This paper discusses the challenges faced by electric power systems due to the increasing use of inverter-based renewable energy resources (IBRs) operating in grid-following mode (GFL) and the limited support they provide for the grid’s reliability and stability. With increased IBRs connected to the grid, electric utilities are increasingly requiring IBRs to behave like traditional grid-forming (GFM) synchronous generators to provide support for inertia, frequency, voltage, black start capability, and more. The paper focuses on developing GFM inverter technologies with L, LC, and LCL filters and investigates the performance of combined GFM and GFL inverters with different filtering mechanisms when supplying different types of loads. It also emphasizes achieving voltage controllability at the point of common coupling of the GFM with the rest of an AC system. EMT simulation is utilized to investigate the interaction of combined GFM and GFL inverters with different filtering mechanisms. The research results will assist electric utilities in ensuring the reliability and stability of electric power systems in the future.
more »
« less
Grid-Forming Converters for Stability Issues in Future Power Grids
Historically, the power system has relied on synchronous generators (SGs) to provide inertia and maintain grid stability. However, because of the increased integration of power-electronics-interfaced renewable energy sources, the grid’s stability has been challenged in the last decade due to a lack of inertia. Currently, the system predominantly uses grid-following (GFL) converters, built on the assumption that inertial sources regulate the system stability. Such an assumption does not hold for the low-inertia grids of the future. Grid-forming (GFM) converters, which mimic the traditional synchronous machinery’s functionalities, have been identified as a potential solution to support the low-inertia grids. The performance analysis of GFM converters for small-signal instability can be found in the literature, but large-signal instability is still an open research question. Moreover, various topologies and configurations of GFM converters have been proposed. Still, no comparative study combining all GFC configurations from the perspective of large-signal stability issues can be found. This paper combines and compares all the existing GFM control schemes from the perspective of large-signal stability issues to pave the way for future research and development of GFM converters for large-signal stability analysis and stabilization of the future low-inertia grids.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 2034938
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10347688
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- Energies
- Volume:
- 15
- Issue:
- 14
- ISSN:
- 1996-1073
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 4937
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Inertia from rotating masses of generators in power systems influence the instantaneous frequency change when an imbalance between electrical and mechanical power occurs. Renewable energy sources (RES), such as solar and wind power, are connected to the grid via electronic converters. RES connected through converters affect the system's inertia by decreasing it and making it time-varying. This new setting challenges the ability of current control schemes to maintain frequency stability. Proposing adequate controllers for this new paradigm is key for the performance and stability of future power grids. The contribution of this paper is a framework to learn sparse time-invariant frequency controllers in a power system network with a time-varying evolution of rotational inertia. We model power dynamics using a Switched-Affine hybrid system to consider different modes corresponding to different inertia coefficients. We design a controller that uses as features, i.e. input, the systems states. In other words, we design a control proportional to the angles and frequencies. We include virtual inertia in the controllers to ensure stability. One of our findings is that it is possible to restrict communication between the nodes by reducing the number of features in the controller (from 22 to 10 in our case study) without disrupting performance and stability. Furthermore, once communication between nodes has reached a threshold, increasing it beyond this threshold does not improve performance or stability. We find a correlation between optimal feature selection in sparse controllers and the topology of the network.more » « less
-
Climate change is expected to intensify the effects of extreme weather events on power systems and increase the frequency of severe power outages. The large-scale integration of environment-dependent renewables during energy decarbonization could induce increased uncertainty in the supply–demand balance and climate vulnerability of power grids. This Perspective discusses the superimposed risks of climate change, extreme weather events and renewable energy integration, which collectively affect power system resilience. Insights drawn from large-scale spatiotemporal data on historical US power outages induced by tropical cyclones illustrate the vital role of grid inertia and system flexibility in maintaining the balance between supply and demand, thereby preventing catastrophic cascading failures. Alarmingly, the future projections under diverse emission pathways signal that climate hazards — especially tropical cyclones and heatwaves — are intensifying and can cause even greater impacts on the power grids. High-penetration renewable power systems under climate change may face escalating challenges, including more severe infrastructure damage, lower grid inertia and flexibility, and longer post-event recovery. Towards a net-zero future, this Perspective then explores approaches for harnessing the inherent potential of distributed renewables for climate resilience through forming microgrids, aligned with holistic technical solutions such as grid-forming inverters, distributed energy storage, cross-sector interoperability, distributed optimization and climate–energy integrated modelling.more » « less
-
With the increasing penetration of non-synchronous variable renewable energy sources (RES) in power grids, the system's inertia decreases and varies over time, affecting the capability of current control schemes to handle frequency regulation. Providing virtual inertia to power systems has become an interesting topic of research, since it may provide a reasonable solution to address this new issue. However, power dynamics are usually modeled as time-invariant, without including the effect of varying inertia due to the presence of RES. This paper presents a framework to design a fixed learned controller based on datasets of optimal time-varying LQR controllers. In our scheme, we model power dynamics as a hybrid system with discrete modes representing different rotational inertia regimes of the grid. We test the performance of our controller in a twelve-bus system using different fixed inertia modes. We also study our learned controller as the inertia changes over time. By adding virtual inertia we can guarantee stability of high-renewable (low-inertia) modes. The novelty of our work is to propose a design framework for a stable controller with fixed gains for time-varying power dynamics. This is relevant because it would be simpler to implement a proportional controller with fixed gains compared to a time-varying control.more » « less
-
Electrical power systems are transitioning from fuel-based generation to renewable generation and transmission interfaced by power electronics. This transition challenges standard power system modeling, analysis, and control paradigms across timescales from milliseconds to seasons. This tutorial focuses on frequency stability on timescales of milliseconds to seconds. We first review basic results for grid-following (GFL) and grid-forming (GFM) control of voltage source converters (VSCs), typical renewable generation, and high voltage direct current (HVdc) transmission. In this context, it becomes apparent that GFL and GFM control functions are needed to operate emerging power systems. However, combining GFL resources, GFM resources, and legacy generation on the same system results in highly complex dynamics that are a significant obstacle to stability analysis. The remainder of the tutorial provides an overview of recent developments in universal GFM controls that bridge the gap between GFL and GFM control and provide a pathway to a coherent control and analysis framework accounting for power generation, power conversion, and power transmission.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.3390/en15144937
