vector machines to predict response to SCS. RESULTS/ANTICIPATED RESULTS: Baseline and post-trial EEG data predicted SCS response at 6-months with 95.56% and 100% accuracy, respectively. The gamma band had the highest performance in differentiating responders. Post-trial EEG data best differentiated the groups with feature weighted dipoles being more highly localized in sensorimotor cortex. DISCUSSION/SIGNIFICANCE OF FINDINGS: Understanding how SCS works and who it works best for is the long-term objective of our collaborative research program. These data provide an important first step towards this goal. 
    more » « less
  2. null (Ed.)
    OBJECTIVES/GOALS: Spinal cord stimulation (SCS) is an intervention for patients with chronic back pain. Technological advances have led to renewed optimism in the field, but mechanisms of action in the brain remain poorly understood. We hypothesize that SCS outcomes will be associated with changes in neural oscillations. METHODS/STUDY POPULATION: The goal of our team project is to test patients who receive SCS at 3 times points: baseline, at day 7 during the trial period, and day 180 after a permanent system has been implanted. At each time point participants will complete 10 minutes of eyes closed, resting electroencephalography (EEG). EEG will be collected with the ActiveTwo system, a 128-electrode cap, and a 256 channel AD box from BioSemi. Traditional machine learning methods such as support vector machine and more complex models including deep learning will be used to generate interpretable features within resting EEG signals. RESULTS/ANTICIPATED RESULTS: Through machine learning, we anticipate that SCS will have a significant effect on resting alpha and beta power in sensorimotor cortex. DISCUSSION/SIGNIFICANCE OF IMPACT: This collaborative project will further the application of machine learning in cognitive neuroscience and allow us to better understand how therapies for chronic pain alter resting brain activity. 
    more » « less
  3. Objective: Although extensive insights about the neural mechanisms of reading have been gained via magnetic and electrographic imaging, the temporal evolution of the brain network during sight reading remains unclear. We tested whether the temporal dynamics of the brain functional connectivity involved in sight reading can be tracked using high-density scalp EEG recordings. Approach: Twenty-eight healthy subjects were asked to read words in rapid serial visual presentation task while recording scalp EEG, and phase locking value was used to estimate the functional connectivity between EEG channels in the theta, alpha, beta, and gamma frequency bands. The resultant networks were then tracked through time. Main results: The network's graph density gradually increases as the task unfolds, peaks 150-250-ms after the appearance of each word, and returns to resting-state values, while the shortest path length between non-adjacent functional areas decreases as the density increases, thus indicating that a progressive integration between regions can be detected at the scalp level. This pattern was independent of the word's type or position in the sentence, occurred in the theta/alpha band but not in beta/gamma range, and peaked earlier in the alpha band compared to the theta band (alpha: 184 ± 61.48-ms; theta: 237 ± 65.32-ms, P-value P<0.01). Nodes in occipital and frontal regions had the highest eigenvector centrality throughout the word's presentation, and no significant lead-lag relationship between frontal/occipital regions and parietal/temporal regions was found, which indicates a consistent pattern in information flow. In the source space, this pattern was driven by a cluster of nodes linked to sensorimotor processing, memory, and semantic integration, with the most central regions being similar across subjects. Significance: These findings indicate that the brain network connectivity can be tracked via scalp EEG as reading unfolds, and EEG-retrieved networks follow highly repetitive patterns lateralized to frontal/occipital areas during reading. 
    more » « less
  4. Objective: Although extensive insights about the neural mechanisms of reading have been gained via magnetic and electrographic imaging, the temporal evolution of the brain network during sight reading remains unclear. We tested whether the temporal dynamics of the brain functional connectivity involved in sight reading can be tracked using high-density scalp EEG recordings. Approach: Twenty-eight healthy subjects were asked to read words in a rapid serial visual presentation task while recording scalp EEG, and phase locking value was used to estimate the functional connectivity between EEG channels in the theta, alpha, beta, and gamma frequency bands. The resultant networks were then tracked through time. Main results: The network's graph density gradually increases as the task unfolds, peaks 150-250-ms after the appearance of each word, and returns to resting-state values, while the shortest path length between non-adjacent functional areas decreases as the density increases, thus indicating that a progressive integration between regions can be detected at the scalp level. This pattern was independent of the word's type or position in the sentence, occurred in the theta/alpha band but not in beta/gamma band, and peaked earlier in the alpha band compared to the theta band (alpha: 184 +/- 61.48-ms; theta: 237 +/- 65.32-ms, P-value P < 0.01). Nodes in occipital and frontal regions had the highest eigenvector centrality throughout the word's presentation, and no significant lead-lag relationship between frontal/occipital regions and parietal/temporal regions was found, which indicates a consistent pattern in information flow. In the source space, this pattern was driven by a cluster of nodes linked to sensorimotor processing, memory, and semantic integration, with the most central regions being similar across subjects. Significance: These findings indicate that the brain network connectivity can be tracked via scalp EEG as reading unfolds, and EEG-retrieved networks follow highly repetitive patterns lateralized to frontal/occipital areas during reading. 
    more » « less
  5. null (Ed.)
    Current techniques for characterizing cybersickness (visually induced motion sickness) in virtual environments rely on qualitative questionnaires. For interactive graphics to create visual experiences that enhance the illusion of presence while mitigating cybersickness, interactive measures are needed to characterize cybersickness. In this paper, we acquire EEG signals from participants as they experience vection-induced cybersickness and compare those signals to a baseline. Our study shows that there is a correlation between the participant-reported cybersickness (as measured by movements of a joystick) and brain EEG signals. Through independent component analysis, we separate those signals which are a result of cybersickness from other sources (such as eye blinks). Our user study finds that there is a highly correlative and statistically significant Delta- (1.0–4.0 Hz), Theta- (4.0–7.0 Hz), and Alpha-wave (7.0–13.0 Hz) increase associated with cybersickness in immersive virtual environments across participants. Establishing a strong correlation between cybersickness and EEG-measured brain activity provides us with the first step toward interactively characterizing and mitigating cybersickness in virtual environments. 
    more » « less