skip to main content
US FlagAn official website of the United States government
dot gov icon
Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.
https lock icon
Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock ( lock ) or https:// means you've safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

Explore Research Products in the PAR
It may take a few hours for recently added research products to appear in PAR search results.


Title: SWprocess: a workflow for developing robust estimates of surface wave dispersion uncertainty
Abstract Non-invasive surface wave methods are increasingly being used as the primary technique for estimating a site’s small-strain shear wave velocity (Vs). Yet, in comparison to invasive methods, non-invasive surface wave methods suffer from highly variable standards of practice, with each company/group/analyst estimating surface wave dispersion data, quantifying its uncertainty (or ignoring it in many cases), and performing inversions to obtain Vs profiles in their own unique manner. In response, this work presents a well-documented, production-tested, and easy-to-adopt workflow for developing estimates of experimental surface wave dispersion data with robust measures of uncertainty. This is a key step required for propagating dispersion uncertainty forward into the estimates of Vs derived from inversion. The paper focuses on the two most common applications of surface wave testing: the first, where only active-source testing has been performed, and the second, where both active-source and passive-wavefield testing has been performed. In both cases, clear guidance is provided on the steps to transform experimentally acquired waveforms into estimates of the site’s surface wave dispersion data and quantify its uncertainty. In particular, changes to surface wave data acquisition and processing are shown to affect the resulting experimental dispersion data, thereby highlighting their importance when quantifying uncertainty. In addition, this work is accompanied by an open-source Python package, swprocess , and associated Jupyter workflows to enable the reader to easily adopt the recommendations presented herein. It is hoped that these recommendations will lead to further discussions about developing standards of practice for surface wave data acquisition, processing, and inversion.  more » « less
Award ID(s):
2120155
PAR ID:
10378913
Author(s) / Creator(s):
;
Date Published:
Journal Name:
Journal of Seismology
Volume:
26
Issue:
4
ISSN:
1383-4649
Page Range / eLocation ID:
731 to 756
Format(s):
Medium: X
Sponsoring Org:
National Science Foundation
More Like this
  1. ; ; (, Geophysical Journal International)
    SUMMARY This paper deals with in situ characterization of the small-strain shear-wave velocity VS and damping ratio DS from an advanced interpretation of Multi-channel Analysis of Surface Waves (MASW) surveys. A new approach based on extracting Rayleigh wave data using the CFDBFa method has been discussed in the companion paper. This paper focuses on mapping the experimental Rayleigh wave phase velocity and attenuation into profiles of VS and DS versus depth, which is achieved through a joint inversion procedure. The joint inversion of phase velocity and attenuation data utilizes a newly developed Monte Carlo global search algorithm, which implements a smart sampling procedure. This scheme exploits the scaling properties of the solution of the Rayleigh eigenvalue problem to modify the trial earth models and improve the matching with the experimental data. Thus, a reliable result can be achieved with a limited number of trial ground models. The proposed algorithm is applied to the inversion of synthetic data and of experimental data collected at the Garner Valley Downhole Array site, as described in the companion paper. In general, inverted soil models exhibit well-defined VS profiles, whereas DS profiles are affected by larger uncertainties. Greater uncertainty in the inverted DS profiles is a direct result of higher variability in the experimental attenuation data, the limited wavelength range at which reliable values of attenuation parameters can be retrieved, and the sensitivity of attenuation data to both DS and VS. Nonetheless, the resulting inverted earth models agree well with alternative in situ estimates and geological data. The results stress the feasibility of retrieving both stiffness and attenuation parameters from active-source MASW testing and the effectiveness of extracting in situ damping ratio estimates from surface wave data. 
    more » « less
  2. ; ; (, Geophysical Journal International)
    SUMMARY A robust, in situ estimate of shear-wave velocity VS and the small-strain damping ratio DS (or equivalently, the quality factor QS) is crucial for the design of buildings and geotechnical systems subjected to vibrations or earthquake ground shaking. A promising technique for simultaneously obtaining both VS and DS relies on the Multichannel Analysis of Surface Waves (MASW) method. MASW can be used to extract the Rayleigh wave phase velocity and phase attenuation data from active-source seismic traces recorded along linear arrays. Then, these data can be inverted to obtain VS and DS profiles. This paper introduces two novel methodologies for extracting the phase velocity and attenuation data. These new approaches are based on an extension of the beamforming technique which can be combined with a modal filter to isolate different Rayleigh propagation modes. Thus, the techniques return reliable phase velocity and attenuation estimates even in the presence of a multimode wavefield, which is typical of complex stratigraphic conditions. The reliability and effectiveness of the proposed approaches are assessed on a suite of synthetic wavefields and on experimental data collected at the Garner Valley Downhole Array and Mirandola sites. The results reveal that, under proper modelling of wavefield conditions, accurate estimates of Rayleigh wave phase velocity and attenuation can be extracted from active-source MASW wavefields over a broad frequency range. Eventually, the estimation of soil mechanical parameters also requires a robust inversion procedure to map the experimental Rayleigh wave parameters into soil models describing VS and DS with depth. The simultaneous inversion of phase velocity and attenuation data is discussed in detail in the companion paper. 
    more » « less
  3. ; ; ; (, Geophysical Journal International)
    SUMMARY Distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) is a relatively new technology for recording the propagation of seismic waves, with promising applications in both engineering and geophysics. DAS's ability to simultaneously collect high spatial resolution waveforms over long arrays suggests that it is well-suited for near-surface imaging applications such as 2-D multichannel analysis of surface waves (MASWs), which require, at a minimum, long, linear arrays of single-component receivers. The 2-D MASW method uses a large number of sensor subarrays deployed along a linear alignment to produce 1-D shear-wave velocity (VS) profiles beneath each subarray. The 1-D VS profiles are then combined to form a pseudo-2-D VS image beneath the entire linear alignment that can be used for the purpose of identifying and characterizing lateral variations in subsurface layering. Traditionally, 2-D MASW is conducted using arrays consisting of either 24 or 48 geophones. While additional receivers could easily be incorporated into the testing configuration, it is rare for researchers and practitioners to have access to greater numbers of seismographs and geophones. When a limited number of geophones are available for deployment, there is a need to pre-determine the geophone spacing and subarray length prior to field data acquisition. Studies examining how the choice of subarray geometry impacts the resulting pseudo-2-D VS cross-sections have been largely limited to synthetic data. In response, this study utilizes DAS data to examine the effects of using various subarray lengths by comparing pseudo-2-D VS cross-sections derived from active-source waveforms collected at a well-characterized field site. DAS is particularly useful for 2-D MASW applications because the subarray geometry does not need to be determined prior to field data acquisition. We organize the DAS waveforms into multiple sets of overlapping MASW subarrays of differing lengths, ranging from 11 to 47 m, along the same alignment, allowing for direct comparison of the derived pseudo-2-D VS results at the site. We show that the length of the individual MASW subarrays has a significant effect on the resulting VS cross-sections, including the resolved location of a strong impedance contrasts at our study site, and evaluate the results relative to ground truth from invasive testing. Our results suggest that the choice of subarray length is important and should be carefully chosen to meet project-specific goals. Furthermore, analysts may consider using multiple subarray geometries during the data processing stage, as is made possible by DAS, to properly evaluate the uncertainty of 2-D MASW results. This study demonstrates the potential of using DAS to collect data for 2-D MASW in a manner that is efficient and flexible, and can be easily scaled up for use with very long arrays. 
    more » « less
  4. ; ; ; (, GEOPHYSICS)
    We develop a new 3D ambient noise tomography (3D ANT) method for geotechnical site characterization. It requires recording ambient noise fields using a 2D surface array of geophones, from which experimental crosscorrelation functions (CCFs) are then extracted and directly inverted to obtain an S-wave velocity ([Formula: see text]) structure. The method consists of a forward simulation using 3D P-SV elastic wave equations to compute the synthetic CCF and an adjoint-state inversion to match the synthetic CCFs to the experimental CCFs for extraction of [Formula: see text]. The main advantage of the presented method, as compared with conventional passive-source seismic methods using characteristics of Green’s function (GF), is that it does not require equal energy on both sides of each receiver pair or far-field wavefields to retrieve the true GF. Instead, the source power spectrum density is inverted during the analysis and incorporated into the forward simulation of the synthetic CCFs to account for source energy distribution. After testing on synthetic data, the 3D ANT method is applied to 3 h of ambient noise recordings at the Garner Valley Downhole Array (GVDA) site in California, using a surface array of 196 geophones placed on a 14 × 14 grid with 5 m spacing. The inverted 3D [Formula: see text] model is found to be consistent with previous invasive and noninvasive geotechnical characterization efforts at the GVDA site. 
    more » « less
  5. ; ; ; (, The Leading Edge)
    Elastic full-waveform inversion (EFWI) is a state-of-the-art seismic tomographic method. Recent advances in technology and instrumentation, combining crosstalk-free source-encoded FWI (SE-FWI) with multicomponent marine data acquisition using ocean-bottom nodes (OBNs), enable full-physics wave propagation and parameter inversion without the computational burden of traditional FWI. With OBN acquisition, P waves, S waves, and P-to-S conversions are recorded. It is not well understood to what extent adding horizontal components to SE-FWI improves the resolution of subsurface modeling. We assess their potential for the reconstruction of shear and compressional wave speeds (VPand VS) by using a synthetic data set modeled after a recently acquired OBN survey in the North Sea. We perform synthetic inversion tests to design suitable strategies that leverage the information recorded in the horizontal components of the data to improve the reconstructed model resolution laterally and in depth. We advocate for a hierarchical inversion approach to recover the elastic parameters. We exploit the P and P-to-S converted waves recorded on the horizontal components to robustly reconstruct both VPand VS. Adding horizontal components to the SE-FWI modeling workflow results in improved spatial resolution, enhanced depth coverage, and more accurate elastic wave speed estimates. 
    more » « less
  • Citation Formats
  • MLA
  • APA
  • Chicago
  • BibTeX
  • Save / Share this Record
  • Send to Email