Natural arches are culturally valued rock landforms common in sedimentary rocks of the Colorado Plateau and additionally occur broadly around the world. Recent notable collapses of some of these landforms have highlighted the need to better understand the mechanics of their failure. While environmentally driven weathering has been the focus of most previous studies of arch collapse, comparably little attention has been given to anthropogenic vibration sources and how these often slight- to moderate-magnitude shaking events might steadily weaken arches over time. We collected 12–15 months of continuous ambient vibration data from arches and nearby bedrock in both anthropogenically ‘noisy’ and ‘quiet’ locations and used these datasets to develop an annual model of arch peak ground velocity based on magnitude-cumulative frequency distributions. Working from these models, we added vibration events of varying magnitude or frequency of occurrence, informed by field data, imitating arch vibration in response to different anthropogenic activities such as helicopter flights or induced earthquakes. We then applied subcritical fracture mechanics principles to predict annual crack growth rates in an idealized arch under these different vibration conditions. Our results demonstrate that in a single year, cracks grow minimally longer (∼1%) in ‘noisy’ environments than in areas not experiencing anthropogenic vibration energy. Few (1+) 30-s moderate-magnitude events (∼15 mm/s) or many (>37,000) 30-s low-magnitude events (∼2 mm/s) cause markedly increased crack growth. Our approach provides a valuable new framework for assessing the range and frequency of occurrence of vibrations experienced by an arch, and for predicting arch damage. Our results, in turn, yield important new outputs applicable in support of conservation management of these and similar landforms world-wide under exposure to a range of human-induced vibration activity.
more »
« less
Ground Motion Amplification at Natural Rock Arches in the Colorado Plateau
Abstract Thousands of rock arches are situated within the central Colorado Plateau—a region experiencing small- to moderate-magnitude contemporary seismicity. Recent anthropogenic activity has substantially increased the seismicity rate in some areas, raising questions about the potential for vibration damage of natural arches, many of which have high cultural value. However, predictions of the vibration response and potential for damage at a given site are limited by a lack of data describing spectral amplification of ground motion on these landforms. We analyzed 13 sandstone arches in Utah, computing site-to-reference spectral amplitude ratios from continuous ambient seismic data, and compared these to spectral ratios during earthquakes and teleseismic activity. We found peak ground velocities on arches at their dominant natural modes (in the range of 2–20 Hz) are ∼20–180 times the velocity on adjacent bedrock, due to amplification arising from slender geometry and low modal damping (0.8%–2.7%). Ambient spectral ratios are generally 1.2–2.0 times the coseismic spectral ratios. Because arches experience highly amplified ground motion, the range of earthquakes considered potentially damaging may need to be revised to include lower-magnitude events. Our results have implications for conservation management of these and other culturally valuable landforms.
more »
« less
- Award ID(s):
- 1831283
- NSF-PAR ID:
- 10378600
- Date Published:
- Journal Name:
- The Seismic Record
- Volume:
- 2
- Issue:
- 3
- ISSN:
- 2694-4006
- Page Range / eLocation ID:
- 156 to 166
- Format(s):
- Medium: X
- Sponsoring Org:
- National Science Foundation
More Like this
-
-
Abstract. Natural rock arches are rare and beautiful geologic landforms with important cultural value. As such, their management requires periodic assessment of structural integrity to understand environmental and anthropogenic influences on arch stability. Measurements of passive seismic vibrations represent a rapid and non-invasive technique to describe the dynamic properties of natural arches, including resonant frequencies, modal damping ratios, and mode shapes, which can be monitored over time for structural health assessment. However, commonly applied spectral analysis tools are often limited in their ability to resolve characteristics of closely spaced or complex higher-order modes. Therefore, we investigate two techniques well-established in the field of civil engineering through application to a set of natural arches previously characterized using polarization analysis and spectral peak-picking techniques. Results from enhanced frequency domain decomposition and parametric covariance-driven stochastic subspace identification modal analyses showed generally good agreement with spectral peak-picking and frequency-dependent polarizationanalyses. However, we show that these advanced techniques offer the capability to resolve closely spaced modes including their corresponding modal damping ratios. In addition, due to preservation of phase information, enhanced frequency domain decomposition allows for direct and convenient three-dimensional visualization of mode shapes. These techniques provide detailed characterization of dynamic parameters, which can be monitored to detect structural changes indicating damage and failure, and in addition have the potential to improve numerical models used for arch stability assessment. Results of our study encourage broad adoption and application of these advanced modal analysis techniques for dynamic analysis of a wide range of geological features.more » « less
-
more » « less
Abstract The dynamic properties of freestanding rock landforms are a function of fundamental material and mechanical parameters, facilitating noninvasive vibration‐based structural assessment. Characterization of resonant frequencies, mode shapes, and damping ratios, however, can be challenging at culturally sensitive geologic features, such as rock arches, where physical access is limited. Using sparse ambient vibration measurements, we describe three resonant modes between 1 and 40 Hz for 17 natural arches in Utah spanning a range of lengths from 3–88 m. Modal polarization data are evaluated to combine field observations with 3‐D numerical models. We find outcrop‐scale elastic moduli vary from 0.8 to 8.0 GPa, correlated with diagenetic processes and identify low damping at all sites. Correlation of dense‐array measurements from one arch validates predictions of simple bending modes and fixed boundary conditions. Our results establish use of sparse ambient resonance measurements for structural assessment and monitoring of arches and similar freestanding geologic features worldwide.
-
Abstract. Helicopters emit high-power infrasound in a frequency range thatcan coincide with the natural frequencies of rock landforms. While a singleprevious study demonstrated that close-proximity helicopter flight was ableto excite potentially damaging vibration of rock pinnacles, the effects on abroader range of landforms remain unknown. We performed a series ofcontrolled flights at seven sandstone arches and towers in Utah, USA,recording their vibration response to helicopter-sourced infrasound. Wefound that landform vibration velocities increased by a factor of up to 1000during close-proximity helicopter flight as compared to ambient conditionsimmediately prior and that precise spectral alignment between infrasoundand landform natural frequencies is required to excite resonance. We defineadmittance as the ratio of vibration velocity to infrasound pressure andrecorded values of up to 0.11 mm s−1 Pa−1. While our resultsdemonstrate a strong vibration response, the measured velocities are lowerthan likely instantaneously damaging values. Our results serve as a basisfor predicting unfavorable degradation of culturally significant rocklandforms due to regular helicopter overflights.more » « less
-
null (Ed.)Abstract Cook Inlet fore‐arc basin in south‐central Alaska is a large, deep (7.6 km) sedimentary basin with the Anchorage metropolitan region on its margins. From 2015 to 2017, a set of 28 broadband seismic stations was deployed in the region as part of the Southern Alaska Lithosphere and Mantle Observation Network (SALMON) project. The SALMON stations, which also cover the remote western portion of Cook Inlet basin and the back‐arc region, form the basis for our observational study of the seismic response of Cook Inlet basin. We quantify the influence of Cook Inlet basin on the seismic wavefield using three data sets: (1) ambient‐noise amplitudes of 18 basin stations relative to a nonbasin reference station, (2) earthquake ground‐motion metrics for 34 crustal and intraslab earthquakes, and (3) spectral ratios (SRs) between basin stations and nonbasin stations for the same earthquakes. For all analyses, we examine how quantities vary with the frequency content of the seismic signal and with the basin depth at each station. Seismic waves from earthquakes and from ambient noise are amplified within Cook Inlet basin. At low frequencies (0.1–0.5 Hz), ambient‐noise ratios and earthquake SRs are in a general agreement with power amplification of 6–14 dB, corresponding to amplitude amplification factors of 2.0–5.0. At high frequencies (0.5–4.0 Hz), the basin amplifies the earthquake wavefield by similar factors. Our results indicate stronger amplification for the deeper basin stations such as near Nikiski on the Kenai Peninsula and weaker amplification near the margins of the basin. Future work devoted to 3D wavefield simulations and treatment of source and propagation effects should improve the characterization of the frequency‐dependent response of Cook Inlet basin to recorded and scenario earthquakes in the region.more » « less
- Free Publicly Accessible Full Text
-
Accepted Manuscript1.0
- Journal Article:
- https://doi.org/10.1785/0320220017
