skip to main content

Title: Interactive Visual Representation of Inter-Connected Requirements in Building Codes
To facilitate a better understanding of building codes, the visualization of the embedded structures of the provisions and requirements of the codes is needed. Existing research efforts in building code compliance checking mostly do not purposefully represent building codes in formats that facilitate human understanding and interaction with the codes, such as XML and hypertext (text with links to other text). Visual programming commonly represents building codes more visually as flowcharts. However, flowcharts are static, and the generation of flowcharts is still manual. To address this lack of interactive visual representation of building code requirement structures, this paper proposes an automated building code structure extraction and visualization method for visualizing building code contents in a way that clearly shows the inter-connections between requirements and allows intuitive user interaction. In this method, to extract the chapter-section-subsection hierarchical structure and cross-reference structure, a new extraction method named Building Code Network Generator (BCNG) is proposed to automatically generate an interactive visualization using a directed network. The performance of the proposed BCNG was empirically tested on Chapters 5 and 10 of the International Building Code 2015, with a resulting precision, recall, and F1-score of 99.4%, 96.3%, and 97.8%, respectively. In addition, the extracted hierarchical more » and cross-reference structures were displayed using an open-source network visualization tool to facilitate human understanding and interactions with the building code requirements in automated compliance checking systems. « less
; ;
Award ID(s):
Publication Date:
Journal Name:
Construction Research Congress 2022
Page Range or eLocation-ID:
1004 to 1012
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. Most of the existing automated code compliance checking (ACC) methods are unable to fully automatically convert complex building-code requirements into computer-processable forms. Such complex requirements usually have hierarchically complex clause and sentence structures. There is, thus, a need to decompose such complex requirements into hierarchies of much smaller, manageable requirement units that would be processable using most of the existing ACC methods. Rule-based methods have been used to deal with such complex requirements and have achieved high performance. However, they lack scalability, because the rules are developed manually and need to be updated and/or adapted when applied to a different type of building code. More research is, thus, needed to develop a scalable method to automatically convert the complex requirements into hierarchies of requirement units to facilitate the succeeding steps of ACC such as information extraction and compliance reasoning. To address this need, this paper proposes a new, machine learning-based method to automatically extract requirement hierarchies from building codes. The proposed method consists of five main steps: (1) data preparation and preprocessing; (2) data adaptation; (3) deep neural network model training for dependency parsing; (4) automated requirement segmentation and restriction interpretation based on the extracted dependencies; and (5) evaluation. Themore »proposed method was trained using the English Treebank data; and was tested on sentences from the 2009 International Building Code (IBC) and the Champaign 2015 IBC Amendments. The preliminary results show that the proposed method achieved an average normalized edit distance of 0.32, a precision of 89%, a recall of 76%, and an F1-measure of 82%, which indicates good requirement hierarchy extraction performance.« less
  2. Existing automated code checking methods/tools are unable to automatically analyze and represent all types of requirements (e.g., requirements that are too complex or that require human judgement). Recent efforts in the area of augmented data analytics have proposed the use of templates to facilitate the analysis of text. However, most of these efforts have constructed such templates manually, which is labor-intensive. More importantly, it is difficult for manually-developed templates to capture the linguistic variations in building codes. More research is, thus, needed to automate the generation of templates to support the tagging and extraction of information from building codes. To address this need, this paper proposes an unsupervised machine-learning based method to extract sentence templates that describe syntactic and semantic features and patterns from building codes. The proposed method is composed of four main steps: (1) data preprocessing; (2) identifying the different groups of sentence fragments using clustering; (3) identifying the fixed parts and the slots in the templates based on the syntactic and semantic patterns of the sentence fragment groups; and (4) evaluating the extracted templates. The proposed method was implemented and tested on a corpus of text from the International Building Code. An accuracy of 0.76 was achieved.
  3. Tang, P. ; Grau, D. ; El Asmar, M. (Ed.)
    Existing automated code checking (ACC) systems require the extraction of requirements from regulatory textual documents into computer-processable rule representations. The information extraction processes in those ACC systems are based on either human interpretation, manual annotation, or predefined automated information extraction rules. Despite the high performance they showed, rule-based information extraction approaches, by nature, lack sufficient scalability—the rules typically need some level of adaptation if the characteristics of the text change. Machine learning-based methods, instead of relying on hand-crafted rules, automatically capture the underlying patterns of the existing training text and have a great capability of generalizing to a variety of texts. A more scalable, machine learning-based approach is thus needed to achieve a more robust performance across different types of codes/documents for automatically generating semantically-enriched building-code sentences for the purpose of ACC. To address this need, this paper proposes a machine learning-based approach for generating semantically-enriched building-code sentences, which are annotated syntactically and semantically, for supporting IE. For improved robustness and scalability, the proposed approach uses transfer learning strategies to train deep neural network models on both general-domain and domain-specific data. The proposed approach consists of four steps: (1) data preparation and preprocessing; (2) development of a base deep neuralmore »network model for generating semantically-enriched building-code sentences; (3) model training using transfer learning strategies; and (4) model evaluation. The proposed approach was evaluated on a corpus of sentences from the 2009 International Building Code (IBC) and the Champaign 2015 IBC Amendments. The preliminary results show that the proposed approach achieved an optimal precision of 88%, recall of 86%, and F1-measure of 87%, indicating good performance.« less
  4. As the number, size and complexity of building construction projects increase, code compliance checking becomes more challenging because of the time-consuming, costly, and error-prone nature of a manual checking process. A fully automated code compliance checking would be desirable in facilitating a more efficient, cost effective, and human error-proof code checking. Such automation requires automated information extraction from building designs and building codes, and automated information transformation to a format that allows automated reasoning. Natural Language Processing (NLP) is an important technology to support such automated processing of building codes, because building codes are represented in natural language texts. Part-of-speech (POS) tagging, as an important basis of NLP tasks, must have a high performance to ensure the quality of the automated processing of building codes in such a compliance checking system. However, no systematic testing of existing POS taggers on domain specific building codes data have been performed. To address this gap, the authors analyzed the performance of seven state-of-the-at POS taggers on tagging building codes and compared their results to a manually-labeled gold standard. The authors aim to: (1) find the best performing tagger in terms of accuracy, and (2) identify common sources of errors. In providing the POSmore »tags, the authors used the Penn Treebank tagset, which is a widely used tagset with a proper balance between conciseness and information richness. An average accuracy of 88.80% was found on the testing data. The Standford coreNLP tagger outperformed the other taggers in the experiment. Common sources of errors were identified to be: (1) word ambiguity, (2) rare words, and (3) unique meaning of common English words in the construction context. The found result of machine taggers on building codes calls for performance improvement, such as error-fixing transformational rules and machine taggers that are trained on building codes.« less
  5. To allow full automation of building code compliance checking with different building design models and codes/regulations, input building design models need to be automatically validated. Automated architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) object identification with high accuracy is essential for such validation. For example, in order to check egress requirements, exits of a building (and their presence or absence) need to be identified automatically through object identification. To address that, the authors propose a new AEC object identification algorithm that can identify needed code checking concepts from building design models based on the invariant signatures of AEC objects, which consisted of Cartesian points-based geometry, relative location and orientation, and material mechanical properties. Building design models in industry foundation classes (IFC) format are processed into invariant signatures, which can fully represent the model data and convert them into computable representations to support automated compliance reasoning. A systematic implementation of the above invariant signatures-based object identification algorithm can be used to automatically conduct building design model validation for code compliance checking preparation. An experimental testing on Chapters 4 and 8 of the International Building Code 2015 and a convenience store design model showed the model validation using the proposed identification algorithms successfully validatedmore »ceiling and interior door concepts. Comparing to the manual validation used in current practice, this new object identification algorithm is more efficient in supporting model validation for automated building code compliance checking.« less